A group of young activists travel to the Amazon rainforest to protest against the clearing of prime forest by an agrichemical company. They indulge in some symbolic protest, make some waves, and then are busted by company thugs and put on a plane. The plane crashes and they are captured by a sadistic tribe which checks to see if there is a virgin among them they can spare, while eating the rest. Extremely graphic and violent story without any coherent redeeming qualities, really. One must admire the commitment of the actors, however: it is truly amazing what they will go through for the art of the film.
Loreza Izzo, Ariel Levy, Aaron Burns, Daryl Sabara, Kirby Bliss Blanton, Magda Apanowicz, Sky Ferreira, Nicolas Martinez, Ignacia Allamand, Ramon Liao
Widely praised-- and over-rated-- fantasy about twins who return to their home town to set up a juke joint with illicit liquor only to run into a band of white vampires. They recruit a Chinese family, the Chows, to provide food, and a blues band, and much is made of the importance of music as an expression of black identity. The vampires are hilarious: they sing and dance to Irish folk songs and converse with the blacks charmingly, asking to be "let in" (though the film doesn't seem to stick entirely to that vampire convention). In other words, they pass as normal white citizens, until they sink their fangs into you. So there is a lot of metaphor and parable about the story, though the last sequence, with the KKK arriving at the church, seems disparate and gratuitous-- somebody wanted more shooting, and the vicarious pleasure seeing bad people mutilated and killed. To me, it tipped the balance of the film and made me question why an allegedly serious film about race would indulge in such voluminous, explicit violence. Why the lavish, fetishistic shots of guns being uncovered, loaded, prepared, of blood spurting and bodies distorted? Because American audiences-- even if they think they are seeing art-- can't get excited about a film like, say, "Keep Walking", that just explores what it's like to be family, to be human. "Sinners" is stylish, beautifully filmed at times, and has several inspired moments (especially musically) but the ship of film lists badly and becomes tiresome in the end.
Michael B. Jordan, Jack O'Connell, Hailee Steinfeld, Miles Caton, Saul Williams, Andrene Ward-Hammond, Tenaj L. Jackson, Dave Maldonado, Helena Hu, Yao, Li Jun Li, Delroy Lindo
Andrea Gibson was the "poet laureate" of the state of Colorado in 2025, the year she died of cancer. "Come See Me in a Good Light" is a work of reverse narcissism in which the director and producers take on the role of projecting the subjects flattering image back upon herself (or "they-self" as "they" would have it). Andrea Gibson grew in a conservative Christian home in a small town in Maine from which she moved to University and then to Colorado where she hooked up with Megan Falley, also a lesbian poet. Some critics of women's literature and film have cited the fact that many novels and films by women tend to be about themselves, how they are feeling, how they are loved for not, mistreated, and how they are victims. "Come See me in a Good Light" is the epitome this characteristic-- which I consider a deficiency. It is a deficiency because poetry and music and film and novels are almost always much more interesting when they are about someone other than the egocentric self. Would you want a Godfather movie about Mario Puzo? Well, some might like that, but without the original Godfather film a book or movie like that would be tedious and boring and probably as banal as Andrea Gibson's poetry, which is nothing more than a stream of blather put on the pedestal of "spoken word" poetry, as if saying it aloud made it less banal. Her "poetry" is mostly about her feelings, her love life, her sense of victimization, her consciousness of just how profoundly she feels things, and so on. Does she have a single poem that examines and explores and illuminates anything outside of herself? Maybe she does, but it isn't in the film. Colorado chose her as Poet Laureate? Andrea is a lesbian of indeterminate gender, which is fine, except that it becomes clear that gender fluidity, in her case, is another victimization trope: no one accepted her, no one loved her, she was bullied in school (thought, apparently, she was a star on the high school basketball team). So her suffering is supposed to win our hearts, just as her sometimes irreverent attitude towards her cancer is supposed to be charming, and her triumphant last poetry reading is supposed to bring us to tears. It was by that stage of the film that I began to resent her, and the film-makers, and the entire genre. Add to that the pedestrian soundtrack, the contrived song at the end, and the wandering narrative structure, and you have a modestly interesting film of no substance. You don't even get to hear a single intact poem without a dreary musical accompaniment to ensure you feel the right feelings about her feelings.
Megan Falley, Andrea Gibson, Tig Notaro
Very beautiful, animated film about a boy who is lost in a snowy landscape. A mole appears to give him advise-- and seek cake. A fox appears, obviously hungry for mole, but a sequence of events turns the tables and the three of them begin a journey where they meet a horse. The boy seeks "home" but is that really what he wants? Looks like water-color animations, with India ink, executed with a light, delicate touch, and a lovely sense of space and time. Watched with Clementine and Kermit and they both liked it very much.
Jude Coward Nicoll, Tom Hollander, Tom Hollander, Idris Elba, Gabriel Byrne,
Lyrical and meditative study of a working man, a lumber jack, in turn of the century Washington State; how he travels to work, how he works, how he meets and marries a woman, has a child, loses everything, and endures. Robert Grainier is a sober, serious man, taciturn man making a living in logging, and responding thoughtfully but quietly to events around him, including the murder of a Chinese worker, another murder of man hiding from a criminal past, the introduction of machinery and trains, and son. Slow-moving at times but never, to my mind, dull. Secondary characters make themselves known through idiosyncrasy and pronouncements (like a bible-belting preacher, or an older lumberjack, or an indigenous store-keeper). Some anachronisms in dress and technology (or is he really in his late 80's near the end of the film), and an exquisite closing song by Nick Cave ("Train Dreams"). Edgerton believably (for the most part) ages through the film and presents the viewer with a panorama of a man's life, from youth to age, through work and accomplishment to tragedy and solitude. Perhaps the scene in which he thinks he recognizes Katy, his lost daughter, is overwrought and melodramatic (I pictured something more subtle and nuanced, particularly for a man as reserved as Robert), but otherwise a beautiful, remarkable film.
Joel Edgerton, Felicity Jones, Alfred Hsing, David Paul Olsen, Paul Schneider, William H. Macy, Rick Rivera
Like "Paisan", Rossellini takes advantage of the spectacular ruins of World War II cities to create a powerful is somewhat schematic drama about survival in terrible circumstances. Edmund is a young boy whose mother has died and father is ill. He begins to assume the responsibility of finding food for his family, bartering in the black market, trading their possessions (what's left of them). He is convinced by a former teacher that some people might be better off dead. He and other teenagers wander the ruins looking for deals, or food, or friendship and protection. "Germany: Year Zero" has a powerful intimacy with it's subject, even if the drama is sometimes contrived, and the acting (by mostly amateurs) is a bit stiff. Does not shy away from suggesting the sexual compromises arranged under the chaotic era of the time though, of course, it cannot be very explicit.
Edmund Moeschke, Ernst Pittschau, Ingetraud Hinze, Franz-Otto Kruger, Erich Guhne, Heidi Blankner, Hans Sangen
Disappointing rendering of the Frankenstein story scripted by del Toro-- not very well. del Toro has said that he wanted Victor Frankenstein to be more like a pop star, and he cited "Wuthering Heights" as one of his inspirations. He also stated that the father-son relationship was at the heart of this story, which would be a surprise to Mary Shelley. Oscar Isaac is the raving Frankenstein, whom we meeting in the Arctic as he fights off a vengeful monster. The trouble is, Frankenstein was chasing the monster-- to expunge the world of his horrible mistake-- but the dramatic dynamic here is the monster chasing Frankenstein. Frankenstein tells his story to an indulgent Captain Anderson (whose ship is stuck in the ice) and then the monster gives his version. Maybe he's just transgender. Either way, we truly are in Wuthering Heights with the monster banging on the window. But this monster is immortal-- are we now in the arena of Marvel comics? The film at times is over-burdened with spectacular but rather ugly CGI (though del Toro did have some sets built and bragged about it, while still resorting to ugly CGI for the wolves and explosions. We are also cheated out of the most dramatic moments, as when the monster first appears, and then reappears, and reappears again: del Toro misses THE SHOT. And there are too many show-downs, the monster being attacked, left for dead, left for dead again, and again. When the crew spot him from the ice-bound ship, instead a titillating shot of an obscure form in the ice and mist, we get a monster POV. When he first appears in Frankenstein's bedroom, what should have been shocking and perhaps terrifying is banal.
Oscar Isaac, Jacob Elordi, Christoph Waltz, Mia Goth, Felix Kammerer, Charles Dance, David Bradley, Lars Mikkelsen
In the opening scene of "Familiar Touch", Ruth, an elderly but sharp (apparently) woman is having lunch with a middle-aged man. It gradually becomes apparent that she doesn't recognize that the man is her son, Steve, and doesn't remember that this was the day on which she would be moved from her home to a nursing facility that she had visited previously and approved of. Steve leads her out to the car and then makes an excuse to go back into the apartment where he retrieves her suitcase. Ruth is perhaps dimly aware of her increasing deficit but, as is the case with many elderly with mental deterioration, she can still function well on some levels. She can still cook and prepare foods and repeat long sentences back to her doctor without missing a word. She's also cooperative, resigned to the change in her life. The heartbreak is in the face of her son who realizes that he has lost his mother forever even while she thrives physically. The staff at this nursing home are exemplary-- one does wonder how many of us could expect the kind of astute indulgence they give Ruth-- and the other residents are not threatening. The tragedy in "Familiar Touch" resounds through the prosaic expression of the anodyne movements and gestures of everyday life for a woman in Ruth's situation, in a nursing home: there is no possible reversal of this trajectory (as is hammered home by a scene at her former house where Steve arranges for her possessions to be removed).
Kathleen Chalfant, Carolyn Michelle, Andy McQueen, H. Jon Benjamin, London Garcia, Joahn Webb
Beautifully rendered account (fairly accurate) of the infamous Dreyfus affair in France in the late 1800's. Dreyfus is convicted of spying and sentenced to the brutal Devil's Island penal colony off the coast of French Guiana. A year later, a antisemite officer, Picquart, disturbed by inconsistencies in the record, decides to reinvestigate the case-- to confirm Dreyfus' guilt. Instead, he finds evidence of corruption in Dreyfus' trial and also determines that another soldier, Esterhazy, is the real spy. Of course, the establishment, averse to admitting error or prejudice, does everything it can to sustain Dreyfus' conviction. Dreyfus himself is not helpful: he is arrogant and inflexible and unpopular among his colleagues. Zola publishes his celebrated "J'Accuse" and himself goes to prison for a year. Eventually, Dreyfus is tried again, and again convicted, but he sentence is lightened and he is then pardoned. We end with Dreyfus asking for restitution from Picquart who refuses. The two have a distant respect for each other. Nitpickers may point out the resonance this case has with Polanski's own perceived injustices in America but... well, a matter of debate, surely.
Jean Dujardin, Pierre Forest, Louis Garrel, Jeanne Rosa, Emmanuelle Seigner, Benoit Allemane, Andrew Marcon, Mathieu Almlric
Beautifully nuanced, meditative film about a woman, Agnes, living in a small New England town while teaching at a small college coming to terms with a sexual assault she experienced as a younger student at the same college by a mentor, Decker. Unexpectedly light touch on the trauma, generous with small moments of humour and pleasure, non-ideological. Agnes' close friend Lydie tells her she is pregnant, ready to move on in life, to marriage and family in a different town. They talk about the abuse and we see a recap of the day after, of Agnes going to the ER to checked for possible disease, discussing whether to report the incident to the police. She decides not to, because he has a family. They report it to college officials who sympathetic but ineffectual. They discover he has resigned his position and is moving away. A fellow teacher, Natasha, is bitterly envious of Agnes' promotion and implies it is because she had sex with Decker, and then offers that she did as well.
Eva Victor, Naomi Ackie, Louis Cancelmi, Kelly McCormack, Lucas Hedges, John Carroll Lynch, Hettienne Park, Marc Carver
Vahid is a mechanic working in a shabby garage out in the country in Iran. One day, a couple and their child arrive after needing a repair to their vehicle. Vahid believes the man might be the government interrogator who tortured him and some fellow dissidents years ago. The man has an artificial leg that squeaks, a sound Vahid remembers all too well. He kidnaps him and takes him around to various associates to try to confirm who he is. Some of these scenes veer-- successfully-- into black comedy (they have him in a wooden box in a van upon which various individuals sit at times, and when his wife calls him because she has gone into labor, they actually go pick her up and bring her to the hospital, and demonstrable care that all is well with the birth event). The capture of Eghbal, the suspected intelligence agent, presents Vahid and his friends with a quandary: how do you address evil without becoming evil? At one point, Vahid wants to bury Eghbal alive, but as he travels around the city talking to his friends (who are also victims of torture) he engages in a lively discussion of the moral aspect of revenge. How do we not become what we despise, when we feel such a powerful urge to exact revenge? The plot--driven largely, outwardly, by the captors trying to determine if the man is who they think he is-- is elliptical and intriguing. Where is this going? It is also free of contrivance: we can't predict who will end up doing what. One of Eghbal's supposed victims is Shiva: we meet her shooting wedding photographs-- of a couple including Goli, who was also a victim. We can't even predict how the police will respond when one of the women in this group goes out with her head-covering. The story starts with Eghbal and his wife and daughter driving along at night when he hits some animal-- possibly a dog. The daughter is upset by the incident but the wife observes that it was "just an accident". Or god's will. Or the fault of the government for not having better streetlights. In same way, it is suggested, the fates of the victims of Eghbal seem random and inconsequential to the majority of people who are aware but do nothing. At one point Hamid, one of the victims, launches into a tirade about those who are passive in the face of evil. Panahi himself had been imprisoned by the Iranian regime and warned not to make any more films; he does so in defiance, though he edited this one in France (thus making it France's entry into the Best Foreign Film category at this year's Oscars).
Vahid Mobasseri, Mariam Afshari, Ebrahim Azizi, Hais Pakbaten, Majid Panahi, Mohamad Ali Elyasmehr, George Hashemzadeh
Sincere, perhaps, but modest documentary about a Norwegian man, Mats Steen, suffering from a degenerative muscular disease, who was able to establish a presence in the online gaming world for a time without disclosing his condition, but conspicuously avoiding any live interactions with the people who came to know him through his gaming identity, Ibelin. And the irresistible temptation to gloss over the parts of the story that don't feel as enriching. Ibelin could be annoying and angry. But online friends recall that he was encouraging at times. Many of them showed up for his funeral. A good part of the documentary consists of video game footage suggesting how his online world was rich and charming and offered him a fantasy that reality could not provide. Never quite more than interesting.
Max Steen, Trude Steen, Robert Steen, Mia Steen, Lisette Roovers, Kai Simon Frederiksen
Vastly over-rated drama about a writer, Aggie Wiggs, in the throes of self-pity after her young son, Cooper, was killed in a car accident and her wife left her suddenly finds her new neighbor, Nile Jarvis, who has been accused of murdering his wife, Madison, though her body was never found. Jarvis is creepy nice and the series plays with expectation: is he really innocent? Is he really a diabolically clever serial killer? And is there sexual attraction between the dowdy, morose, weepy Aggie and this sinister man? The plot expands and expands into a web of compromised FBI agents, real estate developers, politicians, and multiple contrivances not one of which is really very intriguing. You might enjoy the series if you don't find the later developments increasingly preposterous (can you really drag a body to another house and set it up to convincingly look like a murder by the householder; can you get an ostensibly intelligent psychotic killer to confess -- for a recording-- by provoking him into shouting it out). The dialogue sounds like it was written for the audience, not to express character or insight into character. When Aggie conducts her professional work or is interviewed or speaks, she sounds nothing like a professional writer. There just isn't any emotional or intellectual weight to her banal observations. When she is supposedly interviewing Nile for her book, she might has well be having tea with her house guests. Rhys as Jarvis is pretty good but Danes is all weepy suffering, fluttering grimace, and self-pity (even if she masks it as stoicism. She puts her trust in people we have no reason, as an audience, to see as trustworthy. She claims to have compelling proof of something that no lawyer would accept as decisive. She is supposed to be a very successful writer but doesn't seem to have an agent or representative (her publisher calls her directly). She is given to be a extremely good writer but we are told that by contrivance rather than example. Her former wife is supposed to a good enough painter to get a show in New York but the work we see is ridiculously bad. Don't waste your time.
Clare Danes, Matthew Rhys, Brittany Snow, Natalie Morales, Tim Guinee, Hettienne Park, Deirdre O'Connell, Aleyse Shannon, Bubba Weiler, Amir Arison, Jonathan Banks
Just watched Ken Burns' "The American Revolution". Aside from the inflated sense of global importance to the "revolution" and self-monumentalism, it was pretty good. It acknowledged the problem of slavery and the indigenous peoples. But you wouldn't know from Ken Burns that Canada, just a few miles to the north, developed its own responsible, accountable representative governmental institutions without all the violence and mayhem, and it eliminated slavery thirty years before the U.S. When I was in college in the 1970's, an American professor and a Canadian professor used to debate if the "revolution" was really revolutionary or just a war of independence. The Canadian, of course, thought it was merely a war of independence. The colonial governments were already fairly representative-- society did not radically change after the war (only white propertied men could vote) and real British policy was actually controlled by Parliament at the time. Aside from that, most of the series documented the sequence of battles-- a lot of which involved poorly planned supply lines and retreats-- and the squabbles over states' rights. Not very much on the historical or intellectual origins of "the rights of man" or the Constitution. I think Burns' wanted it that way: he is aware of his audience and he was aiming for the mainstream. He was provocative enough to earn some credibility (particularly in regard to the treatment of indigenous peoples) but the series lacked perspective. It pulled it's punches. The French Revolution was far more radical and historically important really-- and was a genuine revolution that had a massive impact on French society, abolishing tithes, limiting the authority of the church, confiscating church lands, ending the feudal system. But it also taught us radicalism has a terrible price.
Peter Coyote, Jeff Daniels, Morgan Freeman, Tom Hanks
Good but not quite great documentary about the celebrated bout between the young and hot George Foreman and the old but still feisty Mohammed Ali in 1974. It's all set up by Don King who approached both Foreman (heavyweight champion at the time) and Ali about a bout for world championship guaranteeing each of of them $5 million no matter who won. King didn't have the money but Mobutu Sese Seko, the brutal dictator of Zaire did. So the fight was set up for Kinshasa, in the middle of a very hot African summer. But then Foreman was cut during a practice round by a sparring partner so the fight was delayed by six weeks. The documentary also picks up on some musical performances in Kinshasa linked to the bout, including B. B. King and James Brown. The bout itself took place at 4:00 a.m. so it could be broadcast in prime time in North America. There is a lot footage of Ali doing his thing and it's not always really interesting, though he could be amusing. Ali was a media slut and he loved hearing himself even when he didn't really have anything important to say. Foreman was very taciturn, which made the fight more dramatic: it seemed a clash of cultures as well as style. The conclusion of the fight was stunning (it looked like Ali was going to lose decisively until the later rounds). The effect of years of boxing on Ali's brain was even more decisive. He died in 2016 of respiratory illness associated with Parkinson's. By all accounts, he was a very kind and generous person to the end of his life.
Don King, Mohammed Ali, George Foreman, George Plimpton, Norman Mailer, B. B. King, James Brown, Spike Lee, Thomas Hauser
The first season was compelling. A group of six thieves break into a Heathrow Airport warehouse managed by Brinks-Mat where, purely by coincidence, a massive pile of pure gold bullion, had been left in a relatively unprotected area. They steal it, and "The Gold" takes off as it is mainly about how to translate the gold bars, serialized and registered, into cash. We never learn exactly where all of the gold went but a lot of it was melted down and deliberately adulterated and then leaked into the system through various banks and gold jewelers who were not too reluctant to look the other way. You tend to root for the thieves, of course, but the police in "The Gold" is at great pains to lecture each other and the viewer on just how really naughty these men were, even when they don't seem to be behaving all that differently from the police, or other businesses. (When trying to arrest Kenneth Noye, the police, in masks, sneak onto his property -- why not just arrest him?-- in the dark and Noye kills one of the officers. A court believed his assertion of self-defense, even if the series doesn't.) In fact, an implicit point of the video is that the line between legitimate businesses (like a time-share vacation home deal) and theft is not all that thick. It's clearly personal for the detectives even if the show doesn't make that explicit (or even seem aware that it should be) who are humiliated when the bad guys keep winning in court (one of them, even after defending himself, even though he is dyslexic). By the end of the second season, most of the fun has gone out of it. And Boyce keeps lecturing us again and again. Note that the character of Nicki Jennings, the female detective who is repeatedly shown to be smarter and even faster than the men, is a complete fictionalization. I take that as a benchmark for the series' accuracy.
Hugh Bonneville, Emun Elliott, Charlotte Spencer, Tom Cullen, Stefanie Martini, Amanda Drew, Jack Lowden, Silas Carson, Sam Spruell, Cooper Cominic, Adam Nagaitis, Tom Hughes
Powerful story set in Taiwan in 1960 about a young boy, Xiao Si'r, who is struggling in school, having been demoted to night classes, and struggling to avoid being drawn into a local gang war among the other adolescent males. His father is mortified by his behavior and tries to sway his patron in town to facilitate his admission back into day high school. He pursues a girl, Ming, that he meets by accident, but she belongs to Honey, a gang leader who is in hiding after murdering someone. There is another gang member, Ma, who also wants Ming. There is a band that performs at the local hall but which also has affiliations with a gang which creates tension with other gangs. Si'r floats among these elements with a quiet form of detachment even while causing mischief (he spies on a local movie set to watch an actress change her clothes) but his connections to his family and community are thin. There is also the tension between the Chinese Nationalists who take over the government shortly after these events, and the indigenous Chinese of Formosa who resent their new overlords. Eventually, in an ending that is strikingly reminiscent of the beginning of the series "Adolescence", he acts decisively, tragically, and pays the consequences. Said to be based on a real story about a similar incident. And, even more oddly, the father and son in "Brighter Summer Day" are played by a real-life father and son, as in "Adolescence".
Change Chen, Lisa Yang, Kuo-Chu Chang, Elaine Jin, Chuan Wang, Han Chang, Hsiu-Chiung Chiang, Stephanie Lai, Chih-Kang Tan, Ming-Hsin Chang, Hui-Kuo Cho, Hsiao-Tsui Tang, Lin Hung-Ming, Hung-Yu Chen, Alex Yang, Danny Deng, Ming-Yang Shih
Documentary about how many school librarians around the country are actively resisting attempts by conservative Republicans to remove books they deem to be unpatriotic or sexually explicit. And the first problem with this documentary arises: there is no attempt to address the issue of left-wing or progressive attempts to ban books or "cancel" ideologically disagreeable expression. To be fair, the proportions are not the same but the issue is. In any case, many interviews and videos of city council or school board meetings in which passionately angry parents and stake-holders address the issue. And here is the second problem: there is lots of conflict and passion but not much overview or perspective on the issue, on the principles of censorship or school curriculums, on the psychology of adolescents struggling with sexual identity. I don't disagree with anything in this film but I didn't learn much from it either.
Suzette Baker, Weston Brown, Becky Calzada, Jeffrey Dove, Carolyn Foote, Courtney Gore
Tense, compelling drama undermined by plausibility issues. A ballistic missile is detected headed towards America-- Chicago, specifically-- and "A House of Dynamite" convincingly dramatizes the various components of the military and political activities carried out in response. The trouble is, the missile is of indeterminate origin. Russia or North Korea or China? They don't know. Submarine, perhaps-- but whose? North Korea might have one. In any case, for the plot to work, we are supposed to be engaged with the central problem of response, given a very brief time period, but the tension depends on the viewer believing that the Pentagon would advocate a nuclear response when it doesn't know who launched the missile. The movie gets fuzzy about who the president is supposed to target-- the fulcrum of this tension is whether he orders retaliation or not while the viewer doesn't even know who the military is suggesting is the target. The tension sputters and fizzles on this arc of evasion. That said, the superb attention to detail and the good acting holds your interest for a while. And I loved the way they showed-- accurately, I think-- the way defects and mistakes will intrude on any military or political plan of action. The Secretary of Defense, for example, wastes precious time calling his daughter: an obvious diversion to cheap sentiment in the middle of a high-pressure crisis. Missiles sent to take down the attacking bomb fail. Critical communications are confused. Generals and political advisors convey a sense that they are concerned about the loss of life, yes, but also about being criticized for a catastrophic failure. But when the Lieutenant-Commander carrying the bombing codes starts offering advice to the President (thereby undermining the entire chain of command) we encounter a false note, a cheap gesture. And the President calls his wife for no discernible reason. And I noted more than a few notes borrowed from "Dr. Strangelove", which remains a far, far better film on the same subject.
Idris Elba, Rebecca Ferguson, Gabriel Basso, Jared Harris, Tracy Letts, Anthony Ramos, Moses Ingram, Jonah Hauer-King, Greta Lee, Jason Clarke, Renee Elise Goldsberry, Kaitlyn Dever
Harsh, intimate biography of Christiane Felscherinow who wrote a book about her horrible descent into addiction and prostitution as a 14-year-old in Berlin in the 1970's. She starts out as an innocent if disconnected teenager who loves David Bowie and becomes attached to other kids her age who are experimenting with drugs. As her boyfriend, Detlef, resists her warnings and experiments with heroin ("H") she eventually joins him and in their desperation to find the next hit also joins him in prostituting herself at the Berlin "zoo", a subway station where other addicts ply their trade. Her mother is not abrasive but not particularly involved; her father is absent. Her step-father is incidental, neither a villain nor a helpful presence. Adults are just generally absent from the daily social and cultural lives of their children. Many of the supporting actors were also addicts or street-waifs-- and look it. "Christiane F" is not very interested in villains or heroes: just the facts, depicted with relentless authenticity, even if the actors are distinctly amateurish at times (Natja Brunckhorst, who was 14 when the film was made, as Christiane, is actually quite good). So at the price of acting chops you have something that feels more authentic and gritty and that works. Sometimes filmed on the streets, without permissions.
Natja Brunckhorst, Thomas Haustein, Jens Kuphal, Rainer Woelk, Jan Georg Effler, Christiane Reichelt, Daniela Jaeger, David Bowie, Andreas Fuhrmann, Christiane Lechle
Superb drama about the lives of the Bronte sisters about the time that their brother Branwell, who also had some artistic talent (painting and sculpture) began to decline into an alcoholic wreck, draining the family's financial resources and straining the lives of the girls and their father, Patrick Bronte, a pastor. The five of them lived in a parsonage owned by the church and the threat to their futures was palpable until the girls began to publish their celebrated novels. The movie quotes the hype-- none of the books by Anne, Emily, or Charlotte Bronte should really be classed with "the greatest in the English language"-- but the movie tactfully avoids the usual biopic kitsch (you can't do that! Nobody's ever done that!). The three secretly submit their manuscripts under the names of men, but the movie doesn't belabor the sexism. When they finally meet their publisher, he is shocked, yes, but also delighted (and he joyfully takes them out to the opera). The acting and filming are wonderful; the script is excellent.
Finn Atkins, Charlie Murphy, Chloe Pirrie, Jonathan Pryce, Rosie Boore, Lara McDonnell, Talia Barnette, Troy Tipple
Somewhat dubious documentary about the use of psychedelics to treat PTSD in veterans of war, specifically some seals, who are clearly suffering dramatic social dysfunction as a result of -- or concurrent with-- wartime trauma in Afghanistan or Iraq. Fascinating, but clearly compromised by advocacy. Who runs this clinic in Mexico that provides the ibogaine and 5-MeO-DMT treatments to the soldiers? Why are there three cameras (including a handheld) covering the treatment? Who is paying for it? How much does it cost? What is the history of the clinic? By omission, one suspects the results may not be as unambiguously successful as depicted. And I am ambivalent about men who are clearly drawn to the psychotic aspects of military action-- specifically the intense "brotherhood" of elite squads, and then find they can't manage a family, or act as a father to their own children. The wife of one of them loses her husband and mourns him and makes all the correct gestures of eternal love, and then rather quickly hooks up with one of the other Seals. Why no discussion of the other well-known experiments with LSD and magic mushrooms? Tantalizing but incomplete. Maybe the best part is the animations trying to dramatize the experience of the drugs. They are evocative and compelling.
Marcus Capone, DJ Shipley, Patsy Shipley, Brian Losey, Matty Roberts, Amber Capone
Striking documentary about volcanoes, focused on the work of Clive Oppenheimer, a researcher who studies them. Scarring visuals of the "infernos", the molten magma that becomes lava when it extrudes through the earth's crust, and the deadly clouds of gases at high temperatures that can cascade down mountainsides at an eruption.
Werner Herzog, Katia Krafft, Maurice Krafft, Clive Oppenheimer
An aging writer returns to his homeland as he approaches death. He sees a little boy being abducted by traffickers of some kind and tries to rescue him (by purchasing him) and send him back to his home in Albania. In the meantime, he ruminates over his life, his lost wife, his childhood, and the meaning of poetry and words (he asks the boys for words which he will pay for) in the face of death. Stilted, contrived at times, and occasionally evocative. Even less often, moving.
Bruno Ganz, Isabelle Renauld, Fabrizio Bentivoglio, Ahilleas Skevis, Iris Chatziantoniou
Also directed and written by Giraud & Szabo. Lovely, kinetic animation about a ladybug that gets separated from her family and ends up inadvertently helping black ants haul off a box of sugar cubes from an abandoned picnic site. When red ants spy the treat and attempt to take it by force, the ladybug gives critical help to the black ants. There is no dialogue-- just cute sound effects for speech-- and the background appears to be photographic video upon which the animations were superimposed. The film is based on a tv series "Minuscule - the private lives of insects". Probably more suited to older (8, 9, 10) kids than younger ones. But beautiful and engaging and never cheap or contrived.
From Netflix, a documentary on the sad demise of the Montreal Expos baseball franchise, and how a sequence of bad ownership decisions, shifting provincial priorities, and MLB's desire to have a franchise in Washington combined to bring an end to a remarkable team, which seemed likely to make the playoffs in 1994 just as the players went on strike. Interviews with fans, former players, and management tell the story of a beloved team that just could not survive in the rarified climate of super-heated player salaries and a government in Quebec that (rightly, in my opinion) refused to fund the building of a new stadium. But aside from that, the documentary is more glitz than substance. A lot of interviews and shots of great players like Pedro Martinez, Larry Walker, Felipe Alou, Vladimir Guerrero, and baseball writer Tom Verducci.
Tom Verducci, Vladimir Guerrero, Larry Walker, Jeremy Filosa, Claude Brochu, Jeffrey Loria, David Samson
I don't know how this ended up on my list. Charming if somewhat dry Japanese animation about a young girl, Shizuku Tsukishima, who sees a familiar name on several library books she has checked out. She develops a crush on the anonymous boy, Seiji Amasawa. We follow her through her daily life, going to school, studying for her high school entrance exams, hanging out with her friends, including Yuko Harada, dealing with her bossy sister Shiho, and her parents. When a boy picks up a book she left behind on a bench and reads her own lyrics to "Country Roads", she is embarrassed and angry, only to discover that he is the object of her romantic fantasies: Seiji. She also follows a cat to a house and discovers a grandfather who repairs exotic objects and runs a small store. They hit it off, of course, and she visits him, and then discovers that he is the grandfather of-- you guessed it-- Seiji. And of course she and Seiji eventually meet and share their dreams and so on. The last scene of the film was memorable: an extended cut of a walkway above a large abutment of some kind and the people and vehicles crossing above it. It evoked, in me, a sense of the utterly prosaic character of the lives of Shizuku and Seiya and the others in the film. It's all just life, walking, biking, eating, reading, passing the various phases of youth and age, marriage, tragedy (a police car, lights flashing, passes as well), and romance. It elevated the movie which was otherwise unremarkable. The animation was broad and artistically bereft, the faces were minimal, the movements were rote.
Yoko Hama, Issei Takahashi, Takashi Tachibana, Shigeru Muroi, Shigeru Tsuyuguchi, Keiju Kobayashi
I would never begrudge Bruce Springsteen privilege of spending time stewing on his own childhood traumas and episodes of depression and alienation. But is it art? "Springsteen: Deliver me From Nowhere" insists that we should all experience a meandering but bland excursion is his own sense of ennui and dislocation after a successful tour and three very successful, commercially and artistically, albums. But is it art? Bruce rents himself a modest-- well, not too modest-- little house in New Jersey where he contemplates his childhood and abusive father and works on some songs inspired by Terence Malick's powerful "Badlands" and Flannery O'Connor. He meets a young woman, Faye, at one of his gigs and they date for a time, and then he ghosts her. We are meant to understand that Springsteen is so beset by a moral or emotional crisis that he can't bring himself to continue the relationship. In this self-serving episode, she castigates him not for being an asshole (which he is, in this case) but for not giving her a chance to assuage his pain. Springsteen records his new songs on a 4-track (with an engineer) in his bedroom and then insists that the record company release it, without promotion or a follow-up tour. Again, for the convenience of the film, we are led to believe that it is a privilege for the record company to release Bruce Springsteen disks, rather than a privilege of a musical artist to be published. We know, if the scriptwriter doesn't, that the company is agreeing to pay a price to keep Springsteen on their roster, for the next album, and the next, which might have a few radio hits on them. The excretable "Born in the USA" gets an airing. Kurt Cobain might have pointed out that a large portion of the audience that embraced the song likely held believes about America that Springsteen would find repulsive. Springsteen dumps the girl and heads out to California where he has a breakdown and seeks therapy. It's all really rather dull and lifeless and actually caused me to re-examine my admiration for Springsteen, who obviously approved of the film (and even endorsed Jeremy Allen White to play him-- based on his performance in "The Bear", the last season of which featured a similarly dull excursion into self-pity. I realized that one of the problems is that Springsteen's songs are just not nearly as compelling as Dylan's, and his solo performances of the songs on "Nebraska" don't have nearly the bite or power of Dylan's solo performances. The secondary characters mostly serve as props or relate self-serving tropes as when we are told that Martin Scorcese wanted Springsteen to star in one of his films-- with Robert DeNiro!-- or when Jon Landau and the engineers in the studio dance about high-fiving each other over finally getting the "sound" of the Nebraska album "right", though Bruce isn't there to tell them that they have it and clearly they had no idea of what exactly he wanted. It's all very mom telling you you were great again, and tiresome, and dull. I was a bit shocked that this film followed the model of "Walk the Line" more than the far, far better "A Complete Unknown". Did the Springsteen brain trust not learn anything from the plethora of recent bio-pics, many of which were obviously contrived and self-serving? I really believe the effect of this film, in contrast to "A Complete Unknown", will be to diminish Springsteen's reputation as an artist. Oh-- and Jeremy Allen White, like Joaquin Phoenix in "Walk the Line", and most other actors impersonating musicians (and singing), is not a convincing substitute, and we know that actors love doing the voice because it practically guarantees and Oscar nomination.
Jeremy Allen White, Jeremy Strong, Paul Walter Hauser, Odessa Young, Stephen Graham, David Krumholtz, Gaby Hoffman, Grace Gummer, Marc Maron, Matthew Anthony Pellicano Jr.
A fable or fantasy about a young woman's coming of age, consciousness of her body, or menstruation, or sexuality, told with dancing vampires and horses and chickens and young maidens in gossamer white gowns dancing or frolicking outdoors and in. Generally incoherent and random and really pretty dull.
Jaroslava Schallerova, Helena Anyzova, Petr Kopriva, Jiri Prymek, Jan Klusak, Alena Stojakova
The fatal mistake in "Popstar", as in "A Mighty Wind", is to start falling in love with your own parody. Most of the hip-hop and rap songs in "Popstar" are written by the director and writer, Akiva Schaffer and Andy Samberg (with a lot of collaborators) and it feels like they started to think that their parodies were not all that unlike the real thing. Not that the real things, in this case, are worth shit (which makes this double mistake). Samberg is Conner who forms a band with his childhood friends Owen and Lawrence and rises to the top of pop stardom doing inane and absurd raps accompanied by visual effects and a DJ mix. Conner is the lead singer and starts to get attitude and decides to go solo, hurting the feelings of Lawrence, who quits to go into farming, and Owen, who stays to play the iPod at their gigs and slavishly adore Conner no matter how arrogant and rude he becomes. Conner pisses off all his friends and associates, begins to lose his popularity, and takes to drinking and drugs. Sound familiar? Ripe for parody-- again and again and again. Judd Apatow in charge, so there's a scene of male frontal nudity (but no female nudity that I can recall). The humor is vulgar and tasteless (including a scene in which Conner is exposed on stage with his penis taped back so it appears he doesn't have one, and another in which he tiresomely insists he's not gay while pleading for tolerance and acceptance of homosexuality). How did they persuade so many pop stars to appear as themselves, including a rather elaborate and mildly funny exercise with Seal being attacked by wolves when Conner proposes to his girlfriend, Ashley. The penultimate performance, a reunion of the original trio, with Michael Bolton (who deserved this). Paul McCartney makes an appearance (yawn), along with Carrie Underwood, Jimmy Fallon, and a list of rappers I never heard of. This is typical Saturday Night Live alumni slop, and typical of Judd Apatow. Sketch comedy that can't possibly earn the 90 minutes. Think of the last song in "Mighty Wind", "A Kiss at the End of the Rainbow", treated with actual reverence as if it was better than a banal parody.
Andy Samberg, Jorma Taccone, Akiva Schaffer, Sarah Silverman, Tim Meadows, Maya Rudolph, Joan Cusack, Imogen Poots, Chris Redd, Edgar Blackmon
Stilted at times but rewardingly loaded with location shooting around Italy right after the end of the war. Episodic: a little Italian boy steals a soldier's shoes. When he traces them back to the dismal building where poor children hang out, he turns away in shock, and leaves his shoes behind. A young woman guides a soldier to a castle only to see him shot by the Germans. She takes his gun and attacks them, even though she didn't seem to care much for him. A solider meets a beautiful young woman. He leaves for a time, on duty, and when he returns to look for her, he is approached by a prostitute. He complains about all the women in Italy becoming whores and talks about his beautiful Francesca. Francesca is the whore he is unknowingly talking to. She assures him that the innocent, beautiful, Francesca still lives in the town and leaves the address with him and waits, in vain, for him to show up. Partisans help American soldiers and British flyers of a shot-down plane but are attacked by Germans. The acting is generally wooden, the dialog seems badly improvised, by the story is compelling because of it's vital authenticity, it's connection to real experience of the war, and the locations of course. Three American chaplains stay at a monastery. They discover that the monks are antisemites when one of them realizes that one of the chaplains is a Jewish Rabbi. They also object to the protestant.
Carmela Sazio, Gar Moore, William Tubbs, Robert Van Loon, Benjamin Emanuel, Maria Michi, Harriet Medin, Merlin Berth, Dots Johnson
Ahmed is at school one day when the teacher, a harsh disciplinarian, ridicules and humiliates a fellow student, Mohamed Reza Nematzadeh, for not having his notebook. He has an excuse: he left it at his cousin's house by mistake. The cousin had the notebook. It is not enough to placate Moalem, the teacher, who reduces Mohamed to tears and warns him that he will be expelled if it happens again. Ahmed goes home at the end of the day and discovers that he has accidentally taken Mohamed's notebook with him. The film traces his determined efforts to get the notebook back to Mohamed, who lives in a small town walking distance away from Ahmed's home. The adults are unsympathetic, more concerned with their own problems than Ahmed's. His mother demands that he do his own homework before going out "to play", and then demands that he look after his baby sister, or help with the laundry. Ahmed finally sets out on his own, only to encounter repeated frustrations as he tries to locate Mohamed's home. We meet lots of Iranians, old people, women, other children, all carrying on with mundane tasks, none of whom helpful. We stay within Ahmed's point of view, his world, his perimeters. Ahmed is admirable but not dogmatic about the right thing to do. "Where is the Friend's House" is representative of one of the highest functions of film: to let us see how others live, what they feel and think, how they express themselves, without the narrative contrivances of Hollywood.
Babek Ahmedpoor, Ahmed Ahmedpoor, Defaei Khodabakhsh, Iran Outari, Ait Ansari, Sadika Taohidi, Biman Mouafi
Odd doesn't even begin to describe this film. There is a family, Sachiko, a seven-year-old girl, Hajime a teenage son, Ayano, an uncle, Yoshiko, the mom, Akira, the grandfather, and Nobuo, the father. They live in a modest little house, eat together, talk, and share. Sachiko keeps seeing a gigantic image of herself hovering over her, even at school, and watching her. She is convinced that doing a backflip off a horizontal bar will vanquish the ghost. Hajime is in love with a classmate, until she goes away, then loves another who joins the Go club. So he learns Go and joins too, and they hit it off. Grandpa writes a song and records it and films a bizarre but charming video. Nobuo is a hypnotherapist and has strange sessions with groups of women. Yoshiko works on animated films. By an hour into the film, I couldn't wait to see what would be conjured up next-- it works on you. It establishes a quirky, meditative mood through extended shots (as of Hajime peddling furiously on his bike, as if to expel overwhelming desire for Aoi), Sachiko trying to do backflips, or just watching her giant self with a serious expression, Nobuo leading his group in relaxation techniques through hypnosis. It really grows on you, partly by withholding the obvious predictables, the resolutions of the tensions it raises. Will Sachiko do the backflip? Will the recording become a hit? Will Hajime get the girl (I think he does)? There are moments of lilting sadness and regret, and moments of delightful quirk, oddball conversations, seemingly banal activities, all of which ultimately charm.
Tomokazu Miura, Satomi Tezuka, Maya Banno, Takahiro Sato, Tadanobu Asano, Tatsuya Gashuin, Tadanobu Asano, Tomoko Nakajima, Anna Tsuchiya, Kaiji Moriyama
Roman Polanski's excellent-- and conspicuously accurate-- retelling of the Dreyfus scandal through the eyes of the head of French army intelligence, Marie-Georges Picquart, an antisemite who personally disliked Dreyfus and thought, at first, that his conviction and court martial were just. But Picquart is a James Comey type: a boy scout who insists on honor and integrity even in the face of a corrupt military establishment determined to preserve their reputations, even at the expense of acquitting a real German spy. Picquart discovers letters written by a French soldier of which the hand-writing matches exactly the alleged letter Dreyfus sent offering to sell information to the Germans. When his superiors discover that he can't be dissuaded from pursuing the matter, they transfer him out of the intelligence department to other cities in France and even to Tunisia. When he returns, he is more determined than ever to make things right, resulting in his own imprisonment (along with writer Emile Zola). There is no Spielbergian happy ending here. Public outcry (though the nation was extremely divided) did force a retrial, during which a witness blundered by making reference to a document the generals knew was compromised, but Dreyfus was convicted again, though his sentence was reduced. He was eventually pardoned. Superbly acted and filmed, briskly edited, smart, and passionate, this is Polanski at his best. In spite of the obvious qualities of the film, and it's acclaim in most quarters, Richard Brody of the New Yorker claimed that the film slyly defends Polanski and tries to rationalize his public disgrace. As Dreyfus observed: I am guilty if I wrote the letter, and guilty if I did not (his accusers idiotically agree). Brody is wrong. The film actually presents an extremely balanced view of all the main characters. Dreyfus himself is no angel-- his proud and demanding; and Picquart was no progressive, and was openly prejudiced against Jews and said so. He suggests a "linchpin" is "the distinction between private and public life" as if Polanski makes the argument, in the film that nobody has a right to judge him for his private behavior. That is a big stretch and an ignorant perspective on a film that accurately and powerfully relates a story of such historic and political and cultural significance.
Jean Dujardin, Louis Garrel, Pierre Poirot, Stefan Godin, Gregory Gadebois, Wladimir Yordanoff, Fincent Perez, Emmanuelle Seigner, Herve Pierre, Kevin Garnichat, Laurent Natrella, Mathieu Amalric, Andre Marcon
Based on the novel by Tove Jansson. Inert story about a young girl, her father, and her grandmother, travelling to a harsh-- and rather ugly-- island cottage for a time after the mother, wife, daughter-in- law has died. Inertia should not be confused with subtlety or tastefulness. The bizarre configuration of this film betrays the fundamentally self-serving role of producer Glenn Close. Why does she and "Father" speak English with accents (vaguely Scandinavian) when the family would obviously speak Finnish to each other (or fluid English if they really want to be that friendly to American audiences)? Why the exaggerated aged trope (Grandmother is practically a cripple, and her face is a prosthetic mask)? It reeks of Oscar bait (Close openly craves one and believes she deserves it). We are "treated" to extensive adoring closeups of the aging Glenn Close-- even a shocking flash of nudity-- even when she really doesn't have anything cinematic to do. Why does Father jump out of the boat when the engine fails, in a storm, and swim back to shore towing the boat (in his thick clothes and coat)? Why is he even out there napping in the boat in the first place? Actually-- why is he even there? He is just another character in recent films who serves as a proxy for all the allegedly useless dads out there who, in the view of the writer and director, have nothing significant to contribute to family life. He is erased, invisible, irrelevant. He has no life, no history, no emotional resonance of any kind. And while not unbelievable it does stretch the willing disbelief of the audience to have Sophia out there with no playmates, no friends, no child-friendly diversions. The actors are generally okay-- because nothing much is demanded of them. The entire project is a miscalculation, a trite pastiche of fake significance. Nell Minow at rogerebert.com says it conveys "profound thoughts about time, memory, loss, and nature through a simplified, meditative, cinematic language of exquisite images and gentle music". Well, the cinematography-- like the music-- is banal, and the profundity, I think, is all in Minow's head. She sees the superficial characteristics of a serious art film-- the austere setting, the accents, the narrative inertia-- and mistakes it for real profundity.
Emily Matthews, Glenn Close, Anders Danielsen Lie
Sinan Karasu has just returned to his modest family home from college, filled with arrogance and cynicism about his career prospects, his friends, and especially his father, who has lost the family home and car to his gambling addiction. Sinan has written a proposal for a book ("free of any faith, ideology and allegiance") entitled "The Wild Pear Tree" for which he seeks a patron; he tries the mayor and a wealthy industrialist but no one is interested. He chats with a girl and here a pattern emerges. He disparages the village and its residents and the girl thinks-- he's including me. He does the same with his own family, and with a writer he meets at a local bookstore, who is remarkably patient with the arrogant would-be writer, until he explodes in a torrential take-down of Sinan's ego that every aspiring writer should hear. And yet, he doesn't discourage Sinan: he just encourages him to find a more authentic voice, and to not condescend to the people who are the subject of his stories. Sinan is, in short, an asshole. He takes the exam to become a teacher but doesn't study for it and is rejected. He helps his father with a well he is trying to dig on a family property outside of town, but finds that his father is also the subject of ridicule from his father, Sinan's grandfather. His father owes money everywhere and is a disgrace to his family. Sinan catches a local Iman stealing apples from a try and engages in a long discussion with him and another young Iman on the nature of Islam and society and truth. Sometimes a character falls asleep and dreams (near the end, a shocking dream). Sinan self-publishes his book but, with limited prospects elsewhere, joins the army. The last part of this long movie is his return home, changed, visibly and psychologically. It works, and lifts the movie, because it is fully consonant with what has come before. The story, we are told, is inspired by writer Akin Aksu's father, and Sinan is based on Aksu himself, and it was filmed-- beautifully-- in Ceylan's childhood environ, Canakkale. There is something about Ceylan's immaculate compositions and selective movements that defy the length: every scene is striking and lovely and yet uncontrived. Music is sparse: mostly an orchestral pitch of Bach which lightly and moodily accents the sequence.
Dogu Demirkol, Murat Cemcir, Bennu Yildirimlar, Hazar Erguclu, Serkan Keskin, Tamer Levent, Oner Erkan, Akin Aksu, Ahmet Rifat Sungar, Kadir Ermik, Ercument Balakoglu, Sencar Sagdic, Sencar Sagdic
Chris and his daughter Sam and Chris' friend Matt set out on a hike along a wilderness trail in New York State. Matt's son, Dylan, decides to not accompany them at the last minute. Matt is kind of a dork-- he even forgets his sleeping bag in the car-- and Chris is not much better. The film reeks of a hatchet job on men in general. Sam cooks and cleans the dishes and imparts loads of precious wisdom to the two men, because, you know-- she's a girl. The men don't seem to have any means of navigation-- they just follow a trail without complication. Chris asks Sam if she is excited about "college", as if there was no particular college she was going to-- just, you know, a college. Then one night, while Chris is asleep, Matt proposes that Sam come into his tent to warm him up. I am not capable to giving this the weight director Donaldson clearly wishes it to have. Sam is devastated and hurt, and even more devastated and hurt when her father is dismissive of the impropriety. She takes revenge but loading his backpack with rocks while he is doing something somewhere. Then she sets out on her own to finish the trail, without explanation. Her father then asks her to drive, which some accept as a token of recognition of something. That he is an asshole, like all men? Do I take any meaning from the fact that they drive a Subaru? One cannot imagine that the writers or director ever went on an overnight hike near any kind of wilderness. Nor can one imagine that anyone involved has any clue about father-daughter relationships. I'm not saying there aren't dim-witted dads out there capable of being ignorant about their daughter's feelings: but no relationship of that duration could be so bereft of intuition or complexity or history or culture. The relationship has no personality, so when we are asked to recognize something tragic about his indifference to her angst about Matt's improper gesture, we whiff. Final note here: Sheila O'Malley at RogerEbert.com inexplicably raved about the film and gave it 4 our 4 stars. She should be impeached for malpractice. No matter how sympathetic you are to the muted politics of this film, no responsible critic should be giving this film the same rating as "The Godfather" or dozens of other acclaimed filmed. That is insane.
Lily Collias, Sumaya Bouhbal, James Le Gros, Danny McCarthy, Julian Grady
"Last Stage" was partly shot in Auschwitz (Birkenau) and director Jakubowska was a prisoner there. The Polish actors who played Germans learned to speak German for their parts. Not brilliant film-making but utterly compelling for it's proximity to the real events, it's locations, and willingness to depict the complex moral conundrums presented by the kapos (Jewish prisoners given some benefits in exchange for managing their fellow prisoners, pressing them into the gas chambers, and removing the bodies. Dwells on the "hospital" and desperate attempts to treat ill prisoners, and the corruption when a new head nurse is appointed who is mainly interested in collecting jewelry and stealing food. The camp looks messy and shabby (muddy and wet); the prisoners look, as you would expect, too well-fed to be convincing, but it is a practical concession for the times. The acting is better than you might expect, and the crowd scenes are extraordinary. Really a very special, very important film.
Wanda Bartowna, Huguette Faget, Tatyana Guretskaya, Antonina Gordon-Gorecka, Marija Vinogradova, Barbara Drapinska, Barbara Fijewska, Anna Lutoslawska, Aleksandra Slaska, Edward Dziewonski, Wladyslaw Broschwicz, Halina Drohocka
How must if have felt to grow up knowing that your father is regarded by most of the world as a heinous monster? The commandant of Auschwitz, Rudolph Hoss? "Command's Shadow" sets out to find out, a bit elliptically: it also picks up the story of the daughter of a survivor of Auschwitz, and her mother's story. Anita Lasker-Wallfisch played the cello, and thus survived, after the Nazis put her in the band that accompanied the selections at Auschwitz-Birkenau. Hans Jurgen Hoss was the son of Rudolph Hoss. The film alternates between the two, comparing memories and attitudes. Hans is uneasy-- he says his father was a very kind man, a good father, and sometimes seems to suggest that he was just following orders. Lasker-Wallfisch is very comfortable with declaring, at first, she has no interest in revisiting the camp, or meeting Hoss. Then she decides she will meet him. Neither party gets sentimental about the experience. It is uncomfortable, clearly, for Hoss, but Lasker-Wallfisch admires his courage for doing it. Hoss' son (Rudolph's grandson) is an evangelical minister who is a bit glib about the whole thing, while acknowledging the weight of history. One feels that he isn't really deeply aware of the complexity of it all. There is a daughter who is still alive at the time of filming (Inge-Brigitt Hoss, a former fashion model): she is even more ambiguous about Hoss' role, defensive, and in denial. She has to be pressed to admit that her father was a great mass-murderer. Not brilliant as documentary but often fascinating and even moving. Good companion to "Zone of Interest". There was another documentary we saw years ago in a similar vein, interviews with children of survivors and children of Nazis-- some of whom continue to deny the holocaust. Can't remember the name of it. Another Son, Rainer Hoss, is controversial: he was convicted of fraud and of exploiting historical interest in his family.
Anita Lasker-Wallfisch, Maya Lasker-Wallfisch, Hans Jurgan Hoss, Kai Hoss
Flabby, over-long, shapeless story about a radical activist (including bombs), Bob Ferguson, and his lover, Perfidia. She is caught and he escapes, along with their daughter, Willa. He goes into hiding and spends the next decade in a haze of drug use and inertia. Willa grows up and Bob's arch enemy, Colonel Steven Lockjaw, is in pursuit. And large stretches of the movie are nothing but pursuit, but again, with the exception of the last high way scenes, the pursuits are flabby and tiresome. If there is a point in here somewhere, I missed it, meaning I had to spend two hours watching the most artistically deprived major actor in Hollywood, DiCaprio, hog the screen, grunting and squelching his face up, and swearing in fury at various impediments. Allegedly based on Thomas Pynchon's "Vineland", Thomas's adaptation could only make partial sense if you knew the ending at the start of the movie. But you don't-- so the point of Lockjaw's obsessive pursuit is so elusive you wonder why all those men in fatigues even bother. There are holes in the sequences (how did Willa even know that the car behind her chasing her down? Why did her rescuer disappear? Why do we even care? Bob is not likeable on any level, not even as a buffoon, which he clearly is. Perfidia disappears from the film-- inexplicably, really. Willa had good reason treat her dad with contempt (he is contemptible, but somehow we are supposed to be moved by her affection for him in the end). Why does the White Nationalist organization even bother with Lockjaw after the revelation? Why does Anderson waste so much narrative juice on the chase scenes, which don't really evoke much of any kind of sensibility while making casual reference to real social and political issues (illegal immigration).
Leonardo DiCaprio, Sean Penn, Benicio Del Toro, Regina Hall, Teyana Taylor, Wood Harris, Alana Haim, Shayna McHayle
Apparently the story was based on a real homosexual relationship between screenwriter Arthur Laurents and Farley Granger. Could that be why the supposed romance between Hubbell and Kate is such a dud? And I mean, a total, mind-numbing, static dud? Noted that Laurents was also a victim of the blacklist in the 1950's. Laurents also felt that Pollack had "fucked up" the movie. Redford also informs us that Streisand had a crush on him during filming but he didn't return her feelings. He believed-- seriously-- that she was giving a brilliant performance and he didn't want to impinge on it. This is bizarre on every level: so many scenes consist of Streisand staring at Redford and you sense that she thinks she is conveying some kind of deep feeling. The only deep feeling that is apparent is her narcissism. She radiates "look at me-- I'm gorgeous!" which might of work had she been at all gorgeous. Pollack excised critical political scenes (including Hubbell informing Katie that "someone had informed on her"-- endangering his career) in order to concentrate on what he bizarrely believed was a compelling love story. The first preview showing feel flat which led to the dreary song being repeated over the zoom out at the end. Anyway. Katie Morosky is a young Jewish communist activist in college while Hubbell Gardiner is a soldier, a conservative mid-western type, dozing at a bar. After a lengthy gaze by Katie, they meet, they argue, they socialize, they go to parties, they go to bed, argue some more, get married, have a baby, then separate. Hubbell, we are given to believe, is a great writer, and eventually he relocates to Hollywood to write compromised screenplays. Katie remains and activist, has a baby, continues to protest against war, against Franco, against HUAC. Years after they separate, they have a cringy meet in New York City-- again, the overly-long gazes, the cringy chat while Hubbell's girlfriend watches silently, the delayed inquiry about the daughter. The biggest problem is that I could never-- not for an instant-- believe in the relationship. Katie is annoying, self-righteous, and boring. She hectors and lectures people. She has no charming or endearing personality traits. Hubbell is so passive that it is hard to even imagine him cheating on her. His writing sounds like a pastel imitation of what a sophomore thinks F. Scott Fitzgerald sounds like. Katie's politics sound like what a sophomore thinks progressive politics sounded like in the 1930's. Drab and dreary.
Barbra Streisand, Robert Redford, Bradford Dillman, Lois Chiles, Patrick O'Neal, Viveca Lindfors, Allyn Ann McLerie, Murray Hamilton, Herb Edelman, Diana Ewing
Leslie Koren was a troubled teenager who was sent, by her parents, to Oakley behavior modification centre in Utah for several years. She graduated. Then she realized or decided that she had PTSD from the terrible experience of being separated from her family and institutionalized at Oakley. It is not clear who runs Oakley, from this documentary, or what kind of treatment she received, or why she concludes that it was traumatizing. This is a somewhat self-serving documentary that simply omits crucial information about her experience, about the centre, about what caused her to be sent there, and why it closed down in 2017(?). She interviews other former students who share their own experiences, with varying perceptions of what the experience actually was. Frustratingly oblique, somewhat moving at times, sometimes suggestive that some of us seek causes for personal grievances. What was the mission of the school? Who set it up, designed the curriculum, and what forms of discipline were used? We don't learn anything about that from this film.
Leslie Koren
Lovely pastoral about three sisters who, upon the death of their father, who was absent from their lives for 15 years, discover a step sister, whom they adopt. They discover, through her, some nuance in their picture of their father, and their mother. Like Ozu, Koreeda focusses on small, telling details. Unlike Ozu, he doesn't have much to tell. But you don't feel bad about that: what you get instead is a sensitive, delicate portrait of families and hope and affection and humor: the stuff of most human relationships.
Haruka Ayase, Masami Nagasawa, Kaho, Suzu Hirose, Ryo Kase, Ryohei Suzuki, Midoriko Kimura
Mary's mother, a brilliant mathematician (did they have to go overboard and suggest that she was one of the greatest math geniuses to ever live?), committed suicide when Mary was six months old. Mary was taken in by Diane's brother, Frank, and has lived with him ever since. Frank is supposed to be smart (he was a college professor) but he never bothered to legalize his custody of her. There are good reasons why, in real life, this makes him stupid or at least insufferably negligent (how did he register her for school?). Her grandmother, Evelyn has had no contact with Mary ever since Diane died but suddenly, at the promptings of a nasty school principal, decides that she must take custody so that she can put Mary, who is a prodigy, into a special school for gifted children because she believes she owes it to the world of mathematicians. Frank opposes her because he wants her to have a "normal" childhood, with friends, and playdates, and red hats, and so on. They end up in court, which decides that Mary should live in a foster home while being evaluated for custody. The main problem with this entire schematic is that the narrative is frequently at odds with itself. Would a judge in this case really decide that Frank, whom we are given to understand is a great father, should lose custody to a an absentee grandmother with a whiny British accent? One assumes there would have been issues, but if you show the issues, then the audience won't feel all righteous and holy when the mean grandmother tries to seize custody. We're supposed to admire Mary's genius but root for Frank when he wants her in a normal class and wants her to act like any redneck child. (Okay-- we aren't shown that Frank is a redneck but, hey, I can read between the lines.) Frank is supposed to be a great dad but he dumps Mary on a babysitter (Roberta) on Friday night so he can hang out at a bar-- what's missing here? He gets angry when Mary "breaks the rule" and comes into his house early in the morning on Saturday-- I presume because he often has a girl over, but the film leaves that out. The "great dad" suddenly decides he's not worthy of Mary and agrees to leave her in a strange foster home for the assessment process. We never see any authentic detail about Frank's caring for Mary, nothing beyond the most obvious schematic: making her breakfast cereal, telling her to go to bed, joking around. Does he do the wash? Make her bed? Change her sheets? He says do your homework but the film couldn't be bothered with working out details of how he might help her with it. Well, audiences probably don't want to be bothered with that kind of gritty detail either. We are supposed to be dazzled by Mary's brilliance but this film doesn't really admire intelligence. It admires the rugged Frank, honest, hard-working, unpretentious. Mary's intelligence is not threatening because it's filtered through her adoration of Frank, and neighbor Roberta (the black character that validates Frank's decency, and soul). Evelyn has an English accent so mid-western American audiences can identify the villain quickly. But would a judge really readily offer a shot at custody to an absentee grandmother with a snotty accent? The film is mostly rubbish, really poorly acted except for Mckenna Grace as Mary. Poorly filmed. Mediocre music. But, yes, a lot of people will enjoy this unchallenging pastiche. Similar to "Good Will Hunting" and "Say Anything" in that it admires intelligence only insofar as it validates redneck authenticity: I may swill beer, play with guns, drive a gas-guzzling 4-wheel drive pick-up truck, and vote MAGA, but smart people love me.
Mckenna Grace, Chris Evans, Elizabeth Marvel, Lindsay Duncan, Jenny Slate, Jon Skiaroff, Octavia Spencer
Why does this film even exist? Two Russian men meet a stranger who claims to be an alien. He has a little device which they handle and which accidentally transports them to an alien planet. There they meet several aliens who, at first, only say "koo". Eventually it is discovered that they speak Russian, and sometimes English. On this planet, matches are very valuable, and the two Russians try to negotiate with them for water and food and transport home. It doesn't really seem all that dangerous-- just baffling. The aliens travel around in shabby-looking pods or a weird wheeled cart. Much of the dialogue is ad-libbed.
Stanislav Lyubshin, Evgeniy Leonov, Yuriy Yakovlev, Levan Gabriadze, Olga Mashnaya, Irina Shmelyov, Lev Perfilov
Searing, moody diagnosis of Leni Riefenstahl, Hitler's worshipful documentarist, maker of "Triumph of the Will" and "Olympiad", both rabidly pro-Nazi films that gloried in the power, majesty, and racial purity of the Germans under Nazi rule. Atmospheric at times, and featuring generally clumsy interviews with Riefenstahl in which she tries desperately to evade any responsibility for Nazi atrocities, while clearly sustaining a strong admiration for Hitler and the Nazi regime. Her claims of ignorance of the horrors of the concentration camps are not completely uncreditable. There is a photo of her reacting to an army unit shooting 20 Jews in Poland when she asked that they be "removed" for a scene she was filming, and she does appear to be horrified. But her anger and defensiveness boil over only confirming to the viewer her culpability. Even more disturbing: the Germans who applaud her statement that she really didn't know what was happening until after the war, and their insistence that the world judges them unfairly. She insists that "everybody" thought Hitler was great until late in the regime. Investigators concluded that she could have been that naive and she was freed soon after the end of the war and ended up living well, walking with Albert Speer (another "innocent"), and, later, making films among the Nubians in Africa where she lived with them and conspicuously admired their culture. Strange, unsettling movie. Good companion movie to "Zone of Interest".
Leni Riefenstahl, Ulrich Noethen, Ernest Ostro, Albrecht Knaus, Dieter Wild, Joseph Goebbels, Rudolph Hess, Adolf Hitler, Albert Speer
Samet is a secondary school teacher assigned to some remote outpost in an area of the mountains Turkey subject to intense winters. He lives with Kenan, another teacher, whom he introduces to a woman he met online, Nuray, who has prosthetic leg after surviving a suicide bombing. Samet was not interested in pursuing a relationship with the woman until he realizes that she and Kenan have hit it off (he is teaching he to drive). Meanwhile, at school, a student, Sevim, has accused both Samet and Kenan of "inappropriate" behavior, rather milder than expected (pinching cheeks and putting arms on shoulders) but potentially damaging. What to make of Samet? He seems sinister at times-- is he grooming Sevim? Or is he just perhaps more friendly than proper for a teacher (a male student in his class complains-- in class-- that he favors certain female students when asking questions). He lies to Nuray (she catches him) and to Kenan, and to his principal. In Ceylan's devotion to realism, there is no intense scenes of resolve, confession, anger, confrontation. As in so much of real life, characters evade and procrastinate, and obfuscate. Even when Nuray confronts him in the presence of Kenan, instead of confession or acknowledgment or apology, we get Nuray asserting her rights as a person, as a woman, and taking Kenan to task for not responding to her messages after (as she guesses) Samet has told him, cryptically, perhaps, that he spent the night and had sex with Nuray. The film is based largely on a diary kept by Akin Aksu of his own experience as a teacher in a similar region. Beautifully filmed and superbly acted, though there are extended scenes of dialogue that do seem to ramble on repetitively for a time. In some cases there is a pay-off: the scene in which Nuray seems to reluctantly accent to sex with Samet is rich with ambivalence and melancholy and reservation-- and yet, she clearly consents and seems affirmed by Samet's acknowledgment of her prosthetic leg. The incident with the students-- the complaint-- is based on a real incident.
Deniz Celiloglu, Merve Dizdar, Musab Ekici, Ece Bagci, Erdem Senocak, Yuksel Aksu, Munir Can DCindoruk, Onur Berk Arslanoglu, Cengiz Bozkurt, Ferhat Akgun, Nalan Kurucim
Soyo Magita is the oldest girl in her small rural school which has a total of six students. She is in the senior class. There is a new boy in town, Hiromi Osawa, just moved to the community from Tokyo. Soyo, in voice over, tells us she thinks he is gorgeous. So begins a long, liltingly measured semi-romantic, but very innocent, relationship. "Gentle Breeze in the Village" is about transitions, from small town life, to graduating senior, to high school. It sensitively explores Soyo's mixed feelings about Hiromi, about school, about moving on to high school, about Hiromi-- who isn't entirely interested in her, though she offers to kiss him as a graduation gift. Soyo's father doesn't like Hiromi (because he comes from a broken family, disgraced by his father's affair) and provides the only "tension" in the story, though even this is modulated. Pastoral, gentle, quiet, meditative, and sweet. I enjoyed it even while conscious of just how little happens, and how clumsy some of the scenes are (as when Soyo gets her foot stuck in a railroad track) .
Kaho, Masaki Okada, Elisa Yanagi, Shoko Fujimura, Yui Natsukawa, Koichi Sato, Saya Miyazawa
Ridiculously bizarre pastiche of a young Japanese girl in a sailor suit (or ball gown) taking on leadership of a Yakuza gang that inadvertently took possession of a large cache of heroin badly wanted by other gangs. Izumi Hoshi is the girl, impish, insouciant, ultimately very moral and very violent (she decries murder but ends up joining the carnage). Her four gang members are comically incompetent except when they're not, and her enemy, fatso, is pretty incompetent too. The shoots are chaotic by movie standards: they make no sense, either as parody or action. But the light-hearted tone of parts of the film belies the actual violence (people do die, bloodily). The cinematography seems accidentally bad, the music is banal, the acting is operatic at best and comical at worst. Hoshi's role in the film is quite chaste, though there is brief nudity of one of her henchman making love to Mayumi Sandaiji, a woman who came to care for her after her father died in a car accident but turns out to be implicated in the rival Yakuza gangs. This is really kind of a trashy movie that might be interesting to see from a sociological point of vew: it was a huge hit in Japan.
Hiroko Yakushimaru, Tsunehiko Watase, Rentaro Mikuni, Yuki Kazamatsuri, Kazuo Kitamura, Akira Emoto, Shinpei Hayashiya
The biting topicality of this film is emasculated by diversions into extended shoot-outs and contrived surprises that don't really surprise so much as baffle. Joe Cross is the laconic sheriff of Eddington, a small town in New Mexico, that is angling for a new computing centre while dealing with the Covid panic. Most of the town, and the mayor's office, are pro-mask, but Cross is not and he defends others who defy regulations on the issue. Meanwhile, Cross's wife and mother-in-law are buried in conspiracy theories, and meanwhile again, Black Lives Matter erupts in town with a number of young people protesting, while also affirming that the land the town is built on belongs to indigenous peoples. It's all messier than the real thing: the polarization descends into incoherence, partly, I suspect, because director/writer Aster doesn't want to take responsibility for one side or the other. Clearly the conspiracy theories are bit whacky, but then what is it that happens in the last reel to take down Sheriff Cross? The subplot in which Cross tries to pin a crime on his deputy is neither here nor there, therefore neither, therefore both, therefore boring and predictable. There is also the affair or rape the Mayor may have committed with Cross's wife twenty years earlier which fuels his hatred for the Mayor. Phoenix is pretty good in the role, though he mumbles a lot, as usual, and the secondary actors are okay, but the music drags and the chase scenes-- probably intentionally preposterous-- also drag. The great disappointment is that the first major film to take on the Covid crisis falls flat and fails to engage with any really salient issues.
Joaquin Phoenix, Deirdre O'Connell, Emma Stone, Micheal Ward, Pedro Pascal, Cameron Mann, Matt Gomez Hidka, Luke Grimes, Amelie Hoeferie, Austin Butler, William Belleau, Keith Jardine
Co-directed by Sydney Pollack (so it says); from a story by John Cheever. The movie is baffling until you realize what is going on. Ned Merrill meets some friends in the backyard of their house at their pool. Everything is convivial and cheerful and he spontaneously decides to swim through pool after pool in a chain from where is to his own pool and his own house. Everyone loves him. Women seem ready to strike up an affair. A former babysitter (he has a wife and two daughters) joins him for a section of the journey and tells him how much she adored him-- so much so that she stole one of his shirts. But when he begins to lean in to her, she flees. (The actress, Janet Landgard, was 34 years younger than Lancaster). This is the first clue that what we are watching is not a banal narrative about a physical journey, but a metaphorical journey through Ned's soul. And the soul becomes uglier and uglier the further along his journey he takes us. It begins with a woman telling him to leave her property because of his neglect of someone in need in a hospital. An unresolved affair. Friends he borrows from and never repaid. Understood this way, the film improves significantly. What doesn't improve is the archaic style of long, lingering shots of faces expressing strong desire-- overly long, by modern standards. And then there are certain montages that do not work, and a sequence obviously filmed in a studio after extensive location shoots elsewhere. There are voice-overs that don't always work either, and the music by Marvin Hamlisch is bombastic and overbearing. Lancaster was 52 at the time of filming (and had had cosmetic surgeries). He did not get along with Director Frank Perry-- neither did the studio-- so Sydney Pollack took over late in production.
Burt Lancaster, Janet Landgard, Janice Rule, Tony Bickley, Tony Bickley, Marge Champion, Nancy Cushman, Bill Fiore, Kim Hunter, Bernie Hamilton, House Jameson, MIchael Kearney, Richard McMurray, Diana Muldaur, Jan Miner
Locke is a reporter working in Chad, shooting film interviews with rebel leaders and the dictator of Chad, Francois Tombalbaye, and a witch doctor, and fruitlessly questing after more dynamic material. A man he meets there, Robertson, staying at the same shabby motel, dies in his room. Locke, dissatisfied with his life (we don't learn much about that until later) decides to assume Robertson's identity. He sets things up to make it look like he is the one who had the heart attack, switches photos on the passports, and sets out to discover Robertson's life. Unfortunately, Robertson was involved in some activities of dubious legality-- weapons dealing-- and this puts Locke into potential trouble. Locke, the objective reporter, escapes into the life of a man directly involved in action, a participant. It is suggested that he is on the side of "good" rebels. He is engaged, while Locke expresses despair at his life as a "reporter" who must remain disengaged. Along the way, he meets a charming young woman, "Girl", and they travel together to various meetings scheduled by Robertson in his diary. Why? It's not clear why Locke feels drawn to adhere to Robertson's schedule, but we know it will be trouble. Beautifully film, well edited and directed, and generally well-acted, with the exception of Schneider. She works in the role but clearly doesn't always know what to do with her lines. (I discovered that she was at times heavily medicated for a back problem. Ah ha.) The scenery is fabulous-- all location shooting, including Algeria-- and the story is compelling. The final shot, a very long continuous sequence, is a marvel. What if you could give up your identity and live someone else's life for a while? This is Jack Nicholson's favorite of his own films. The execution of a prisoner by firing squad is real.
Jack Nicholson, Maria Schneider, Jenny Runacre, Ian Hendry, Steven Gerkoff, Ambrose Bia, James Campbell, Charles Mulvehill
Atrocious, disorganized, slop. Allegedly a sequel to the exquisite "Wings of Desire" (or "Heaven Over Berlin"). Cassiel, who chose to remain an angel, in the earlier entry, sees a young girl about to fall from a great height and magically becomes human in time to catch her. He revels in becoming human-- which is contrary to the spirit of the original (the whole point of the original is that there was a reason Cassiel remained an angel) and that tension fueled the beauty of Damiel's embrace of it. Cassiel loses the money he gets for his armor quickly and embarks on a life of crime, even stealing a gun to use to rob a convenience store. He links up with an organized crime figure (and saves his life) but revolts when asked to deal weapons and porn. We don't learn why he suddenly wants to go straight. He visit Damiel who is glad to see him, but then mysteriously ends up homeless and vagrant (why didn't he stay with Damiel?). Marion is almost romantically kind to him-- but doesn't insist the homeless Cassiel come stay with her and Damiel. Raphaela, an angel, advocates for him with Emit Flesti ("time"?) who seems malevolent, when he's not. Mikhail Gorbachev makes and appearance. Lou Reed sings a song and joins the action. Peter Falk reprises his role from the first film. Even tries another variation of the best line: "I can't see you but I know you're there" but this time it falls flat. They steal the guns using acrobatics in some kind of fascinating old Nazi structure (where they built Messerschmitt's). Cassiel acrobatically rescues a girl from pirates or gangsters who then seem to surrender to nobody. It is a giant mess that looks like Wenders set out to make a sequel with no narrative, no script, bad improvisation, access to some remarkable buildings, interesting music (But Nick Cave contributes a banal tribute to Cassiel, which isn't earned.) What were they thinking?
Peter Falk, Bruno Ganz, Natassia Kinski, Otto Sander, Horst Buchholz, Mikhail Gorbachev, Lou Reed, Heinz Ruhmann, Solveig Dommartin, Rudiger Volger, Willem Dafoe, Ronald Nitschke, Monika Hansen
A documentary that is far more interesting for its content than it deserves. The Duggar family became a sensation on TLC in the 1980's because, well, they have about 19 kids. They are fundamentalist Christians and audiences were entranced by the seemingly blissful life of the family as shown on TV. They were deeply entrenched with the Bill Gothard evangelistic movement and his Institute in Basic Life Principles. The family lived out Gothard's values of dominant father, submissive mother and children, puritanical sexual values (no dating, no kissing before marriage, modest dress) and rejection even of Disney films. At one point, Joshua Duggar admitted to his parents that he had touched several of his sisters over their clothing in a sexual manner. None of the girls even knew it had happened until the scandal broke. The parents freaked and actually called police on him. The police-- sensibly-- regarded the infraction as insubstantial, told him not to do it again, and released him. The documentary would have you believe that even though the girls didn't even know it happened, they were traumatized and Joshua should have been locked up for life. As it was, the story eventually leaked, the family weathered the storm for a while (Jill Duggard said she was sorry it had ever come out) and interviews with Megyn Kelly and others ensued. The point is that while the sex scandals rode the wave of public hysteria, the real scandal was the way the family cashed in on celebrityhood and indulged in a lavish materialistic lifestyle, all the while deceiving people about how the family actually operated (with loads of corporate punishment, and suppression of the girls). Gothard himself was accused by dozens of women in the organization of "inappropriate" sexual behavior and had to resign. Patriarch Jim Bob Duggar ran for political office several times (losing each time). The series is rich with interviews with friends, cousins, and associates of the Duggars, and extensive interviews with Jill Duggar Dillard and her husband (who seem fairly "with it") but bereft of thoughtful or useful analysis, that might point out, for example, how the Duggars fanatically promoted their sexual values (chastity and purity) while obviously displaying pride and materialism, and not much compassion, generosity, or real kindness. No concern for the environment or poverty or racism. And certainly not an ounce of humility. Note: Dr. Kristin Kobes Du Mez from Calvin University appears to give substantial comments.
Derick Dillard, Jill Dillard Duggar, Brooke Arnold, Kristin Kobes Du Mez, Deanna Duggar, Jim Bob Duggar, Bill Gothard, Michelle Duggar, Bobye Holt
Ridiculously over-rated 90 minutes of Dom DeLuise mugging and gesticulating a la Jerry Lewis as Father Fyodor who, along with ex- aristocrat Vorobyaninov and con man Ostap Bender are after a set of chairs of which one might contain invaluable jewelry hidden in the cushion by Vorobyaninov's mother during the Russian Revolution. That's the mcguffin, the excuse for a long series of substandard burlesque routines, improbable coincidences, and rather lavish sets and costumes. Filmed in Yugoslavia and Croatia standing in for Moscow and Siberia, with unexpectedly large and convincing crowd scenes, horse-drawn wagons, and Eastern European architecture, and a relatively sophisticated soundtrack. Brooks says this is his favorite of his own films; why? It's almost exclusively physical humor, and the plot is not clever or engaging. Having some of it occur in front of a statue of Dostoevsky doesn't make it any more sophisticated. The dialogue sometimes sounds badly improvised, and the original darker ending of the book (Ippolit murders Ostap) was changed to make it more congenial to American audiences.
Ron Moody, Frank Langella, Dom DeLuise, Mel Brooks, Andreas Voutsinas, Diana Coupland
Dramatization of the infamous McMartin child abuse case in which the owner, owner's daughter, and grandson, and numerous other employees were charged with having committed horrendous child abuse at the McMartin Day Care. Follows the efforts of cynical lawyer, Danny Davis, who defends the grandson, Ray Buckey, and his mother, Peggy (the other charges were eventually dropped before going to trial). The story is familiar: idiot "therapist" assesses the children as abused-- especially if they denied being abused-- and uses anatomically correct dolls to extract sensational stories of sodomy and fellatio and other atrocities, so shocking that the community pre-judges the suspects and the DA is pressured into laying charges even as the evidence begins to unravel. There was prosecutorial misconduct and a local tv reporter was caught having an affair with the therapist while reporting favorably on her diagnoses. That said, this is, artistically, a terrible movie, poorly acted and filmed, and sensationalistic and unkind and unfair to both sides.
James Woods, Mercedes Ruehl, Lolita Davidovich, Sada Thompson, Shirley Knight, Henry Thomas, Mark Blum, Alison Elliott, Chelsea Field, Richard Bradford, James Cromwell
Ugly, desperate, self-serving attempt to rehabilitate Yoko Ono's image. Yoko Ono was a mediocre "artist" of contrived, banal images and words who charmed Lennon into inviting her into the Beatles orbit at the time they were recording Let It Be. She was a parasite, using Lennon's privilege and access to advance her own career, distastefully adding her preposterously absurd screech to recordings and live performances, and orchestrating louche events like the "bed-in for peace" in Montreal. Various personages, including Klaus Voorman, testify to her admirable character and sterling artistic taste, even claiming that "Imagine" is Yoko Ono lyric. Mostly consists of filming around Lennon's Tittenhurst Park, of John singing or organizing the back-up band (including George Harrison and Jim Keltner) and the children and John and Yoko frolicking around the acreage.
John Lennon, Yoko Ono, Jim Keltner, Phil Spector, Ray Connolly, Julian Lennon, Daniel Richter, Kieron Murphy, George Harrison, Jack Dunbar, Alan White, Nicky Hopkins
I am a bit too harsh, perhaps, in resentment of Nighy's terrible taste in portraying Williams as a self-pitying, self-absorbed, even manipulative character, rather than as a man wizened to the ways of the world but determined to have a monument of some kind to his mediocre life. Nighy, from the first, speaks to his condition the way a wobbling man speaks to his drunkenness. The mistake is that a drunk is not trying to fall-- he's trying to stand up. Nighy plays Williams as if he is trying to fall, all self-effacement and suffering, and self-consciously significant. He ends up giving the film a pompous feel, a sense of unearned self-importance. The gist of the story is the a nameless, faceless bureaucrat, Williams, learns he has cancer and likely has no more than eight or nine months to live. He has spent his life, along with his colleagues, trying to evade responsibility and action. After trying to indulge some partying with an acquaintance (a shabby, vulgar excursion to a tent of exotic dancers is included), he meets up with a young woman from his department and comes off creepy by trying hard not to sound creepy. He actually tells her (though not his son) that he is dying-- a severe misjudgment in this film because it's so obviously, dangerously manipulative, and when she sheds tears-- is that not pity? Does Williams really want this relationship to be based on pathos? Is it because the film-makers and writers couldn't stomach the idea that he might have a romantic relationship with Miss Harris? In any case, Williams, as a sort of penance for his years of shiftless effort, sets out to see that a playground is built at a ruin for a group of petitioning mothers. The playground is monumental-- it seems rather antiseptic to me, as presented in the film, but in a crucial homage to the original of this story, "Ikiru", Williams is seen swinging on one of the swings at night in a snow storm, expressing satisfaction at his achievement. The film's cleverest idea, however, is to have William's death occur in the middle of the film and shift the action to the four colleagues who ride the same train to work every morning. They discuss the change in Williams and argue over whether he knew he was dying when he set out to get the playground built. This dialogue to me doesn't elucidate the core issues. What if he took action because he knew he was dying? How is that more important to them than if he had simply realized that their evasive management style did nothing but make people miserable and dissatisfied?
Bill Nighy, Aimee Lou Wood, Alex Sharp, Adrian Rawlings, Hubert Burton, Oliver Chris, Michael Cochrane
Note: no director is named at IMDB. Mukoda is the creator and writer. The title refers to a "class of beings who powerful and usually benevolent but can be in conflict and opposition". The four sisters, Makiko (married with two children), Tsunako (the oldest, a widow with a married boyfriend), Takiko (the librarian), and Sakiko (whose partner is a boxer), discover that their father may be having an affair. Their responses vary from guilty complicity to indifference to shock and horror (Takiko). But the series (7 episodes) is not about the dad, really, but about the relationships between the four sisters, which is explored with nuance and subtlety and convincing richness. They often prepare and consume meals together and not a moment goes by where you don't feel that they are in the meal, tasting the food, arranging the table, as if it was something, of course, they were used to doing for most of their lives. Crises are not played for melodrama but as exposition; they love each other and are loyal but their not selfless or self-sacrificing. This is, as some reviewers stated, one of the best miniseries on television.
Rie Miyazawa, Machiko Ono, Yu Aoi, Suzu Hirose, Masahiro Motoki, Ryuhei Matsuda, Kisetsu Fujiwara, Jun Kunimura, Jun Kunimura
Yuichi Hasumi is your classic shy, weak, approval-seeking Japanese school boy. He latches on to the friendly Shusuke Hoshino who makes him part of his gang (they steal CD's, and rob a Porsche owner). But he also adores a pop singer named Lily Chou-Chou, whose music, as imagined for the film permeates the sound-score. Moody, instrospective, it reflects the adolescent mind in it's self-pitying tone, its narcissism, and melancholy. The film is quite immersive in the school scenes, large numbers, spontaneity, life. There is bullying and cliquishness and the dread of being excluded or repulsed. Yoko Kuno is a brilliant piano player (favoring Debussy) who is bullied by the girls. Things change and Hoshino becomes a kind of monster, bullying Yuichi, and other classmates. The film fails in three significant ways: the dialogue sounds badly improvised at times, the actions are often contrived (hey, let's rob a guy; hey, let's go to Okinawa), and the idiotic hand-held herky-jerky camera approach. This hand-held technique does not reflect any kind of human reality, especially since the director jump cuts to different perspectives in the same sequence. It's idiotic and annoying. That said, the performances are often quite good, and the general atmosphere, of disillusioned emptiness and ennui, is very striking. Even haunting.
Hayato Ichihara, Shugo Oshinari, Ayumi Ito, Takao Osawa, Izumi Inamori, Yu Aoi
How a small village in Czechoslovakia endured the communist take-over after World War II. The film scans the life of the village in segments about a year or less or more apart, showing how the communist party tried to seize control of the farms and workers and how the village tried hard to resist and eventually complied-- partly. Some individuals complied immediately while others offered stubborn resistance. The church endured though the organist had to flee. The collective farm failed as workers refused to invest their labour into it. A photographer who has poured all of his work and passion and life's savings into a store is forced to surrender it to the party. This is a very down-to-earth, quite non-political film: it doesn't really advocate for either side-- it just dramatizes how collectivization fails because humans are lazy, corruptible, and selfish. The most elegant scene is the group of carnival dancers who greet Frantisek (the leader of the resistance) wearing masks of animals and monsters, dancing around his car. Beautiful film in some ways, but amateurishly filmed and acted. A slice of history, a story, a revelation from the ground.
Flastimil Brodsky, Radoslav Brzobohaty, Vladimir Mensik, Waldemar Matuska, Drahomira Hofmanova, Pavel Pavlovsky, Vaclav Babka, Josef Hilnomaz, Vera Galatikova
Verena Tarrant is a young, beautiful suffragette and advocate for women's intellectual equality in the 1870's in Boston. Olive Chancellor is a more established activist who discovers her and makes a concerted effort to manipulate and manage her and keep her away from the men who, she senses, might overcome her principles and seduce her into a conventional marriage and domesticity. There is an edge to Olive's possessiveness-- is she a lesbian? It looks very much as if she is. Verena is not dogmatically heterosexual but the signals are all there, especially when she meets Basil Ransom, who is wittily but decidedly retrograde. Not only does he believe women are inferior and that they belong in the home but, having served in the Confederacy, he has racist views in general. But he is SO charming-- can Verena resist him? It is credit to James' novel that the journey is so entrancing, allusive, and raw. Olive despises Basil of course-- out of principle, mostly-- and is all too aware of Verena's vulnerability, which I found very believable, having known women personally who talk a good line about equality and intellectual sophistication but seem drawn to men who want to put them in their place. A real treat here is the range of secondary characters, mostly fellow activists, and the strange practices of Verena's father who seems to believe in mesmerism and faith-healing and some kind of Christian Science. Henry James' sister, Alice, lived in a relationship similar to the one sought by Alice: two women living without a man. ANd there is Dr. Prance, an independent observer of all this who makes the most astute observations and seems above the fray. And Olive's widowed sister who also has her eyes on Basil. And Wallace Shawn as a reporter. And Jessica Tandy as a resolute old-guard activist. All expertly played. Verena is described by James (cited in Ebert) as "the most extraordinary mixture of eagerness and docility. . .She took all that was given her and was grateful, and missed nothing that was withheld." That's a wonderful description of her -- at first. In the end, she is more drawn to the self-infatuating magnetism of a man who knows his own mind and thinks he will know hers.
Christopher Reeve, Vanessa Redgrave, Jessica Tandy, Madeleine Potter, Nancy Marchand, Wesley Addy, Barbara Bryne, Linda Hunt, Nancy New, Wallace Shawn, Jon Van Ness
Beautiful, elegiac drama about a father, Youbong, and his daughter (Songhwa) and son (Dong-ho) who travel around the Korean countryside performing "Pansori" (music improvised or recited by a singer accompanied by a single drum). They perform in public squares, sometimes to draw customers for potion vendors, or to accompany other public gatherings, or in restaurants. Youbong is a monster, to be blunt: he drives the children to rehearse and rehearse and brutally critiques their performances. The two children are not really his: the daughter was "adopted" as a kind of student, and the son came from a woman he had a relationship with who died in childbirth. The son is eventually fed up with his father's brutality and leaves, bringing heartbreak to Songhwa. The father eventually devises a plan to ensure that Songhwa remains with him until he dies. Years later, we follow Dong-ho, who is now married with children, as he tries to locate Songhwa. It's a trail of heartbreak and the ending was not satisfying to me, but the journey was exquisitely sad and tragic. Somewhat reminiscent of "La Strada".
Kim Myung-gon, Jung-hae Oh, Kim Kyu-chul, Sae-kil Shin, Byeong-kyeong Ahn
Truly off-beat film about a middle-aged doctor, Archie, in the middle of a divorce, and a young dissatisfied housewife, Petulia. Petulia is witty and daring and Julie Christie gorgeous (played with her native British accent) who is married to a wealthy but somewhat unstable man, David, Richard Chamberlain gorgeous. Archie is put off at first gradually becomes infatuated with Petulia and realizes, in a moment of crisis, that he is in love with her. Lester is a clever director and his daring style was influential: quick cuts to explanatory sequences, witty diversions (two nuns driving away from the hospital in a white Porsche), performances by Janis Joplin and the Grateful Dead incorporated into the film, a bullfight in Mexico, an aquarium penguin circus. I was never sure if it was working, however. Petulia is narcissistic and needy and can't resolve her own desires, while it's hard to buy Archie not finding her annoying. A funky, hip film at a time of social upheaval, without the condescension or contrivance of many other films of the era.
George C. Scott, Julie Christie, Richard Chamberlain, Arthur Hill, Shirley Knight, Pippa Scott, Roger Bowen, Vincent Arias, Joseph Cotten
Outstanding, lavish production of the sweeping novel by di Lampedusa about the decline of the Sicilian landed aristocracy during the time of Garibaldi's push to create the nation Italy (at a time when it was ruled by various dukes, the French, the Austrians, and others. Don Fabrizio Corbera is the "leopard" of the tale, the powerful Prince of Salina, forced, through circumstances and corruption to surrender more and more pieces of his domain until the real power has shifted to parvenus like Sedara who bully and wheedle their way into power, symbolized by the marriage of Corbera's nephew, Tancredi, to Sedara's conniving daughter, Angelica. Corbera is always resistant to the changes but distinctly ambivalent and ends up being a party to his own decline. He forbids his beautiful, intelligent daughter, Concetta, from marrying the man she loves passionately, Tancredi, because he needs the alliance with Sedara to survive. In the end, at the last great ball of his era, he dances with Angelique, a potent, iconic moment in which the tension of the first five chapters are distilled into one exquisitely beautiful and tragic moment. Beautifully filmed and acted (aside from Kim Rossi Stuart's method acting), excellent soundtrack, and historically fascinating.
Kim Rossi Stuart, Benedetta Porcaroli, Saul Nanni, Deva Cassel, Francesco Colella, Astric Meloni, Paolo Calabresi, Gaetano Bruno, Francesco Di Leva, Alessandro Sperduti
Mind-numbing self-dialogue of Proust's "In Search of Lost Time" or whatever the hell they call it nowadays. Charles Swann is in love with Odette-- a prostitute-- or is she?--a courtesan?-- and spends most of his day looking at himself, thinking about himself and Odette, fantasizing about Odette being unfaithful (with another man or a woman), thinking about himself thinking about himself thinking about Odette and getting dressed. You could not imagine a more quintessential representation of the idle rich than this. All of the major characters (except for the numerous servants) spend all of their time socializing or throwing dinners or meeting for tea or going to the park, or lusting for men or women. That said, this is a lavish costume drama with impeccable dressage and props (beautiful mansions, parks, the streets of Paris with numerous horse-drawn carriages). It all looks very beautiful but for what? The novel, of course, is held in incredibly high esteem by people who should know better. It is unusually, scandalously frank about sexual matters and I think a portion of the esteem comes from admiration for that part of it. But the narrative, the wildly unconventional text, and the ruthless narcissism, to me, are misjudged. I think it is largely inane, and the movie is faithful to it's inanity. It is a very beautiful failure, with one thing to its credit: Ornella Muti is remarkable as the ravishingly beautiful Odette. One can believe Swann would be obsessed and insanely jealous.
Jeremy Irons, Ornella Muti, Alain Delon, Fanny Ardant, Marie-Christine Barrault, Anne Bennet, Jean-Francois Balmer, Jacques Boudet, Jean-Louis Richard, Geoffroy Tory, Vincent Martin
Tight, energetic story about a couple of grocery store clerks who want to go to a rave and are mistakenly set up by police for a drug bust. Comical misadventures ensure when Ronna, suspicious, flushes the drugs down the toilet but then has to steal over-the-counter cough medications to substitute for them so she can return them to the dealer and get her money back (and free Claire, who was forced to sit as "collateral"). She and Claire then go to a rave where she sells more of the cough medications as "ecstasy". Meanwhile, a clerk she substituted for (needing extra money to make her rent) goes to Vegas with friends and raises the ire of a bouncer when he touches a girl at a topless dance club, accidentally shooting him, leading to a chase, and leading the bouncers to follow him to LA. We then follow Zach and Adam, two actors who have been coerced by Burke, a police detective, to try to entrap Ronna (as we circle back to the first sub-plot). The scenes are handled with panache and the dialogue is funny and sparkly and the acting is actually quite good. Sarah Polly as Ronna has a grounded savoir faire the works well against the intensity of the action, the chases, and the violent confrontations in the other plots. Well-written and filmed.
Sarah Polley, Katie Holmes, Jay Mohr, Scott Wolf, Taye Diggs, Suzanne Krull, Desmond Askew, Nathan Bexton, Timothy Olyphant, Desmond Askew, Melissa McCarthy
The Guardian loves Season 4 of "The Bear". "Where once The Bear made pulses pound, now it lets the happy tears flow; the second half of the season is like one long therapy session." Yes it is. It's become like an old 70's soap opera with better music. Long lingering close-ups of characters having feelings and feelings about feelings and feelings about the other characters having feelings. Most of the feelings appear to be self-pity. In the process, they have discarded all the plot points that made it interesting. Carny says he's quitting (which I suspect is a development added so he could express more feelings) but he is supposed to own The Bear. Is he selling it? No, because he wants to hand it off to Sydney. And why the ravishing attention to the brilliant menu items while characters declare the restaurant is a disaster? Why does Sydney decide to stay with The Bear instead of signing with Shapiro when she knows it could close any time? Is Ritchie a partner now-- without putting up any cash? If this is where Season 5 is headed, I'm out.
Jeremy Allen White, Ebon Moss-Cachrach, Ayo Edebiri, Lionel Boyce, Liza Colon-Zayas, Abby Elliot, Matty Matheson, Edwin Lee Gibson, Oliver Platt, Molly Gordon
From a story by Philip K. Dick but it would be a massive insult to the writer to list him as the official author of this piece of shit. It is not forgivable that in the Dick story John Anderton fights to save the "Pre-Cog" Program. In Spielberg's sanitized, anesthetized version, he fights to destroy. The average Spielberg fan does not countenance ideas that are genuinely challenging or disturbing. In the future, someone has developed a system using "Pre-Cogs", humans who can see the future, who have "precognition", to arrest people who are about to commit a murder. This part is pure hokum here, though Dick, apparently, had some more complicated explanation for how they could do it. This is a big problem for the movie. In Star Trek, we get that some day science could build a laser gun that a man could carry in his pocket, or even a transporter (if you look into quantum physics), or robots that look like humans. It is a real stretch to imagine anything like the "Pre-Cogs" that any reasonable person would believe was reliable and accurate. It's hocus-pocus, magical thinking, ghosts and curses and witchcraft, that can't survive the sci-fi conventions of the genre. The "Pre-Cogs" don't even have physical proximity to the alleged criminals "thinking" about committing murder. Okay-- suspend your disbelief. It's more fun even if a stretch. You still have to account for a legal system that recognizes thought crime, which is sort of dealt with with the idea that "criminals" are placed in a coma instead of prison. In "Minority Report", John Anderton (who is fat and bald in the Dick story, but here is the virile, cunning, fast-running, action-figure Tom Cruise) is the chief of this avant garde police department, the "pre-crime" unit, and leads the crack team out to arrest people before they kill. These "criminals" are then basically put into a coma. There is a banal discussion of the legal ramifications with Danny Witwer who represents the Attorney General, but there is no risk of boring the audience with an intelligent discussion of the issue. Of course-- this being a Spielberg film--Anderton turns out to be the next suspect himself (!) when one of the precogs identifies him as a future murderer, forcing him to run very fast for a long period of time while the camera ravishes his thin, virile manly physique. And run again. And dispatch eight or so equally virile pre-crime officers sent to arrest him. He goes to visit a Dr. Hineman in the clumsiest scene in which the details of the pro-cog program are rather dryly elucidated. It's a clumsy, tedious scene, and the most unsuccessful sequence in the film, though Lois Smith at least develops a bit of character. There are more misadventures-- a former wife (this being a Spielberg film, the family will inevitably be restored because it's the cheapest, easiest, most obvious movie trick of resolution), and a conniving corporate bureaucrat played by a wasted Max Von Sydow. There is a lot more unbelievable contrivance, including the revelation that Anderton didn't really commit murder-- geez!-- and if he had, he would have been justified (again, because of injury to his FAMILY). And his ex-wife someone incredibly overcoming the entire state security apparatus to break Anderton out of prison. Burgess not being able to think of any way more clever to sustain his conspiracy than to shoot Witwer. Anderton confronting Burgess at a public banquet! It's more bizarre than a Spielberg film. Well, it is a Spielberg film. And note, Burgess murdered Anne Lively because after the man he hired to kill her failed (obviously, because of precrime), the second attempt would be treated as an "echo" and disregarded by the precrime unit. They wouldn't even be curious? They wouldn't even bother to check in on Lively, just in case? They wouldn't find it unimaginably weird that Burgess would be in the echo? Maybe... Finally, we are led to believe that the flaw in precrime, if Burgess doesn't kill Anderton, would discredit the program. Really? The public would rationally decide that a program that promised to almost eliminate murder but might have a flaw in it should be discarded? (In the book, it is not.) Spielberg almost always steals a few scenes from other films, so you may have noticed one grifted from "Clockwork Orange". The scenes of computer access through fingers waving in the air was boring. Sure, it looked hi-tech, but I doubt anyone will ever prefer interacting with data that way over a good screen and a mouse or a better mouse. It's all very ugly and stupid and flogged over another nauseating John Williams score and graded in bleak, greenish colors. Of course, the film generally gets rave reviews. The Guardian hated it. Berardinelli and Ebert slobbered over it: an action film with brains! The New York Times was ambivalent, while acknowledging the popular appeal. Ebert declares: "Tom Cruise’s Anderton is an example of how a star’s power can be used to add more dimension to a character than the screenplay might supply." You are completely wrong-- and I think you know it. Tom Cruise is an actor's actor in the worse sense. Even when he thinks he is evoking a real person in a real situation you know that he is evoking an actor acting the way the audience would think an actor would act in that situation. He never brings anything fresh or unexpected to his roles. He is constantly doing what he thinks is emoting and checking himself in the mirror of his own vanity and conceit as a "star". He'll even do something that looks vaguely self-effacing, because he knows great actors do it, but he will do it because it is something he thinks great actors do, not because the character his playing calls for it. He demands scenes of him running very fast, defeating large numbers of opponents with incredible dexterity, and suffering like Christ as all American action heroes must do. Spielberg never gets great acting performances because he sees acting the same way. It's just part of the surface of the film-making product. The audience must be told what to feel and they receive the message in familiar tropes that don't allude to real life, but to movie cliches. And I have yet to see a movie that is so heavily CGI in which the actors have had time or opportunity to really develop their roles. Ebert knows better and he does appreciate truly great films but he clearly also wants to retain a relevance to the average movie-going schmuck who wants to believe that films like "Minority Report" and dozens of others are actually profound and important. In the comments on IMDB, one person tries to explain some plot flaws with the idea that Anderton, arriving at Crow's apartment and seeing the photo of his son, Sean, among the debris, would "make him want to execute Crow at the spot". Let's not get stupid: he would want to know if his son was still alive and where he was. Finally: John Williams music is, as always, absolutely wretched. It could be done by computer and surely will be soon.
Tom Cruise, Colin Farrell, Samantha Morton, Max Von Sydow, Steve Harris, Neal McDonough, Lois Smith, Tim Blake Nelson, Kathryn Morris, Mike Binder, Jessica Harper, Peter Stormare
What can you say about a Wim Wenders film? From the moment it starts you wonder if it is going anywhere, if anything was actually planned or scripted, and just how careless was the director about details. Then, gradually, it begins to work. In this case, a German writer named Philip Winter is travelling through America noting it's bereft urban landscapes, it's vacant television and radio, it's inhuman scale and disorder. He is reprimanded by his German editor in New York for taking pictures instead of writing, as he was assigned, which he justifies by saying he can't understand what he is seeing and needs images to try to sort his experiences. As he is trying to purchase tickets to fly back to Germany, he learns that there is a air traffic controllers strike there and he can only get there by going to some other city and then taking trains. A young woman with a young daughter are also trying to get tickets and he assists her with his better English. The first available flight is the next day so they end up sharing a hotel room. The next morning, the woman, Lisa, leaves early without her daughter, Alice, who is nine. She leaves a note promising to meet them at the Empire State Building but she never shows up. She leaves another note at the hotel saying she had to attend to her former boyfriend who may be threatening suicide if she leaves him. She tells Philip to go ahead to Amsterdam with Alice where she will catch up with them. She fails to show up there as well, leaving Philip with Alice and the problem of unloading her, which he wishes to do. He sets off with Alice to seek out her grandmother even though Alice can't remember her name, the city she lives in, or any other useful details. It's a road movie about three individuals with barely any connection to any place or to anyone other than themselves. Philip is clearly eager to unload Alice and Alice knows it, and wants badly to find her grandmother or reconnect with her mother. She and Philip establish a relationship, grudgingly, but in a way that is far more compelling than the usual Hollywood take. When Philip tells her he wants to leave her with the police, her long, assessing gaze at him is utterly heartbreaking, because their relationship has, until then, been so fraught and difficult. Alice is not going to throw a tantrum: she's old enough to know adults will disappoint and life can be harsh. Philip is a bit of a self-centered jerk. He does leave her at one point and goes to a rock concert (Chuck Berry) and it is Alice who finds him back. This is a film with real heart and authentic emotion and with the heartless integrity of giving you a raw impression of the harshness of modern life, of its dissonance, the fragmentation of relationships, It is telling that the last scene is not of the happy, imminent reunion of mother and child, but of Alice and Philip on a train, moving fast through the countryside, sharing a window, gazing out upon the world.
Yella Rottlander, Rudiger Vogler, Lisa Kreuzer, Edda Kochl, Ernest Boehm, Hans Hirschmuller, Didi Petrikat
Some of the top actresses in Hollywood, including Candice Bergen and Natalie Wood, refused to audition for the role of Daisy. Marlon Brando turned a role down because they wouldn't pay him enough. That tells you something about the wildly disastrous making of this movie, though the poor dubbing of almost all of the dialogue played a big part as well. The biggest disaster is Mia Farrow who is catastrophically wrong for Daisy and (as she herself acknowledged afterwards) had absolutely no "chemistry" with Redford as Jay Gatsby. Redford is also a disaster: wooden and mindless-- he's just reading his damn lines. You see an ounce of development in either of their characters, no dynamic, no heart. To summarize the plot: Jay Gatsby met Daisy when they were both young, before he joined the army. In the book, he more or less raped her at the time, but she obviously felt drawn to him. He begged her to marry him but she refused because he was poor. She married a rich Chicago man instead, Buchanan. Gatsby went off to war and when he came back he went into bootlegging with a clever underground figure, Meyer Wolfsheim. He got rich and tracked down the married Daisy and build a mansion across the bay from her mansion and began holding lavish parties there. Nick Carraway lives in a small house next door and Gatsby uses him to reconnect with Daisy. Clearly, they start an affair, but you wouldn't know if from this prurient version of the story, or from the book, if I remember it correctly. Tom Buchanan, Daisy's husband, is having his own affair with Myrtle Wilson, the wife of a garage owner, George Wilson. There are some unexpected complications all around, some lavish party scenes of exuberant dancing like no one ever saw at any real party, and the one thing that comes through loud and clear is the pointlessness of it all-- because the movie itself is pointless, diffuse, a dud. That said, enough of the original novel sneaks through the noise to sustain an interest in the characters and the exploration of class and the myths of American capitalism to make worth a look. That's why a 7 instead of a 6.
Mia Farrow, Robert Redford, Sam Waterston, Bruce Dern, Howard Da Silva, Scott Wilson, Karen Black, Lois Childes, Roberts Blossum, Edward Herrmann, Arthur Hughes
Bridget, wanting to get out of her server job at a restaurant, accepts a position as nanny for an inter-racial lesbian couple, Maya and Annie, to look after their daughter, Frances, and sometimes their newborn, Wally. She strikes up a relationship with another server, Jace, gets pregnant, gets an abortion, hits on a guitar teacher, Isaac, and falls into misadventures looking after Frances, an insouciant five-year-old. It's all very quirky and personal and delightfully free of artifice and contrivance. Nobody is a saint here, not the lesbian couple, not Isaac, and not even Bridget. Everyone is flawed and somewhat self-seeking, just like you and me. It's not a brilliant film, and there is one cloyingly gauche scene at the end of Frances basically propping Bridget's ego, but is affecting and moving at times and real expression of a real generations ambivalence about roles and gender and sexual identity. And it has an odd fascination with Bridget's periods, which flash up periodically (ha ha) after her abortion. You don't see that very often.
Kelly O'Sullivan, Ramona Edith Williams, Charin Alvarez, Lily Mojekwu, Max Lipchitz, Jim True-Frost, Mary Beth Fisher, Francis Guinan, Rebecca Spence
Dan is having a bad day, at work, and home. He is also about to be deposed for a lawsuit his family is filing against the family of a young girl who may have encouraged his son to commit suicide (in a pact. The daughter, Christine, survived). While working construction, he inadvertently annoys an actress in a community theatre production. They are putting on "Romeo and Juliet", and, as it happens, they need more cast members. And, as it happens, their Romeo quits because their Juliet, Rita, is too old and smokes. So Dan is recruited to play Romeo, even if he is in his 50's. We are in the area of independent film quirk but director O'Sullivan resists most temptations and delivers a movie with heart and with enough surprises to demand your attention. The story of his son's suicide, of course, parallels the story of Romeo and Juliet, and the intersection of the two streams leads to some powerful and moving moments, as when Daisy (Dan's daughter, who also joins the theatrical troop), introduces the play. Not without its flaws: most glaringly, the actors in the stage play sometimes deliver their lines in method-actor mutation, which a stage actor could (or should) never, ever do, if you actually want the audience to hear the lines. And the reaction shots of Dan's wife, Sharon, when his speeches as Romeo allude to their son's death, are heavy-handed and sometimes cringy. But the film has a strong earthy appeal, good performances from Katherine Mallen Kupferer as Daisy and Dolly De Leon as Rita, and an interesting, original story.
Dolly De Leon, Tara Mallen, Keith Kupferer, Katherine Mallen Kupferer, Hanna Dworkin, Dexter Zollicoffer, Lia Cubilete
What a waste of a stellar cast! Arms dealer Zsa-Zsa Korda (the name is a rather lame joke) sort of wants his daughter, whom he placed in a convent at the age of five, to inherit his wealth and position. Liesl is ambivalent or not, resentful Korda's past sins, but cooperative enough to generate a series of random plot develops that don't hang together enough to be even really mildly amusing. It's as if Anderson has begun to believe his own press, and, obsessed with quaint, amusing, isolated sequences, forgot to work on story or character. The result is a banal excursion into imagery and sound that cumulatively mean nothing. It isn't even worthwhile recounting the "plot", which reads like a bad adolescent adventure story in which every chapter is written by a different adolescent each of whom has a little imagination and no endurance. And it ends with-- fuck this-- a family reunion, as Liesl and Korda play cards together. Really? Anderson? All the actors play their parts as dry, dry, dry, all enthusiasm muted beyond catatonia. This is is a mistake film that risks endangering Anderson's entire reputation for quirky comedy that somehow alludes to some aspect of human behavior that can seem compelling to us. Here, he is just playing with himself.
Benicio Del Toro, Mia Threapleton, Michael Cera, Willem Dafore, F. Murray Abraham, Tom Hanks, Bryan Cranston, Charlotte Gainsbourg, Bill Murray, Jeffrey Wright, Scarlett Johansson, Hope Davis, Benedict Cumberbatch
Suspenseful, tightly acted thriller about a group of British intelligence agents, enmeshed romantically, that appears to have been penetrated or betrayed concerning a software virus called Severus which had been developed by the intelligence agency as a prototype-- never intended to be used-- and which has potentially catastrophic consequences if applied. George Woodhouse is given the task of finding the mole and stopping the software from being implemented. The suspects include his wife, Kathryn. But Severus is obviously a MacGuffin, intended to provide the framework for a careful, intense study of relationships among individuals who routinely conduct "black bag" exercises. These are tasks that are so secret that even your spouse or romantic partner can't know about them. And they provide an opportunity for cheating or any other activity you wish to keep secret. George proclaims insistently to Kathryn that he would even kill for her, but he does investigate her and finds details of her most recent "black bag" operation that implicate her as a suspect. In the meantime, other details emerge about the others in the group. One of them is a psychiatrist responsible for certifying the mental competence of the members of the team and she has intense sessions with some of them. There are suggestions of cliche in the story but they are consistently misdirected beautifully. Characters are nuanced and complex, beautifully acted; dialogue is insistently brave and confounding. I wasn't fooled by the gun on the table for one minute (and wondered that James would not have guessed the same thing) but it's a minor flaw in an otherwise excellent film.
Michael Fassbender, Cate Blanchett, Marisa Abela, Tom Burke, Naomie Harris, Rege-Jean Page, Kae Alexander, Ambika Mod, Gustaf Skarsgard, Pierce Rosnan
Six part series (per year) about the investigation of cold cases by the usual dedicated, selfless, hard-working, principled detectives, headed by Claire Slater. Extremely schematic and cliche-ridden and severely under-developed. The remains of a young black man, Jimmy Sullivan, are discovered during the demolition of a house in London. We learn that he disappeared forty years previous. So detective Cassie Stuart sets out to interview anyone who knew him at the time. Unfortunately, the writers, following (badly) the template established by Agatha Christie, make everyone a suspect. Everyone also seems to have a remarkable memory of events from 40 years ago. They all also seems to assume they are suspects leading to the near comedy of characters immediately denying they had any responsibility for something they haven't been accused of. One character is charged with a robbery that happened at the same time as the murder-- 40 years later! The wide swath of suspects all of whom do have something to hide gets tedious quickly, as does the self-righteousness of the detectives and the secondary characters (like the children of two of the suspects) who demand that justice be done, as if they know who was purely innocent and who was purely guilty. Characters are flat, predictable, and boring. And why so many suspects? Because the writer and director has so little to say beyond the facile tropes of former fascist, corrupt priest, former gang-member, abusive-husband? Really sub-par as far as mini-series go. Highly rated on IMDB: don't believe them.
Gemma Jones, Pippa Nixon, Adam Astill, Dominic Power, Trevor Eve, Akin Gazi, Cherie Lunghi, Bernard Hill, Vanessa Hehir, Ade Oyefesco, Brian Bovell, Nicola Walker, Tom Courtenay, Sandra James-Young, Sanjeev Bhaskar, Tamzin Malleson, Claire Goose
A teacher, Junpei, who studies entomology is wandering through an area of dunes one day examining and collecting various insects. He stumbles into a village where the residents steer him to a pit outside of town. He descends via a rope ladder which is then withdrawn leaving him no escape. Living in the pit is a young mysterious woman who advises him that they must collect sand in buckets which are then retrieved by the villages who, in turn, supply her (and him) with food and water. He rebels, naturally, and tries to escape but is unable to make any headway against the slippery sand. The woman, who says her husband and daughter are buried somewhere nearby, clearly wants him to remain with her. She is resigned to the conditions of her life and only desires modest possessions, like a radio. Their relationship is sometimes sensual, as when she bathes him, and other times antagonistic as he savagely criticizes her for accepting the conditions of her life. The villagers deride and mock them and demand that they perform sex for their viewing pleasure. Months go by and Junpei appears to begin to accept his fate as well. Is this all analogy? Parable? A metaphor for the working classes? All of the above? It' s hard to tell. It works best as a metaphor for the condition of the working poor who gradually begin to believe in their own degradation and exploitation. But there are no rich antagonists in "Woman in the Dunes", no class warfare really-- the villages appear to be of the same class as the woman and Junpei. In a broader sense, you could say we all live in a pit of our own making, carrying out pointless tasks, relishing our tiny, insignificant achievements, raging sometimes with dissatisfaction. "Woman in the Dunes" is very well-acted and filmed (in black & White) and intriguing for the most part. The scenes of Junpei struggling to climb through the sand don't entirely work: the actor is obviously exaggerating the difficulty with copious grunts and groans, but the scene of the woman being hoisted up by rope was startling.
Eiji Okada, Kyoko Kishida, Koji Mitsui
This frolicking aimless chronicle of college geniuses gone amok is supposed to be funny but isn't, really, and supposed to be somewhat based on real science, which might or might not be true but doesn't matter because the rest of the parody isn't close enough to anything real to be funny. Mitch is a prodigy recruited to college to work on a laser project with Chris, another genius, who is neglecting his academic work in favor of pranks and partying. Kent is another student who competes against Chris for a desirable internship and sabotages his work. The CIA secretly wants the laser to kill people with. The boys irrationally sabotage it not to make it fail but to make it hit the wrong target (and then, so it seems, blow itself up). None of the pranks or sabotage holds up to more than a fleeting, wavering eye. It's all just a lot of noise and cliche and uninteresting characters.
Val Kilmer, Patti D'Arbanville, Robert Prescott, Jon Gries, Gabriel Jarret, William Atherton, Michelle Meyrink
Also directed by Charlotte Vandermeersch. Bruno and Pietro meet as young boys in a small village in the Italian Alps. Bruno is the son of a farmer whose parents are absent while Pietro is a city boy on vacation with his mother. I think we are supposed to absorb that they have some kind of idyllic summer together frolicking in the meadows and chasing cows and rough-housing though somehow this failed to come off for me. Petro returns to Turin. His parents want Bruno to come live them so he can go to school but his father forces him to stay in the mountains and tend the livestock. They meet again, years later, and reconnect, though, once again, I just don't see that any sense of real friendship or emotional intimacy exists. Bruno always seems to have a chip on his shoulder. Pietro-- who probably should have a chip on his should-- doesn't seem to. Bruno marries and has a child but his cheese business starts to fail while Pietro travels to Nepal and meets a girl and writes a book. It's all very melancholy and kind of nostalgic, helped with eerie songs (in English) and the luscious mountain landscapes (not helped by the video format-- why was this not wide screen?). The characters are more like types than individuals. Shifts in tone and plot are abrupt. The acting is not particularly good. There is a compensating value in the length (2.5 hours) that deceptively adds gravitas to what is otherwise a rather slight story or relatively uninteresting characters.
Lupo Barbiero, Christiano Sassella, Elena Lietti, Chiara Jorrioz, Filippo Timi, Flammetta Olivieri, Francesco Palombelli, Andrea Palma
Horrible, tawdry, sloppy sequel to "Back to the Future" which essentially repeats the same plot points with weakly contrived variations. In the future, Biff turns out to be a millionaire who ruins the town. Turns out he somehow acquired a copy of a sports almanac from 1950 to 1980 that gave him the winners of all major sporting events allowing him to bet on them and make a killing. A blatantly convenient mod is that George McFly is deceased-- because Crispin Glover asked too much money to reprise his role. This is 108 minutes of sophomoric humor, lousy schtick, and repetitive sequences (Marty trying to recover the almanac). It also reprises the contemptible "Johnny B. Goode" version in which Michael Fox writhes on the floor playing his electric guitar solo and the audience rightly responds with baffled indifference and he says "your kids are gonna love it". It is a great tragedy that he is right.
Michael J. Fox, Christopher Lloyd, Lea Thompson, Tom Wilson, Elizabeth Shue
Jan Bijvoet is an Theo Koch-Grunberg, an American interested in exotic plants in the jungles of Columbia and in the explorations of German ethnologist, Evan Schultes, who disappeared in the same area years earlier. To facilitate his explorations, he connects with a local shaman, who turns out to be the last of his tribe, Karamakate. We see two stories in parallel: Karamakate being recruited to save the life of Schultes, who has grown mortally ill and is helped by a native guide, Manduca, whom he has rescued from a rubber plantation. Filmed in glorious black-and-white, exquisitely composed, and suspenseful, "Embrace of the Serpent" is wonderfully evocative of the mystery and danger of the jungle, the various indigenous peoples who live along it's bends, the pernicious influence of the church and the rubber companies, and the dangers from the Columbian military. The various tribes speak in various indigenous dialects, including Ticuna, Bora, Andoque, Yucuna, and Muinane, and Schultes and Koch-Grunberg add German to the mix. The incidents are based on real events from the journals of both of the two men. Koch-Grunberg became famous through his books on the subject; he died in Brazil from malaria in 1924. We are confronted relentlessly with the Karamakate's critique of "the whites", who despoil the jungle, kill and enslave natives, and bring with them mindless materialism and greed (he mocks Schultes for the luggage he insists on dragging along with him). There is a Catholic missionary how has made himself into a "messiah" and crucifies some of his adherents and lashes children for disobedience. It's a fascinating story, beautifully filmed.
Nilbio Torres, Antonio Bolivar, Jan Bijvoet, Brionne Davis, Miguel Dionisio Ramos, Luigi Sciamanna
Uneven but entertaining drift of "Big Chill" about a group of college friends who performed together meeting up in a lavish mansion inherited by one of them for a reunion party. Peter is the privileged host, heir to the mansion, obviously gay but perhaps bi-sexual, sparking the interest of hopeless romantic Maggie, who thinks he is within range. Brian is married to a narcissistic tv star, Carol, and feels trapped by his career writing shit for her tv show. In the "how did you get this job category", Rita Rudner doesn't look the role at all-- but she is a co-writer of the film. Roger and Mary have had twins but one of them died; Roger writes advertising jingles. Sarah is a slut, which emerges during the social gatherings-- she even had sex with Andrew once upon a time. They are all witty and funny and sometimes caustic and dramatic. Peter saves what is a allegedly a bombshell for the last day but his news has lost a lot of shock value due to historical developments. It's all diverting and amusing if not weighty and not particularly groundbreaking in any form whatsoever.
Stephen Fry, Emma Thompson, Hugh Laurie, Kenneth Branagh, Alphonsia Emmanuel, Imelda Staunton, Richad Briers, Phyllida Law, Rita Rudner, Tony Slattery
Unusual, intimate, quirky film about two cousins, Benji and David, who travel to Poland to take a tour and to visit their grandmother's village and see the house she grew up in. Benji is reckless, impulsive, and self-involved; David is insecure, contemplative, and shy. The tension is played for laughs at times, and at other times, for tragedy. David wishes he could be more outgoing and popular, like Benji, but he also discovers pain at the heart of Benji's irreverence. What begins as a sidelight-- the relationship between the two--gradually becomes the centre of the excursion and the story dodges the most likely cliches to become a richer, more sensitive study of dissatisfaction and insecurity and grief. But the tour of Lublin, and Majdanek, a concentration camp that is mostly still intact today, is a real treat, handled sensitively, and integrated well into the story. There are no cheap laughs or contrivances: the actors clearly transmute their genuine feelings about the camp into their characters.
Jesse Eisenberg, Kieran Culkin, Kurt Egyiawan, Jennifer Grey, Liza Sadovy, Will Sharpe
Interesting film set in Germany in 1933. The Roth family is prosperous and well-connected until Adolf Hitler is made chancellor. Old family friends begin to turn on the Roths (who are not explicitly identified as Jewish) except for Martin Breitner, who is in love with Freya. The threats to the Roths and other "non-aryans" grows until the Professor is imprisoned, and Martin and Professor Werner flee to Austria, along with Freya. A curiosity really, well-acted and written, but in the style of the melo-drama's of the time, with some odd shots of the mountains and figures skiing. Unusual in that it dramatizes the rise of Nazism rather than the war itself, and the consequences (they flee to Austria, for heaven's sake).
Margaret Sullavan, James Stewart, Robert Young, Frank Morgan, Robert Stack, Bonita Granville, Irene Rich, Maria Ouspenskaya, Gene Reynolds, William T. Orr, Thomas W. Ross, Ward Bond, Esther Dale
Gritty, realistic, intense drama set in a Pittsburgh hospital emergency room overseen by the stalwart Doctor Michael Robinavitch and populated by a raft of new young talent as doctors, interns, and staff. Very explicit at times with a plethora of medical details. Like "Hill Street Blues" but even more radically devoted to multiple story lines. Each episode covers one hour in one chaotic day including a mass shooting. The doctors are fully realized, each with their own foibles, short-comings, strengths, and beefs. Perhaps a few too many near miraculous interventions that mostly succeed, and some inconsistencies in character: Robinavitch is an experienced, smart chief who suddenly collapses emotionally, and who risks the lives of other patients by spending too much time and resources on his step-son's girlfriend. He inexplicably blames himself not for risking the lives of other patients but for disappointing his step-son who repudiates him, while we are given to understand that he took extraordinary measures-- unfairly-- to save her. One female doctor wears a police bracelet for something she did in relation to her estranged husband, which goes off at inopportune moments. One doctor has been dipping into the narcotics, and is reported by another doctor who herself makes reckless moves creating needless risk. For a series that gives us unusually graphic images of surgical procedures and burns and gunshot wounds, the scariest details of all-- the finances-- are ignored. Of course, ER's must treat all patients regardless of ability to pay in the U. S., but they will receive bills and notices from collection agencies. Is this part of a continuing culture in American medical dramas through which viewers receive the illusion that the medical establishment will always provide them with great care even if they personally will be screwed financially by the system? Part of that process may be the magnification of Dr. Robinavitch into a kind of holy martyr who must endure extraordinary suffering while his associates assure us of his magical virtue. I would have found it more compelling if the makes of this series could have restrained themselves a little in that regard, and would have given him more consistency as a character. Some of his actions were jarring and not really organic to what we know of his character. Nevertheless, and extraordinary series. Not quite up to the level of "The Wire" (I doubt that the characters who really should disappear-- like Dr. Langdon, and Dana Evans-- will not be returned) but pretty good.
Noah Wyle, Tracy Ifeachor, Patrick Ball, Katherine LaNasa, Supriya Ganesh, Fiona Dourif, Taylor Dearden, Isa Briones, Gerran Howell, Shabana Azeez, Shawn Hatosy, Amielynn Abellera, Jalen Thomas Brooks, Brandon Mendez Homer, Deepti Gupta
Audiences seem to adore the trope of the grumpy old man with the loyal wife who undergoes a transformative experience and learns to have feelings. It's "A Man Called Ove" (or the Americanized version, "A Man Called Otto"), it's "Harry and Tonto", it's "About Schmidt", it's "A Christmas Carol", it's "Grumpy old Men"-- of course. "As Good as it Gets". "Groundhog Day". "Saint Vincent". It's an old, tired theme which is not to say it can't be given a fresh treatment. "Song for Marion" is not a fresh treatment. But worse than that, it is poorly acted, poorly written, poorly directed, and mawkish and cringy. I will admit that the cinematography is quite decent. In many of these, the cure for grumpiness is a cheerful young lass, maiden, or a child-- usually a girl. In this case, it's the relentlessly cheerful Gemma Atherton who doesn't display very much of the choir director / teacher sensibility necessary to carry it off. Arthur's wife, Marion, is in a choir but she is also dying of cancer. Her doctor is ridiculously beautiful because, well, why not? Grumpy Arthur reluctantly takes Marion to choir practice and then leaves to smoke outside. Elizabeth is the choir director who is generously interested in Arthur and urges him to join the choir after Marion dies. These transactional sequences are very unconvincing. There is obviously a subtle sexual undertone to the relationship which must be submerged to protect the Hallmark sensibilities of the script. That sensibility is also betrayed when Elizabeth introduces the choir to a song about sex and they are all accepting but titillated, as if this is unspeakably naughty but they are going to shock everyone and do it anyway. No, it's not shocking, and it's not really very amusing either. And "Love Shack", which they also perform, is even more lame than the original. And then we get to the Hallmark point of the film: Arthur singing a sad love-song to Marion at a choir contest from which the choir was disqualified because it wasn't (subtext here) snotty enough for the judges, who nevertheless awarded a prize to them. There is also a perfunctory subplot about Arthur not getting along with his son, James, which is so undeveloped I don't know why they bothered, though we are shocked when Arthur, after Marion's death, announces that he never wants to see James again (even though he has a grand-daughter, Jennifer. I'm not saying you won't need a hanky (though I didn't). "Song For Marion" touches on real human dramas-- aging, disappointment, illness, death-- and though it has nothing fresh to say, dramatizing those issues does carry some weight. It's too bad this movie just glosses over them. I seem to remember that it was inspired by the documentary "Young at Heart", which was far, far, far better than this piece of kitsch.
Terence Stamp, Gemma Arterton, Christopher Eccleston, Vanessa Redgrave, Barry Martin, Orla Hill, Calita Rainford, Calum Sivyer
Bob Climan directs and manages a chorus of elderly men and women, based in Northampton, Massachusetts, who perform edgy rock songs for the public (and appear to draw big audiences). Rehearsals are interspersed with personal interviews, videos, and interactions with the choristers and the director-- who is a bit of a task manager. But the strength of this charming and compelling work is the personalities of several of the performers, particularly Fred Knittle, who has a terrific voice and appealing personality, and takes a lead role in the performance (returning after an absence of ten years), and Eileen Hall, very sharp (for her age), and Bob Salvini and Joe Benoit, who both have health issues. The mortality question is always in the background and "Young@Heart" is the best kind of documentary-- it makes you think of deeper issues beyond the surface, particularly when some of the singers show determination to attend rehearsals and performances because no matter what the challenge is, the music means that much to them. They try "I Feel Good" and work hard at the rhythm, and Cold Play's "Fix You", and, delightfully, "I Want to be Sedated". They-- wonderfully-- thank you!-- perform with a live band, keyboardist, drummer, violin, and guitar. Of course the voices are a mixed bag, sometimes off, sometimes magically "on", never autotuned. The shots of audience reactions are not juiced. Director Bob Climan isn't patronizing or condescending-- he expects a lot from this crew. The cinematography is notably lackluster but the sound is generally good.
Joe Benoit, Helen Boston, Louise Canady, Donald Jones, Fred Knittle, Steve Martin, Bob Salvini, Bob Cilman, Steve Walker
Odd, ambling comedy-drama about a man who, released from prison, is compelled to rejoin his gang of grave-robbers, finding and steal artifacts from ancient history in and around somewhere in Italy. Arthur has a special gift for divining these buried tombs, and a haunting memory of a girl, Beniamina, his former love, who re-appears to him at times. His motley crew are comical and impulsive, and there is a rival crew working for Spartaco, a dealer in the found antiquities. "La Chimera" is filled with odd sequences of comedy, music, and dance. Arthur hangs out with Flora, a maternal figure, Beniamina's mother, who tries to protect him, in vain, while seeming to want to set him up with Italia, a student-maid she exploits. Is it really about the unethical use and abuse of antiquities in the the modern world, the exploitation required to seize and possess them, and the hypocrisy of worshipping ancient artifacts while exploiting the poor who generate them? Or is that too logical for this amusing but sometimes bizarre compilation?
Josh O'Connor, Carol Duarte, Vincenzo Nemolato, Isabella Rossellini, Alba Rohrwacher, Lou Roy-Lecollinet, Yile Yara Vianello
Loses five points for clumsily, desperately, distastefully inserting some kind of positive moral lesson (be confident, be yourself, have friends) into an otherwise moderately inventive fantasy about four teens transformed into different bodies launched into a jungle through a video version of the Jumanji board game (they should have stuck to the board version) and must escape through various challenges (and learning to work together -- yawn). Really, really dreary, predictable, dull, and lifeless.
Dwayne Johnson, Karen Gillan, Kevin Hart, Jack Black, Rhys Darby, Bobby Cannavale
A journalist-- we don't see much of that role-- and recovering alcoholic Justin Kemp is summoned for jury duty in the case of James Sythe who is accused of murdering his girlfriend, Kendall Carter, one night after a fight at a bar. Her body was found at the bottom of a ravine showing signs of bludgeoning and witnesses place Sythe following her as she tried to walk home from the bar after their fight. Kemp was at the bar that night and remembers hitting a deer on the way home. As the trial unfolds, Kemp begins to realize he may have hit Kendall, but if he confesses to it, with his history of alcoholism and DYI's, he could be in very big trouble (as advised by his lawyer). So he tries to do the right thing by persuading the jury that Sythe could be innocent. Those scenes are more than reminiscent of "12 Angry Men": there 's some outright theft going on there-- no wait! It's a homage! Apparently. Kemp's wife is also expecting a baby. She had previously been expecting twins and lost them. From there, the story tries to give us a conscientious portrait of the justice system gone wrong. We see that an eyewitness had his testimony shaped by the police, and that the police never seriously pursued any other possible suspects. This is not shown with any sophistication or subtlety-- it's more sophomoric and schematic than that. The jury is shown as impetuous and naive and eager to convict a man who has a history of offenses. One juror decides to break the rules by investigating on his own-- he is expelled from the jury but his leads inspire the DA to inquire into repair records for vehicles on or about the date of the crime. Typical of Eastwood films, the acting is borderline sitcom quality, flat, and uninspired (Eastwood hates retakes and doesn't rehearse extensively). The script is banal displaying a rudimentary but shallow understanding of court proceedings and investigative procedures, No discussion of the route to Kendall's house vs. the route to Sythe's house, or of where Sythe claims he went after driving away, or of what specifically was repaired on Kemp's car, or if Sythe's house was searched for bloody clothing or shoes, and so on. Eastwood dispenses with those details in favor of the transactional relationships between Kemp and his wife and the DA and the jury. The conversation between Kemp and the DA in which he proposes his own case as a kind of hypothetical and makes a plea for dispensation just doesn't pop. It made me cringe in disbelief that he would open himself up to a potential criminal charge like that. We are assumed to want to give this movie some respect because it deals with serious issues and doesn't cater to the mob with violence or sensation. But the script is weak and the performances-- especially Nicholas Hoult--even weaker. Hoult spends a lot of time trying convey someone conscience-stricken but he comes off more pathetic than that. He is constantly trying to look like someone afraid being caught, which is a code for the audience to know he deserves to be caught. Did Eastwood cop out at the end? It looked like we were in for a downbeat but more authentic conclusion than we got.
Nicholas Hoult, Toni Collette, J. K. Simmons, Kiefer Sutherland, Zoey Deutch, Megan Mieduch, Adrienne Moore, Hedy Nasser, Leslie Bibb, Cedric Yarbrough, Amy Aquino
Spielberg without a decent story, and, well Spielberg being Spielberg. Tedious sequence of jungle trails, chase, screaming, a few extras becoming snacks, more chase, more screaming, various nefariousnesses, and so on. You get the sense that no one's even trying to make a serious movie anymore: just put dinosaurs on the screen and let the actors yell. Add a helicopter and a ship and a few guns.
Jeff Goldblum, Julianne Moore, Pete Postlethwaite, Arliss Howard, Richard Attenborough, Vince Vaughn, Vanessa Lee Chester, Peter Stormare, Richard Schiff
Outstanding TV series about the guests at an exotic hotel in Thailand under the umbrella of "The White Lotus". It's a bit of destination-porn, but the drama, characterization, writing, and filming are all very good. We get three old friends, Kate, Laurie, and Jaclyn, one of whom is a successful actress (who is paying) reuniting for a dicey week of snippy envy, jealousy, and judgement. They collide over sex with a hunky staff member, Valentin. There is a family, the Ratliffs, supposedly there so Piper can do some research on Buddhism. The father, Timothy, finds out that prosecutors are after his company and him and he is likely to face a harsh prison sentence when he returns. There is a woman employee who is training, it appears, but wants to open her own spa. She sees Greg, the man she suspects murdered Tanya in the previous series, and her son suggests they blackmail him. Another staff, a guard, is courting beautiful young Mook, but she wants someone more ambitious. He tries to fit the bill. Then there is Rick Hatchett, with his girl friend, Chelsea, who plans to murder the owner of the resort, Jim Hollinger, whom he believes caused the death of his father years ago. "White Lotus" is fresh and there are wonderfully unexpected plot twists-- and a few holes (would Timothy really forget what he left in the blender before going to bed?) But the characters are well-drawn and acted, the sets are entrancing (of course), and the weirdness quotient is just about right. A bit of satisfaction, a bit of heartbreak in the end.
Jon Gries, Jennifer Coolidge, Natasha Rothwell, Leslie Bibb, Carrie Coon, Walton Goggins, Sarah Catherine Hook, Jason Isaacs, Lalisa Manobal, Michelle Monaghan, Sam Novla, Patravadi Mejudhon, Parker Posey, Patrick Schwarzenegger, Tayme Thapthimthong, Aimee Lou Wood, Arnas Fedaravicius, Christian Friedel, Charlotte Le Bon, F. Murray Abraham
A company named Lumon has developed a procedure by which employees can severe their minds so that all of their experiences at work are completely isolated from their experiences at home. At work, they are known as "innies" and at home, "outies". They have no memory of the work at home or of home at work. For all they know, they could be married to a co-worker. We mostly follow Mark Scout, though the other characters are given generous space. Mark's wife died in a car accident so he embraced the idea of having a large part of his day "severed" so he didn't have to think or even know about his loss. Of course this is problematic (how do you keep language, and technical knowledge, separate from incidental memory?). But the set up is intriguing. Especially when the worlds begin to collide, as when the co-workers, Mark, Helly, and Dylan, and Irving-- find a way to temporary integrate the personalities. Or, rather, let the "innie" out into the world for a brief time. Since we're not sure what Lumon is really up to, the consequences are mysterious. And what does Lumon actually produce? What do they want? It appears that the company may be mostly about the process of severance itself, but Erickson is obviously saving that kind of revelation for later seasons. The acting is very good, especially Adam Scott and Britt Lower, and-- hell, everybody. And the first two seasons are mostly satisfying. But there is a hint of a tendency to wallow in cinematically beautiful scenes without providing a good narrative drive to them, as when Harmony meets an old friend, Hampton, in her home town and then meets him at the factory and then the house where Sissy lives. Is this really going anywhere? The concept is rich and has a lot of resonance with the realities of corporate culture and mindless management tropes and occasionally it profoundly touches on issues of human connection, love, and identity. I am just not sure at this point that it's really going anywhere-- the real challenge.
Adam Scott, Britt Lower, Zach Cherry, Tramell Tillman, Jen Tullock, Dichen Lachman, Patricia Arquette, Michael Chernus, John Turturro, Christopher Walken, Marc Geller, Sarah Bock, Karen Aldridge, Olafur Darri Olafsson, Micahel Cumpsty
Rambling, shambling film that follows a 12-year-old, Marta Ventura, as she prepares for her confirmation in a small town in Italy. Marta's family is from Switzerland but has moved back to this small town in Southern Italy, one assumes because the father has abandoned them. Very low-key, prosaic story, Marta fighting with her sister, attending confirmation classes with a number of disinterested village children, discovering a box of kittens, ending up, through happenstance, traveling with the priest to his own hometown to pick up a large crucifix. Marta says little, and articulates nothing in speech, but conveys her alienated personality through action and body language. The church is shown to be hopelessly distant, irrelevant, and silly through Rohrwacher's realistic depiction of the rites and ceremonies and the darkly uncaring priests and a bishop who take part in the confirmation. There is a riveting sequence at the church in the priest's abandoned home town: an elderly priest at first believes Don Mario is stealing the crucifix. While Mario takes a call outside, Marta asks him the meaning of the latin phrase of "my father, why has though abandoned me" and he gives Marta a stunning lecture on Jesus and how he was rejected by everyone and his own family thought he was insane. When Marta later tells Mario what Don Lorenzo said, he veers off the road and hits a barrier and the crucifix flies off into a river. Refreshingly free of mission: none of the adults are really bad, nor good. The priest, the uncle, the man who hauls away the kittens-- they don't threaten. They are just part of the community Marta cannot connect to. A remarkable, uncompromising slice of life.
Yile Yara Vianello, Salvatore Cantalupo, Pasqualina Scuncia, Anita Caprioli, Renato Carpentieri, Maria Trunfio
The pitfalls are obvious: curmudgeonly old man (single of course, or virtually single in this case) meets young mom with cute kid and proves that he has a heart of gold. "St. Vincent" does a remarkable job of dodging the obvious traps. Vincent remains curmudgeonly to the end, and he really is an asshole-- not just a safely anodized version of one. Melissa McCarthy is also a gift here, allowed to act rather than mug. She is Maggie, a young mom moving in next door to Vincent, with a young son, Oliver, who is played very well by Jaeden Martell. He isn't too cute or contrived or passive. He has a personality and he develops a great repartee with Vincent. Vincent, through happenstance, becomes Oliver's babysitter while mom Maggie works at a hospital. Vincent demand to be paid and he takes Oliver out on unsuitable excursions to the bars and horse tracks. They do some betting together and Oliver becomes attached to Vincent even while he seems to disdain him. Vincent's wife, Olive, is in a nursing home, suffering from Alzheimer's. Daka is a prostitute who is pregnant and services Vincent on a regular basis though Vincent, in financial trouble, sometimes doesn't pay her. Perhaps the one false note is when the nursing home informs Vincent that it cannot continue to care for Olive if he stops paying them. Vincent acts as if this is an act of cruelty, as if we live in a system in which premium care should be or is offered to anyone regardless of ability to pay. But Vince berates the nursing home director as if the system is her fault. The film resolves the issue without really dealing with it by side-stepping it. The cinematography is good, if nothing special, but the music, songs by Jeff Tweedy, Wilco, Dylan, and others, is excellent.
Bill Murray, Naomi Watts, Melissa McCarthy, Chris O'Dowd, Terence Howard, Jaeden Martell, Kimberly Quinn, Dario Barosso, Ann Dowd
Incomprehensibly dull comedy about a murder in the White House. "World's Greatest Detective" Cordelia Cupp (flatly portrayed by "Orange is the New Black" actor Uzo Aduba) is summoned to the scene and basically holds an entire state dinner entourage hostage while she bird-watches and then interrogates staff and witnesses until she succeeds in assembling a disordered collection of useless incidents providing the audience with an incoherent impression of conniving, lying, self-seeking suspects. The story doesn't just have a few red herrings: it has only red herrings, and the viewer is bludgeoned with arbitrary plot twists and revelations until it doesn't care who did it any more. There is an occasional laugh. But there is also the unforgiveable fact that Cordelia Cupp is incredibly boring. She gives long-winded, tedious speeches that are supposed to impress or amuse us in some way but the plot is so ridiculously thick and under-developed that I began to wish someone would just shoot her. Inexplicably, IMDB gives it an 8.3. What??!!! The Guardian gives is 4 our of 5 stars and calls it "gleeful escapism". Perhaps for masochists. The fundamental problem is the satirical elements don't hang on any kind of structured narrative that gives you revelations or nuance. It's all just patter and misdirection. I don't sense any real awareness of how people might behave in the situation being parodied. The makers couldn't even be bothered to identify Republicans or Democrats-- as per Hollywood's pernicious commitment to the principle of lowest common denominator. Al Franken is pretty good as Senator Filkins but even he becomes tiresome after the umpteenth iteration of witnesses refusing to identify who they saw leaving the room where the body was found. And you begin to feel really sorry for the cast that has to sit around and look interested while Cordelia prattles on and on about her "brilliant" theories of the case, which is mostly half-baked mystery thriller cliches from Sherlock Holmes and other fictional detectives. The penultimate revelation is so protracted and ridiculously contrived that it just fizzles. It can be done: Peter Sellers as Inspector Clouseau comes to mind, but not with the dreary approach and uninspired performances of this series.
Uzo Aduba, Giancarlo Esposito, Molly Griggs, Ken Marinao, Randall Park, Susan Kelechi Watson, Jason Lee, Al Franken, Jane Curtin, Kylie Minogue
Another testament to my principle that most directors should not be delusional enough to assume that they can also write. "Canadian Bacon" is more a series of bad sketches than a comedy. An unpopular U. S. president is urged by advisors to find a new enemy to rally the electorate around in opposition. After a series of clumsy accidental incidents, he settles on Canada, which is holding a woman who came over with a group of vigilantes to litter. The woman is being held in a hospital (free health care). Not always or even often funny, there are few good gags, like the OPP officer demanding that graffiti on a stolen van be translated into both official languages. There are references to the Blue Jays and the CN tower. A lot of filming appears to have been on the Canadian side of the Niagara River, including the power station. Confirmed: filmed in Niagara-on-the-Lake, St. Catharines (12-mile creek), Oshawa, Pickering, etc. Not much effort made to a develop a coherent plot (and there are several ridiculous holes), and there are obvious borrowings from "Dr. Strangelove". Rip Torn does a sub-par impression of George C. Scott in "Strangelove", and Moore conjures up something like a "war room". Passably enjoyable but meandering and soft.
John Candy, Alan Alda, Rhea Perlman, Kevin Pollak, Rip Torn, Kevin J. O'Connor, Bill Nunn, G. D. Spradlin, Steven Wright, Jim Belushi, Brad Sullivan
Lane Dixon is a former medical student on the run from something. While hitch-hiking (in California somewhere) he is picked up by Bob Goodall, a black man with some formidable skills and creepy mannerisms. The story of the two of them navigating northern California runs parallel to the story of Frank LaCrosse, an FBI agent tracking a serial killer, who wins the sympathy of a local Sherriff Buck Olmstead, for reasons that might remain mysterious to us if we don't put much weight on intuition and gut sense. Olmstead is running for re-election against slick McGinnis, who isn't all bad. Anyway, the serial killer has kidnapped LaCrosse's own son (because we won't care about him catching the kidnapper - murderer unless it's personal, I assume) and left mysterious clues about how to find him, which will only work if a large number of random factors don't mess up the timing of it all. In the meantime, Serial Killer Bob offs several people he has known for years. Why? I think they were supposed to be clues to LaCrosse. Yes, it's all pretty preposterous, and features the horrible Hollywood trope at the time (and today) of having the monster, who we think is dead except we know he isn't, come back to life, once, twice, hell -- why not five times-- to once again threaten the handsome hero. A bigger problem in "Switchback" is that Jared Leto is invisible as a character.
Jared Leto, Danny Glover, Dennis Quaid, Claudia Stedelin, Ian Nelson, R. Lee Ermey, Ted Levine, William Fichtner
Thirteen-year-old Jamie Miller is arrested in his home by a formidable squad of police who also take evidence and transport him to a detention centre. His parents and sister are shocked. Each episode of the four runs in real time from beginning to end, so the first one follows his arrest and processing by the police, an interview with his father, and details the procedural steps required by the police to handle a youth charged with murder. The second episode focuses on the school Jamie attended and the efforts by the police to find more information about Katie Leonard, the victim, and to try to locate the knife that was used. Jamie's friends try to evade questioning because one of them may have been complicit. The fourth and most powerful episode-- it's actually stunning-- is an interview of Jamie by Briony Ariston, a psychologist, seven months after the murder. In a searing sequence questions and answers we learn a lot about Jamie's mind-set, his attitudes, and his character. It is clear that Briony is not favorably impressed, and nor are we. Jaime is frighteningly volatile, and continues to refuse to take responsibility. The last episode stays with the family, on dad, Eddie's, birthday, and the melancholy attempts by the family to find some normalcy. This is challenged by an act of vandalism: someone painted a slur on Eddie's truck (he is a plumber). As well, an employee of a hardware store confronts Eddie to express his "support", while Eddie is painfully aware that Jamie deserves to be in prison. Jamie is not excused or rationalized in this series: he is a mystery but one that we grasp, a boy with a good upbringing and all the advantages, who is probably bullied at school and mocked by some of the girls, who just explodes in rage at the decisive moment. It is a real and as gripping as a drama ever was about this troubling subject. Uniformly well-acted and filmed (all in one take for each episode).
Extremely popular but mediocre dramatization of how the British Post Office and it's contractor, Fujitsu, brutally ripped off numerous Postmasters or subPostmasters (referred to as "Horizon IT Scandal") between 1999 and 2015. Essentially (and contrary to the implications of the narrative), the software used to manage the postal operations was buggy and prolifically added significant charges to the accounts of more than 900 subpostmasters, who were then convicted of fraud or forced to cover shortfalls out of their own pockets. Some (actually, a lot: 236) were actually imprisoned for it. Some committed suicide after being financially ruined and having their reputations publicly destroyed. It's a great story with great potential. IMDB users seem to love it. But the acting is strikingly awful, the dialogue is banal, and the narrative lacks any kind of detail or reasonable facsimile of detail about exactly what the software does, how it works, and how people respond to errors. Did the writers think viewers would be bored by details, or by the actual language you might hear at inquiries into the issue? The drama is also not very compelling. When Alan is waiting to see how many people show up for the first meeting, it looks more like a gathering of cult members than a group of independent business owners seeing each other for the first time. One man comes late to the meeting and says "sorry I'm late" before showing any interest in confirming that he's at the right place. (Even if he was sure, the more human thing to do is to ask: "is this meeting of the subpostmasters?" or "Are you Alan?". More alarming is the passive character of Alan Bates' leadership of the subpostmasters action. The series alludes to the enormous disappointment when the award (about 59 million pounds) will mostly be paid to the lawyers and "investors" in the action. Bates is conspicuously approved of by key members of the group-- we know that many if not most may have felt (justly) betrayed by Bates' ineffective management of the cause. They "won" but only after extremely lengthy delays, and the victory was pyrrhic. The flattering coda showing Bates still fighting on raises suspicions. It's a point that shouldn't have needed to be made.
Toby Jones, Monica Dolan, Julie Hesmondhalgh, Shaun Dooley, Ian Hart, John Hollingworth, Katherine Kelly, Lia Williams
Perverse but sometimes brilliant short series about a pair of newscasters (presenters, or what have you), Madeline and Douglas, who, outwardly, at least, have "chemistry", until some anonymous person tweets that Douglas made an off-color "sexist" joke while drunk at a wedding. The first mistake in this series is Douglas seeming to admit that he made the joke without remembering what it was (he is asked to repeat the joke over and over again). The second major mistake is having Douglas, supposedly a well-known media personality, be completely clueless about how to manage a softball lob from an anonymous hater (or, as far as we know, a prankster) until, when necessary for a plot twist, he suddenly and dramatically seizes the moment. It's sudden assertiveness is as if from a different character altogether. Douglas and Toby, his producer, immediately act as if the tweet will be believed by everyone and can't be readily disputed. The most obvious path, to simply dismiss it as fake news, doesn't seem to occur to them. If he doesn't remember the joke, why confirm it at all? Add to this the ridiculously preposterous suggestion of crafting an actual anodyne joke of mild offensiveness for Douglas to admit, and one begins to lose faith in the narrative. But then we go back in time to have the scintillating conversation in Toby's apartment between Toby and ambitious young presenter Madeline. Toby, like Harvey Weinstein, suggests (without saying so directly) that Madeline will get the position she lusts for if she has sex with him. Spoiler alert!!! This is big problem for the series. Madeline doesn't leave, in disgust, even when Douglas appears at the door to invite her down to the bar. Douglas, seeing "Do Not Disturb" on the door handle, assumes, without judging harshly, that Madeline has accepted the proposition and goes away. Madeline later blames him for not rescuing her. From what? Herself? She could have walked out, obviously, at any time. Why is Douglas at fault here, as the story obviously firmly decides? And here is where the series is, finally, gutless: the story would have made sense and could have been powerful if Madeline had, in fact, made the bargain. But "Douglas is Cancelled" wants it both ways. They want to condemn Toby for making the proposition and Douglas for not stepping in while preserving Madeline's dubious virtue by having her reject Toby's advances and then, ridiculously, photograph him naked in his bathtub as if that could be used to blackmail him. But Madeline did not-- when Toby's intentions became clear-- reject the offer and leave. "Douglas is Cancelled" treats this but like a feature. The writer (Steven Moffat) also seems to have forgotten that Toby is single. Why should he give a damn if a young ingenue broadcaster posts pictures suggesting that she was in his bathroom while he was taking a bath? It's plainly ridiculous. And it would still be his word against hers as to how the circumstance came about. It would also look like Madeline had accepted the bargain. It also definitely shows that Madeline did get her position through manipulation rather than merit (Moffat seems to assume the audience will believe that she automatically has the merit). And it is also clear that Madeline has manipulated events to get rid of her co-host, Douglas, to have the program platform all to herself. For all it's flaws, the one brilliant segment, Madeline's dialogue with Toby in his hotel room, is remarkable, daring, and provocative. Too bad the rest of the series doesn't live up to the quality of this sequence.
Karen Gillan, Hugh Bonneville, Ramanique Ahluwalia, Simon Russell Beale, Alex Kingston, Ben Miles, Nick Mohammed, Madeline Power
The redeeming characteristics of this melodramatic contrivance are the spectacular crowd scenes and the glorious location settings (including a steam locomotive), and real winter scenes. The rest is meh. The real inspiration is a man named Cornelius Rost, an Austrian private, who gave us a "tall tale" rife with exaggeration and fancy about his spectacular escape from a Siberian gulag after he was imprisoned at the end of World War II. The name used in the story is Clemens Forell. The real story is not even close to the wild adventures author Bauer transcribed from Rost's oral accounts. There was a German doctor who helped Forell by encouraging him to leave immediately one night and giving him a backpack full of supplies after which he committed suicide. There were two hunters who adopted him as part of their team until one murdered the other and then pushed him down a cliff. There is a Russian officer, Kamenev, who, like Javert in Les Miserables, pursues Forell across the continent and keeps popping up at inopportune moments, as when Forell finally makes it to the bridge leading into Iran. There is a beautiful indigenous woman who nurses him back to health and makes love to him in a teepee. It's all quite preposterous and badly acted and contrived, but the scenery is fabulous. The music is drab, perfunctory semi-classical background colour. The film is mostly in German with the Russians talking Russian until they don't-- they suddenly talk German. Forell, we are told, can speak some Russian, but that doesn't explain the other inconsistencies. In some wintry scenes, breath is visible for some shots and not for others. Many sequences seem to have only a passing familiarity with the realities that inspired them: vague procedures and practices are shown that leave you wondering if any of this is based on real memory. The consensus in Germany now is that the entire story is a fabrication, as is another film "The Way Back" about a man named Slawomir Rawicz.
Bernhard Bettermann, Anatolly Kotenyov, Iris Bohm, Irina Pantaeva, Hans-Uwe Bauer, Andre Hennicke, Antonio Wannek, Irina Narbekova, Vladimir Korpus, Igor Filchenkov
Unusual, mystical animation about a group of animals trying to survive a cataclysmic flood. As the waters rise around them, a retriever, cat, secretary bird, capybara, and ring-tailed lemur find a stray boat and jump aboard and are swept along by currents and then, after finding a sail boat, the wind, through an odd world of decaying ancient buildings. No humans appear and the animals never talk: they make their natural sounds, and behave mostly like real animals, until it becomes necessary for one of them to man the tiller of the sailboat, or rescue some of their number from a dangerous predicament late in the film. Also, dogs can't or shouldn't eat fish: the bones will choke them. And there is a long stretch where you worry about them finding food. The cat finds some fish, but you will wonder what they are going to do for food. Beautifully animated almost entirely in Blender, magical at times, compelling because we want the cat to survive, and we enjoy them working out little compromises that ensure their survival. Synthetic music, mostly, effective and allusive. Relatively free of the worst of contrivances you often see in animated films about animals. Enigmatic ending suggestive of some kind of self-realization.
No Actors No Actors for "Flow"
Based on book by Marcelo Rubens Paiva, the son of Rubens Paiva. True story about the disappearance of Reubens Paiva, a former Congressman in Brazil in 1971. Told from the point of view of his wife and family who struggle to get by while wondering if he is alive or dead. His wife, Eunice, and daughter Eliana, were also arrested at the time but released after a few days. Most of their friends and professional acquaintances are too frightened to be much assistance, and the government, officially, at first denies that they are holding him, but eventually the truth comes out: he was tortured and then murdered and his body either thrown into the ocean or buried in a mass grave. None of the soldiers involved, though identified, were ever brought to justice. Eunice eventually became a rights lawyer with a particular interest in the rights of indigenous peoples whose land was being taken in the Amazon forest. Well-acted and film, if not as compelling as films like "Missing" or "Z". It's power lies in the mundane details of the family's life after Rubens is taken, the delicate conversations in which they avoid the obvious, hiding information from the younger children and the daughter living in England at the time. I assume we are meant to see mostly the triumph of Eunice's will to make something of her life afterwards, the successes of the children, and the tragedy of her last years when she suffered from Alzheimer's. We are given the moment she receives his official death certificate from the government, but I was not as moved by this as I think the film intended. What good is the acknowledgement of an evil for which no one is really held accountable? And actress Fernanda Torres played better as the much older Eunice than the earlier scenes in which her purported age was not altogether convincing. A brilliant touch, however, was having Torres mother play the elderly Eunice: that worked. But over all a good film on an important issue.
Fernanda Torres, Fernanda Montenegro, Selton Mello, Valentina Herszage, Maria Manoella, Luiza Kosovski, Cora Mora, Olivia Torres, Charles Fricks, Humberto Carrao, Maeve Jinkings
Based on story idea by Sam Shepherd. One day Wal Henderson receives a call from a remote town in Texas: a man called Travis Henderson was found passed out in a bar. He needs help. Walt flies out to Texas, rents a car, and picks him up: it is his long lost brother who disappeared for four years after his marriage broke up. He has been wandering the dessert, we assume, or the environs, but we never get any details about how he didn't starve to death, and meet with any other unfortunate demise. Walt picks him and brings him home to his sympathetic wife, Anne, and son Hunter. Only, Hunter is actually Travis' son, which creates a bit of tension with Anne who doesn't want to lose custody. Travis eventually connects with his son and sets out to find his mother who we learn is living in Houston from where she deposits money into an account for Hunter on the same day of every month. Those are the incidental details but "Paris, Texas" is really about the harsh, wasted, vacant landscape of the outposts in the wilderness and the sterile cityscapes of America, and how the emotional life of some men and women is as dislocated and unattached as the dessert gas stations and motels and city apartments in the sensitively filmed story-- accented beautifully by Ry Cooder's music, mostly slide guitar and dobro. The slow-moving story gets to you, hauling you along pace-fully on these long road trips, dawdling conversations (some of which sound improvised), and characters gazing out at the cityscape, the airport, and the highways. It is America, emptied of contrivance and illusion, wounded and desperate, lonely and alone. Wenders is a meditative director, but he will also toss in a sequence of man on a bridge preaching to no one, warning hysterically of an impending doom that no one can escape. Hunter is played with quiet delicacy by the child of co-writer L. M. Kit Carson. The ending was not satisfying to me-- Wenders is an optimist there. It felt to me like Jane had no life other than waiting for Travis to show up and that long last scene in the peep show seemed as remote from the rest of the film as the last scene in "Wings of Desire" in the bar where the characters clumsily enunciate their soulful desires to each other. Perhaps he felt the audience needed a light at the end of the tunnel. It also reminded me of the last scene of the searchers, but in a diminished form. It also should be observed that Travis's account of his early marriage to Jane will make you cringe, but Jane doesn't even communicate her discomfort with the incidents he describes, and the film doesn't seem to resolve the tension between his solicitude at the peep show and his consciousness of just how badly he managed the relationship early in the marriage. It's all a little too pat, too facile.
Harry Dean Stanton, Natassia Kinski, Dean Stockwell, Aurore Clement, Bernhard Wicki, Hunter Carson, Tom Farrell
Bryan Fogel is an amateur cyclist who, shocked by Lance Armstrong's revelations, sets out to prove that athletes can get away with doping on a grand scale because of laxity among the authorities enforcing the doping rules at international competitions, including the Olympics and the Tour de France. But along the way, the story takes a big detour into the affairs of a Russian doping enforcement administrator who actually facilitates doping for Russian athletes and, bizarrely, agrees to help Fogel with this scheme. Fogel takes up elaborate procedures, taking shots and storing his urine, while bigger events unfold involving Grigory Rodchenkov, the Russian facilitator. The Sochi Olympics comes along-- with the Russians taking a record haul of gold medals-- and the Rio Olympics coming up, and Rodchenkov leaves Russia and is questioned by U. S. authorities, and the New York Times which writes an expose. Scandal erupts but the Russians hunker down and the IOC ignores advice from it's own investigative teams and allows the Russians back into competition, while Rodchenkov, fearing for his life, must go into hiding. An uneven film-- I'm skeptical of Rodchenkov's accounts, and a good deal of screen time is occupied by sequences not convincingly connected to the central point. Rodchenkov is, after all, the bad guy here, who turned on his masters, but Fogel becomes so attached to him that his perspective is untrustworthy. I am surprised-- then I am not surprised-- that it won "Best Documentary" at the 2018 Oscars.
Bryan Fogel, Dave Zabriskie, Grigory Rodchenkov, Don Catlin, Richard McLaren, Dick Pound, Thomas Bach, Vitally Mutko
Robie and Alex Flores return to their home town of Eagle Pass, Texas, to meditate on their childhood in the border city, the collusion of Latin and American culture, their parents, and the loss of their brother, Marcelo. We are not told in the film that Marcelo died in Mexico after, probably, having an epileptic seizure while near a body of water. So Robie and Alex process their grief while showing us numerous scenes of activities in Eagle Pass, the border, a park, teens and children playing sports, and themselves being filmed and filming. It all doesn't amount to very much-- there's no real substance to their reflections or visuals.
Robie Flores, Alex Flores, Marcelo "Mars" Flores
Lively, fascinating story of Tyrus Wong, a brilliant Chinese artist who worked for Disney for a while (on "Bambi") but also, amid widespread discrimination against Asian artist, developed his own career as an artist. Intimate look at his family life and his background poverty, and his honorable father who borrowed the money to send him to art school.
Tyrus Wong
Elwood, a promising young black high school student, is caught in a car driven by a car-thief in Florida and is sent to a reform school, Nickel Academy (named after a founder) where he meets and befriends Turner. "Nickel Boys" dramatizes the horrifying events that actually happened at many of such institutions (for blacks and for indigenous Americans) though it is based on a fictional novel by Colson Whitehead. Elwood is inspired by the civil rights movement while his friend Turner is far more cynical and believes nothing about American racist culture will change. They become aware of torture, possible sexual abuse, and even murder at the academy and decide to flee, but guards chase them down. The film unusually shoots from the perspective of either of the two main characters, sometimes alternating, sometimes viewing from behind a character's head. Unexpectedly (to me) this works, even when they sometimes flip characters in the middle of a sequence. Well-filmed and beautifully acted, and with a daring, stirring, original soundtrack.
Ethan Herisse, Brandon Wilson, Aunjanue Ellis-TAylor, Ethan Cole Sharp, Sam Malone, Najah Bradley, Gabrielle Simone Johnson, Gralen Bryant Banks, Luke Tennie, Trey Perkins, Craig Tate, Tanyell Waivers
Also written by Line Langebek Knudsen. Karoline is a young woman living in Copenhagen in 1919. Her husband has been to war and not returned. She works for Jorgen sewing uniforms, and flirts with her. When she becomes pregnant, he agrees to marry her but his mother disapproves and the wedding is off. Karoline's husband returns, disfigured, from the war, and wants to resume their marriage but she rejects him. She meets a woman, Dagmar, who knows who to handle illegitimate babies, finding loving families for them, and Karoline brings her baby to her, and eventually joins her in her store where she helps with other illegitimate babies. We learn some very uncomfortable truths about women's lives at the time, the fate of the babies, and the harsh options available to women in Karoline's position. Filmed beautifully in black and white, with a stark, searing soundtrack, and astonishing recreations of the city-scape, the film builds up a corrosive sense of sustained suspense and lingering horror-- not at any violent or horrifying monster, but at the monstrosity of life in that era, for women, for soldiers, for everyone. Karoline is neither an innocent victim nor an instrument of justice or retribution. The male characters arrive with the viewer's expectation of violence or abuse but they are merely the vessels of the institutionalized social norms of the time. We are surprised by the twists this movie does not take, until it takes one very shocking turn. Brilliantly acted and directed, and unforgettable.
Vic Carment Sonne, Trine Dyrholm, Besir Zeciri, Joachim Fjelstrup, Tessa Hoder, Ava Knox Martin, Soren Saetter-Lassen, Benedikte Hansen
Hard to believe this is by the same director as "Once Upon a Time in Anatolia" but it is. If the TV sitcom "Seinfeld" is supposed to be about nothing, "Clouds of May" really is about nothing. Muzaffer wants to make a film using his parents, Emin and Fatma, and nephew Ali, as actors. He hangs around, films them talking about being in the film (or not wanting to), and follows Emin to his land which he is worried about: the government is sending agents around to tag the trees and claim the property. It's not clear how this works exactly. Emin wanders his property, gives line readings with the aid of prompter, while Muzaffer directs. Muzaffer's friend Saffet is considering moving to Istanbul to find a job and Muzaffer discourages him and they argue about his prospects there. Ali has to carry an egg without breaking it for 40 days to get a watch from his dad. Ali and Muzaffer find a tortoise and study it for a time. And that's about it. Why did the film win such acclaim? Because it wouldn't be cool to dis a film that is so anti-film as this? Or did some critics really love the cinematography and editing and sound? I suspect a bit of both. It's a kind of folk film: just us normal people hanging around doing what we usually do, mostly, and talking about making a film which we never know much about. It's a diversion, not unpleasant, but not really as special as its partisans would have you believe.
Emin Deylan, Muzaffer Ozdemier, Fatma Ceylan, Mehmet Emin Toprak, Muhammed Zimbaoglu, Sadik Incesu
Lavish, delicate, impressionistic film of Proust's "Time Regained". Ruiz tries to capture the flavor and tone of Proust's alleged masterpiece, with subtle shifts in time, having characters sometimes face their younger selves, or watch re-enactments of scenes from memory, including parties and teas and numerous conversations. Marcel remembers women he adored and men indulging homosexual liaisons. Sometimes it is suggested that he is present, observing from a discrete distance. Other times, we hear conversations Marcel is not likely to have heard-- his imagination, I presume, of what was talked about. The characters age, talk about the war (World War I), about friends who were changed. These are privileged folk, living in extravagant mansions, with servants and maids attending to them, some with discernible mild distaste for their chores, as one would expect. Does it all work? I'm not sure-- the milieu is so distant from my own that it doesn't always feel connected to a familiar reality. But it is beautiful to watch.
Catherine Deneuve, Emmanuelle Beart, Vincent Perez, John Malkovich, Pascal Greggory, Marcello Mazzarella, Marie-France Pisier, Chiara Mastroianni, Arielle Dombasie, Edith Scob, Elsa Zylberstein, Christian Vadim, Dominique Labourier, Philippe Morier-Genoud, Mathilde Seigner
Based on a novel by Scott Heim. Two boys, Neil and Brian, are sexually abused by their little league coach. Based on Heim's personal experience, this very odd contrivance veers towards uncomfortably empathetic treatment of the pedophile coach-- he is very nice to Neil, grooming him, obviously, and Neil doesn't, at first, seem very disturbed by this experience. Why? Because he's gay? The film doesn't want to imply that he became gay because of the experience, but the implication hovers over it's treatment of Brian, who, the film would have us believe, blacked out and repressed the memories of the abuse. This is discredited dime-store psychology. Neil grows up to be a male prostitute and we see extended sequences of him having sex with creepy male customers, including one who brutalizes him. Brian, in the meantime, has a memory of a UFO. He somehow-- no explanation-- links his memory lapse to Neil, seeks him out, and together they break into the house formerly owned by the coach (on Christmas Eve, with the tree and presents visible), so Brian's memory can be prompted. The implausibility of this and many other sequences is disturbing, given the context. Is Araki trying to say something about sexual abuse, or is it a character portrait of two troubled youth? If it's meant to be a portrait, it's a banal excursion. Gordon-Levitt is okay in the role, but he seems completely unattached to the world he lives in-- he doesn't even lock the door when leaving the apartment, and he seems clueless about the signals given by the abusive customer. The child Neil, who is supposed to be eight, is left unattended by his mother, and is able to spend time at the coach's house with accountability. That's possible, but the film doesn't show us how that's possible. Unusually, the film does show more about the sex than we can expect (apparently, filmed in such a way that the child actors did not actually perform some of the intimate scenes). Araki has the distinction of having directed a film that Roger Ebert gave zero stars to his trilogy including "Totally F***ed Up".
Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Brady Corbet, Elizabeth Shue, Chase Ellison, George Webster, Rachael Nastassja Kraft, Lisa Long, Chris Mulkey, Bill Sage, Michelle Trachtenberg, Riley McGuire, Mary Lynn Rajskub, Mary Lynn Rajskub
Iman is a judge-investigator for the Islamic administration in Tehran. He has just been promoted and receives a handgun for protection, because of dissident threats to the government. His wife is pleased, and delighted at the prospect of more money, better housing, and the prestige, but his daughters are sympathetic to some of the protests going on after the real-life death of Mahsa Amini, the 22 year-old Kurd, who was arrested by the moral police for not wearing her hijab correctly. Iman is at first reluctant to execute the government's harsh measures but learns to compromise. His wife harangues here two daughters, Rezvan and Sana, to remain uninvolved in any activity that could endanger Iman's position, but when a friend of theirs, Sadaf, is seriously injured in a demonstration, tensions rise. Then Iman's pistol goes missing. And suddenly, "Seed of the Sacred Fig" becomes and entirely different movie. From a thoughtful, expressive, insider look at Iranian culture and politics, it transforms into a cheap horror-thriller, with Iman madly hauling his family off to a remote residence that is embedded in some kind of ancient ruin-- with prison cells! The absurdity of this sequence becomes manifest when the three women escape on foot and decide to separate. There is no comprehensible explanation for this strategy, especially since they all reunite when required for the penultimate resolution. It was really quite bizarre, and hugely disappointing. The film went from an eight to a five in the transition. I cannot even imagine what the producers and editors were thinking. Even more bizarrely, the film nominated for best foreign film at the Academy Awards for 2025. Be it also noted that because the story line was considered too intense for teenagers, older actresses (31 and 32) had to be used for the roles of what were intended to be teenage daughters and their friend (who were about to enter college).
Soheila Golestani, Missagh Zareh, Setareh Maleki, Mahsa Rostami, Niousha Akhshi, Reza Akhlaghirad
Based on novel by Ford Maddox Ford. BBC series about a doomed marriage between Christopher Tietjens and Sylvia Satterthwaite. She is a sophisticated, amoral shrew who torments Christopher precisely because he is so "good" and pure and forgiving. She can't stand it. There's a good lesson in human moral behavior here: he is a constant reminder to her of her own deficiencies and cruelties. But Christopher also belongs that class of English male protagonists who might as well go around hitting themselves in the face with a 2 by 4. He is so self-righteous and pious that one almost roots for Sylvia. His true love, in this scenario, is Valentine Wannop, played by the incomparable face of Adelaide Clemens who was 23 at the time but looked 17. I say face because I'm not sure if she can act or not: she's just so compelling to look at, that one gets Christopher's obsession with her immediately. Valentine is introduced as a suffragette who becomes a teacher and is so besotted with Christopher's purity and perplexity that she explicitly offers to ruin her own reputation and prospects gladly for an hour or so with him. It's unclear what was all left on the cutting room floor but there is no doubt the story meanders unpredictably and sometimes inexplicably. Christopher is sent to the continent as a horse wrangler but is maliciously sent to battle by people who detest him for the same reason Sylvia does. Sylvia pursues him to publicly accuse him of having a mistress-- she identifies Valentine-- which he righteously denies. Sylvia has affairs (she doesn't know if her son, Michael, is Christopher's) and then doesn't (she declares that she has been chaste for five years, then complains that she made the sacrifice for nothing). Somehow a tree called Grobby is central to something but it wasn't clear to me what it was. Cumberbatch, as Tietjens, looks like he's still working on his craft at this stage of his career, and sometimes merely appears prissy and prim and masochistic. He refuses to divorce Sylvia, but, in the end, it is suggested that he will shack up in his lavish mansion with Valentine anyway. Entertaining at times, but I wouldn't watch it again.
Roger Allam, Benedict Cumberbatch, Ellio Levey, Patrict Kennedy, , Tom Mison, Adelaide Clemens, Miranda Richardson, William Ellis, Rebecca Hall, Janet McTeer, Rupert Everett
Captain Douglas, on loan from British Petroleum, is put in charge of a small team to go behind German lines (400 miles) and blow up a fuel depot. Colonel Leech is the cynical commander of the group who is instructed to just make sure Douglas makes it back alive (after other British officers on assignment with him did not). This is a familiar trope: disreputable men, with criminal records and dispositions to brutality, form a capable team that, through cunning and ruthlessness, are able to accomplish what more conventional men cannot. (We see another British team, dispatched for the same mission, fail spectacularly). Leech is so brutal that he forces Douglas to watch helplessly as the Germans launch a surprise attack on a British platoon. Douglas begins to learn from him and the team becomes ruthless in pursuit of their mission. But, this being the late 1960's, "Play Dirty" is pessimistic-- even cynical-- about the purpose of missions and the military in general, ending with a sardonic "don't do it again" in response to one more atrocity. Similar to "Bridge on the River Kwai" in that respect. Compelling action sequences, and the spectacle of real practical effects make it very watchable, even enjoyable on that level. Well-acted and written.
Michael Caine, Nigel Davenport, Nigel Green, Harry Andrews, Patrick Jordan, Daniel Pilon, Bernard Archard, Mohsen Ben Abdallah, Mohamed Kouka, Vivian Pickles
Another cautionary tale about directors who think they don't need a writer. Director Corbet wrote this script, with help from his partner, Mona Fastvold. And it shows. A lot of sequences play like actors improvising, sometimes tastelessly and badly. Laszlo Toth is a concentration camp survivor who makes it to America (in a very bad, hand-held jerky camera sequence) and takes menial work to survive though he was an accomplished architect back home in Budapest. His cousin Attila, and Catholic wife Audrey (Attila-- Jewish-- is assimilated) takes him in, gives him a room in his shop, and sets him up to work in his furniture store, through which he meets the Van Burens, a very wealth family. He designs a library for them and after initial rejection (and validation by an architecture magazine) is hired to build an ambitious community centre. But they hedge on his work, hiring a second architect to review his drawings. Laszlo, in the meantime, succeeds (with help) in bringing his wife and niece over from "somewhere" in Europe-- a displaced persons camp. My point is, none of these details is carefully thought through or developed with any sense of reality. Well, it is "loosely based" on "The Fountainhead" by Ayn Rand, and it shows. Laszlo, we are given to understand, is the genius who visionary designs are impeded by mediocre men who can't possibly comprehend his monumental intellect. For all that, the buildings we see are incomparably ugly. There is a reason "brutalism" never caught on. (Habitat 67 at Expo 67 in Montreal is "Brutalist".) Some very weird, cringy sequences, like when Laszlo meets Attila for the first time after the war and they hug and hug and hug with homoerotic overtones. He also has an intimate relationship with Gordon, a black man, with no discernible purpose in the story, or individual characters. Virtue-signalling? (Laszlo stands up for him a relief service when the kitchen runs out of food.) He seems to exist only to prove that Laszlo is less racist than the other characters. Laszlo doesn't seem sexually interested in his wife, after she arrives, but we don't really get any development there either. His niece, Zsofia, seems to have a sexual encounter with Van Buren's son-- or does she? Is it rape or consensual? Laszlo has an opium addiction. The discussions with the building foreman, Leslie Woodrow, and Laszlo and Van Buren seem detached from any real process or situation or detail, as if the actors improvised those scenes without regard to the narrative. I assume we are supposed to get how visionary geniuses are often obstructed by mediocre men, which is what Ayn Rand would have us know. Queerly, this kind of dynamic resonates most famously with Nazi Germany, and the Brutalist structures echo Speer's vision of German architecture under the Reich. Like Coppola's "Megalopolis", "The Brutalist" is a mess, sloppy, unconvincing, and indulgent. Brody always seemed to me to be angling for another Oscar, while most of the supporting cast were actually quite serviceable had this been a more coherent film.
Adrien Brody, Guy Pearce, Felicity Jones, Joe Alwayn, Raffey Cassidy, Stacy Martin, Isaach De Bankole, Alessandro Nivola, Jonathan Hyde, Jonathan Hyde
It's hard not to believe that "Black Box Diaries" was only nominated for an Academy Award for best documentary for ideological, political reasons. This is a mediocre vanity project in which Ito, directing herself, filming herself, recording herself, weakens the political point by making the story about herself, her own passion for not being ignored. It's about me. As a result, we get very, very little information about the alleged miscreant, Noriyuki Yamaguchi, a celebrated Japanese journalist. The fact that Yamaguchi is probably guilty doesn't alter the fact that "Black Box Diaries" is not good journalism and not a good documentary. There is no attempt to present a journalistic survey of the issues, the personalities involved. There are gratuitous scenes (like Ito trying to chase down a member of parliament) that have no bearing on story or content. We barely know what Yamaguchi is accused of, exactly. Even worse, Ito asks us to feel for her story because we feel sorry for her, because she cries on camera, threatens to commit suicide, is mocked and ridiculed on social media. But because she hasn't laid out the stakes or the social context of the story, we are unmoved. She's not wrong about the issues, but inviting the viewer to respond to them because we feel sorry for her is still manipulative and short-sighted. Showing herself bobbing to "I Will Survive" in a car after the verdict in her favor is nearly cringy. This should have been a podcast. It should be nowhere near the Oscar for best documentary; it isn't remotely in the class of many brilliant previous winners like "The Fog of War", "Grey Gardens", "Bowling for Columbine", "Citizenfour" or many others.
Shiori Ito, Norijyki Yamaguchi
Fascinating, powerful, impressionistic documentary on the assassination of Patrice Lumumba, focusing on the events leading up the coup, and counter-pointing them with a slew of jazz performances, linked by a tour of the Congo and other African countries by Louis Armstrong who, unknowingly, was being manipulated by the CIA, to provide a distraction or cover for various nefarious goings-on in the Congo and it's breakaway state, Katanga. The heart and driving force of the story is, of course, the incredibly valuable metals mostly found in the Katanga province and coveted by the U.S. and Belgium, including uranium, radium, copper, cobalt, zinc, cadmium, germanium, manganese, silver, gold and tin. As Lumumba took control of the Congo government after Belgium was finally forced to cede it's independence, the Western powers realized that the mining company, UMHK (Union Miniere du Haut Katanga) might actually have to return some of the value of the products to the people of the Congo. Even worse, Lumumba, who was receiving support from Khrushchev (as well as India, and many other recently independent African countries), might consider other markets, like the Soviet Union. When it was evident that most of the Congo supported Lumumba, the Americans and Belgians began bribing parliamentary representatives in the Congo to vote to depose Lumumba. At the U.N., Dag Hammarskjold was clearly manipulated into sending a peacekeeping force that actually became a tool of the Katanga separatists (led by When that didn't work, they recruited a Colonel (why is it always a Colonel) named Mobutu (later known as Mobutu Sese Seko) to lead a coup, arrest Lumumba, and eventually assassinate him. Malcolm X famously reacted to Kennedy's assassination with the phrase "the chickens have come home to roost", alluding to the assassination of Lumumba. It was an altogether despicable and appalling episode in American foreign policy (led by Allan Dulles) and Belgian colonial history. The film is bold and daring, building momentum through its carefully curated segments of jazz by artists like Duke Ellington, Ella Fitzgerald, Mile Davis, Nina Simone, John Coltrane, and, of course, Louis Armstrong. The music is not background: it is evocative of the chaos of events at the time, the various solos, ensembles, and discordant acts of various elements of the disaster, and the intense personalities of vital players like Lumumba, Castro, Malcolm X, Nasser, and others.
Patrice Lumumba, Nikita Khrushchev, Dag Hammarskjold, Dwight Eisenhower, Louis Armstrong, Andree Blouin, Joseph Kasavubu, Paul Henri Spaak
Sincere documentary about the residential schools in British Columbia near the Sugarcane Indian Reserve, St. Joseph's Mission in Williams Lake. Noisecat is the grandson of a surviving victim of the abuses at the Catholic-run school. The style is more impressionistic, investigating the emotional and psychological impact of the abuse on generations of indigenous families, rather than documentary. And here weaknesses show, in the focus on how the trauma of the residential schools personally harmed the relationship between Julian and his father. I watched this one day before watching "Soundtrack to a Coup D'Etat" and noted how "Soundtrack" was relatively free of the somewhat self-serving narrative of "Sugarcane". Yes, the residential schools were terrible and the priests and nuns who ran them-- and the Catholic church as an institution-- are responsible for the grievous harms they caused. But it is also clear that the subjects of the film find it convenient to attribute substance abuse, neglect, and other personal failures to the demon of the schools. We didn't need to see Julian pressure his father into admitting he was absent to get the point. It nudges the film into personal therapy and virtue signaling, at the expense of the drama. On the plus side, we hear from Rick Gilbert and his wife Anne, devout Catholics, who seem more ambivalent about the issue-- smartest element of the movie. But they do travel to Rome to hear Pope Francis give a disappointing "apology" for the schools. It is quite possible that he doesn't entirely believe the schools were not a fundamental "good" in the lives of the indigenous children, in spite of a few shortcomings (a la Strangelove). The music is good-- sparse and evocative-- the cinematography is okay.
Willie Sellars, Charlene Belleau, Whitney Spearing, Ed ARchie Noisecat, Julian Brave NoiseCat, Kye7e Kye7e, Jean William, Rick Gilbert, Anne Gilbert
One of those French movies in which characters announce how they are so existential and conflicted and where they are so moved by the same ennui that seems off-putting to the viewer. Stephane works for Maxime, who runs a shop that repairs violins for well-known musicians. They meet Camille, an astonishingly beautiful violinist (who seems about 20 years younger than the married Maxime) who needs some work done. She falls for Maxime at first, and he leaves his wife and acquires a new apartment for the two of them. But Stephane is the introvert, the sensitive, soulful partner, and she is moved by his more sophisticated awareness of her amazing talent. Or is she? It's hard to tell what moves her. And the characters have that mode of sophistication in which Maxime actually seems to be angry at Stephane because he has made Camille unhappy by not hitting on her-- which, of course, makes her more infatuated with him. What is Camille's relationship with Regine? Hard to tell-- but if it weren't for the year the film was made in (1992) one would suspect they were lesbians. One also suspects that maybe Stephane is homosexual-- how else to explain his lack of interest in bedding Camille? It may have seemed deep and interesting in 1992 but it doesn't today. The dialog is stiff and schematic. Stephane's dry resistance offends more than intrigues. Maxime would strike one today as a predator. Camille doesn't seem to have anything to offer Stephane anyway, other than her beauty. Incidentally, Emmanuelle Beart is quite credible as a violinist, though that is not her performance that you hear. Impressive.
Daniel Auteuil, Emmanuelle Beart, Andre Dussollier, Elizabeth Bourgine, Brigitte Catillon
Prabha and Anu are nurses working in a hospital in Mumbai. Parvaty is a friend who is having landlord issues. "All We Imagine as Light" is a symphony of quiet interactions, conflicts and resolutions, uncertainties, resolves, and friendship. Prabha has a husband in Germany she has barely met-- an arranged marriage. Anu has a boyfriend and a family beginning to urge her to accept and arranged marriage. Parvaty is being evicted from her apartment by a crooked landlord and decides to return to her village. It is through her that Prabha learns lessons of acceptance and friendship, expressed towards Anu, though the transition is somewhat mysterious: she performs cpr and mouth-to-mouth on a drowning victim, which evokes a mystical experience with her husband, though it was never clear to me if this was fantasy or projection or myth. Ultimately, it's not about that: it's about friendship, impermanence, aspiration, and love, and mostly, loneliness. A beautiful, affirming film.
Kani Kusruti, Divya Prabha, Chhaya Kadam, Hridhu Haroon, Azees Nedumangad, Anand Sami
Yuval Abraham is a Jewish journalist and friend of Basel ADra, a Palestinian activist. "No Other Land" documents the struggle of a small Palestinian community in the West Bank to survive years of harassment by the Israeli military attempting to "persuade" them to leave. The courts have prevented Israel from simply interning them, so, instead, the JDF bulldozes their buildings, harasses them, arrests them at protests, and so on, until, finally, Israeli settlers move in an actually attack (with guns) the community. Compelling for content, not style. A lot of the footage is very shaky, poorly composed shots of stuff happening, and aimless conversations between Basel and Yuval, talking about how they don't get enough media attention. They're right but it gives the documentary an off-putting polemical tone. I suspect that a portion of the favorable reviews it gets is due to the political content, not to the power of the film. The film doesn't fairly represent the Israeli view, the suspicions they may have about the community's loyalty to Palestinian hostility to Israel.
Yuval Abraham, Basel Adra, Hamdan Ballal
Elliptical, obtuse film about two boys who get into trouble at school, told from different points of view a la "Rashomon". First, Minato's mother, Saori Mugino, gives her experience dealing with her son's teachers and principal after an incident in which he is struck and insulted by a teacher. The teachers and principal prove to be incredibly obtuse and cryptic about what happened, while profusely apologizing. We get the point of view of the teacher, Hori, who is alleged to have been at a "hostess" event the night the building caught fire. We get Minato's version, and then his friend, Hoshikawa's version. Other bit players-- particularly the principal, and a classmate-- also offer deceitful contributions. All of the accounts vary considerably and we have to extract the truth from their varying accounts, where we discover that the adults have been manipulative, deceitful, and oppressive, while the two boys have been innocent, natural, and wholesome. All of this to get the message out that the boys, who are "different" (ie. homosexual) are oppressed and harmed by the adults (and their classmates) around them. The music, by Ryuichi Sakamoto, is delicate and impressionistic and works well; the cinematography is pedestrian. The acting is reasonably good. The two boys have chemistry though one does wonder about the adult nature of the story they are asked to tell.
Sakura Ando, Eita Nagayama, Soya Kurokawa, Hinata Hiiragi, Akihiro Kakuta
Controversial operatic film about a Mexican cartel lord who decides to transition to female, while moving his family to Switzerland to protect them. His transition serves two purposes: it allows him to go into hiding and exit the cartel business, and he really wants to be a woman. After five years, however, he longs to be reunited with his family and employs the lawyer, Rita, who arranged his transition, to convince his wife, Jessi, and children that he is a cousin of the disappeared husband and father, and they must move into her house in Mexico. Complications ensue, as one might expect, particularly when his ex-wife takes up with Gustavo and wants to marry Jessi. Karla Sofia Gascon, who portrays Emilia, is a trans woman actress, and is reasonably convincing in the role-- the audience might be surprised when she is encountered years after the transition-- but Zoe Saldana as lawyer Rita is the real star of the film. Unfortunately, the clever cinematography, striking musical numbers, and excellent performances can't deflect some major flaws, not the least of which is the ridiculous suggestion that helping family members recover the bodies of family members killed by the cartels is somehow admirable when led by Emilia-- who, as Manitas, was responsible for a lot of deaths himself. It's insulting and trivializing of the issue. Latino critics have also been scandalized by the absurdly inaccurate accents employed by Saldana (Rita) who was supposed to be native Mexican and Selena Gomez as Jessi. And there's more! LGBQ+ advocates don't think the portrayal of the trans Emilia was honoring enough of their cause. In emotional tone, the movie spirals into a trans "Wuthering Heights" at times, and the director couldn't resist the temptation of a spectacular ending at the expense of credibility (who would bring ransom to the kidnappers at an isolated location where they would have no reason leave a witness). It just doesn't live up the grandiose schematic in the end but it's great fun at times and Zoe Saldana really does give an Oscar worthy performance.
Zoe Saldana, Karla Sofia Gascon, Selena Gomez, Adriana Paz, Edgar Ramirez, Mark Ivanir, Eduardo Aladro
Dry, passionless story about a woman with terminal cancer, Martha, who reconnects with an old friend, Ingrid, partly in order to arrange to have someone with her when she terminates her life with a pill acquired through the "dark web". Mysteriously reviewed kindly by several reviewers, I am baffled that the director of "Matador", "All About My Mother", and "Talk to Her", is capable of such a flat, life-less production on such a compelling subject. Firstly, the dialogue is remarkably banal, predictable, and cliche-ridden (as when Ingrid cites Martha's work as a journalist based in Paris, of course, or when Ingrid tells Martha she is busy moving- "you know what moving is like"-- as if she assumes we need to know that Martha may have moved sometime previously). Julianne Moore and Tilda Swinton are both, normally, capable actresses, but here they seem completely unrehearsed, at times as if they are reading from cue cards. All the twists-- well, not really "twists"-- of the plot are transactionally, flatly rendered. Any possible complications are tidily resolved. Damian is introduced as a token former lover with no discernible role in the outcome. The police seem weirdly interested in whether a terminally ill cancer patient might have offed herself, and the threat of being caught hovers over the narrative as if it really had any relevance. Ingrid and Martha have a near gay experience with each other, intimate, affectionate, but nothing much is made of it. Then, ridiculously, Michelle, Martha's daughter, enters the plot, played by Tilda Swinton , desperately trying to look twenty years younger (and failing). There is some kind of reproachment between the deceased Martha and Michelle, we are supposed to believe, but it is handled with numbing flatness. The music is mostly string-quartet-ish: pretty good but not enough to move the viewer. Almodovar makes sure we know how positively the two women feel about even transient sexual relationships.
John Turturro, Julianne Moore, Tilda Swinton, Alessandro Nivola, Juan Diego Botto, Alex Hogh Andersen, Victoria Luengo, Esther McGregor
Erratic but entertaining series about "Slough House", a division of MI5 where failed agents go. In each of the four seasons (so far), they inadvertently become enmeshed in a very big, significant intelligence screw-up (usually due to corruption or nefarious rogue elements) and somehow manage to overcome the bad guys but still end up looking like screw-ups. Well acted and well filmed, clever, a bit over the top at times, but fresh and diverse.
Gary Oldman, Jack Lowden, Kristin Scott Thomas, Hugo Weaving, Jonathan Pryce, Ruth Bradley, James Callis, Joanna Scanlan, Saskia Reeves, Christopher Chung, Rosalind Eleazar, Aimee-Ffion Edwards, Kadiff Kirwan, Naomi Wirthner, Sean Gilder
Charming, genteel, modest meditation on friendship, love, and languor. Four women arrange a month-long vacation in an Italian castle on the coast of the Mediterranean in April and find the experience pleasant and invigorating. Not much really happens: they arrive out of the dismal English rain and their shabby dissatisfying lives and revel in the sunshine and beauty of the villa (including a staff of cook, cleaner, and handyman-gardener). Rose is moody and reserved. Lotty is vivacious and optimistic. Mrs. Fisher is older, tidier, more fixated on order and punctuality. Caroline is a beautiful actress who is having an affair with Rose's husband and there is a lovely moment of astute forbearance when he surprises the group by arriving to connect with Caroline without knowing that his wife is there as well. Not much happens, other than the women talking and exploring and napping and reveling in a newfound sense of pleasure in themselves. It's almost likes "Babette's Feast" with a garden standing in for the food. Even Mrs. Fisher lightens up. It's all very pleasant and wholesome without being sentimental or contrived and you realize how the movies have trained you to expect bitter conflict or ridiculous coincidence or despair and how refreshing it is to see this film deliver it's unexpected affirmations of simple conviviality. "Enchanted April" was filmed in the same castle where author Elizabeth von Arnim wrote the novel it is based on, while staying there for a time. There is no road leading to the castle: cast and crew had to walk up a hill for mile to reach the location.
Alfred Molina, Joan Plowright, Miranda Richardson, Polly Walker, Josie Lawrence, Neville Phillips, Jim Broadbent
The idea must have seemed good: a close look at a companion to the sickly Lytton Strachey, a young woman who seems, at first, to identify as a boy, but later becomes rather vividly heterosexual, and her enduring relationship with the writer. They meet and flirt-- not seriously-- and eventually establish a menage a trois with a man named Ralph Partridge. Partridge eventually fell in love with another woman and broke the arrangement. Carrington longed to marry Strachey but he wouldn't have it and she was so anguished at his death of stomach cancer that, a month later, she shot herself. Contrary to some critical opinion, "Carrington" is lifeless and dull, though lavishly filmed in old mansions and gardens. Emma Thompson never finds her character, never evokes the charisma Carrington is said to have had (numerous men fell in love with her and wanted to marry her), and Pryce seems steadily distant and morose. It just doesn't work. Even the love scenes seem perfunctory. We never do find out what Strachey was famous for (mostly critical tomes on the Victorian era, though he was "inspired" by Dostoevsky) or what he really cared about, other than himself. The film is restrained, I suppose, but so restrained that it seems static and rote.
Emma Thompson, Jonathan Pryce, Steven Waddington, Samuel West, Rufus Sewell, Penelope Wilton, Janet McTeer, Jeremy Northam, Alex Kingston, Peter Blythe
Here's the outline of the story: Elizabeth turns 50 and shockingly discovers that men prefer younger women. After a car accident, she is offered "the substance", a magical potion that will make her young again. She accepts it and a younger Elisabeth is born-- like the alien in "Alien" from her body-- and gets to live the life for seven days before she must hibernate for seven days while Elisabeth goes back to her own 50-year-old body. The new Elisabeth, now called Sue, goes for an audition, becomes a hit, and is so absorbed in her delightful new life (she is actually joyfully accepting and embracing being judged for her physique) that she starts to hedge on the rules, resulting in grotesque permutations of her body. Dennis Quaid plays a slimeball producer named Harvey. I assume he represents all of us disgusting men, leering and chortling while eating-- always a dead giveaway for the villain-- and promoting Sue to the New Year's Eve extravaganza. And then it all breaks down as does the film, into a voluminously overcooked final scene starkly reminiscent of the restaurant scene in Monty Python's "The Meaning of Life" (except, in comparison, the Python sketch had taste. Once again, we have women making a corrosive film about how they feel about what they think men feel about beauty and youth and sex. Even better: what lesbian women think men think. And they are absurdly wrong about nearly every aspect of it. Well, wait-- I suppose there is a category of men who admire thongs and large breasts-- clearly, that is what Fargeat thinks most men are obsessed with. But then she inadvertently proceeds to create a striking, vulgar, obscene, grotesque symphony to the idea that aging women are not beautiful. She tries to shift the blame here to men, but it's Elisabeth who buys into the equation. Fargeat makes a token attempt (when Fred bumps into Elizabeth and expresses an interest in her) to suggest that there might be a rare man who does care about character, but it is Elizabeth who finds herself inadequate and in spite of Fargeat's manipulation, it really is her own fault. This monumental film fails to make the case for the feminist critique at the heart of its concept. There's the irony: she eviscerates men for judging women by their physical beauty but ends up building the entire edifice of her film on the argument that beauty really matters-- it's just that men don't judge it correctly. It's like Amy Schumer constructing entire films in order to contrive a scenario in which men find her irresistibly attractive-- while condemning men for preferring more conventionally beautiful women. "The Substance" is a reimagination of "The Picture of Dorian Gray", though far more repellent and obscene. In fact, what it's missing is the soul of the Wilde story, a structure that reveals something about character and relationships. There is nothing in "The Substance" that probes beneath any surface whatsoever. It's all about shocking scenes of vulgarity and disgust-- mostly, women's disgust with their own bodies. The most dishonest feature of the film is the focus on the "male gaze" when we know that women judge each other far more harshly than men do. That said, it's a clever film. The direction is creative and fresh and striking and involves hundreds of technicians creating colorful sets and then it's all spoiled by herky-jerky handheld shots to conceal the failure to conceptualize action sequences. Many shots, mostly close-ups of needles and flesh, are dragged out to the point where you really wish Fargeat would just get on with it. Other scenes are arbitrarily repetitive with no dramatic effect. Why on earth did this receive a standing ovation at Cannes? Liberals relishing anything that smacks of reverse misogyny? Or the transgressive effect, where something you think other people will find shocking must be daring and original, like Lars Von Trier's "Antichrist" or "Nymphomaniac"? Audiences can sometimes fail to distinguish between something is shocking because it is artistically or intellectually daring (like "Rashomon" or "Monsieur Verdoux" or Von Trier's "Dogville".
Demi Moore, Margaret Qualley, Dennis Quaid, Edwward Hamilton-Clark
Ah ha! Written by Ruth Bader Ginsburg's nephew! Unfortunately, that helps explain this mediocre fluff-piece in tribute to Ruth Bader Ginsburg. The main focus is on her landmark case before the 10th Circuit (not the Supreme Court) over whether a male bachelor was equally entitled to a tax break for hiring a care-worker for his elderly mother while he worked at his job (Moritz v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue). But we get a generous dollop of her relationship with her husband, Martin, who, as the film shows, was very supportive, successful in his own career, and progressive politically. The film fares less honorably in the portrait of Melvin Wulf, the head of the ACLU, who is shown to be sexist, bullying, and unenthusiastic about taking on Moritz. In fact, the ACLU almost immediately supported the case. Two of the women, Dorothy Kenyon and Pauli Murray, never participated in preparations for Moritz as shown in the film, which is too bad, because Pauli is one of the few characters in the film that breathes any life. This is a painfully mediocre film, poorly acted and poorly directed. Felicity Jones is way to young to play Ginsburg at almost any age (she was barely older than the actress playing her daughter), and the scene in which Ginsburg presents her rebuttal-- taking a long time to gather her nerves (I presume)-- is pure bad melodrama. And it never happened. Ginsburg did not flub any part of the presentation and did not even give a rebuttal.
Felicity Jones, Armie Hammer, Justin Theroux, Sam Waterston, Kathy Bates, Cailee Spaeny, Jack Reynor, Stephen Root, Chris Mulkey, Wendy Crewson, Sharon Washington
The first twenty minutes or so are compelling. Dr. Robert Neville, a military scientist of some kind, is all alone in Manhattan having survived a terrible virus that was supposed to kill cancer but instead killed most humans, or changed them into vampire zombies. They have to stay in the dark, so we have the best part of the film: Neville wandering around abandoned Manhattan. Hunting. And trying to find a cure for the virus. Good use of silence and pretty good special effects until the CGI intrudes, and until the idiot director resorts to jerky hand-held camera movements to generate vicarious "action". This is early CGI and not very good. The zombies were supposed to be actors in make-up by it was decided they looked too much like mutant mimes so they were also replaced by CGI creatures, also to the films disadvantage. The biggest problem is that Will Smith is a lousy actor who inhabits this role with all the gravitas of a wet mop. The one scene in which he is marginally effective is, well, marginally effective. But when he does his scientist thing it's hard to believe that this man knows the difference between a test tube and a microscope.
Will Smith, Alice Braga, Charlie Tahan, Salli Richardson-Whitfield, Willow Smith
(Developed by David Simon) "We Own This City" (6 episodes, on Crave) is one of the best drama series on policing and crime I have ever seen. Based relatively tightly on a true story about corrupt police offices in Baltimore in the aftermath of the Freddy Gray scandal, it dissects the tension between the public demand for "tough on crime" policing and the efforts of the justice department (under Obama) to reign in police abuse and racism (an effort that died with the election of Trump).Jon Bernthal, as Jenkins, is terrific, and most of the cast is also very good. The series flips back and forth, cleverly, between incidents of corruption (the police stealing money and drugs from dealers, and money from other innocent people who happen to fall into their crosshairs) and the investigators from the FBI and the justice department, as well as a Civil Rights investigator who has a hard time persuading people that there is any hope of change. The police force in Baltimore was so rife with corruption that it became difficult to prosecute anyone even for actual crimes because so many potential jurors had had run-ins with the police and were prejudiced against them. (Note: it's not really prejudice when your attitude is well-founded). Surprisingly, many of the cops caught in the investigation become eager to cooperate (except for two of them) and the court system did seem to pull through in convicting them.
Jon Bernthal, Jamie Hector, Josh Charles, Dagmara Dominczyk, Wunmi Mosaku, Delaney Williams, McKinley Belcher III, David Corenswet, Domenick Lombardozzi, Nathan Corbett, Don Harvey, Treat Williams, Darrell Britt-Gibson, Bobby Brown
All Contents Copyright © Bill Van Dyk 2017 All Rights Reserved
This is from \dev\moviespdo\reports\reports2024.php.