SNL Stars

The list of comedians commonly assumed to be the big stars of SNL includes:

    • Chevy Chase
    • John Belushi
    • Bill Murray
    • Eddie Murphy
    • Martin Short
    • Chris Farley
    • Tina Fey
    • Will Ferrell
    • Billy Crystal
    • Dan Ackroyd
    • Amy Poehler
    • Steve Martin (a frequent host)

Quick– name a single important movie that any of these “stars” made?   Yes,   I challenge you to name a movie made by an SNL alumnus that really mattered.   Here’s some candidates:

Some of these were okay as entertainment.  None of them, with the exception of “Groundhog Day”, which was, at moments, transcendent, or “Lost in Translation”, really mattered in any serious way.  “Punch-Drunk Love” was completely out of character for Adam Sandler (so out of character it’s the only Sandler movie I can stand) and doesn’t really qualify as the product of an SNL alumnus.

So, while reading the book “Saturday Night Live”, I kept cringing when someone or another would go on and on about what a great “star” so-and-so was when I couldn’t think of single movie this star was in that was important in any way to me– except, perhaps, Bill Murray.  Here’s another discussion of the issue.  In fact, Tina Fey’s “Date Night” had the singular honor of being one of a very, very tiny number of movies that was so bad I walked out on it.  Now, I rarely give up on a movie no matter how bad it is because I consider it always educational to see what Hollywood is up to even if the answer is “not very much”.  But it is well known– to me, at least–  that SNL alumni have starred in some of the worst movies ever made in the past 45 years.   That is amazing, and it’s a testament to the power of celebritydom in modern entertainment.  Hollywood moguls routinely believe that a well known TV comedian will draw droves of fans to their movies.

It’s not a coincidence.  Getting famous for a TV role is not the same as getting famous for a movie role– though the difference is fading with the production of higher quality TV dramas like “The Wire” and “The Pitt”– the difference between Chevy Chase and Peter Sellers.  Between David Morse and Robert Duvall.  At least some movie actors have some reverence for the artistic aspect of their work; TV actors are mostly doing sketches.  Variety show actors are doing skits.

Steve Martin’s “Shopgirl” is an interesting specimen.   A. O. Scott at the New York Times said this about the film:

[It] is a resolutely small movie, finely made and perhaps a bit fragile. Under the pressure of too much thought, it might buckle and splinter; the characters might look flimsy, their comings and goings too neatly engineered, their lovability assumed rather than proven…

That captures beautifully perhaps the least unsuccessful work of film art by an actor (/writer) associated with SNL (on par with — and similar to– “Lost in Translation” with Bill Murray).  Almost there, but limited, perhaps by the boundaries of aspiration.  Martin knows there’s something substantial out there that he is reaching for (like “Grand Canyon“, in which he also starred, perhaps, directed and written by Lawrence Kasdan), but can’t quite reach it himself.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *