Bill Maher

Bill Maher Gives his Incredibly Deep Well-Grounded Profound Take on the History of Palestine in a lecture directed to Chappell Roan.  I don’t know who Chappell Roan is but I suspect that Maher is picking on an easy target here, as he often does.

This is a dumbed down, abbreviated version of the history of Palestine.  And it’s mostly wrong.  But Maher doesn’t let his prejudice inhibit his arrogance: he mocks anyone who dares to believe what is obvious: Israel’s actions in Gaza are criminal.

It’s a shame Maher wastes his talents on this dreck, with tedious laugh breaks from the audience and guests.  Why does he do that?  It makes me cringe.  It appears to be conducted.   His guests for that program are compelled to sit there and smile awkwardly at each round.  If I were one of them, I would leave.  You want to conduct a sequence of punchlines with coordinated audience applause?  Go for it but I have a bus to catch.  I am not a prop for the alleged audacity of your smug put-downs of woke excess.

That is the difference between Bill Maher and John Oliver, by the way.  Maher is smug and cynical and pious about his own rectitude.  Oliver is not.  Oliver regularly, and brilliantly, embraces some seemingly idiotic project as a gesture of humility and insatiable curiosity.  These gestures keep him from the kind of contemptuous arrogance that subverts Maher’s claimed insouciance.

He’s not wrong on most of the facts– except by omission–  but would rather score a quick vulgar putdown than make a coherent point.  And his criticism of the excesses of woke Democrats is not off target, but he seems cumulatively selective and one-sided.  Would Bob Jones University ever invite a liberal speaker?  No they would not.  They wouldn’t even countenance the presence of John McCain– not conservative enough.

He also likes to have conservatives (like Mike Pence) on his show to hi-light and grant appreciative luster for the 10% of things they did right, while mocking and ridiculing people get 90% of what they do right.

This particular episode, defending Matt Damon from accusations of homophobia because he admitted that in his youth he sometimes called gay men “fags”, is absolutely right.

But.

His comments on the October 7, 2023 attack by Hamas that killed over 1200 people are certainly not really “politically incorrect”: he has a raft of conservative and MAGA people on his side on this issue.  Yet he adopts this tone of sarcasm as if he is the adult in the room who knows about this history and he must indulgently learn those liberal critics of Israel’s genocidal attack in retaliation on Gaza about the true facts.  There is nothing wrong with having a well-founded strong opinion about Gaza and Israel but his tone implies that other points of view that can be well-founded and intellectually credible are ridiculous compared to his own enlightened take on the subject.  They are not.

It is very possible to be appalled and horrified by both the Hamas attacks on Israel, and by Israel’s utterly brutal revenge destruction of almost the entirety of Gaza and their attacks on south Lebanon.   It is possible to find both Hamas and Netanyahu monstrous.  Most of the people I know who have thought about the issue feel that way.  Maher doesn’t seem to think it is a credible point of view.   If you condemn Netanyahu, he thinks he can tag you as pro-Hamas.

Maher adopts the dubious rationale of Palestine being the historic homeland of the Jews– he even cites the bible–  so, after an absence of 2000 years, they are entitled to re-occupy it, and he suggests that it was not occupied by anyone else at the time.  I didn’t hear the word Nahkba once in his diatribe.

There is no moral law that rationalizes possession of a specific land according to who occupied it at any previous point in time.  The world is full of places where peoples were driven out or annihilated or migrated.  The idea of restoring everyone to their original native land is a recipe for chaos and does not serve any higher moral purpose.  Does he have the same perspective on the Sioux or other indigenous tribes?  On the Irish?  Brazil?

Maher believes that Israel’s actions in Gaza are above reproach, justified by Hamas’ attack of October 7th, and Hamas’ avowed mission of destroying Israel.  He’s not wrong about Hamas, but I do not believe that Israel’s response is proportionate or responsible.  Where is the end of this progression?  The two-state solution is almost dead, but the endless cycle of attack and revenge is not much of an alternative.  Does Maher have any problem with the long-term status of Palestinians living in the region?  Will they become second class citizens of an apartheid Israel?

Maher’s recent work belongs on Fox; not HBO. The net result of his rants is to convince people that because both sides of the American divide can be ridiculed, they are both essentially the same.  His point is not moral truth.  His point is that he is smarter than the people he ridicules by cherry-picking their public statements because he make witty vulgarities out of what seems obvious.  Or he has a guest like John Fetterman and suddenly he’s a docile, congenial host, conspicuously ignoring questions about Fetterman’s health and fitness.

And yet, in a bizarre and incomprehensible attempt to buff his bipartisan credentials,  he actually had the idiot harpy Anne Coulter on.  Have a conservative on your show?  By all means.  But Anne Coulter is a phony, sponsored conservative apparatchik who doesn’t deserve the exposure, and Maher is an idiot for putting her on his show.  Jordan Peterson?  The man whose whole shtick is making idiot right-wingers feel smart.

The effect of his bipartisan ridicule is this:  Donald Trump is the same as Kamala Harris.  Pete Hegseth is the same as Lloyd Austin.  Robert Kennedy Jr. is the same as Anthony Fauci. Andrew Miller is the same as Jake Sullivan.

This is a mistake John Oliver does not make.  Maher is too narcissistic to bother with concrete solutions; Oliver almost never loses his rational perspective.  He always offers a possible remedy for the toxic behaviors he describes. Oliver believes that taking potshots at everything from a safe virtual tower of pious cynicism is a lousy way to do commentary and leads to quietism and indifference.

Would Maher ever run for political office?  And then have to be accountable for the actual implementation of his views?  What, I would be very interested know, does he think politicians should do?  Raise the minimum wage?  Increase tariffs?  Tax the rich?

He knows that there is another Bill Maher out there in wait who will shred his performance the way he shreds others.

Maher has a degree from Cornell University in English literature and history.  You wouldn’t know it.

He’s not all bad.  He’s right, here, mostly, about political aides, but, again, note how he implies that the Democrats and Republicans are equally absurd.  They are not.  There will always be a few on the fringe in either party who are idiots, but the Republicans have made idiocy their uniform identity with Donald Trump.

I suspect Maher is simply trying to please the lowest common denominator.

There is a resonant fable we can attach to Maher, though.  In 2002, while hosting “Politically Incorrect”, Maher agreed with a guest that, whatever else you call them, the 9/11 hijackers were not cowards, while people firing cruise missiles from 2,000 miles away were cowardly.  It tells you everything you need to know about American culture, and perhaps culture in general, that “Politically Incorrect” was then cancelled for being politically incorrect.  The lesson is that everyone wants everyone else to think they are open-minded and intellectually courageous but the minute a genuinely courageous opinion generates a backlash, everyone ducks under the covers and shits themselves.

“No one is ever smarter from going on Bill Maher,” Ms. Pollitt said in an interview on Thursday.

One final observation: Bill Maher did a piece I generally liked on cancel culture.  Unfortunately, he missed the forest.  All the examples he gives are from “woke” crowds and institutions and universities objecting to certain controversial jokes without making a single reference to conservatives who are actually so much more regressive on the issue that you almost forget about them.  Come on Maher: you’ve got to be kidding me.  The party that will excommunicate anyone who doesn’t salute the flag (and display a lapel pin), praise Jesus, bow before the military, and praise America as the greatest, bestest, most wonderfullest nation in the history of the universe— you give them a pass?  That’s not political correctness? Nobody is more politically correct than a conservative.  You just don’t notice it as much because, unlike liberals, they don’t even simulate broad-mindedness and tolerance.

Okay. In fairness, here’s a recent attempt to take on the hypocrisies of Republicans.  And here he is giving it to extremists and their enablers on both sides.

And here’s another good response to Maher’s arguments about Israel.

Subtleties of Beauty

Anne Frank and her friend.

Above is a photo I found online of Anne Frank and a friend of hers, Nanette Konig, at about the same age.  I found it fascinating for various reasons not the least of which is the contrast between two similar faces, both of which are beautiful in their own way, but one of which is more beautiful in an aesthetic sense.

I repeat: Anne Frank is absolutely a beautiful person.  Reader her famous diary: she was gifted, curious, intelligent, compassionate, and authentic.

But the girl on the left has a more attractive face.  Why?  The reason I was fascinated by the differences is that it is very hard to describe exactly what it is that is different about the two faces.  The arrangement of features is more pleasing on Nanette’s face.  Could you measure it? Could you calculate a formula for it?

There is no way to know how beautiful each of them was in the dynamic of physical presence.  It is not unusual to hear or read about a really beautiful woman and then find pictures of her that don’t seem to live up to the expectation.   I then assume that the subject really was more beautiful than the picture shows.  Mimi Farina is one example.  By all accounts, she was the most attractive of the three Baez sisters, but the photos I can find of her don’t seem to show that.  I’ll trust the opinions of people who knew her, who insist she was amazingly beautiful, and concede to myself that photos are not sufficient.

Above, we have two very similar faces, dark hair, wide-set eyes, defined chin.  Yet, the girl on the left seems to me to be “prettier” than Anne Frank.  Why?  What is it about the arrangement of features, the character of the various attributes, the nose, the cheeks, the eyes, the chin, that produces such a different effect?  Is there an objective standard of beauty that it corresponds to more closely than Anne?  Is it random, or just personal preference?

At best, I think Anne’s nose is a bit longer, her eyes perhaps not quite as wide set, her smile a little less embracing.  Her upper lip is a little thinner, her nose a little more angular, her eyebrows a touch darker.

I would wager that most people would see the same distinction that I see, though people generally find it “distasteful” to judge anyone based on appearance.  I absolutely agree.  I am not judging the person– just the appearance.  I don’t believe for a moment that most of us don’t do that, whether we admit it or not.

I don’t believe there’s anything wrong with acknowledging something that we all do.  I have no problem acknowledging that Nanette may not have been as nice or courageous or articulate as Anne.  I have no problem acknowledging that physical beauty does not necessarily tell you anything about a person’s character (though Albert Camus, famously, said that after the age of 21, everyone is “responsible for your face”).

There was a moment in my life when it was driven home to me that life is utterly unfair.  As I was walking one sunny afternoon, I encountered three high school students walking towards me.  As they drew closer, I looked up into the faces.  One of them was startling.  It was stunningly beautiful.  And more than beautiful: it was kind, intelligent, warm, inviting, healthy.  Everything about this person’s face was exquisite.

I frankly was not sure if this person was a male for female: the face was that perfect.  It didn’t look like a feminine boy or a masculine girl.  It just looked like the perfect symmetry of nose, eyes, mouth, forehead, chin– everything in perfect form and proportion.

Once, when I was in high school myself, I ascended the inner staircase of the Brock’s monument in Queenston, Ontario.  The staircase is narrow and very close, and on the way down I passed a group of girls going up.  I looked up into the face of one of them as I passed her, inches away.  She had red hair and freckles and green eyes and the shiniest, most radiant, beautiful skin I have ever seen.  She seemed startled to see me looking into her eyes and I was probably startled by what I saw.

Did either of them “earn” that face?  No.  It was a gift, of genetics and god, and chance, and personal history, and good health.  And incredibly unfair: I have no doubt that those faces could wreck havoc where-ever they wanted to whenever they wanted to.

May be a black-and-white image of 2 people

Mimi Farina (left), Stephen Stills, and Joan Baez.

To The Posters of Family Faith and Farm Videos

There are some lovely videos of farmers out there farming with their children with texts declaring their good values and principles and faith.  I responded to one of them like this:

I love your values. Respect, integrity, support for “the underdog”. But I wonder what you think about people who claim to share your values but, in their personal lives and policies, show a lack of integrity, poor character, meanness of spirit, preferential treatment of the rich, and divisive political rhetoric? I see people who claim the support of evangelical Christians who don’t seem to reflect the values expressed by Jesus Christ, who pursue riches relentlessly, sew hatred of minorities, and shamelessly lie. Yet an overwhelming majority of Christians seem to adore them. I’m perplexed. I wonder if you really believe what you say you believe.

The Legendary Trump

Dear Donald,

Do you really want to go down in history as a great president? Your face on Mount Rushmore? A legend? A game-changer? Someone who made a lasting impact on almost every citizen?

You’ll never be remembered for stealing Greenland or bluffing Iran or enabling Putin and Netanyahu. Nobody will love your chaos in Democrat-led cities. Melania’s biopic will never win an Oscar. Your ugly gold-leaf decorations will be removed by the next administration before they even take office. History will record that inflation was already declining before you were inaugurated and hasn’t much declined since. Your crypto currency will collapse into Ponzi inertia.

Here it is: pass a national single-payer universal health care program. Cut out the insurance companies. Set standardized rates for procedures and hospital care. Tax the billionaires and the oil companies to help pay for it.

You are the only politician in America that can do it. The Democrats can’t possibly rally enough bipartisan support to even extend Obamacare. You can do it: rally the MAGAverse to your side, threaten the stubborn Senators and Representatives into compliance, primary the resisters, and give Schumer a hug. If the Supreme Court challenges you, threaten to expand it and stock it with compliant yes-men or Democrats like Elizabeth Warren.

The evangelicals will eventually support it because it is one of the best political expressions of “family values”, and, contrary to most conservative politics, actually does seem “Christian”.

There will be lots of opposition at first but you know how to bully them aside. In ten years, a large majority of people will wonder how they ever got by without it. How could we have been the only developed nation that didn’t have it for so long? Who was this genius who gave it to us? Yes, Donald J. Trump!

You’ll be remembered forever, like Franklin Roosevelt, like Eisenhower, like Lincoln.

You’re welcome.

The Politically Correct “Star Trek New Worlds”

For not the first time, the custodians of the Star Trek legacy have decided deflower Mr. Spock.

What, my friends, was unique and interesting about Mr. Spock in the original TV series?  It was that he was a rational person who believed in Reason and Science, in contrast to the humans around him who were still wildly swayed by their emotions (though one could argue that Kirk, in his best moments as captain, acted rationally).

Spock would sometimes inform the captain that the odds of succeeding in a particular course of action were miniscule– and then Kirk would take the gamble anyway.  This was TV land, so Kirk’s unlikely gambles always succeeded but, even as a  12-year-old watching “Star Trek” for the first time, I thought they should have showed us that Spock was usually right, and gambles against ridiculous odds were foolish.

We all want the virgin.  Yes, I am comparing the character of Spock to a virgin.  The creative teams that handled the Star Trek franchise realized they had a lovely virgin on their hands, a character who, through his dedication to Science and Reason, had won the admiration of an entire generation of sci-fi fans.  It is similar, to me, to the appeal of a young virgin in a whorehouse.  Who does the guest most want to deflower?  Not those tired old saggy whores, but the young beauty who has never been violated.   In the same way, for cheap dramatic effect, they wanted to twist Spock’s character and have him become emotional at a moment of peak tension.  You see?  Even Spock agrees with my cheap emotional insistence that the entire crew of the Enterprise be risked in order to save his buddy, Kirk, even though it is unreasonable to do so.

In a subsequent iteration (“Star Trek Into Darkness”, 2013), they even had the older Spock time-travel so he could advise the younger Spock to “go with your feelings”.  I cringed.

And now we have “Star Trek: Strange New Worlds” in which “the series takes the opportunity to explore Spock’s human emotions before he becomes more computer-like”.

Thank you.  You just destroyed the most interesting character in the entire series.

Again.

Not only that, but Spock gets a human girl-friend, Nurse Chapel, whom, we are given to understand, becomes one of “Spock’s great teachers about his humanness”.

I think I’m going to vomit.  Not only do they emasculate Spock’s rationality– they emasculate his gender.  And clearly, the purpose is to attack the alleged “toxic masculinity” of the original version.  Captain Pike, in this new version (set ten years before the original series), is “more thoughtful and empathetic” and likes to bake.  I’m not making this up.  The character of La’An Noonien-Singh, the “chief of security”, was, we are told, bullied as a child because of her ethnicity.

The courage of the original producers to include an Asian, a Russian, and a black woman among the command personnel has been replaced by gratuitous adherence to woke ideology.

And we get a prequel that is more socially “progressive” than the most socially progressive program on TV in the 1960’s except that in 2025 it’s not progressive at all: it is utterly conventional, by today’s standards.

I am a progressive.  But there are times when I get why so many right-wing podcasters attack the culture of political correctness.  Having a Mr. Spock who is masculine and rational is not a political endorsement of masculinity or rationality: it is recognition that such things exist, given the storyline about the planet Vulcan, and have existed, and will always exist (sometimes it feels like the stereotypical forms of masculinity are returning right now).

And I would join the argument that Mr. Spock’s rationalism is good, and more likely than Kirk’s hunches, to lead to victory or success.

It would have been far, far more interesting, to let Spock’s rationality play out because, as in real life today, the Rational and Coherent and Scientifically Defensible, is under attack by MAGA and the reams of people who really believe that American healthcare is superior to that in all the other nations, even if it is free for everyone, and that the recycling label on the bottom of your plastic jug means it will be recycled, and the evidence or climate change is the product of a hoax, and that nations should negotiate for the release of hostages.

It would be electrifying to see Spock inform his crew that negotiating for the release of a hostage would make the strategy successful for their adversaries and will only ensure that more hostages will be taken.  Or that promoting minorities by ethnicity rather than merit would diminish the effectiveness of the crew.  Or that a crew member shouldn’t be so thin-skinned about a harmless sexually suggestive joke.

The new series, “Strange New Worlds” appears to at least embrace more of a sense of humor than the dour “Next Generation” did.

My Previous Dissection of the Issue

Robert Munsch

Dementia Is Stealing the Imagination of Robert Munsch, Children’s Book Writer – The New York Times

From a New York Times article on Robert Munsch, a comment on other children’s books:

The results fill the shelves of children’s bookstores today: the joyless and relentlessly realistic books inspired by various pedagogical frameworks; the strained, platitudinous and inexpertly rhyming stories published by celebrities.

I agree with him. I find many children’s books are obsessively moralistic and pious.

And, on “Love You Forever”: “Some readers found the book too sentimental, almost drippy. Also creepy. Even Oedipal. ‘It is the most loved and the most hated book I’ve ever seen,’ one bookseller told The Times.”

I’m with the group that find it sentimental and “creepy”. Apparently, kids laugh at the story and moms cry. This dad cringes.

Your mileage may vary.

Surprised to read that Munsch had issues with depression and bipolar disorder and a drinking and drug problem way back when. And not so way back. Sadly, he is now suffering from dementia and other physical frailties. After watching one of his brothers die very slowly from Lou Gehrig’s disease he is considering MAID.

I’m not a fan of his writing (they remind me of badly improvised dialogue in some films) but I admire his attitude and his irreverence for traditional story-telling.

The article in the New York Times is quite moving. He lives in Guelph, Ontario, Canada.

Nothing New Under the Sun

In regard to here.

It’s about someone named Aaron Renn.

Mr. Renn loves city life, and has lived in Manhattan, Chicago and Indianapolis. Carmel is different. Here, church bells chime full hymns over the town square. It’s a place where it’s easy to forget Mr. Renn’s best-known idea: his warning to Christians that America is in an era of distinct hostility to believers like them, and that they must gird themselves to adapt to, as the title of his recent book put it, “Life in the Negative World.”

I don’t think there is anything new here at all. Christians have a habit of periodically engaging in wildly enthusiastic embrace of some new “reinterpretation” that seems more engaged and relevant and intellectually credible. (Jesus Freaks, Christian Contemporary Music, Blue Like Jazz, and so on.) And then you investigate it more closely and you see that it’s the same old redneck fire and brimstone, pieties and hypocrisies, patriarchy, smugness, and materialism.

And, of course, extreme right-wing politics. No, you’re not smart now.

It’s not really Christian at all.  It’s superstition combined with reactionary politics.  It’s the politics of the rich and privileged, which isn’t all bad, but mostly is.  It’s paranoia and conformity, banality and self-regard.  The same old, same old, same old.  The blah blah blah of middle America.

It’s a sweet, wonderful world, if you’re in the club, of consumer trinkets, antiseptic public life, and space for all those men to get off to Vegas for a glorious weekend once in a while, of gambling and prostitutes and Wayne Newton, because, after all, boys will boys.

 

The Palladium, a proud edifice built in Carmel to demonstrate that even conservative Republicans can have good taste, features acts like Mickey Dolenz, Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat, Itzhack Perlman, Emmy-Lou Harris, The U.S. Army Field Band and Male Chorus, and an official release party for some country singer named Tege Holt who sounds pretty harmless.

Emmy-Lou Harris and Itzhack Perlman are esteemed but safe choices.  The others speak for themselves.  They remind me of the problem Trump is going to have bringing A-list acts to the Kennedy Centre now that he is it’s chief.

The Kennedy Center Honors

With Trump taking over the Kennedy Centre, we can look forward to Ted Nugent, Kid Rock, Mel Gibson, Kanye West, the Village People, and professional wrestlers receiving the honors.

That sounds like a joke, but we have learned that Trump is, in fact, a joke.  The joke is real.  He might well do the Village People.

Well, why not?  If they have previously “honored” Cher, Lucille Ball, Amy Grant, and others, why the fuck not The Village People?   (List of honorees.)

I don’t begrudge platforms out there that honor popular artists.  They have their place.  Actually, they are all over the place,  They are endless and infinite, a gigantic pool of triviality and self-infatuation that serves the masses when they want to believe that the trashy spectacle they prefer is somehow, literally “honorable”.   That the artists they love earned their way to popularity and were not the product of massive pr machinery that manipulated you into finding them interesting.

You have the Grammys, the Superbowl, the Emmys, the Hollywood Walk of Fame,  and all the banquets and dinners you could ever dream of.

And obviously, there are platforms that honor genuinely elite achievements in the arts, the Pulitzers, the Nobels, the Bookers, and numerous foundations and charities.

The Oscars straddle that uneasy compromise, trying very hard to be credible and popular at the same time.  They rewarded “Midnight Cowboy”.  They also rewarded “Avatar”, “Titanic 1997” (the awful James Cameron version),  “Rocky”, “Out of Africa”,  “Dances With Wolves”,  “Forrest Gump”,  “Braveheart”, and “Driving Miss Daisy”.  And “Gladiator”.  And “Chicago”.  Oh my– I didn’t think the list was that bad.  “The King’s Speech”.  And “Green Book”.

Okay– that’s not much of a compromise.  It’s all out craven publicity machine servitude.

In one of the most astounding acts of cultural reversal ever, the Kennedy Center even honored George Carlin in 2008 (with the Mark Twain Prize).  Yes, George Carlin of the seven words you can never say on television.   Even more shockingly, he accepted.  Shamefully, I think.  Shamelessly, I fear.

He died in June of that year.

In all seriousness, Carlin’s acceptance of the honor is one of the most depressing moments in the last 50 years.  For everyone, whether you know it or not.  The ultimate anti-establishment satirist, the caustic jester of the rich and privileged class, the man who mocked false values and hypocrisy for his entire career, feted and honored by a massive gathering of politicians, billionaires, celebrity journalists, and other privileged phonies.  And yes, of course, some legitimately honorable attendees: the bait.

Bill Cosby was honored (rescinded). The Who was honored — but they’re British.  I didn’t know they honored foreigners.

They honored both Cher and Philip Glass one year. I don’t think you could find two nominees whose audiences are less likely to overlap than those two.

The problem for Trump will be that not very many A-listers would probably be willing to make themselves available for the festivities given the current political climate. The problem solves itself because Trump’s constituency probably doesn’t believe Kid Rock and Roseanne Barr are not A-listers.

Should be interesting. Trump and Melania did not attend the annual festive night while President to not “distract” from the event with the political fall-out. (Some potential nominees would have refused the “honor”). So I presume, he plans to attend now, which means he needs a list of potential nominees who have no qualms about appearing with him (and attending the honorific dinners: Chairman’s Luncheon, State Department Dinner, White House Reception, and Honors gala performance).

Trump, while ceaselessly mocking the establishment, also craves the status and recognition that goes with hobnobbing with celebrated artists and performers. He loves to say, “look at this really smart guy and he’s hanging out with me.” I imagine he pictures himself posing for pictures with, say, previous honorees Bruce Springsteen, Paul McCartney, Yo-Yo Ma, Meryl Streep, Steven Spielberg, Joni Mitchell.

It’s just hard to imagine nominees who will go along with this with Trump in office and hosting, aside from The Village People, Ted Nugent, and Kid Rock. Kanye West, definitely. Wayne Newton and Loretta Lynn. Lee Greenwood.

Not exactly A-List in any respect.

They don’t want to be too embarrassed. I suspect he’ll find some marginally respected artists who will be tempted by the exposure and the opportunity to sample hors d’oeuvres with Megyn Kelly or do the frug with Elon Musk.

 

The Shambolic Church

The evangelical church in American will never be able to wash away the pungent stain of having supported Trump. He radiates sleaze, materialism, sexual immorality, selfishness, mendacity, cruelty, and ignorance.

He’s your guy.

He’s your aspiration. He’s your exemplar. He’s your totem.

All of your preaching and outward habits manifest as pure unbridled hypocrisy. You can never again stand up and claim to represent virtue and morality because we all now know that it is a sham.

John Williams to tell you What to Feel

I keep seeing online commentators raving about John Williams musical scores.  Here’s a list of some of his projects.

    • Valley of the Dolls (1967)
    • Towering Inferno (1974)
    • Sugarland Express (1974)
    • Fiddler on the Roof (1971) *  (unfair really: the music in “Fiddler” is from the musical by Sheldon Bock and Sheldon Harnick)
    • E. T. the Extra-Terrestrial (1982)
    • Raiders of the Lost Ark (1981)
    • Jurassic Park (1993)
    • Catch Me if You Can (2002)
    • Beach Blanket Bingo (just kidding)
    • Harry Potter (first three films, 2001-2004)

He has received the National Medal of the Arts (2009) and he is an Honorary Knight Commander of the Order of the British Empire.

And he is boring as hell.

I have watched a lot of movies.  I don’t think I ever thought a John Williams score was evocative or compelling in any of the films he has scored.  He is almost always bombastic, always predictable, and never striking or original or fresh.  His music is there for insecure directors who don’t have faith in their own work and want to make sure the audience knows what they are supposed to be feeling.

Here are some movies that I thought did have strong scores:

    • Amelie (Yann Tiersen, 2001)
    • Elevator to the Gallows (Miles Davis, 1958)
    • Psycho (Bernard Herrmann, 1959)
    • The Graduate (Paul Simon, 1968)
    • Blade Runner (Vangelis, 1982)
    • Once Upon a Time in America (Ennio Morricone, 1984)
    • The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly (Ennio Morricone, 1966)
    • Dr. Zhivago (Maurice Jarre, 1965)
    • Paris, Texas (Ry Cooder, 1984)
    • Wings of Desire (Jurgen Knieper, Nick Cave, 1987)
    • Godfather (Nina Rota, 1972)
    • The Third Man (Anton Karas, 1949)
    • To Kill a Mockingbird (Elmer Bernstein, 1961)

In most of those movies, there is at least one sequence in which the music plays a powerful role in shaping your emotional response to the action on the screen.  The wistful, luminous score of “Amelie”, for example, has tinge of melancholy that deepens our response to the loneliness and regret expressed by characters she meets in the film.  “The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly” gives scenes of stark tension, fear, and waste.  Maurice Jarre’s music for “Dr. Zhivago” conveys the long and desire of Zhivago for his lost love, and life.  Vangelis contribution to “Blade Runner” helps create that disorienting, broken, shabby environment of the dystopian future.  Paul’s Simon’s music accentuates the generation gap at the heart of “The Graduate”.  The moody, exhausted landscape of a broken city and culture reverberate in Anton Karas’ zither music in “The Third Man”.

I am astonished that Steven Spielberg chose John Williams to provide the music for “Schindler’s List”.  And then I am not astonished.  Spielberg is a good director of schematic action sequences, and he can give you some good drama, but he invariably sloshes into sentimentality and contrivance, as in the last scene of “Schindler’s List”, and the awful, awful last scene of “Saving Private Ryan” (Ryan, as an older man, weeping at a graveyard in Normandy).

So, yes, John Williams is perfect, for a movie maker who never trusts his audience to “get it”.  The music is there to tell you how to feel, just in case the drama itself didn’t sink in.