2011-09-07
The narrative: 8 dangerous anarchists from Austin, Texas travel to Minneapolis in August 2008 intending to sew chaos, destruction, and mayhem during the Republican National Convention. Thank God a trusted, patriotic FBI informant was among the radicals to help the police and FBI intervene in the nick of time, saving property and lives, and preserving the safety and security of Sarah Palin.
It's a simple, comprehensible narrative. And American justice is about narratives, not facts, not truth. The narrative is compelling to frightened American juries and judges. You can't be too careful. The two boys, who did not commit a crime-- at least nothing that was defined as a crime before 9/11-- were convicted, locked up for two and four years.
The truth is more complex. Yes, the boys assembled some Molotov cocktails at the house they stayed in in Minneapolis during the Republic National Convention in 2008. But they never used them. It's not clear that they ever had any serious intent of using them. In a rational world, they never broke the law. They no more broke the law with their assembled bombs than any member of the NRA broke the law by carrying a concealed handgun. Is a concealed handgun alarming? Only to a rational person.
But what role did FBI informant Brandon Darby play in all this? Would they have ever even build the Molotov Cocktails if he hadn't organized the trip to Minneapolis in the first place. Did he hector them, tirelessly trying to persuade them that the depths of depravity they saw in Minneapolis-- and it was depraved (police phalanx, tear gas, batons)-- called for something stronger than a protest sign.
PBS-- the only U.S. network that does any serious journalism anymore-- aired a documentary recently-- "Better This World"-- that offered a compelling glimpse of the dynamics of homeland insecurity, paranoia, manipulation, and the use of informants by the FBI. Brad Crowder and David McKay come off as youthful, passionate, and naive. Brandon Darby, the informant, is cynical, manipulative, and dishonest. The results are appalling.