The Sad Way of All Medical Dramas: The Pitt (Season 2) Descends into Soap

The surest sign that a medical drama has descended into the depths of  television vulgarity is when one of the patients is a relative or close friend of one of the doctors.  Mel King’s sister is admitted.  Why the hell do we suddenly have patients with close relationships with the doctors? Then another: an old friend of Robanovitch’s.  Then another.   It is a tip-off that more obscenity is to come.

The inevitable second bad sign: characters start treating other characters like family.   Robinavitch is planning a sabbatical on a motorcycle and nurses and doctors nag him about safety in a way that feels like a projection of the perceived audience’s feelings about Robinavitch.  Not the audience I like– but the mass audience out there now dropping in to see “The Pitt” because of all the acclaim.  Other characters are beginning to offer advice and uncomfortably intimate expressions of concern for each other.  The proverbial “television family”.  We project our feelings of warmth and trust upon these avatars of our own narcissism.

And the third, most fatal sign: the doctors start treating each other.

“The Pitt” started out well.  Very well.   It was the averred intent of the program to focus on the action in the ER of a major hospital, and season one did so, and it was scintillating.  Fresh.  Shocking at times.  Frank.  We all know where medical drama’s usually go: to dreck and soap but  “The Pitt” was going to be different.  It was going to be rich with texture and depth and insight.  It actually asserted that it was NOT going go the way of “ER” and “St. Elsewhere” (which also started out well), or “Grey’s Anatomy” or– horrors!– “House” (probably the drama of this bunch with the highest ratio of narcissistic piety).

Season 2 started out okay– more shocking scenes and some texture and depth.  Until.  Until we realized– about episode 11– that Noah Wyle (a producer) was mugging for an Emmy.  Until we started getting long heart-to-heart conversations between the regulars while patients are shown waiting for one of the damn doctors to actually come and treat them.  Until we are treated to mawkish displays of characters “caring too much”, getting all self-righteous and pious about defending “my nurses”, or standing up to ICE, or planning to deprive an elderly couple of their independence after a very brief interaction with them about a minor injury: oh how smug and insular that little episode was!

A patient attacks a nurse and Charge Nurse Dana Evans, armed, apparently, with some kind of powerful sedative, Versed, (which she just happened to have in her pocket), jumps him and knocks him out, and everybody is just kind of isn’t that adorable that she is so protective of her charges even after we find out that the patient was on a bad drug trip.  The repellent aspect of this sequence is the way the show manipulates the viewer into seeing Evans as a hero by having the patient later curse and swear at the doctors.  It’s a cheap trick.  It would have been far more interesting if he had been shown to be somewhat appalled at himself and perhaps remorseful at learning he would be charged.  But the then the audience wouldn’t have been able to congratulate themselves for siding with the virtuous Evans, whom we are given to understand is “feisty” and smart– and, of course “cares too much”–  which is a way of allowing a character to behave in ways that we would otherwise would find annoying or offensive or illegal.

Incidentally, have you ever been in an Emergency Room at a major hospital?  How often would you hear doctors or nurses saying “fuck this” or “fuck that”?  And why do almost all the characters do it when, in real life, a good portion of any group do not?  It makes all the characters begin to sound alike, dulling the interesting diversity in this group in the first season.

The real reason they do it?  Actors love it: it’s a badge of “authenticity” and grit.  Actors rarely offer to be the character that provides realistic balance to the array of personalities in the story.

And the problem with introducing more and more patients who are directly related to the doctors?  We see Duke, a dear, witty, bearded friend of Robinavitch come in for a sore throat.  I was puzzled as to why he was admitted.  With a sore throat?  But he languishes in a room for a long, long, long time while Robinavitch carries on various conversations and drops in on other patients and lectures this resident or that and kvetches over paperwork.  One wonders why the hell he doesn’t go take care of his patient. Someone wants us to believe that none of the other doctors  in the ER can handle the various issues that arise.  Seriously?  Our world is on the brink of disaster, if this is true.  It’s not.

We wonder why Robinavitch, who had been shown to be a patient, caring Chief Attending Physician in Season 1, is suddenly short-tempered, intolerant, and  irrational.  And then we realize where we are heading:  to the most predictable  marshland of TV Drama cliche:  Robinavitch is going to get some therapy to deal with his trauma goblins.  He’s not a prick!  Oh, no: he’s got trauma!  He’s going to cry and break down!  He will seek therapy because even an amazing charge physician like Robinavitch is not qualified to deal with his “issues” all by himself.   He needs a credentialed therapist!  He will find healing and love. And I will mentally puke with disgust and curse the TV gods for taking another promising drama and turning it into wretched dreck.  And curse the vanity of actors/producers who shamelessly promote themselves by providing  the story with exhibitionist scenes of wildly extravagant emotional breakdowns at the expense of dramatic integrity.

In another episode, or the same one, a different hospital that was hacked pays the ransom to get back on line.  That’s realistic but it would have been nice to have an acknowledgment of the problem: paying off ransomware hackers encourages more ransomware.  The script should have acknowledged that issue.

In the new world of the second season of “The Pitt”, we enter the realm of affirmations and therapy and the fantasy of nurses and doctors who always find time to have emotional conversations in the middle of an ER we have been led to believe is frenetic with urgent medical emergencies. Unfortunately, S02E14 descends even further, with the preposterous sequence in which Dr.  Langdon redeems himself in Robinavitch’s eyes by performing a near miraculous procedure, a “closed reduction of facet joint” on a traffic accident victim.  Seriously?  And we’re not back in the worst traditions of the medical drama?  (We are).

And Robinavitch will not be the only doctor to take the path of TV therapy (in which the only cure for emotional distress is to uncover the “trauma” that caused it — because it is always caused by trauma, and not by deficiencies or weakness of character):  Dr. Al-Hashimi must reveal to Robinavitch– whom she has known for exactly one day– her own past trauma (involving an ailment) which, again, is offered as an excuse for emotional distress, lavished on the viewer while patients continue to mob the ER. What a pity.  Robinavitch has become a bore.

This episode, written by Noah Wyle himself, appears to credit the claims of some critics that Wyle is pandering for an Emmy.  Now it’s all about him and how he just cares so damn much that can’t bear to even leave on his sabbatical because– we are given to believe– nobody else can run the ER like him.  This is obviously bullshit.  If it were true, the ER could never survive since he can’t possibly be there all the time, and there is nothing remarkable about the day being dramatized that would not be remarkable about any day in the ER. We are further encouraged to believe that Wyle is heroic and beloved for his dedication when any self-respecting physician would actually likely get royally pissed off at him interceding in every case like an overbearing nanny.  “I only do it because I want the best.”

Even worse, we have a doctor who has been on his feet racing around for 15 hours straight: in TV land, everything goes right and he saves lives.  In real life, you make mistakes when you are exhausted and can’t resist taking a shortcut here or there and someone in some lawsuit is going to point out that it is a fucking bad idea to work 15 hours straight. The dynamic of other physicians expressing concern about his health makes me cringe.  He is their boss and the creative team behind these episodes seem clueless about the psychological dynamics of boss-staff relations.  When they question his well-being, they are questioning his competence.  People in the position of Robinavitch would take umbrage in real life.

I am reminded of the decline in “West Wing” when suddenly Leo was hectoring President Bartlett about his behavior and policies.  It was stupid.  No President would put up with it for a second.

What would have improved these episodes immeasurably would have been a creditable character ridiculing Robinavitch and pointing out how his obsessive enmeshment with all of the decisions being made is not the product of virtuous professionalism but of narcissism.

Episode 15: well, there it is.  It’s now the Noah Wyle show.  Pity the rest of the cast who now get the delicious opportunity to deliver five or six lines in a one hour program, because all the rest of the screen time is now occupied by Robinavitch’s kvetching about maybe not wanting to come back after his sabbatical.  Then it really takes the plunge: he hints about considering suicide.

Because, well, he just cares too damn much!

It’s preposterous.  “The Pitt” hasn’t laid the groundwork for that kind of epochal development.  They want Robinavitch to be a saint who insists on interceding with every other ER physician’s process and can’t leave even when he’s exhausted and doesn’t think anyone can match his level of genius and leadership, and then they suddenly want him to be broken and considering suicide?  It’s a gratuitous and banal twist in his character and almost certainly the product of the actor Wyle having control over the script and direction.

The scene of the day-staff on the roof watching fireworks while “America the Beautiful” plays was gauche; just restrained enough to avoid being called “gauche” but not elegant enough to not be gauche.

If this is where “The Pitt” is headed, I will not be back, 

Ecstatic!

From Here.

Just read this!  It is astonishing.

Oprah Winfrey, Reese Witherspoon and Jenna Bush Hager looked ecstatic as they stood onstage at the Ford Foundation in Manhattan earlier this year, posing with a new book. The crowd was so large it required an overflow room.

The book is a memoir, “The Tell” by Amy Griffith.  “One of the wealthiest women in the country”.

In the memoir, Ms. Griffin, 49, writes that she engaged in illegal psychedelic-drug therapy. While under the influence of MDMA, the active chemical in Ecstasy and Molly, she said she recovered memories of being raped on many occasions by a middle-school teacher in Amarillo, Texas, starting when she was 12.

How can anyone dare to continue to pose the question– so purely rhetorical it stinks– of why someone would tell the story of sexual abuse if it wasn’t true?  Well, isn’t it obvious?  Oprah, Reese, and Bush are all ecstatic– ecstatic– to present a book about the terrible, awful, horrible experience of sexual abuse.  Of a woman, Amy Griffith, who was raped when she was 12.   They are, I repeat, ecstatic.

Yes, of course they are not ecstatic about the abuse.  They are ecstatic about the privilege of presenting the information about it to the entire world– they are ecstatic about so many people hearing about it, buying the book (because they want to read about it), watching and relishing the endless talk-show regurgitations, the tears, the virtue signaling, the triumphalism.  And Griffin is ecstatic that she now has an excuse for why she felt so lousy about herself for so long even though she had everything anyone could ever want in life.  She is ecstatic to declare that she is a victim.

The unspeakable facet of victimhood that no one wants to talk about?  Privilege.  Usually, to excuse drug addiction, depression, professional failure.  I was good but then someone made me bad.

All of which, in this case, appears to be based on a fraud.

A former classmate of Ms. Griffin has told the same story– even about some of the actual specifics of Ms. Griffin’s telling– except that it involved a different teacher.  Did Ms. Griffin– who couldn’t remember the abuse without the assistance of a therapist and hallucinogens– lift the story from her classmate, while changing the identity of the alleged abuser?  This is pertinent: some people have decoded Ms. Griffin’s story and identified the teacher who committed the alleged abuse.  But it is not the same teacher identified by the former classmate.  And no other former students of the teacher identified from Griffin’s book have ever come forward with allegations about him.

An “expert” on MDMA says “the reliability of memories retrieved with MDMA… are often symbolic”.   He adds that even if the memories are not true, people can “develop stories that help them make sense of their life”.  Well, that’s a generous spin on confabulation.

I don’t think you could be more damning about it.  It’s okay to lie if it makes you feel better about yourself, even if you make very serious allegations about an innocent person, a teacher, whose reputation has been severely damaged.

Ms. Griffin’s “defamation lawyer” says this:  “the mere sending of this document [a letter from the Times asking for clarification] has caused additional trauma and extreme physical and emotional harm to a survivor of sexual assault, which is inexcusable.”  This from the lawyer of a woman doing everything she can to let the entire world know about her “abuse”.  This, from the lawyer of a woman who is “ecstatic” to appear on Oprah and talk about it with other celebrities.

How dare you challenge the honesty of a self-described victim of abuse?

The Times also asked the publisher if they had fact-checked the story.  The publisher responded to the Times by saying that Dial Press is a publisher, not an investigator.

With all the publicity, a family support organization in Amarillo, where Ms. Griffin is from, provided facilities for any individual to come forward to get help if they had been sexually abused.  After six months, not a single taker.

The danger in all this is that once again the idea of “recovered memories” is put into the mainstream and is sure to inspire others to recover memories of abuse and come forward and make allegations.  We’ve been through this cycle before I thought we had mostly come to our senses: recovered memories are not reliable and should never be the basis of public allegations.   The issue has been studied, researched, and tested, and it failed decisively.

More on Recovered Memories

At Home in Hibbing

The hazards of living up to your own myth: Bob Dylan has a new book. A reviewer in NYRB:

At times ‘The Philosophy of Modern Song’ feels like a sci-fi project set in a parallel universe where Bob Dylan stayed home in Hibbing and inherited his father’s electrical supply store.

Sometimes a well-known writer or artist begins to realize it is safer to be obscure and allusive than to try to produce something as dazzling and brilliant and disputable as your reputation betakes. From the reviews, it sounds like he’s just putting out a long list of songs that struck him as interesting in some way and then making random allusions to random things that came into his mind as he listened to them. I’m not saying it wouldn’t be an interesting read, but it sounds like it might be less interesting than a Jesse Welles concert, which was engaged, challenging, and fresh.

Conservatives Will Never Be Cool

I recently heard a right-wing influencer on a podcast chortle about how magnificent it was that now, on college campuses and high school cafeterias, it was now “cool” to be conservative.

Rule number 1: if you have to tell people you’re cool, you’re not cool.

That has always been true, going back to the 1950’s, when parvenus and pretenders would don a beret, tuck a Ginsberg under an arm, light up a smoke, and trek out to the local folk club for some rebel vibe.  The cool guys and chicks were the ones who left when you walked in.

Rule number 2: it is never cool to adhere to a culture of hate and grievance.  Especially when grievance is your defining characteristic and your grievance is that smart, educated, cool people have always looked down on you.

Rule number 3: Just how cool do you think, “and I’m proud to be an American/Where at least I know I’m free” is?  It is a monumentally stupid line (“at least” sounds like something a desperate eight-year-old says when realizes he can’t get his yoyo back from his big sister).

Adjunct to Rule Number 3:  Patriotism is never cool.  You are averring a blind obedience to a fake ideology and culture that is manipulating you for perverted ends (usually oil profits).  There is no good reason for patriotism, which essentially consists of bellowing platitudes and bragging that your country is better than everyone else’s.

Rule number 4:  there is a difference between parody and mockery.  Parody and satire are cool; mockery is banal, tiresome, but it does require a lower IQ threshold.  There will never be a conservative “Dr. Strangelove or how I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb”.  The closest thing to a really searing conservative satire might be some Monty Python skits (as in “Life of Brian” when a member of the Palestinian Liberation Front declares that he wants to be a woman) but it is the essence of cool to be able to self-parody and if you parody a cool self you’re still cool.  Conservatives are so bitterly immersed in grievance that they can’t bear self-parody.

Rule number 5: William F. Buckley Jr. was a fop.  He wasn’t always wrong– cool people can handle anomalies– but he was always a pretentious fop and a snob– exactly the kind of intellectual that right-wing influencers today would find so insufferable if he wasn’t the goddess of nice reactionaries.  Jordan Peterson is a milquetoast current incarnation of the posture.  Charlie Kirk was a wannabe imitation of Buckley who didn’t understand that you shouldn’t wear kilts if you’re going to walk on stilts.  Okay– you should actually know history and economics before you engage in trivial quibbles about the subject with credulous audiences.  He could argue anything– that is not a compliment.

 

 

 

Disney and Hefner

As T-Bone Burnett observed, in the song “Hefner and Disney”, Disney and Hugh Hefner actually have a lot in common. Both are selling air-brushed facsimiles of something desirable but not real, catering to our shallowest desires for easily digestible, consumable tripe. They are both purveyors of smut in their own realms.

The Facebook Stream of Sewage II

According to AI, Yes, “Facebook’s algorithm is explicitly designed to show you content it predicts you will find interesting, relevant, and engaging, based on your past behavior.”

If that’s true, it is a colossal– even perverse– failure. I’ve learned to never respond to any of the voluminous provocative posts (mostly from thinly disguised carbon industry flacks, anti-trans evangelicals, pipeline and Danielle Smith partisans, and Beach Boy fans) and keep telling Facebook to never show any posts from those sources again. It has no effect. The same type of posts keep reappearing under different names. They almost never refer to any kind of publicly accountable institution or journal or scientific body.

Is Facebook being paid to push them into my news stream even when it’s algorithm should show that I detest them? It seems odd that such a large proportion of these items could be coming straight from Pete Hegseth’s Twitter feed or Stephen Miller’s cesspool of a brain.

It’s possible that their algorithm is incredibly bad at its job. On the other hand, Zuckerberg has been cozying up to these people. It’s possible Facebook is actively promoting their cause without telling anyone.

The Facebook Stream of Sewage I

Facebook is becoming a bottomless torrent of scurrilous innuendo, provocative click-bait distortions, cherry-picked data, and apocalyptic predictions of utter doom and disaster if this or that government policy isn’t changed immediately. All designed to enrage you and get you to click and comment and share. All sponsored by Facebook’s advertisers and enabled by government policy which has decided that internet platforms are not responsible for content.

No amount of “blocking” stops them– they reappear under different names, different fake foundations or “news” sites, or under the name of some deservedly obscure podcaster. They come from both sides of the aisle though, to be fair, a majority in my feed seem convinced that Satan has become prime-minster of Canada and that we will soon run out of solar power.

If you do a quick search on any of the stories, you will often find they are false or distorted. You can’t afford to assume any of them are reliable.

There is a reason why established media outlets, conservative or liberal, are more reliable sources of information. They have editors and fact-checkers. They are transparent. They have reputations. They respond to criticism. Now somebody will point out one story out of thousands that had a mistake in it and declare that you can’t trust the media. So you trust some Facebook or TikTok loudmouth you never heard of instead? I usually find that people who say “you can’t trust the media” actually mean “I only trust the media that confirms what I already believe”.

And there are some who would argue that there is a vast global conspiracy out there that controls all of the mainstream media outlets and prevents the truth from being heard. That would be an incredible achievement. I can’t help you.

The sources of this perspective never seem to have a long series of specific facts and research or vetted data to show it. Just “I heard…”.

For those of us who prefer to get the news from established, accountable, well-documented journalists, Facebook should offer an option to shutdown ALL of those feeds. They are awful and their effect on our politics and culture is vile. If I want to know about something, I know which sources are trustworthy, from a range of political perspectives, and can go there.

Rogers & Hart: Blue Moon

In an article in the New York Times, Jesse Green lauds the new biopic of Lorenz Hart (“Blue Moon”) for its relative honesty in dealing with Hart’s homosexuality and alcoholism.  In the process, he savagely ridiculed biopics from the 1940’s and 50’s that lionized these Broadway composers while completely ignoring the factors in their lives that made them who they were.

Some letter writers– more than a few– objected to the criticism of these early biopics, arguing, essentially, that the antiseptic, homogenized, white bread version of the lives of artists like Lorne Hart presented in these films was virtuous in some way, honorable.  Pleasing.  Kind of true.  

I never ceased to be amazed at just how willing most people are to embrace something they know to be a lie rather than admit to an unpleasant– to them– truth.

Truth does matter. Fantasy is these cases is not neutral. It’s a way of imposing an audience’s prejudices on the raw material of real life and manipulating events to gratify them. And if there is an audience for the kind of fantasies those early biopics provided, then, for heaven’s sake, write a story and make up the characters. What I object to is hanging a fantasy on a simulacrum of an artist’s real life as if “this really happened this way”. I want to know something like what really happened.

Springsteen: Deliver Me From Nowhere

I was very disappointed in the new Springsteen biopic, “Springsteen: Deliver me From Nowhere”.

It achieved one thing remarkable: it made Springsteen boring. And it took the unfortunate path of having secondary characters act as one-dimensional props for slavish admiration of the “tortured genius”. Did we all learn nothing from the wonderful Dylan biopics?

Artists seem to love the idea that they have suffered greatly for their art.  It creates the illusion of heft and substance where none might exist.  It is odd that Springsteen, with all of his songs about urban disillusionment, driving, roads, the streets, hot girls who let you unzip their jeans, and so on, should cave to the most familiar and tired tropes.  I don’t begrudge for one second Springsteen’s embrace of therapy for his depression: just the idea that this particular passage of his life is worthy of his first serious biopic, and that it should be rendered with such contrived self-regard (having secondary characters allude to your genius because if you did it yourself you would look conceited).

There is one particular sequence that I think is a “tell” of the director’s intent.  After Springsteen ghosted a girl he was seeing (and romancing),  (acknowledged as a fictional “composite” character by the film-makers) she confronts him with slyly flattering dialogue (let me ease your pain!) instead of really letting loose on the guy who just treated her like a jerk.  From her point of view, he used her and then dumped her.   Just because we might like Springsteen doesn’t really change the facts here. 

The director/writer seemed to have made no effort to give her personhood, an identity, a history, a face.  He used her.  And now his biopic uses her.  He ignored her repeated efforts to connect with him after the sex no longer interested  him.  Yes, he ghosted her.  But all she can talk about is how he must be suffering.

It’s appalling.  Even worse, it’s bad art.  It makes the film dull.

As for the singing, Cooper says this, about White doing Springsteen’s voice:

it wasn’t about mimicry or imitation; it was about finding the truth of who Bruce is

Seriously?  Listen to yourself!  The “truth of who Bruce is” is the kind soft, platitudinous Hollywood bullshit that sells movies, that film-makers hope to have audiences mumbling to themselves as they leave the theatre, that 50-year-old women say when they have finished their memoirs.  I just heard the truth of who Bruce is.  And what is that?  Well, that he hurts.  He’s very, very sad. And wrote some great songs on that album I never bought because it didn’t have any hits on it.  It’s Bruce!  Yeah!  Born in the USA!

“Springsteen: Deliver me From Nowhere” is so bad it has made me reassess my long admiration for him, and to wonder if this film will not do permanent damage to his reputation as an artist.  Something which, however, I admit did not start with this film.  When I first encountered Springsteen’s albums, “Born to Run” and “Darkness on the Edge of Town”, I was blown away by the sheer velocity and volume of his voice.  On songs like, “Backstreets”, Springsteen poured out his rage in song, at the wasteland of deindustrialized America, at his haunted father’s frustration, at the girl who dumped him.  It seemed, at the time, to be powerful in a way that Bob Dylan’s voice never was.

Springsteen’s voice on those albums is still impressive but not as convincing as it used to be and I have since come to have a greater appreciation of Dylan’s singing on his albums from the 60’s and early 70’s.  Yes, he is pretty wretched now (almost unbearable), but his vocals on “Like a Rolling Stone”, “Lay Lady Lay”, “The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll”, and so on and so on, is more than satisfactory.  He is subtle at times, nuanced, beautifully paced, evocative.

Sometimes Springsteen just shouts.

Dylan’s biopics (“A Complete Unknown”, “I’m not There”), in contrast to “Deliver Me From Nowhere”, did nothing but elevate his status.

TokTik Tik Tik

Very skeptical that the deal giving Americans “ownership” of TikTok is what Trump claims it is. There are holes you could drive a bus through, the most obvious being the surprise attachment of a United Arab Emirates corporation to the club. The UAE has extensive ties to China. It also seems to allow for China to continue to “update” the algorithm. Which is exactly what the ownership change was supposed to address, isn’t it?

The UAE component is MGX, chaired by Sheikh Tahnoon bin Zayed Al Nahyan.  Got that?  Explain why the deal is worth $14 billion while ByteDance is valued at $300 billion.  Yes, the U.S. is brokering a deal giving the UAE royal family, Abu Dhabi, a big stake in a company Congress determined was a risk to U. S. security and personal privacy.

My bet is that we will never see the real details of this transaction, but we can rest assured that some people are going to be very rich when it is done.