Bill Maher

Bill Maher Gives his Incredibly Deep Well-Grounded Profound Take on the History of Palestine in a lecture directed to Chappell Roan.  I don’t know who Chappell Roan is but I suspect that Maher is picking on an easy target here, as he often does.

This is a dumbed down, abbreviated version of the history of Palestine.  And it’s mostly wrong.  But Maher doesn’t let his prejudice inhibit his arrogance: he mocks anyone who dares to believe what is obvious: Israel’s actions in Gaza are criminal.

It’s a shame Maher wastes his talents on this dreck, with tedious laugh breaks from the audience and guests.  Why does he do that?  It makes me cringe.  It appears to be conducted.   His guests for that program are compelled to sit there and smile awkwardly at each round.  If I were one of them, I would leave.  You want to conduct a sequence of punchlines with coordinated audience applause?  Go for it but I have a bus to catch.  I am not a prop for the alleged audacity of your smug put-downs of woke excess.

That is the difference between Bill Maher and John Oliver, by the way.  Maher is smug and cynical and pious about his own rectitude.  Oliver is not.  Oliver regularly, and brilliantly, embraces some seemingly idiotic project as a gesture of humility and insatiable curiosity.  These gestures keep him from the kind of contemptuous arrogance that subverts Maher’s claimed insouciance.

He’s not wrong on most of the facts– except by omission–  but would rather score a quick vulgar putdown than make a coherent point.  And his criticism of the excesses of woke Democrats is not off target, but he seems cumulatively selective and one-sided.  Would Bob Jones University ever invite a liberal speaker?  No they would not.  They wouldn’t even countenance the presence of John McCain– not conservative enough.

He also likes to have conservatives (like Mike Pence) on his show to hi-light and grant appreciative luster for the 10% of things they did right, while mocking and ridiculing people get 90% of what they do right.

This particular episode, defending Matt Damon from accusations of homophobia because he admitted that in his youth he sometimes called gay men “fags”, is absolutely right.

But.

His comments on the October 7, 2023 attack by Hamas that killed over 1200 people are certainly not really “politically incorrect”: he has a raft of conservative and MAGA people on his side on this issue.  Yet he adopts this tone of sarcasm as if he is the adult in the room who knows about this history and he must indulgently learn those liberal critics of Israel’s genocidal attack in retaliation on Gaza about the true facts.  There is nothing wrong with having a well-founded strong opinion about Gaza and Israel but his tone implies that other points of view that can be well-founded and intellectually credible are ridiculous compared to his own enlightened take on the subject.  They are not.

It is very possible to be appalled and horrified by both the Hamas attacks on Israel, and by Israel’s utterly brutal revenge destruction of almost the entirety of Gaza and their attacks on south Lebanon.   It is possible to find both Hamas and Netanyahu monstrous.  Most of the people I know who have thought about the issue feel that way.  Maher doesn’t seem to think it is a credible point of view.   If you condemn Netanyahu, he thinks he can tag you as pro-Hamas.

Maher adopts the dubious rationale of Palestine being the historic homeland of the Jews– he even cites the bible–  so, after an absence of 2000 years, they are entitled to re-occupy it, and he suggests that it was not occupied by anyone else at the time.  I didn’t hear the word Nahkba once in his diatribe.

There is no moral law that rationalizes possession of a specific land according to who occupied it at any previous point in time.  The world is full of places where peoples were driven out or annihilated or migrated.  The idea of restoring everyone to their original native land is a recipe for chaos and does not serve any higher moral purpose.  Does he have the same perspective on the Sioux or other indigenous tribes?  On the Irish?  Brazil?

Maher believes that Israel’s actions in Gaza are above reproach, justified by Hamas’ attack of October 7th, and Hamas’ avowed mission of destroying Israel.  He’s not wrong about Hamas, but I do not believe that Israel’s response is proportionate or responsible.  Where is the end of this progression?  The two-state solution is almost dead, but the endless cycle of attack and revenge is not much of an alternative.  Does Maher have any problem with the long-term status of Palestinians living in the region?  Will they become second class citizens of an apartheid Israel?

Maher’s recent work belongs on Fox; not HBO. The net result of his rants is to convince people that because both sides of the American divide can be ridiculed, they are both essentially the same.  His point is not moral truth.  His point is that he is smarter than the people he ridicules by cherry-picking their public statements because he make witty vulgarities out of what seems obvious.  Or he has a guest like John Fetterman and suddenly he’s a docile, congenial host, conspicuously ignoring questions about Fetterman’s health and fitness.

And yet, in a bizarre and incomprehensible attempt to buff his bipartisan credentials,  he actually had the idiot harpy Anne Coulter on.  Have a conservative on your show?  By all means.  But Anne Coulter is a phony, sponsored conservative apparatchik who doesn’t deserve the exposure, and Maher is an idiot for putting her on his show.  Jordan Peterson?  The man whose whole shtick is making idiot right-wingers feel smart.

The effect of his bipartisan ridicule is this:  Donald Trump is the same as Kamala Harris.  Pete Hegseth is the same as Lloyd Austin.  Robert Kennedy Jr. is the same as Anthony Fauci. Andrew Miller is the same as Jake Sullivan.

This is a mistake John Oliver does not make.  Maher is too narcissistic to bother with concrete solutions; Oliver almost never loses his rational perspective.  He always offers a possible remedy for the toxic behaviors he describes. Oliver believes that taking potshots at everything from a safe virtual tower of pious cynicism is a lousy way to do commentary and leads to quietism and indifference.

Would Maher ever run for political office?  And then have to be accountable for the actual implementation of his views?  What, I would be very interested know, does he think politicians should do?  Raise the minimum wage?  Increase tariffs?  Tax the rich?

He knows that there is another Bill Maher out there in wait who will shred his performance the way he shreds others.

Maher has a degree from Cornell University in English literature and history.  You wouldn’t know it.

He’s not all bad.  He’s right, here, mostly, about political aides, but, again, note how he implies that the Democrats and Republicans are equally absurd.  They are not.  There will always be a few on the fringe in either party who are idiots, but the Republicans have made idiocy their uniform identity with Donald Trump.

I suspect Maher is simply trying to please the lowest common denominator.

There is a resonant fable we can attach to Maher, though.  In 2002, while hosting “Politically Incorrect”, Maher agreed with a guest that, whatever else you call them, the 9/11 hijackers were not cowards, while people firing cruise missiles from 2,000 miles away were cowardly.  It tells you everything you need to know about American culture, and perhaps culture in general, that “Politically Incorrect” was then cancelled for being politically incorrect.  The lesson is that everyone wants everyone else to think they are open-minded and intellectually courageous but the minute a genuinely courageous opinion generates a backlash, everyone ducks under the covers and shits themselves.

“No one is ever smarter from going on Bill Maher,” Ms. Pollitt said in an interview on Thursday.

One final observation: Bill Maher did a piece I generally liked on cancel culture.  Unfortunately, he missed the forest.  All the examples he gives are from “woke” crowds and institutions and universities objecting to certain controversial jokes without making a single reference to conservatives who are actually so much more regressive on the issue that you almost forget about them.  Come on Maher: you’ve got to be kidding me.  The party that will excommunicate anyone who doesn’t salute the flag (and display a lapel pin), praise Jesus, bow before the military, and praise America as the greatest, bestest, most wonderfullest nation in the history of the universe— you give them a pass?  That’s not political correctness? Nobody is more politically correct than a conservative.  You just don’t notice it as much because, unlike liberals, they don’t even simulate broad-mindedness and tolerance.

Okay. In fairness, here’s a recent attempt to take on the hypocrisies of Republicans.  And here he is giving it to extremists and their enablers on both sides.

And here’s another good response to Maher’s arguments about Israel.

The Sad Way of All Medical Dramas: The Pitt (Season 2) Descends into Soap

The surest sign that a medical drama has descended into the depths of  television vulgarity is when one of the patients is a relative or close friend of one of the doctors.  Mel King’s sister is admitted.  Why the hell do we suddenly have patients with close relationships with the doctors? Then another: an old friend of Robanovitch’s.  Then another.   It is a tip-off that more obscenity is to come.

The inevitable second bad sign: characters start treating other characters like family.   Robinavitch is planning a sabbatical on a motorcycle and nurses and doctors nag him about safety in a way that feels like a projection of the perceived audience’s feelings about Robinavitch.  Not the audience I like– but the mass audience out there now dropping in to see “The Pitt” because of all the acclaim.  Other characters are beginning to offer advice and uncomfortably intimate expressions of concern for each other.  The proverbial “television family”.  We project our feelings of warmth and trust upon these avatars of our own narcissism.

And the third, most fatal sign: the doctors start treating each other.

“The Pitt” started out well.  Very well.   It was the averred intent of the program to focus on the action in the ER of a major hospital, and season one did so, and it was scintillating.  Fresh.  Shocking at times.  Frank.  We all know where medical drama’s usually go: to dreck and soap but  “The Pitt” was going to be different.  It was going to be rich with texture and depth and insight.  It actually asserted that it was NOT going go the way of “ER” and “St. Elsewhere” (which also started out well), or “Grey’s Anatomy” or– horrors!– “House” (probably the drama of this bunch with the highest ratio of narcissistic piety).

Season 2 started out okay– more shocking scenes and some texture and depth.  Until.  Until we realized– about episode 11– that Noah Wyle (a producer) was mugging for an Emmy.  Until we started getting long heart-to-heart conversations between the regulars while patients are shown waiting for one of the damn doctors to actually come and treat them.  Until we are treated to mawkish displays of characters “caring too much”, getting all self-righteous and pious about defending “my nurses”, or standing up to ICE, or planning to deprive an elderly couple of their independence after a very brief interaction with them about a minor injury: oh how smug and insular that little episode was!

A patient attacks a nurse and Charge Nurse Dana Evans, armed, apparently, with some kind of powerful sedative, Versed, (which she just happened to have in her pocket), jumps him and knocks him out, and everybody is just kind of isn’t that adorable that she is so protective of her charges even after we find out that the patient was on a bad drug trip.  The repellent aspect of this sequence is the way the show manipulates the viewer into seeing Evans as a hero by having the patient later curse and swear at the doctors.  It’s a cheap trick.  It would have been far more interesting if he had been shown to be somewhat appalled at himself and perhaps remorseful at learning he would be charged.  But the then the audience wouldn’t have been able to congratulate themselves for siding with the virtuous Evans, whom we are given to understand is “feisty” and smart– and, of course “cares too much”–  which is a way of allowing a character to behave in ways that we would otherwise would find annoying or offensive or illegal.

Incidentally, have you ever been in an Emergency Room at a major hospital?  How often would you hear doctors or nurses saying “fuck this” or “fuck that”?  And why do almost all the characters do it when, in real life, a good portion of any group do not?  It makes all the characters begin to sound alike, dulling the interesting diversity in this group in the first season.

The real reason they do it?  Actors love it: it’s a badge of “authenticity” and grit.  Actors rarely offer to be the character that provides realistic balance to the array of personalities in the story.

And the problem with introducing more and more patients who are directly related to the doctors?  We see Duke, a dear, witty, bearded friend of Robinavitch come in for a sore throat.  I was puzzled as to why he was admitted.  With a sore throat?  But he languishes in a room for a long, long, long time while Robinavitch carries on various conversations and drops in on other patients and lectures this resident or that and kvetches over paperwork.  One wonders why the hell he doesn’t go take care of his patient. Someone wants us to believe that none of the other doctors  in the ER can handle the various issues that arise.  Seriously?  Our world is on the brink of disaster, if this is true.  It’s not.

We wonder why Robinavitch, who had been shown to be a patient, caring Chief Attending Physician in Season 1, is suddenly short-tempered, intolerant, and  irrational.  And then we realize where we are heading:  to the most predictable  marshland of TV Drama cliche:  Robinavitch is going to get some therapy to deal with his trauma goblins.  He’s not a prick!  Oh, no: he’s got trauma!  He’s going to cry and break down!  He will seek therapy because even an amazing charge physician like Robinavitch is not qualified to deal with his “issues” all by himself.   He needs a credentialed therapist!  He will find healing and love. And I will mentally puke with disgust and curse the TV gods for taking another promising drama and turning it into wretched dreck.  And curse the vanity of actors/producers who shamelessly promote themselves by providing  the story with exhibitionist scenes of wildly extravagant emotional breakdowns at the expense of dramatic integrity.

In another episode, or the same one, a different hospital that was hacked pays the ransom to get back on line.  That’s realistic but it would have been nice to have an acknowledgment of the problem: paying off ransomware hackers encourages more ransomware.  The script should have acknowledged that issue.

In the new world of the second season of “The Pitt”, we enter the realm of affirmations and therapy and the fantasy of nurses and doctors who always find time to have emotional conversations in the middle of an ER we have been led to believe is frenetic with urgent medical emergencies. Unfortunately, S02E14 descends even further, with the preposterous sequence in which Dr.  Langdon redeems himself in Robinavitch’s eyes by performing a near miraculous procedure, a “closed reduction of facet joint” on a traffic accident victim.  Seriously?  And we’re not back in the worst traditions of the medical drama?  (We are).

And Robinavitch will not be the only doctor to take the path of TV therapy (in which the only cure for emotional distress is to uncover the “trauma” that caused it — because it is always caused by trauma, and not by deficiencies or weakness of character):  Dr. Al-Hashimi must reveal to Robinavitch– whom she has known for exactly one day– her own past trauma (involving an ailment) which, again, is offered as an excuse for emotional distress, lavished on the viewer while patients continue to mob the ER. What a pity.  Robinavitch has become a bore.

This episode, written by Noah Wyle himself, appears to credit the claims of some critics that Wyle is pandering for an Emmy.  Now it’s all about him and how he just cares so damn much that can’t bear to even leave on his sabbatical because– we are given to believe– nobody else can run the ER like him.  This is obviously bullshit.  If it were true, the ER could never survive since he can’t possibly be there all the time, and there is nothing remarkable about the day being dramatized that would not be remarkable about any day in the ER. We are further encouraged to believe that Wyle is heroic and beloved for his dedication when any self-respecting physician would actually likely get royally pissed off at him interceding in every case like an overbearing nanny.  “I only do it because I want the best.”

Even worse, we have a doctor who has been on his feet racing around for 15 hours straight: in TV land, everything goes right and he saves lives.  In real life, you make mistakes when you are exhausted and can’t resist taking a shortcut here or there and someone in some lawsuit is going to point out that it is a fucking bad idea to work 15 hours straight. The dynamic of other physicians expressing concern about his health makes me cringe.  He is their boss and the creative team behind these episodes seem clueless about the psychological dynamics of boss-staff relations.  When they question his well-being, they are questioning his competence.  People in the position of Robinavitch would take umbrage in real life.

I am reminded of the decline in “West Wing” when suddenly Leo was hectoring President Bartlett about his behavior and policies.  It was stupid.  No President would put up with it for a second.

What would have improved these episodes immeasurably would have been a creditable character ridiculing Robinavitch and pointing out how his obsessive enmeshment with all of the decisions being made is not the product of virtuous professionalism but of narcissism.

Episode 15: well, there it is.  It’s now the Noah Wyle show.  Pity the rest of the cast who now get the delicious opportunity to deliver five or six lines in a one hour program, because all the rest of the screen time is now occupied by Robinavitch’s kvetching about maybe not wanting to come back after his sabbatical.  Then it really takes the plunge: he hints about considering suicide.

Because, well, he just cares too damn much!

It’s preposterous.  “The Pitt” hasn’t laid the groundwork for that kind of epochal development.  They want Robinavitch to be a saint who insists on interceding with every other ER physician’s process and can’t leave even when he’s exhausted and doesn’t think anyone can match his level of genius and leadership, and then they suddenly want him to be broken and considering suicide?  It’s a gratuitous and banal twist in his character and almost certainly the product of the actor Wyle having control over the script and direction.

The scene of the day-staff on the roof watching fireworks while “America the Beautiful” plays was gauche; just restrained enough to avoid being called “gauche” but not elegant enough to not be gauche.

If this is where “The Pitt” is headed, I will not be back, 

Ecstatic!

From Here.

Just read this!  It is astonishing.

Oprah Winfrey, Reese Witherspoon and Jenna Bush Hager looked ecstatic as they stood onstage at the Ford Foundation in Manhattan earlier this year, posing with a new book. The crowd was so large it required an overflow room.

The book is a memoir, “The Tell” by Amy Griffith.  “One of the wealthiest women in the country”.

In the memoir, Ms. Griffin, 49, writes that she engaged in illegal psychedelic-drug therapy. While under the influence of MDMA, the active chemical in Ecstasy and Molly, she said she recovered memories of being raped on many occasions by a middle-school teacher in Amarillo, Texas, starting when she was 12.

How can anyone dare to continue to pose the question– so purely rhetorical it stinks– of why someone would tell the story of sexual abuse if it wasn’t true?  Well, isn’t it obvious?  Oprah, Reese, and Bush are all ecstatic– ecstatic– to present a book about the terrible, awful, horrible experience of sexual abuse.  Of a woman, Amy Griffith, who was raped when she was 12.   They are, I repeat, ecstatic.

Yes, of course they are not ecstatic about the abuse.  They are ecstatic about the privilege of presenting the information about it to the entire world– they are ecstatic about so many people hearing about it, buying the book (because they want to read about it), watching and relishing the endless talk-show regurgitations, the tears, the virtue signaling, the triumphalism.  And Griffin is ecstatic that she now has an excuse for why she felt so lousy about herself for so long even though she had everything anyone could ever want in life.  She is ecstatic to declare that she is a victim.

The unspeakable facet of victimhood that no one wants to talk about?  Privilege.  Usually, to excuse drug addiction, depression, professional failure.  I was good but then someone made me bad.

All of which, in this case, appears to be based on a fraud.

A former classmate of Ms. Griffin has told the same story– even about some of the actual specifics of Ms. Griffin’s telling– except that it involved a different teacher.  Did Ms. Griffin– who couldn’t remember the abuse without the assistance of a therapist and hallucinogens– lift the story from her classmate, while changing the identity of the alleged abuser?  This is pertinent: some people have decoded Ms. Griffin’s story and identified the teacher who committed the alleged abuse.  But it is not the same teacher identified by the former classmate.  And no other former students of the teacher identified from Griffin’s book have ever come forward with allegations about him.

An “expert” on MDMA says “the reliability of memories retrieved with MDMA… are often symbolic”.   He adds that even if the memories are not true, people can “develop stories that help them make sense of their life”.  Well, that’s a generous spin on confabulation.

I don’t think you could be more damning about it.  It’s okay to lie if it makes you feel better about yourself, even if you make very serious allegations about an innocent person, a teacher, whose reputation has been severely damaged.

Ms. Griffin’s “defamation lawyer” says this:  “the mere sending of this document [a letter from the Times asking for clarification] has caused additional trauma and extreme physical and emotional harm to a survivor of sexual assault, which is inexcusable.”  This from the lawyer of a woman doing everything she can to let the entire world know about her “abuse”.  This, from the lawyer of a woman who is “ecstatic” to appear on Oprah and talk about it with other celebrities.

How dare you challenge the honesty of a self-described victim of abuse?

The Times also asked the publisher if they had fact-checked the story.  The publisher responded to the Times by saying that Dial Press is a publisher, not an investigator.

With all the publicity, a family support organization in Amarillo, where Ms. Griffin is from, provided facilities for any individual to come forward to get help if they had been sexually abused.  After six months, not a single taker.

The danger in all this is that once again the idea of “recovered memories” is put into the mainstream and is sure to inspire others to recover memories of abuse and come forward and make allegations.  We’ve been through this cycle before I thought we had mostly come to our senses: recovered memories are not reliable and should never be the basis of public allegations.   The issue has been studied, researched, and tested, and it failed decisively.

More on Recovered Memories

The Politically Correct “Star Trek New Worlds”

For not the first time, the custodians of the Star Trek legacy have decided deflower Mr. Spock.

What, my friends, was unique and interesting about Mr. Spock in the original TV series?  It was that he was a rational person who believed in Reason and Science, in contrast to the humans around him who were still wildly swayed by their emotions (though one could argue that Kirk, in his best moments as captain, acted rationally).

Spock would sometimes inform the captain that the odds of succeeding in a particular course of action were miniscule– and then Kirk would take the gamble anyway.  This was TV land, so Kirk’s unlikely gambles always succeeded but, even as a  12-year-old watching “Star Trek” for the first time, I thought they should have showed us that Spock was usually right, and gambles against ridiculous odds were foolish.

We all want the virgin.  Yes, I am comparing the character of Spock to a virgin.  The creative teams that handled the Star Trek franchise realized they had a lovely virgin on their hands, a character who, through his dedication to Science and Reason, had won the admiration of an entire generation of sci-fi fans.  It is similar, to me, to the appeal of a young virgin in a whorehouse.  Who does the guest most want to deflower?  Not those tired old saggy whores, but the young beauty who has never been violated.   In the same way, for cheap dramatic effect, they wanted to twist Spock’s character and have him become emotional at a moment of peak tension.  You see?  Even Spock agrees with my cheap emotional insistence that the entire crew of the Enterprise be risked in order to save his buddy, Kirk, even though it is unreasonable to do so.

In a subsequent iteration (“Star Trek Into Darkness”, 2013), they even had the older Spock time-travel so he could advise the younger Spock to “go with your feelings”.  I cringed.

And now we have “Star Trek: Strange New Worlds” in which “the series takes the opportunity to explore Spock’s human emotions before he becomes more computer-like”.

Thank you.  You just destroyed the most interesting character in the entire series.

Again.

Not only that, but Spock gets a human girl-friend, Nurse Chapel, whom, we are given to understand, becomes one of “Spock’s great teachers about his humanness”.

I think I’m going to vomit.  Not only do they emasculate Spock’s rationality– they emasculate his gender.  And clearly, the purpose is to attack the alleged “toxic masculinity” of the original version.  Captain Pike, in this new version (set ten years before the original series), is “more thoughtful and empathetic” and likes to bake.  I’m not making this up.  The character of La’An Noonien-Singh, the “chief of security”, was, we are told, bullied as a child because of her ethnicity.

The courage of the original producers to include an Asian, a Russian, and a black woman among the command personnel has been replaced by gratuitous adherence to woke ideology.

And we get a prequel that is more socially “progressive” than the most socially progressive program on TV in the 1960’s except that in 2025 it’s not progressive at all: it is utterly conventional, by today’s standards.

I am a progressive.  But there are times when I get why so many right-wing podcasters attack the culture of political correctness.  Having a Mr. Spock who is masculine and rational is not a political endorsement of masculinity or rationality: it is recognition that such things exist, given the storyline about the planet Vulcan, and have existed, and will always exist (sometimes it feels like the stereotypical forms of masculinity are returning right now).

And I would join the argument that Mr. Spock’s rationalism is good, and more likely than Kirk’s hunches, to lead to victory or success.

It would have been far, far more interesting, to let Spock’s rationality play out because, as in real life today, the Rational and Coherent and Scientifically Defensible, is under attack by MAGA and the reams of people who really believe that American healthcare is superior to that in all the other nations, even if it is free for everyone, and that the recycling label on the bottom of your plastic jug means it will be recycled, and the evidence or climate change is the product of a hoax, and that nations should negotiate for the release of hostages.

It would be electrifying to see Spock inform his crew that negotiating for the release of a hostage would make the strategy successful for their adversaries and will only ensure that more hostages will be taken.  Or that promoting minorities by ethnicity rather than merit would diminish the effectiveness of the crew.  Or that a crew member shouldn’t be so thin-skinned about a harmless sexually suggestive joke.

The new series, “Strange New Worlds” appears to at least embrace more of a sense of humor than the dour “Next Generation” did.

My Previous Dissection of the Issue

The Bear

The Guardian loves Season 4 of “The Bear”. “Where once The Bear made pulses pound, now it lets the happy tears flow; the second half of the season is like one long therapy session.” Yes it is. It’s like the whole show is seeing a bad therapist. It’s become like an old 70’s soap opera, with better music. Long dreary close-ups of characters having feelings and feelings about feelings and feelings about the other characters having feelings about feelings until most of the characters begin to sound alike.

Clearly, a lot of improvised dialogue. Not everyone should write dialogue.

Maybe not really “feelings” so much as over-flowing self-infatuation.

What’s left of plot and narrative makes little sense.

I don’t necessarily think it’s a mistake to make Sydney a young genius.  But I’m not convinced by Ayo Edebiri’s performance in the role.  She does nothing to convey the kind of personality you see in people who are extremely accomplished or intensely ambitious.  She is decidedly mundane in demeanor, prosaic, even dull.  Nobody thought to insert scenes in which she has a real rapport with the other staff, or pleasure in success, or a deep-seated commitment to her tasks.  She is predictable.

Monkee See

Here’s the well known story about the Monkees:

In the mid 1960’s– 1966, to be more precise– Screen Gems decided that a TV show inspired by (read– copied from) the Beatles’ movies “Help” and “A Hard Day’s Night”– might be a hit.  They already had a young British singer and potential heart-throb Davy Jones under contract so they put out an ad in Variety looking for young male singers/actors and held auditions. They ended up with a couple of actual musical artists in Peter Tork and Michael Nesmith, and a singer Mickey Dolenz.  They were hired as employees of Screen Gems and put to work.

The whole project was a typical piece of exploitive corporate derivative trash.  It was conceived of as trash, executed as trash, and will never not be be trash, no matter how much nostalgia one wafts over it.  It catered to the most manipulable segment of the television audience, adolescents and pre-teens.

The original sin of this project was Screen Gems trying– not too, too hard– to make it look like the Monkees were a real band.  They tried to hide the fact that the musicians on their first album were all paid studio ringers, though the vocals were provided by the actual Monkees.  On the TV show, the Monkees pretended to be playing their instruments as they performed the songs.  They were also pretending to sing, but that goes without saying– almost every piece of dreck at the time used studio recordings dubbed over the video of the performance, even on American Bandstand and Hullabaloo.  (Ed Sullivan was, generally, the rare exception.)

The boys did record the vocals, in a studio.  Producer Don Kirshner quickly discovered that they had to bring the boys in one at a time or they would clown around endlessly and run up expensive studio time without getting a decent take down.

Here’s the popular conception about it today: the Monkees really wanted to write their own songs and play their own instruments and they complained bitterly that the studio, led by a crass producer, Don Kirshner, wouldn’t let them.  Most writers about the issue today are sympathetic to the band members.  They were oppressed and exploited by Screen Gems and their talents cruelly repressed.

Because, after all, they really were a great band.

Let’s get that out of the way for a moment: the Monkees were a shallow pop band of no artistic significance whatsoever.   Like ABBA and Bobby Sherman and David Cassidy and the Partridge Family, they were a product, shallow, derivative, inane, and trivial.  The studio musicians used on the recordings were competent– sometimes excellent– but they were interchangeable parts of a complex of almost mechanical production.

(I saw a recent interview with Bobby Hart, one half of one of the song-writing teams that wrote songs for the band, and he was quietly lobbying for more respect by insisting that “Last Train to Clarksville” was actually a protest song because the narrator had been drafted and was going to Clarksville to be sent overseas: “I don’t know if I’m ever coming home”.  Yeah.  Deep.)

They began to believe their own press.  They became delusional, attributing their popularity to something magical they had in themselves, outside of the entertainment complex that nurtured and managed and exploited them.

I am not sympathetic.  I absolutely believe that Michael Nesmith, and Peter Tork, and Davy Jones, and Mickey Dolenz should have been completely free to not sign contracts with Screen Gems, not audition for them, and embark on musical careers on their own, play gigs, rehearse, practice, go to New York, whatever they want.  On their own.  Without the massive and overwhelming support of the Hollywood machinery that made them famous.

Nesmith might well have had a career.  He had money– his mother invented Liquid Paper (that’s a whole other era!) and time.  Tork was somewhat known as a solo artist in New York, though I doubt he would ever have become famous.  Dolenz and Jones were not going to have an impact anywhere, though Jones might have made it on TV as a Bobby Sherman type teen heartthrob for as long as it lasts.  They were all born on third base and thought they hit a triple.

But this righteous indignation!  If I had been in Kirshner’s position (as much as I despise him), I would have fired them all and enthusiastically encouraged them to go for it: embark on careers in the music industry and fulfill your heart’s most passionate desires, to write songs and perform with your instruments, and the best of luck to you.

Does that mean we won’t be on TV in prime time every week for a couple of years?  Well, no: that’s the job you turned down.

That is not what you were hired for.  And that’s not the agreement that was signed.  You voluntarily signed up to be actors in a contrived, derivative TV program.  Then you decided you wanted to be co-creators of the TV show for which you were hired as actors.   The creative jobs were already taken when you signed on.  Good bye.

It is unseemly to take advantage of the monumental publicity apparatus Screen Gems provided them and the privileged access it gave you and declare that, as someone else observed, you really are Vulcans.*

It’s similar in some ways to Hilary Clinton running for president.  Yes, she may have been cute and had a great hair-style, but she obtained the platform from which to run by virtue of being married to Bill Clinton, who did start from nothing, built a career as a local politician and then a governor, acquired a stable of donors to fund a presidential run, and ran for and won the presidency.  He gave you some high-profile jobs in his administration– and a lot of privileged connections– which you leveraged into a Senate run and then a run for the presidency which, against all odds, you lost, to an idiot, the worst candidate for president in 200 years.

She may have been smart.  She may have been as qualified as any other presidential candidate in recent history.  But there really are lots of those around.  She was the fucking wife of a former president who leveraged her privileged access to the corridors of party politics to push herself to the front of the line.

  • * Peter Tork stated:  “The Monkees creating the album Headquarters was like Leonard Nimoy becoming a Vulcan”.  Here.

 

 

 

Profound Contrived Authencity: Little Bird (the MiniSeries)

Together, they reached for what Moscovitch calls “profound authenticity,” and created an opportunity for narrative activism: the idea that victims can help heal their trauma and change attitudes by telling their stories.  Globe & Mail

I don’t mind if someone wants to make a film or mini-series that “will help heal trauma and change attitudes”.  Just don’t put it on my playlist.

Changing attitudes is not the mission of real art.  Real art is about expression, revelation, insight, and beauty.  The minute you say, “oh, and we want people to  adopt our political views”, you have sold out the aesthetic dimension to the social dimension.  To make a film to tell people what to think about the way indigenous people were treated in Canada is to make a bad film.  To make a film about the way indigenous people were treated in Canada, just make a good film.  And if you are authentic about it, tell us what you know about the subject: not what you want us to think. And be honest: don’t caricature or exaggerate or make things up just to drive your point home.  Watch a film like “Come Sunday” which makes its point without dumbing down the issues.

So when my wife asked me to find the series “Little Bird” for her to watch, I checked it out.  I thought, it might be good.  I might want to watch it.  I looked for reviews on line and found the “review” (it’s not a review: it’s a press release disguised as news) linked above.

I suspect this series is about making liberal viewers feel great about themselves: I watched a sad story about injustice and felt bad for the victims for I am a good person.

I watched the first ten minutes.  As I feared, it starts by showing the girls who were abducted by the Canadian Child Family Services and RCMP living in nearly idyllic conditions with their happy affectionate parents.   Even worse: there’s that jerky hand-held camera work that immediately conveys “oh look how authentic we are we’re pretending we’re actually filming the real thing which wouldn’t be possible if we had a tripod” vibe.

I am immediately repulsed by most films that show parents being incredibly tolerant and affectionate and patient and loving with their kids as a setup for imminent tragedy or threat.  Nobody interacts with their children the way these parents do.  It’s manipulative and dishonest.  It is the hallmark of bad direction.  And that is how “Little Bird” starts.

In “Little Bird,” Bezhig is driven by her newly emerging repressed memories.  Variety

Oh no.  Seriously?  We’ve been through this movie before and it did not turn out well.  Not at all.    Not this time either.

Podemski: We looked at all the various ways in which trauma presents itself. Especially when it has been repressed for many years . We worked with our two story advisors, Nakuset and Raven Sinclair, who supported us in shaping the way in which our lead character, Esther, experienced PTSD through intrusive memory. We were able to express this authentically through the use of acoustic and visual layers which I think played very authentically throughout the story.

Okay, firstly, it’s not the trauma that has been repressed but the memory of it.  And memories are not repressed.  That is a fake trope from the 1980’s that has pretty well lost all credibility.   And the method by which they decided to tell the story of the “repressed” memories sounds more like therapy than art.  But please don’t try to claim anything like “authenticity” when you are clearly constructing a narrative that projects a political and social idea rather than any particular real human experience.

 

A CBC article on the movie contains this flag:

WARNING: This story contains distressing details

Oh please fuck off with your trigger warnings.   This is bullshit.  What kind of news is “distressing”?    A man falsely accused of rape while feminists claim that women never lie about sexual assault?  Al Franken resigning his seat in the Senate over ridiculously trivial allegations of inappropriate behavior?  Tax-payer subsidized sports stadiums?  Music by Neil Diamond?  Senile white men running the U.S. government?   Prescription drugs developed at publicly-funded universities which cost pennies to manufacture selling for $30,000 a pop?

 

 

 

The Indefinite Obscurely Described Effusively Vague President of the Television Political Drama

I’ve pretty well had it with TV dramas and their predictable, formulaic, antiseptic, generic piss-pot features.

I watched about ten minutes of the Netflix drama “The Diplomat”.   The first bad sign is also the most fatal: what political party does the President belong to?  The answer?  None.   Apparently, the biggest, most central, most essential dynamic of American politics is absent– like Barbie’s Ken’s penis– because the fucking makers of this show don’t want to offend the half of America that doesn’t like the other half’s political party.

Oh, the British prime-minister is identified as a Tory.  I presume that is so they can safely mock him.  But it makes it even more bizarre that Rayburn is not identified as a Democrat, which is obviously what the show’s creators intend Democrats to think.  Republicans will have to be content imagining that there could be an intelligent, ethical Republican president, and will be gratified to discover that Rayburn is not identified as otherwise in an obvious manner.  But everybody knows that an intelligent, rational, educated leader will be a Democrat or John McCain.

This has been a monumentally stupid component of American mass entertainment since the beginning of television time, right up to just before “The West Wing”, and immediately thereafter.  “The West Wing” brilliantly defied this convention and that’s why it is still regarded as one of the best Television dramas of all time (along with “The Wire”).

Go ahead and tell me if I missed anything.  Keri Russell, using her most anguished constipated oh-I-suffer-so face, plays Kate Wyler, a spunky but smart and competent American diplomat who doesn’t get the respect she deserves even though she is clearly way smarter and spunkier than President Rayburn and his fat, bald Secretary of State Miguel Sandoval, who disapproves when (sigh) Kate “goes rogue to get the job done”.

Kate is not only an overly familiar trope; she is a cliche.  Hers is probably the most familiar trope in entertainment right now: the supposedly tough, roguish, smart, feisty female who shows up all the privileged white men.  The female fans go, “oh — I’m like her. I’m smart and capable and feisty– and smoking hot!– and I don’t get the respect and admiration I deserve!”  This is the media’s form of masturbation.  There will almost certainly be a scene in which she is dragged kicking and screaming to some big event in a fabulous gown and high heels.  Because if she willingly dressed in a fabulous gown and high heels she would be revealed as a vain, superficial, poseur.

Having just watched “State of Play” (the terrific BBC version; not the lame movie with Russell Crowe and Helen Mirren), my taste in political drama has been corrupted.  I’ve watched extensive patches of the contrived “The Americans” and the tediously suffocating “Homeland”.   But after watching “State of Play”, I allowed myself to expect reasonably credible story lines, and I expect characters to be a little less transparently self-serving and narcissistic.

There is no way that any politician or executive with the privilege that they wield would put up with a self-righteous little snit like Kate Wyler telling them they are wrong and they should listen to her and do what she tells them.  Nobody in a position of power will tolerate it.  It’s an affront to their self-respect and egos.  Even if she’s right, they won’t keep her around.  Actually, especially if she’s right.  And in “The Diplomat” aside from the usual defensively scripted token “error” (her only fault was she cared too much), Kate is going to be right all the time, and the men around her are going to be wrong over and over again, and yet they will thrash that dynamic at you over and over again because it is so fucking gratifying to the quasi-feminist audiences out there they will just eat it up.

Incidentally, in some later episodes of “The West Wing”, the writers had Toby and Leo arguing vigorously with President Bartlett and telling him he was doing something unethical or stupid.  These were the weakest episodes of the series and betrayed the fundamental intelligence of the first four years under Aaron Sorkin who understood that no President, no matter how competent,  would tolerate an underling lecturing him on ethics — at least, not for any longer than it would take to have them hand in their resignation.

The Pointless Irrelevant Useless Mind-Numbing Grammys

If they really feel auto-tuned vocalists deserve Grammys, by all means, let’s have a category for that. And lets have a “Truth in Packaging” note at the bottom of the screen when they use it live, as many now do, or at least when they lip-synch to an auto-tuned vocal (so they are actually faking it twice). I might actually tune in to watch if they have a category of “honest to god actual singing” awards, especially if they actually have real musicians playing the instruments on the recording. Until then, every Grammy Awards show should open with Simon & Garfunkel’s “Fakin’ It”.

Won’t someone please create an award restricted to non-auto-tuned performances?  And let me answer my own question: all of the major media companies benefit from the auto-tune scam.  They all sell the same types of artists, the same types of product, the same shit.

There is one possibility: a website devoted to non-auto-tuned artists accompanied by real honest-to-god musicians playing real honest-to-god instruments.   No synthesizers, sequencers, drum machines, and so on allowed.  I would start it myself if I didn’t have more than enough other activities to keep me busy.  They could have articles and links and they should create an annual award for  honest artists in several categories not including rap or hip hop whatever flavor of the decade rears it’s ugly head.

I would suggest these categories:

  • Folk
  • Rock
  • Pop (for the inevitable dreck)
  • Classical
  • Soul
  • Gospel

And no fucking other categories.  Not one, not ever.  Each category would have two sub-categories, for performance and composition.

I suspect that a website like that could develop an impressive following, though it would probably never hit mainstream acceptance.  Vinyl is doing pretty well lately, but it’s no threat to Spotify.

Incidentally, “Grammys” is correct; not ‘Grammies’.

 

The Captive Psychiatrist

The great challenge of American film and literature is this:  the protagonist must disclose powerful personal stories of past abuse or crushing disappointments or betrayals to win the audience’s sympathy (and excuse his addictions, infidelities, and other bad behavior) but telling all this to the object of his or her affections would come off as self-pitying.  The only plausible venue for this type of disclosure is the therapist’s couch.  But in the popular imagination, only a weak effeminate pussy would voluntarily become so vulnerable as to disclose such details, so it must be dramatized as coerced.  Somehow, we must create a dramatic situation in which the protagonist can simultaneously disclose his vulnerabilities and mock the inquisitorial mind.

Here’s the problem, and it’s not a small one:  no psychiatrist or psychologist worth his salt would waste a minute of time on a patient that doesn’t want to cooperate.  It is a bedrock principle of psychotherapy that you can’t provide therapy to someone against his will.

And what therapist would even want to try?

But what if it’s a condition of probation, or shared custody of the children, or a job?  The problem does not change.   If a patient behaved the way Will Hunting behaves in “Good Will Hunting”, the therapist would almost certainly wish him luck in future endeavors and tell him he has willfully thrown away his probation or the job or the custody arrangement or what have you.

And so we have “A Clockwork Orange”, “Good Will Hunting” and “Shawshank Redemption” and “One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest” and “Gangs of New York”, “Antwone Fisher”, and perhaps the worst of all, “Reign Over Me” (in which Liv Tyler played the psychiatrist– seriously) and so on.   It’s become an extremely tiresome trope, a sure indicator that a film writer has run out of ideas or is concerned that his audience is so stupid they won’t get the point of the story.

(An additional trope in many of these films is the therapist who cares so much that he or she chases down the reluctant patient and begs them to receive therapy.  Seriously.  The audience is invited to project themselves into a character so lovable that professional psychiatrist and psychologist will abandon personal schedules and work obligations in order to track them down and drag them into their healing arms.)

“The Sopranos” toys with the issue and frequently straddles the line.  Tony has a real problem: panic attacks.  He stops seeing Dr. Melfi for a while but the panic attacks resume.  He tries a different psychiatrist, who proves ineffectual.  He returns to Dr. Melfi on just barely believable terms, though he frequently blurts out something like, “I’ve had enough of this crap”.  The audience projects itself into a character who thinks he’s smarter than a psychiatrist.

What’s really going on in these scenes is the writer is trying to show that he is smarter than a psychologist or psychiatrist.

The most contemptible examples of this are those mildly enlightened films that pretend to have a real theme, an idea, an enlightened perspective on something, like “Reign Over Me” and “Good Will Hunting”.   “Good Will Hunting” lays the groundwork for the millions of Trump followers who are convinced that those educated elites are really no smarter than the average janitor (played by the charismatic Matt Damon).  But it would not be an asset to the character to have Will admit to how much harm he has suffered from his traumatic upbringing unless he is compelled to admit it; thus, the kludge plot mechanism of having his probation depend on attending therapy sessions with the utterly charming and sexy Robin Williams– who, nevertheless, threatens to kill him at their first session after Will makes light of Dr. Maguire’s wife.  (And the probation?  Another tired trope: Will was involved in a gang fight.  Because he is a bad boy?  Oh no– one of the gang members used to abuse Will when he was a child.  Hollywood loves bad boys but not if they’re really bad, just as they love titillation, but not real, honest sex.)

I used to work in a children’s mental health centre.  I can tell you that almost none of the psychiatrists or psychologists in these films approach believability.  Dr. Melfi in “The Sopranos” is particularly inept.  Now, I’m not saying that psychiatrists or psychologists can actually be smart and effective.  But they do have extensive training and they will have some idea of how they are going to approach the task at hand, even if their approach is contrived or transparent or just plain ridiculous.   Dr. Maguire in “Good Will Hunting” is supposed to win our respect by showing how tough he is when Will mocks his (deceased, unknown to Will) wife.

It’s not admirable: it’s downright stupid.