Parody-do-duh!
Randall said she did not know about any of that. "It was just my simple understanding that I thought you were allowed to write parodies in America," she said, "I have read parodies, and I wanted to write one." NY Times, April 26, 2001
Alice Randall, a black country and western song-writer, has written a novel called "The Wind Done Gone" which sounds like it might be a wonderful parody of "Gone With the Wind". But the soul-less Scarlett police who guard the "legacy" (ha ha ha) of Margaret Mitchell's ridiculous novel have taken Randall to court to prevent her novel from being published by Houghton-Mifflin (preview copies now fetch $250 each on eBay). They have argued that the novel is an infringement of copyright because she uses characters and settings from the original Mitchell novel.
Well, duh.
Exactly how would you do a parody without referencing the subject of the parody?
A Federal District Court in Atlanta decided that Randall would just have to do her parody without the subject. It ruled that Houghton-Mifflin could not publish and sell her book. The ruling is being appealed.
And it should be. It's a dumb ruling.
Update - May 25, 2001: A higher court has just ruled that publication of the book can proceed, because the lower court's ruling makes too great an infringement on the right of free speech, because it is "prior restraint".
Interesting note: Microsoft, Dow Jones & Company, and AOL Time Warner have filed briefs in support of Ms. Randall. I'm not sure why, but it's curious.
