Bill Maher

Bill Maher Gives his Incredibly Deep Well-Grounded Profound Take on the History of Palestine in a lecture directed to Chappell Roan.  I don’t know who Chappell Roan is but I suspect that Maher is picking on an easy target here, as he often does.

This is a dumbed down, abbreviated version of the history of Palestine.  And it’s mostly wrong.  But Maher doesn’t let his prejudice inhibit his arrogance: he mocks anyone who dares to believe what is obvious: Israel’s actions in Gaza are criminal.

It’s a shame Maher wastes his talents on this dreck, with tedious laugh breaks from the audience and guests.  Why does he do that?  It makes me cringe.  It appears to be conducted.   His guests for that program are compelled to sit there and smile awkwardly at each round.  If I were one of them, I would leave.  You want to conduct a sequence of punchlines with coordinated audience applause?  Go for it but I have a bus to catch.  I am not a prop for the alleged audacity of your smug put-downs of woke excess.

That is the difference between Bill Maher and John Oliver, by the way.  Maher is smug and cynical and pious about his own rectitude.  Oliver is not.  Oliver regularly, and brilliantly, embraces some seemingly idiotic project as a gesture of humility and insatiable curiosity.  These gestures keep him from the kind of contemptuous arrogance that subverts Maher’s claimed insouciance.

He’s not wrong on most of the facts– except by omission–  but would rather score a quick vulgar putdown than make a coherent point.  And his criticism of the excesses of woke Democrats is not off target, but he seems cumulatively selective and one-sided.  Would Bob Jones University ever invite a liberal speaker?  No they would not.  They wouldn’t even countenance the presence of John McCain– not conservative enough.

He also likes to have conservatives (like Mike Pence) on his show to hi-light and grant appreciative luster for the 10% of things they did right, while mocking and ridiculing people get 90% of what they do right.

This particular episode, defending Matt Damon from accusations of homophobia because he admitted that in his youth he sometimes called gay men “fags”, is absolutely right.

But.

His comments on the October 7, 2023 attack by Hamas that killed over 1200 people are certainly not really “politically incorrect”: he has a raft of conservative and MAGA people on his side on this issue.  Yet he adopts this tone of sarcasm as if he is the adult in the room who knows about this history and he must indulgently learn those liberal critics of Israel’s genocidal attack in retaliation on Gaza about the true facts.  There is nothing wrong with having a well-founded strong opinion about Gaza and Israel but his tone implies that other points of view that can be well-founded and intellectually credible are ridiculous compared to his own enlightened take on the subject.  They are not.

It is very possible to be appalled and horrified by both the Hamas attacks on Israel, and by Israel’s utterly brutal revenge destruction of almost the entirety of Gaza and their attacks on south Lebanon.   It is possible to find both Hamas and Netanyahu monstrous.  Most of the people I know who have thought about the issue feel that way.  Maher doesn’t seem to think it is a credible point of view.   If you condemn Netanyahu, he thinks he can tag you as pro-Hamas.

Maher adopts the dubious rationale of Palestine being the historic homeland of the Jews– he even cites the bible–  so, after an absence of 2000 years, they are entitled to re-occupy it, and he suggests that it was not occupied by anyone else at the time.  I didn’t hear the word Nahkba once in his diatribe.

There is no moral law that rationalizes possession of a specific land according to who occupied it at any previous point in time.  The world is full of places where peoples were driven out or annihilated or migrated.  The idea of restoring everyone to their original native land is a recipe for chaos and does not serve any higher moral purpose.  Does he have the same perspective on the Sioux or other indigenous tribes?  On the Irish?  Brazil?

Maher believes that Israel’s actions in Gaza are above reproach, justified by Hamas’ attack of October 7th, and Hamas’ avowed mission of destroying Israel.  He’s not wrong about Hamas, but I do not believe that Israel’s response is proportionate or responsible.  Where is the end of this progression?  The two-state solution is almost dead, but the endless cycle of attack and revenge is not much of an alternative.  Does Maher have any problem with the long-term status of Palestinians living in the region?  Will they become second class citizens of an apartheid Israel?

Maher’s recent work belongs on Fox; not HBO. The net result of his rants is to convince people that because both sides of the American divide can be ridiculed, they are both essentially the same.  His point is not moral truth.  His point is that he is smarter than the people he ridicules by cherry-picking their public statements because he make witty vulgarities out of what seems obvious.  Or he has a guest like John Fetterman and suddenly he’s a docile, congenial host, conspicuously ignoring questions about Fetterman’s health and fitness.

And yet, in a bizarre and incomprehensible attempt to buff his bipartisan credentials,  he actually had the idiot harpy Anne Coulter on.  Have a conservative on your show?  By all means.  But Anne Coulter is a phony, sponsored conservative apparatchik who doesn’t deserve the exposure, and Maher is an idiot for putting her on his show.  Jordan Peterson?  The man whose whole shtick is making idiot right-wingers feel smart.

The effect of his bipartisan ridicule is this:  Donald Trump is the same as Kamala Harris.  Pete Hegseth is the same as Lloyd Austin.  Robert Kennedy Jr. is the same as Anthony Fauci. Andrew Miller is the same as Jake Sullivan.

This is a mistake John Oliver does not make.  Maher is too narcissistic to bother with concrete solutions; Oliver almost never loses his rational perspective.  He always offers a possible remedy for the toxic behaviors he describes. Oliver believes that taking potshots at everything from a safe virtual tower of pious cynicism is a lousy way to do commentary and leads to quietism and indifference.

Would Maher ever run for political office?  And then have to be accountable for the actual implementation of his views?  What, I would be very interested know, does he think politicians should do?  Raise the minimum wage?  Increase tariffs?  Tax the rich?

He knows that there is another Bill Maher out there in wait who will shred his performance the way he shreds others.

Maher has a degree from Cornell University in English literature and history.  You wouldn’t know it.

He’s not all bad.  He’s right, here, mostly, about political aides, but, again, note how he implies that the Democrats and Republicans are equally absurd.  They are not.  There will always be a few on the fringe in either party who are idiots, but the Republicans have made idiocy their uniform identity with Donald Trump.

I suspect Maher is simply trying to please the lowest common denominator.

There is a resonant fable we can attach to Maher, though.  In 2002, while hosting “Politically Incorrect”, Maher agreed with a guest that, whatever else you call them, the 9/11 hijackers were not cowards, while people firing cruise missiles from 2,000 miles away were cowardly.  It tells you everything you need to know about American culture, and perhaps culture in general, that “Politically Incorrect” was then cancelled for being politically incorrect.  The lesson is that everyone wants everyone else to think they are open-minded and intellectually courageous but the minute a genuinely courageous opinion generates a backlash, everyone ducks under the covers and shits themselves.

“No one is ever smarter from going on Bill Maher,” Ms. Pollitt said in an interview on Thursday.

One final observation: Bill Maher did a piece I generally liked on cancel culture.  Unfortunately, he missed the forest.  All the examples he gives are from “woke” crowds and institutions and universities objecting to certain controversial jokes without making a single reference to conservatives who are actually so much more regressive on the issue that you almost forget about them.  Come on Maher: you’ve got to be kidding me.  The party that will excommunicate anyone who doesn’t salute the flag (and display a lapel pin), praise Jesus, bow before the military, and praise America as the greatest, bestest, most wonderfullest nation in the history of the universe— you give them a pass?  That’s not political correctness? Nobody is more politically correct than a conservative.  You just don’t notice it as much because, unlike liberals, they don’t even simulate broad-mindedness and tolerance.

Okay. In fairness, here’s a recent attempt to take on the hypocrisies of Republicans.  And here he is giving it to extremists and their enablers on both sides.

And here’s another good response to Maher’s arguments about Israel.

The Coming Retrenchment

Trump will die or leave at some point in the near future.  What then?

There is a core of true believers in the Republican Party who will do and think whatever he tells them to do or think.  Is there anyone who can replace his position in their fantasy world of Goober Triumphant?  J. D. Vance?  Rubio?  DeSantis?  So far, we haven’t seen the combination of irrational adoration and random policy impulse in anyone else.  There was this illusion of Trump as the genius businessman (something he demonstrably was not: he went bankrupt seven times) who knew how to get rich (he was always rich: his daddy gave him $450 million according to the New York Times).

He did know how to get richer though: create this mythic creature, the genius businessman, and sell the illusion to the public through a TV show.  Trump only became rich when he became a celebrity, the most worthless business of all.

His success in politics is due largely to the unforeseeable combination of his own ignorance of political discourse: his straightforward vulgarity was appealing to a large constituency of Americans who don’t think educated people are really smarter than they are, and massive discontent with the economy and popular culture.  While Democrats became monomaniacal about transgender and race issues, Trump focused on the economy and derided political correctness.

Do not underestimate the appeal of someone who doesn’t couch his ideas in delicate phrases and banal platitudes.  Here’s where I empathize with his base.  Listen to Chuck Schumer for a while.  He, like most politicians, constantly reaches for the vague, the generic, the bland.

Trump gives idiotic answers to question from reporters but they are answers.

So, one day, Trump either dies or his term in office ends.  There are a lot of Representatives and Senators, I believe, who will be massively relieved.  They currently live under the constant threat of Trump’s mad base turning on them with one Tweet, one off-hand remark, one disparaging word from their divine leader.  Will they want to see a successor with the same power?  Is there such a being among the ranks of Republican governors and congressional leaders who can replicate that power?

I don’t think so.  Vance could muster some support but he has no demonstrated charisma.  DeSantis, we know, has none, and can’t rally the wider base of Republican members.  The mediocre politicians who pronounce their slavish adoration of Trump cannot do the one thing critical to his success: persuade the party that they are rogues who think for themselves and don’t give a damn about the establishment’s public approval.

There is another complication: the avaricious, ambitious coterie of Trump loyalists are likely to quickly fragment into warring factions striving for dominance splitting the base into numerous constituencies not one of which will be strong enough to dominate the party the way Trump has.

It will be in the interests of a considerable portion of the party to not again allow a single personality to dominate the way Trump has.  They will have a tiny sliver of self-respect at play.  Daddy’s gone: the siblings will want to be their own man.

 

 

 

The Illusion on the Hill

Ross Douthat of the New York Times, the resident reactionary on this liberal paper, enjoys nothing so much as erecting straw men and then knocking them down.

In this column, he tries to argue that America was essentially a Christian nation before the 1960’s, and then those evil hippies, liberals, environmentalists, feminists, and civil rights leaders came along and ruined everything.  He takes up the idea that America could return to it’s biblical roots, or not, but obviously should.

The fundamental lie in his argument is something that has become rapturously evident only since Donald Trump began his run for the presidency: America was never really a “Christian nation”.  It proclaimed itself to be it, adopted the symbols and emblems, sang their hymns, and never really believed in any of it.  What does America’s so-called religious right really believe?  My tribe against your tribe.  My grievance against your competence.  Tradition and ignorance against innovation and science.  Women as handmaids.  White male privilege.

Douthat wants you to believe that from the time of the War of Independence (it wasn’t really a “revolution”), America has modeled itself on principles derived from the Bible and the ministry of Jesus Christ.  Well, in a way– the bible does not really tell us that there is anything wrong with slavery.  In fact, it urges slaves to be “good” slaves.  Pick that cotton with enthusiasm!  Nurse that baby!  Make that bed!  Take a few lashes occasionally if necessary.  And the bible doesn’t envision women working 9:00 to 5:00 office jobs, or becoming astronauts.  Or, for that matter, getting paid to do anything.

If a person in the U.S. is anti-abortion, he or she is also almost certainly believes this:

    • climate change is a myth
    • guns are good and keep honest citizens safe from crime
    • homosexuality is unnatural and sinful
    • unions are bad
    • expensive government programs that benefit the poor are a waste of money and encourage indolence and irresponsibility
    • systematic racism is not a problem in America
    • socialized health care is a pernicious, evil idea that will inevitably lead to communism
    • capital punishment is appropriate and good for serious crimes
    • there are only two genders and ever will be

Why?  If there are sound reasons for being opposed to abortion (at any stage of pregnancy, they will insist), why do so-called “pro-life” voters almost invariably hold most of the other  values as well?  The only explanation is that they are not really “pro-life” at all: they are tribalists and anything that promotes their tribal interest is good and anything that promotes someone else’s tribal interest is bad.  Their moral judgements are determined by their loyalty to their tribe, not to their bible or Reason or evidence or science.  If their tribe believes we need a new ballroom or reflecting pool or deportations, then they will try to argue that they agree because they have thought carefully about it and came to the conclusion that these beliefs are valid and justifiable and supported by evidence.

But if that was true, they would be a substantial variety in the views they hold on those issues.  It is inconceivable that large numbers of people would all hold the same view on so many issues if they approached those issues with genuine principles, or if they had the integrity to admit it when evidence shows they are wrong.

They don’t.  They are loyal to their tribe.

Now the first thing one might say in defense of these conservatives is that liberals do it too.  Firstly, that is partly true.  Secondly, two wrongs don’t make a right.  But I think a far larger number of liberals hold diverse views on these various issues than conservatives do.   Bill Clinton famously embraced capital punishment and proclaimed the end of the welfare state.  (And he balanced the budget.)  Obama deported more people than Trump (check it out: it’s true).  Biden was pathetically servile towards Israel.  Kamala Harris was tough on crime in her role as Attorney-General of California.  Bernie Sanders is opposed to most gun regulation.

 

My Life – Bill Clinton

First of all, seriously?  “My Life”?  Nobody at Knopf or Clinton’s cabal could think of anything more allusive or intriguing than “My Life”?

I just finished Clinton’s monumental (in size, at least) autobiography of 950 pages.  Here are some takeaways.

The writing is serviceable but not remarkable.  Too much of it consists of long sequences of events, meetings, trips, and milestones, with occasional interludes of analysis, self-congratulation, and admiration for people who admired him.  It reflects the source material: 8 years of detailed notes, chronological order, some reflection and insights gained in retrospect.  Too much, at times, like a list.  I never stopped to think, oh, that’s a great sentence or paragraph, from a literary point of view.

Clinton left three years of budget surpluses.  Yes, it’s true.  He is the only president since Jimmy Carter to even come close to balancing the budget (though in his last year, Carter did leave a $60 billion shortfall).  The Republicans under George W. Bush immediately pissed it away with tax cuts without cutting any popular programs.  You can’t convince me that this is not an intentional strategy: whine and holler about deficits, but be sure to leave them for your Democratic successor so you can run on the issue again.   (You can count on the voters having a short memory.) (Obama reduced the deficit; Trump blew it up).  If congress had stuck to Clinton’s overall budget plan, the U.S. could have paid off it’s national debt in 10 years.  If there was an ounce of sincerity in the claims the Republicans make about addressing the deficit, they had a glorious opportunity to demonstrate it.  They did not.

Clinton accomplished a lot.  He appointed competent people.  He crafted useful, productive legislation on everything from education to the environment.  He tried to improve the lives of average Americans, mostly successfully.   He left an unemployment rate of about 4% and very a very healthy GDP.

Al Gore may have been the most competent vice-president since Lyndon Johnson.  And yes, he really did play a significant role in the creation of the internet (as a Congressman).

Presidents have to attend an incredible number of ceremonial events, dinners, parades, parties, and so on.  It strikes me as kind of idiotic, actually.  They should just elect a Presidential-Shaman to do all that kind of shit and let the real President do his work in peace.  This kind of profile attracts a certain type: men who love jetting all around the world and visiting exotic and beautiful locations, surrounded by Secret Service agents and staff, staying in lavish hotels or palaces–  all while claiming to be working on American foreign policy.  Sometimes they are.  Sometimes they are just thrilled to chat with the Queen or receive an exclusive personal tour of a museum or castle.  In Clinton’s case, Hillary and Chelsea got to share in the largesse.  How nice that the president can privilege his own family at taxpayer expense.

Did I even mention the obscenity of having a military band play fucking “Hail to the Chief” every time you enter a room?  Seriously?  What kind of monumental moron thought this was useful or appropriate or even not absurd in any way?  It is literally cartoonish.

In one of the most embarrassing passages, Clinton heralds Yeltsin’s successor in Russia, a tight-lipped reserved former KGB agent named Vladimir Putin, as a very promising world leader.  He also visits Hafez Al-Assad, dictator of Syria,  who massacred 30,000 civilians in the town of Hama, and reports how delightful he was.  Seriously, Bill?

Benjamin Netanyahu was at work sabotaging peace deals with the Palestinians long before Trump came along, though Clinton was pretty clue-less about it.  All those “surprising” developments that prevented Netanyahu from implementing his side of the agreements?  Just coincidences, according to Clinton.  Bad luck!  Darn it!  And Bibi seemed so excited about finally signing a peace deal and getting that two-state solution everyone knew was the only pathway to peace!

Kenneth Starr remains one of the most repulsive human beings to ever investigate anything– second, perhaps, to Senator Joseph McCarthy.  And let’s not confine the stink to Whitewater and Monica Lewinsky:  Starr defended Jeffrey Epstein against the first set of charges in 2007 and helped negotiate the sweetheart deal that allowed Epstein to walk.  He defended Trump at his impeachment hearings, directly contradicting most of what he said during Clinton’s impeachment hearings.  We don’t know what exactly he did at Baylor in regard to a pair of students charged with sexual assault, but he was fired for it.

Janet Reno was an extremely regrettable choice as Attorney-General though Clinton doesn’t want to admit it.  And it wasn’t just Waco.

As everyone knows, Arafat had the deal the Palestinians wanted in Clinton’s last year in office.  Israel had made very significant concessions under Ehud Barack– probably costing him re-election– including a Palestinian State but Arafat seemed terrified of having to actually govern, rather than just lead an eternal insurrection.  Or, he may have been losing it: Clinton thought his faculties had “declined” by that point.  (Has anyone considered whether Trump might resemble Arafat in that respect: a preference for nurturing grievances against a viable opposition over actually governing.)

Al Gore would have won Florida (actually, he probably did win Florida), and the presidency, if Ralph Nader hadn’t run for President as an independent in 2000.  I think Al Gore would have been an excellent president– a Bill Clinton without the scandals (like Barack Obama).  He was forward-looking, smart, accomplished, and competent.  If he had won, there probably would not have been a war in Iraq.  9/11 would probably have still happened  though given that there were warnings and given Gore’s cautious nature, it might not.  The U.S. budget would have continued on it’s path to eliminating the debt.  But the 2008 financial meltdown would still have happened: Gore was an enthusiastic supporter of Clinton’s deregulation of the financial industry.

Which leads me to Ms. Brooksley Born.  Clinton does not mention the name “Brooksley Born” anywhere in this voluminous biography.   You should watch this documentary to see why.  For a summary of what happened, check this.  This one item is the most disgraceful lie (by omission) in the book, one that Clinton probably knew he could get away with: do you know who Brooksley Born is?

Clinton (and Gore) decided, on the advice of people like Robert Rubin, Henry Paulson, Larry Summers, and Alan Greenspan, that deregulating the financial markets would lead to wonderful magical entities like Enron that would make countless Americans rich.  They either knew or should have known that the essential nature of these financial instruments is that they allow ruthless money-mangers to make fortunes by deceiving investors into putting their money into accounts that provide no real economic value to the economy but from which they can skim off millions of dollars in management fees.  They exist to facilitate the extraction of wealth from gullible investors.

They surely knew it would at least make thousands of money-managers rich in the filthiest way you can imagine.  Brooksley Born, who was head of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, thought these instruments of bundled risk created the conditions under which major bank defaults and massive fund collapses could occur and she opposed them.  Clinton fired her. 

Instead of the fantasized wealth, deregulation led directly to the bubble burst in the late 1990’s and the massive financial meltdown of 2008 and the collapse of Bear Stearns and the Lehman Brothers banks.   It is striking that Clinton admits to the Lewinsky affair, and alludes to other “indiscretions”, but not to the worst decision of his administration with the most catastrophic consequences.  “Brooksley Born” is not in the index of “My Life”.  Clinton refuses to name the most prescient financial advisor in his administration.  It seems he can’t bear to take responsibility for this one.  While American’s were insanely obsessed with the sex scandals, the far more consequential real scandal slipped right under their noses.

Clinton was very enthusiastic about free trade, a position that seems quaint today.  I’m not saying he was wrong.  I think he was probably right.  Trump has succeeded in convincing a lot of people that going back to the same policies that caused the Great Depression is a great idea.

Clinton thought bringing China into the World Trade Organization was the only way to keep them from following the path that would lead to war in the future, by keeping them engaged with trading partners in the developed world, and encouraging them to gradually become more democratic.  He had no concern about their lower production costs undermining American industrial capacity.  He doesn’t discuss the impact they could have by holding massive reserves of American currency.   He doesn’t discuss the idea of holding China to conditions: advances in human rights, unions, democracy, before they can expand their trade within the WTO.

But then, he doesn’t mention the fact that robotics cost America far more industrial jobs than off-shoring ever would.

The jury is still out on that one.  It may well be that, in the long term, integrating China into the global economic system was a stroke of genius.  It may well turn out to be a gigantic mistake.  Cuba today remains a thorn in the side of America largely because, right after Castro’s revolution, the U.S. tried to bully it into compliance with it’s hegemonic interests rather than engaging with them constructively.  Castro turned to Moscow because America turned away from Havana.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Speed Cameras

We are repeatedly told that more people speed if there are no cameras. But the data showing that safety is actually compromised is extremely thin. There are a lot of things we could do that would make life “safer” (like banning electric bikes, for instance, or skate-boarding, or skiing) but we don’t do them all because we don’t always believe the trade-off is worthwhile.  But there are people in our local government who don’t believe that anything that serves the interest of car drivers is a benefit.  And everyone wants to be seen to fall over themselves when it comes to the safety of children.

There is something about speed cameras that carries a tone of “gotcha!” for reasonable people who usually drive carefully. You feel you are being nitpicked for a brief moment of inattention.  You feel like you are being punished even when you are a conscientious driver.  And of course it absolutely feels like a money grab.

Crucible 2023

In an article in an issue of the New York Review of Books, 2023-11-02,  Stacy Schiff lambastes “The Crucible”, apparently because instead of giving John Proctor his comeuppance for cheating on his wife (which she connects to Arthur Miller cheating on his wife, Mary, with Marilyn Monroe), the play gives it’s comeuppance to a society in which hysteria drives well-meaning people to charge innocent people with ridiculously preposterous crimes (of witchcraft) and then hangs them.  Revisionism gone berserk.

Schiff knows something about Salem.  She is the author of “The Witches: Salem, 1692”.  How did she do?

The Guardian liked her work:

These are upsetting tales and Schiff writes movingly as well as wittily; this is a work of riveting storytelling as well as an authoritative history.

Wikipedia tells us:

Writing in the New York Times Book Review, Jane Kamensky said the book was “curiously flat” and provided a “tenuous grip on the period,” concluding: “For all her talents in sketching the who, what, where and when of the Salem trials, [the] vexed question of why is one that Schiff simply cannot manage.”[13] Writing in The Wall Street Journal, Felipe Fernández-Armesto found that Schiff offered “a trial narrative unsurpassed for detail and impressive for her mastery of the fragmentary and frustrating sources,” but said that she “uncovers no new clues to understanding” how the sides in the trials aligned.

What a shame.   The two takes on her book are not incompatible.  Sounds like an exciting read but, perhaps, lacking in depth.

But, considering her skewering of Arthur Miller (she makes numerous allusions to his vanity), it is not surprising that she “uncovers no new clues to understanding”.  She has reduced Miller’s masterpiece to just another episode of male privilege, toxic patriarchy, and petty grievance.  She relishes details of Miller’s affair with Marilyn Monroe and breakdown of his marriage at the time he was writing “The Crucible”.  And here is John Proctor, having cheated on his wife, made the hero.  (The parallels break down quickly: Abigail Williams, with whom Proctor had his affair, doesn’t suggest Marilyn Monroe on any level.)

Miller was also angry at his friend, director Elia Kazan, for folding to the House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC).  Miller, unlike Kazan, steadfastly refused to name names.  He was indicted for Contempt of Congress and sentenced to a fine and prison time but won on appeal in 1958.

For feminists, there is a problem at the core of “The Crucible”, so it’s no wonder Schiff wants to take it on.  The problem is that the “afflicted girls” whose hysterics devolved into rabid accusations of numerous innocent adults  of practicing witchcraft, in the town of Salem, we are told, should not be believed.  Doctrinaire feminists, of course, insist that when women (or girls) make accusations, they should always be believed.  Especially when Abigail Williams, the lead accuser, charged John Proctor with having used her sexually, which he confessed was true.

“To Kill a Mockingbird”, which so far has escaped Schiff’s scrutiny, has the same problem:  we root for the hero, Atticus, who questions and discredits a woman’s account of being raped.

The girls are intoxicated with their newly discovered power, to wreck havoc upon the men in authority (and women), to control discourse, to compel society to bow to them in subservience to whatever whims their intoxicated rage produces.  They have no compunction about it even when it leads to hangings and abuse and torture.  But Schiff is not interested in whether any of them were ever sorry about that: she is only interested in whether Proctor, an otherwise decent man, was sorry enough about his infidelity.   So in her mind (and the mind of several feminist writers she cites), the play needs to be rewritten to highlight the predicament of the young girls.   Which is?  Well, that intoxicating fever didn’t last.  Massachusetts eventually recanted– the biggest surprise in history– and decided that the witch hunt was a witch hunt and paid some compensation to surviving victims.

Nobody who made the false accusations was ever punished.

Schiff points out that Miller didn’t stick to the historical record.  Neither did Peter Schaffer in his play “Amadeus” but neither “Amadeus” or the “The Crucible” is historic reenactment.  That has always seemed obvious to me, if not the general public.  Both, however, use real history as the springboard to their greater purpose: the mystery of talent bestowed upon an unworthy vessel, and the horror of a society swept into hysterical delusion and driven to commit horrifying acts against the innocent on its behalf.

Incidentally, Elia Kazan’s wife, Molly, pointed out to Miller that “there really are communists”.  Oh, well, that justifies it then!  A lot of MAGA people would agree.  So let’s put up that monument to Joseph McCarthy.

Yes, I’m being sarcastic.  But an incredible number of conservatives out there, most pungently Anne Coulter, believe that the red-baiting, lying, thuggish, ignoramus– Joseph McCarthy– was right.

 

Here We Go Again

After the disasters in Iraq and Afghanistan, the political class swore that they would never again enter an armed conflict without knowing, in advance, what the off-ramp would be; how they would exit gracefully. Now Rubio and other Republican leaders are openly saying “never mind that– we’ll figure it out when we come to it”.

Unbelievable.

Though it was mildly amusing to see Republican leaders stumble over explaining how the GREAT INCREDIBLE SUCCESS of bombing Iran’s nuclear facilities didn’t actually accomplish what they said it did so they had to do it over again.

They also said (after the scandal of not finding WMD’s in Iraq) that they would ensure that the justification for the war (in this case, allegedly, long range missiles that could hit the continental U. S.) had been properly vetted. Yeah, complete blank on that. Trump’s own intelligence agencies say there is no evidence that Iran is even close to building missiles like that.

As for regime change, I cannot imagine that anyone seriously thinks the IRG is just going to put down their guns and disappear, especially when a successor regime might actually try some of them for mass murder. Trump, who has no real or imagined authority to do it, promised them immunity. Was he going to put them on trial, and then give them a pass or pardon? Without boots on the ground?

Does FIFA have a war prize they can give him now that Trump is bored with the peace thing.

Ecstatic!

From Here.

Just read this!  It is astonishing.

Oprah Winfrey, Reese Witherspoon and Jenna Bush Hager looked ecstatic as they stood onstage at the Ford Foundation in Manhattan earlier this year, posing with a new book. The crowd was so large it required an overflow room.

The book is a memoir, “The Tell” by Amy Griffith.  “One of the wealthiest women in the country”.

In the memoir, Ms. Griffin, 49, writes that she engaged in illegal psychedelic-drug therapy. While under the influence of MDMA, the active chemical in Ecstasy and Molly, she said she recovered memories of being raped on many occasions by a middle-school teacher in Amarillo, Texas, starting when she was 12.

How can anyone dare to continue to pose the question– so purely rhetorical it stinks– of why someone would tell the story of sexual abuse if it wasn’t true?  Well, isn’t it obvious?  Oprah, Reese, and Bush are all ecstatic– ecstatic– to present a book about the terrible, awful, horrible experience of sexual abuse.  Of a woman, Amy Griffith, who was raped when she was 12.   They are, I repeat, ecstatic.

Yes, of course they are not ecstatic about the abuse.  They are ecstatic about the privilege of presenting the information about it to the entire world– they are ecstatic about so many people hearing about it, buying the book (because they want to read about it), watching and relishing the endless talk-show regurgitations, the tears, the virtue signaling, the triumphalism.  And Griffin is ecstatic that she now has an excuse for why she felt so lousy about herself for so long even though she had everything anyone could ever want in life.  She is ecstatic to declare that she is a victim.

The unspeakable facet of victimhood that no one wants to talk about?  Privilege.  Usually, to excuse drug addiction, depression, professional failure.  I was good but then someone made me bad.

All of which, in this case, appears to be based on a fraud.

A former classmate of Ms. Griffin has told the same story– even about some of the actual specifics of Ms. Griffin’s telling– except that it involved a different teacher.  Did Ms. Griffin– who couldn’t remember the abuse without the assistance of a therapist and hallucinogens– lift the story from her classmate, while changing the identity of the alleged abuser?  This is pertinent: some people have decoded Ms. Griffin’s story and identified the teacher who committed the alleged abuse.  But it is not the same teacher identified by the former classmate.  And no other former students of the teacher identified from Griffin’s book have ever come forward with allegations about him.

An “expert” on MDMA says “the reliability of memories retrieved with MDMA… are often symbolic”.   He adds that even if the memories are not true, people can “develop stories that help them make sense of their life”.  Well, that’s a generous spin on confabulation.

I don’t think you could be more damning about it.  It’s okay to lie if it makes you feel better about yourself, even if you make very serious allegations about an innocent person, a teacher, whose reputation has been severely damaged.

Ms. Griffin’s “defamation lawyer” says this:  “the mere sending of this document [a letter from the Times asking for clarification] has caused additional trauma and extreme physical and emotional harm to a survivor of sexual assault, which is inexcusable.”  This from the lawyer of a woman doing everything she can to let the entire world know about her “abuse”.  This, from the lawyer of a woman who is “ecstatic” to appear on Oprah and talk about it with other celebrities.

How dare you challenge the honesty of a self-described victim of abuse?

The Times also asked the publisher if they had fact-checked the story.  The publisher responded to the Times by saying that Dial Press is a publisher, not an investigator.

With all the publicity, a family support organization in Amarillo, where Ms. Griffin is from, provided facilities for any individual to come forward to get help if they had been sexually abused.  After six months, not a single taker.

The danger in all this is that once again the idea of “recovered memories” is put into the mainstream and is sure to inspire others to recover memories of abuse and come forward and make allegations.  We’ve been through this cycle before I thought we had mostly come to our senses: recovered memories are not reliable and should never be the basis of public allegations.   The issue has been studied, researched, and tested, and it failed decisively.

More on Recovered Memories

The Diplomat: Sanitized and Anodyne

I haven’t watched the Netflix series “The Diplomat” yet.  I’m not sure I intend to.  Why?  Because like almost every other TV show, the  makers refuse to identify any political parties to which the main characters belong.

TV (and movies) traditionally adopt the “lowest common denominator” principle of everything.  No religion, no political beliefs, no specific characteristics of any particular character for fear of alienating potential viewers who don’t adhere to or admire that detail.

You are asked to suspend your disbelief, to thrill to the devious connivances of various politicians and diplomats, without once any of them making any reference to the one thing that most defines them: politics.

Which is not to say that the plot line of “The Diplomat”, aside from the excision of the most elemental political reality in their lives, is even remotely plausible.   Assassination plots, abductions, third-rate diplomats pulling strings at the White House and 10 Downing Street without getting slapped down by the Secretary of State or Foreign Minister or their bureaucracies.  The Prime-Minister physically assaulting a campaign manager.

Debra Kahn brandishes her credentials as a former writer of “The West Wing”.  Let’s get that out of the way: Aaron Sorkin is the writer that made “The West Wing” magnificent.  Kahn came along around Season 4, with Sorkin’s departure,  and stayed to Season 7, during which the quality of writing declined significantly.

 

 

Conservatives Will Never Be Cool

I recently heard a right-wing influencer on a podcast chortle about how magnificent it was that now, on college campuses and high school cafeterias, it was now “cool” to be conservative.

Rule number 1: if you have to tell people you’re cool, you’re not cool.

That has always been true, going back to the 1950’s, when parvenus and pretenders would don a beret, tuck a Ginsberg under an arm, light up a smoke, and trek out to the local folk club for some rebel vibe.  The cool guys and chicks were the ones who left when you walked in.

Rule number 2: it is never cool to adhere to a culture of hate and grievance.  Especially when grievance is your defining characteristic and your grievance is that smart, educated, cool people have always looked down on you.

Rule number 3: Just how cool do you think, “and I’m proud to be an American/Where at least I know I’m free” is?  It is a monumentally stupid line (“at least” sounds like something a desperate eight-year-old says when realizes he can’t get his yoyo back from his big sister).

Adjunct to Rule Number 3:  Patriotism is never cool.  You are averring a blind obedience to a fake ideology and culture that is manipulating you for perverted ends (usually oil profits).  There is no good reason for patriotism, which essentially consists of bellowing platitudes and bragging that your country is better than everyone else’s.

Rule number 4:  there is a difference between parody and mockery.  Parody and satire are cool; mockery is banal, tiresome, but it does require a lower IQ threshold.  There will never be a conservative “Dr. Strangelove or how I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb”.  The closest thing to a really searing conservative satire might be some Monty Python skits (as in “Life of Brian” when a member of the Palestinian Liberation Front declares that he wants to be a woman) but it is the essence of cool to be able to self-parody and if you parody a cool self you’re still cool.  Conservatives are so bitterly immersed in grievance that they can’t bear self-parody.

Rule number 5: William F. Buckley Jr. was a fop.  He wasn’t always wrong– cool people can handle anomalies– but he was always a pretentious fop and a snob– exactly the kind of intellectual that right-wing influencers today would find so insufferable if he wasn’t the goddess of nice reactionaries.  Jordan Peterson is a milquetoast current incarnation of the posture.  Charlie Kirk was a wannabe imitation of Buckley who didn’t understand that you shouldn’t wear kilts if you’re going to walk on stilts.  Okay– you should actually know history and economics before you engage in trivial quibbles about the subject with credulous audiences.  He could argue anything– that is not a compliment.