Everybody Feels Good

The goal, Mr. Stone said: “Make sure everything works and everybody feels good.”  NY Times

I am deeply concerned about the trend described in this article in the New York Times.  Theatre companies are reviewing their products to root out anything that might cause offense to some communities.  They are fixing the productions.  They are cleaning them up.  They are purifying them.  They are sanitizing them.

They are trying to make sure that everyone in the theatre feels good about the production.

This should be the art world’s worst nightmare.

If not for the offense given without apology to certain people, there would have been no “Rites of Spring”, no “Huckleberry Finn”, no “Cabaret”, no “Guernica”, no “Sergeant Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band”, no “Blonde on Blonde”, no Jonathan Franzen, no “M*A*S*H”.

What they are doing is conforming their music and lyrics and texts to the lowest common denominator, which is death for artistic quality.

Most bizarrely, “The Book of Mormon” is being cleaned up.   This is a classic instance of people loving the rogue, which is, something that appears to be transgressive and “naughty” but isn’t really so we can all feel like we are common folk with a good sense of humor but not really immoral in any way even though the real reason we like transgressive art and titillation is because it does invite us to indulge in immoral fantasies without being accountable for them.

Get that?  That’s why Bill Maher’s “Politically Incorrect” was permitted as long as it wasn’t really politically incorrect.  The minute he said something really politically incorrect — that the terrorist who attacked the World Trade Centre and the Pentagon on 9/11 were not cowards– it was cancelled.  [It has since reappeared on HBO  in 2003 as “Real Time with Bill Maher”.  Maher himself copped out, apologizing for his comments– so, I guess he wasn’t really “politically incorrect”.   Well, at least he did drop the name.

He also had people like Ann Coulter on the show.  Coulter is not really legitimate dissent.  She is a conservative harpy-zealot sponsored by dark conservative money and masquerading as a journalist.

 

 

The Diplomat: Sanitized and Anodyne

I haven’t watched the Netflix series “The Diplomat” yet.  I’m not sure I intend to.  Why?  Because like almost every other TV show, the  makers refuse to identify any political parties to which the main characters belong.

TV (and movies) traditionally adopt the “lowest common denominator” principle of everything.  No religion, no political beliefs, no specific characteristics of any particular character for fear of alienating potential viewers who don’t adhere to or admire that detail.

You are asked to suspend your disbelief, to thrill to the devious connivances of various politicians and diplomats, without once any of them making any reference to the one thing that most defines them: politics.

Which is not to say that the plot line of “The Diplomat”, aside from the excision of the most elemental political reality in their lives, is even remotely plausible.   Assassination plots, abductions, third-rate diplomats pulling strings at the White House and 10 Downing Street without getting slapped down by the Secretary of State or Foreign Minister or their bureaucracies.  The Prime-Minister physically assaulting a campaign manager.

Debra Kahn brandishes her credentials as a former writer of “The West Wing”.  Let’s get that out of the way: Aaron Sorkin is the writer that made “The West Wing” magnificent.  Kahn came along around Season 4, with Sorkin’s departure,  and stayed to Season 7, during which the quality of writing declined significantly.

 

 

Sanitizing Himself

A recent article in the New York Times by JoAnna Novack  lauded Adam Sandler thusly.

I responded:

Excuse me? The journalist should be astute enough to realize that Sandler showing clips of celebrated comedians at his show is a blatantly self-serving gesture: include me, please. I belong up there with Jerry Lewis and Chris Farley and Norm MacDonald. Yes, actually Sandler does belong in that category– but not within a mile of Charlie Chaplin!  It is journalistic malpractice to not note the colossal difference in quality between the three vulgarians and Chaplin.

What the writer finds endearing and humanizing is the thin patina of self-mockery that conceals Sandler’s sneering sensibility, that constant invitation to be complicit in the dirty joke, the vulgarity; always the first resort of an inadequate comedian.

Hollywood’s Gay Lovers

Most laughable headline of the day:  “Andrew Garfield Comes out as Gay”.  Ha ha.  There never was anything to come out of.  And even more laughable: “40 Celebrities You Didn’t Know where LGBT”.  Seriously?  We didn’t know?

There has always been a multitude of gay actors in Hollywood, gay directors, gay casting directors, and gay audiences.   Until relatively recently, Hollywood did it’s best to conceal the sexual orientation of its biggest stars, primarily for two reasons.  1.  homosexuality was considered deviant.  2.  audiences craved at the least the allusion that male romantic leads were genuinely sexually attracted to the female romantic leads.  Rock Hudson, Tab Hunter, Montgomery Clift, Laurence Olivier, John Gielgud.  Okay– nobody cared if John Gielgud was attracted to the actresses.

And let me amend that, with a nod to Mitch Hedberg: Hollywood used to try to conceal the sexual orientation of its gay actors.  It still does try to conceal the sexual orientation of its gay actors, but it used to too.

The key to the success of men like Rock Hudson was that he was handsome and charming without being the least bit dangerous.  By “dangerous”, I mean conveying an authentic interest in having sex with the female protagonist.  You just can’t picture Rock Hudson actually groping Doris Day.  You can’t picture Doris Day being genuinely worried about finding herself alone in a bedroom with Mr. Hudson.

You can’t picture Doris Day being groped either, but it is imaginable.

For women in the audience, this is not a problem.  A lot of women would be quite happy living with a gay man anyway, so having one up there on the screen buying flowers and opening the door for lovely actresses with substantial breasts and living in a tidy apartment and being well-groomed is an embraceable fantasy.

I cannot watch Andrew Garfield or Leonardo Di Caprio or Timothy Chalamet or Jim Parsons or Neil Patrick Harris, or Zachary Quinto or Tom Cruise or the hosts of others romancing those beautiful actresses without finding those scenes patently ridiculous.  Channing Tatum?  Come on!  Matthew Rhys?  They are absurd.  There is no desire in this transition, no lust in the characters eyes, no urge to grope or caress or squeeze: just that congenial tidy mop of amusing chatter.

In 2024’s “We Live in Time”, Garfield is supposed to fall deeply in love with Florence Pugh and if you don’t believe in it you are not going to feel the weight of this great tragic story involving (oh no!) a terminal illness (“Love Story” anyone?).  But that doesn’t matter to the audience.  As a gay man, Garfield has mastered the nuance of being servile and domesticated and solicitous and that is what some women seem to want in their Hollywood heroes.

I am more than pleased to say that I haven’t seen “We Live in Time”– I don’t think I could stomach it, and I certainly don’t want to waste the time.

Films with a convincing masculine lead:

Train Dreams

Who’s not gay?

Stanley Tucci

Prince

Charlie Chaplin

 

 

Mel Brooks’ Careeer

The original film of “The Producers” was brilliant, and the moment when “Springtime for Hitler” opened in front a stunned audience may have been one of the ten funniest moments on film, ever. It’s a great pity that you can’t see it for the first time over again.

Since then… meh. Too broad, too much slapstick and physical humor, too many bodily function jokes.

No other film by him had the consistent tone and and narrative integrity of “The Producers”.

Disney and Hefner

As T-Bone Burnett observed, in the song “Hefner and Disney”, Disney and Hugh Hefner actually have a lot in common. Both are selling air-brushed facsimiles of something desirable but not real, catering to our shallowest desires for easily digestible, consumable tripe. They are both purveyors of smut in their own realms.

Rogers & Hart: Blue Moon

In an article in the New York Times, Jesse Green lauds the new biopic of Lorenz Hart (“Blue Moon”) for its relative honesty in dealing with Hart’s homosexuality and alcoholism.  In the process, he savagely ridiculed biopics from the 1940’s and 50’s that lionized these Broadway composers while completely ignoring the factors in their lives that made them who they were.

Some letter writers– more than a few– objected to the criticism of these early biopics, arguing, essentially, that the antiseptic, homogenized, white bread version of the lives of artists like Lorne Hart presented in these films was virtuous in some way, honorable.  Pleasing.  Kind of true.  

I never ceased to be amazed at just how willing most people are to embrace something they know to be a lie rather than admit to an unpleasant– to them– truth.

Truth does matter. Fantasy is these cases is not neutral. It’s a way of imposing an audience’s prejudices on the raw material of real life and manipulating events to gratify them. And if there is an audience for the kind of fantasies those early biopics provided, then, for heaven’s sake, write a story and make up the characters. What I object to is hanging a fantasy on a simulacrum of an artist’s real life as if “this really happened this way”. I want to know something like what really happened.

Film: “The Good One”

Sheila O’Malley at rogerebert.com gives “Good One” four our of four stars. That means she rates this bare-bones, muted film in the class of “The Godfather”, “12 Angry Men”, “Zone of Interest”, and so on.

I would call that movie critic malpractice. I give it 2 our of 4, and I think that’s generous.

The Politically Correct “Star Trek New Worlds”

For not the first time, the custodians of the Star Trek legacy have decided deflower Mr. Spock.

What, my friends, was unique and interesting about Mr. Spock in the original TV series?  It was that he was a rational person who believed in Reason and Science, in contrast to the humans around him who were still wildly swayed by their emotions (though one could argue that Kirk, in his best moments as captain, acted rationally).

Spock would sometimes inform the captain that the odds of succeeding in a particular course of action were miniscule– and then Kirk would take the gamble anyway.  This was TV land, so Kirk’s unlikely gambles always succeeded but, even as a  12-year-old watching “Star Trek” for the first time, I thought they should have showed us that Spock was usually right, and gambles against ridiculous odds were foolish.

We all want the virgin.  Yes, I am comparing the character of Spock to a virgin.  The creative teams that handled the Star Trek franchise realized they had a lovely virgin on their hands, a character who, through his dedication to Science and Reason, had won the admiration of an entire generation of sci-fi fans.  It is similar, to me, to the appeal of a young virgin in a whorehouse.  Who does the guest most want to deflower?  Not those tired old saggy whores, but the young beauty who has never been violated.   In the same way, for cheap dramatic effect, they wanted to twist Spock’s character and have him become emotional at a moment of peak tension.  You see?  Even Spock agrees with my cheap emotional insistence that the entire crew of the Enterprise be risked in order to save his buddy, Kirk, even though it is unreasonable to do so.

In a subsequent iteration (“Star Trek Into Darkness”, 2013), they even had the older Spock time-travel so he could advise the younger Spock to “go with your feelings”.  I cringed.

And now we have “Star Trek: Strange New Worlds” in which “the series takes the opportunity to explore Spock’s human emotions before he becomes more computer-like”.

Thank you.  You just destroyed the most interesting character in the entire series.

Again.

Not only that, but Spock gets a human girl-friend, Nurse Chapel, whom, we are given to understand, becomes one of “Spock’s great teachers about his humanness”.

I think I’m going to vomit.  Not only do they emasculate Spock’s rationality– they emasculate his gender.  And clearly, the purpose is to attack the alleged “toxic masculinity” of the original version.  Captain Pike, in this new version (set ten years before the original series), is “more thoughtful and empathetic” and likes to bake.  I’m not making this up.  The character of La’An Noonien-Singh, the “chief of security”, was, we are told, bullied as a child because of her ethnicity.

The courage of the original producers to include an Asian, a Russian, and a black woman among the command personnel has been replaced by gratuitous adherence to woke ideology.

And we get a prequel that is more socially “progressive” than the most socially progressive program on TV in the 1960’s except that in 2025 it’s not progressive at all: it is utterly conventional, by today’s standards.

I am a progressive.  But there are times when I get why so many right-wing podcasters attack the culture of political correctness.  Having a Mr. Spock who is masculine and rational is not a political endorsement of masculinity or rationality: it is recognition that such things exist, given the storyline about the planet Vulcan, and have existed, and will always exist (sometimes it feels like the stereotypical forms of masculinity are returning right now).

And I would join the argument that Mr. Spock’s rationalism is good, and more likely than Kirk’s hunches, to lead to victory or success.

It would have been far, far more interesting, to let Spock’s rationality play out because, as in real life today, the Rational and Coherent and Scientifically Defensible, is under attack by MAGA and the reams of people who really believe that American healthcare is superior to that in all the other nations, even if it is free for everyone, and that the recycling label on the bottom of your plastic jug means it will be recycled, and the evidence or climate change is the product of a hoax, and that nations should negotiate for the release of hostages.

It would be electrifying to see Spock inform his crew that negotiating for the release of a hostage would make the strategy successful for their adversaries and will only ensure that more hostages will be taken.  Or that promoting minorities by ethnicity rather than merit would diminish the effectiveness of the crew.  Or that a crew member shouldn’t be so thin-skinned about a harmless sexually suggestive joke.

The new series, “Strange New Worlds” appears to at least embrace more of a sense of humor than the dour “Next Generation” did.

My Previous Dissection of the Issue

At the Circus With Wim Wenders

“Shiny Happy People” (Documentary on Prime) is about people who see life in this world as an insignificant temporary smudge of reality in which we are tested for admission to the ecstatic after-life of angels and gossamer clouds of beauteous immortality. Obsessive about sexual purity and utterly blind to sins like vanity, materialism, selfishness, militarism, gun fetishes, and so on, many of the leaders of the movement inevitably succumb to sexual scandals and material corruption.

I think of Wim Wenders exquisite film “Wings of Desire” in which an angel, after watching humans live out their joys and sorrows and regrets and passions, longs to become mortal and live in the world, and have a smoke, and drink coffee, listen to music, and go to the circus, and feel desire for someone beautiful.