I believe Obama probably doesn't really like the Patriot Act. I'll bet
he also really thought he was going to change things. I believe that
he doesn't quite have the guts we thought he had when he was running for
president. The American military and intelligence establishment, I
figure, confronted him with their juiced-up scenarios of what could happen
if one of these guys that they just know is a terrorist were able to
blow up a subway station or the Statue of Liberty or something, and I'm sure
the Republicans made sure he knew that they would be all over Fox News
blaming him-- and liberals in general-- for the heart-rending deaths of
innocent, lovable, happy, employed American citizens.
The essential dynamic here is this: if the intelligence agency really
had enough accurate information to justly convict a person of a
terrorism-related offense, they could easily do so legally any time they
wanted. In fact, American juries fall all over themselves to
convict anybody-- especially colored or foreign people-- of any offense
imaginable, given the opportunity to do so, upon even the flimsiest evidence
(and even, as recently reported, when the suspect has been exonerated by DNA
evidence!).
The Patriot Act only exists so that the government can circumvent the
normal, rational requirements of the constitution and lock somebody up just
because they just know, in some intangible, irrational, unprovable, way,
that the varmint was up to no good.
I personally find it hard to believe RIM's
assertions that the encryption on the data stored by their Blackberry
servers can only be cracked by the user. The spiel given to the
media today sounded painfully precise and specious.
India, China, Saudi
Arabia, and several other nations have announced that they want RIM to give
them access to software that will allow them to read users' messages and
data. For a week or so, it seemed like it was something RIM could
do, but didn't want to. Then they announced that, no, they couldn't do
it. Only the user could unencrypt his own data.
Hmmm. Hmmmmmm.
Silent through all this was the U.S. Government, which, thanks to the
Patriot Act, can now lock you up without a warrant, send you to Jordan or
Syria to be tortured, then imprison you in Guantanamo for five years, with
no consequences whatsoever (thanks, Obama, for tricking us into believing
you really thought this was unconstitutional or an affront to human rights
in some way). Does RIM want me to believe that the U.S. government was
content to be told that they would not be allowed to look at anyone's data?
Tough luck, Mr. Cheney-- that is a user's private information.
You have no constitutional authority to look at it without permission.
All Contents Copyright
© Bill Van Dyk
2010 All Rights Reserved
Font: Verdana