The Sad Way of All Medical Dramas: The Pitt (Season 2) Descends into Soap

The surest sign that a medical drama has descended into the depths of  television vulgarity is when one of the patients is a relative or close friend of one of the doctors.  Mel King’s sister is admitted.  Why the hell do we suddenly have patients with close relationships with the doctors? Then another: an old friend of Robanovitch’s.  Then another.   It is a tip-off that more obscenity is to come.

The inevitable second bad sign: characters start treating other characters like family.   Robinavitch is planning a sabbatical on a motorcycle and nurses and doctors nag him about safety in a way that feels like a projection of the perceived audience’s feelings about Robinavitch.  Not the audience I like– but the mass audience out there now dropping in to see “The Pitt” because of all the acclaim.  Other characters are beginning to offer advice and uncomfortably intimate expressions of concern for each other.  The proverbial “television family”.  We project our feelings of warmth and trust upon these avatars of our own narcissism.

And the third, most fatal sign: the doctors start treating each other.

“The Pitt” started out well.  Very well.   It was the averred intent of the program to focus on the action in the ER of a major hospital, and season one did so, and it was scintillating.  Fresh.  Shocking at times.  Frank.  We all know where medical drama’s usually go: to dreck and soap but  “The Pitt” was going to be different.  It was going to be rich with texture and depth and insight.  It actually asserted that it was NOT going go the way of “ER” and “St. Elsewhere” (which also started out well), or “Grey’s Anatomy” or– horrors!– “House” (probably the drama of this bunch with the highest ratio of narcissistic piety).

Season 2 started out okay– more shocking scenes and some texture and depth.  Until.  Until we realized– about episode 11– that Noah Wyle (a producer) was mugging for an Emmy.  Until we started getting long heart-to-heart conversations between the regulars while patients are shown waiting for one of the damn doctors to actually come and treat them.  Until we are treated to mawkish displays of characters “caring too much”, getting all self-righteous and pious about defending “my nurses”, or standing up to ICE, or planning to deprive an elderly couple of their independence after a very brief interaction with them about a minor injury: oh how smug and insular that little episode was!

A patient attacks a nurse and Charge Nurse Dana Evans, armed, apparently, with some kind of powerful sedative, Versed, (which she just happened to have in her pocket), jumps him and knocks him out, and everybody is just kind of isn’t that adorable that she is so protective of her charges even after we find out that the patient was on a bad drug trip.  The repellent aspect of this sequence is the way the show manipulates the viewer into seeing Evans as a hero by having the patient later curse and swear at the doctors.  It’s a cheap trick.  It would have been far more interesting if he had been shown to be somewhat appalled at himself and perhaps remorseful at learning he would be charged.  But the then the audience wouldn’t have been able to congratulate themselves for siding with the virtuous Evans, whom we are given to understand is “feisty” and smart– and, of course “cares too much”–  which is a way of allowing a character to behave in ways that we would otherwise would find annoying or offensive or illegal.

Incidentally, have you ever been in an Emergency Room at a major hospital?  How often would you hear doctors or nurses saying “fuck this” or “fuck that”?  And why do almost all the characters do it when, in real life, a good portion of any group do not?  It makes all the characters begin to sound alike, dulling the interesting diversity in this group in the first season.

The real reason they do it?  Actors love it: it’s a badge of “authenticity” and grit.  Actors rarely offer to be the character that provides realistic balance to the array of personalities in the story.

And the problem with introducing more and more patients who are directly related to the doctors?  We see Duke, a dear, witty, bearded friend of Robinavitch come in for a sore throat.  I was puzzled as to why he was admitted.  With a sore throat?  But he languishes in a room for a long, long, long time while Robinavitch carries on various conversations and drops in on other patients and lectures this resident or that and kvetches over paperwork.  One wonders why the hell he doesn’t go take care of his patient. Someone wants us to believe that none of the other doctors  in the ER can handle the various issues that arise.  Seriously?  Our world is on the brink of disaster, if this is true.  It’s not.

We wonder why Robinavitch, who had been shown to be a patient, caring Chief Attending Physician in Season 1, is suddenly short-tempered, intolerant, and  irrational.  And then we realize where we are heading:  to the most predictable  marshland of TV Drama cliche:  Robinavitch is going to get some therapy to deal with his trauma goblins.  He’s not a prick!  Oh, no: he’s got trauma!  He’s going to cry and break down!  He will seek therapy because even an amazing charge physician like Robinavitch is not qualified to deal with his “issues” all by himself.   He needs a credentialed therapist!  He will find healing and love. And I will mentally puke with disgust and curse the TV gods for taking another promising drama and turning it into wretched dreck.  And curse the vanity of actors/producers who shamelessly promote themselves by providing  the story with exhibitionist scenes of wildly extravagant emotional breakdowns at the expense of dramatic integrity.

In another episode, or the same one, a different hospital that was hacked pays the ransom to get back on line.  That’s realistic but it would have been nice to have an acknowledgment of the problem: paying off ransomware hackers encourages more ransomware.  The script should have acknowledged that issue.

In the new world of the second season of “The Pitt”, we enter the realm of affirmations and therapy and the fantasy of nurses and doctors who always find time to have emotional conversations in the middle of an ER we have been led to believe is frenetic with urgent medical emergencies. Unfortunately, S02E14 descends even further, with the preposterous sequence in which Dr.  Langdon redeems himself in Robinavitch’s eyes by performing a near miraculous procedure, a “closed reduction of facet joint” on a traffic accident victim.  Seriously?  And we’re not back in the worst traditions of the medical drama?  (We are).

And Robinavitch will not be the only doctor to take the path of TV therapy (in which the only cure for emotional distress is to uncover the “trauma” that caused it — because it is always caused by trauma, and not by deficiencies or weakness of character):  Dr. Al-Hashimi must reveal to Robinavitch– whom she has known for exactly one day– her own past trauma (involving an ailment) which, again, is offered as an excuse for emotional distress, lavished on the viewer while patients continue to mob the ER. What a pity.  Robinavitch has become a bore.

This episode, written by Noah Wyle himself, appears to credit the claims of some critics that Wyle is pandering for an Emmy.  Now it’s all about him and how he just cares so damn much that can’t bear to even leave on his sabbatical because– we are given to believe– nobody else can run the ER like him.  This is obviously bullshit.  If it were true, the ER could never survive since he can’t possibly be there all the time, and there is nothing remarkable about the day being dramatized that would not be remarkable about any day in the ER. We are further encouraged to believe that Wyle is heroic and beloved for his dedication when any self-respecting physician would actually likely get royally pissed off at him interceding in every case like an overbearing nanny.  “I only do it because I want the best.”

Even worse, we have a doctor who has been on his feet racing around for 15 hours straight: in TV land, everything goes right and he saves lives.  In real life, you make mistakes when you are exhausted and can’t resist taking a shortcut here or there and someone in some lawsuit is going to point out that it is a fucking bad idea to work 15 hours straight. The dynamic of other physicians expressing concern about his health makes me cringe.  He is their boss and the creative team behind these episodes seem clueless about the psychological dynamics of boss-staff relations.  When they question his well-being, they are questioning his competence.  People in the position of Robinavitch would take umbrage in real life.

I am reminded of the decline in “West Wing” when suddenly Leo was hectoring President Bartlett about his behavior and policies.  It was stupid.  No President would put up with it for a second.

What would have improved these episodes immeasurably would have been a creditable character ridiculing Robinavitch and pointing out how his obsessive enmeshment with all of the decisions being made is not the product of virtuous professionalism but of narcissism.

Episode 15: well, there it is.  It’s now the Noah Wyle show.  Pity the rest of the cast who now get the delicious opportunity to deliver five or six lines in a one hour program, because all the rest of the screen time is now occupied by Robinavitch’s kvetching about maybe not wanting to come back after his sabbatical.  Then it really takes the plunge: he hints about considering suicide.

Because, well, he just cares too damn much!

It’s preposterous.  “The Pitt” hasn’t laid the groundwork for that kind of epochal development.  They want Robinavitch to be a saint who insists on interceding with every other ER physician’s process and can’t leave even when he’s exhausted and doesn’t think anyone can match his level of genius and leadership, and then they suddenly want him to be broken and considering suicide?  It’s a gratuitous and banal twist in his character and almost certainly the product of the actor Wyle having control over the script and direction.

The scene of the day-staff on the roof watching fireworks while “America the Beautiful” plays was gauche; just restrained enough to avoid being called “gauche” but not elegant enough to not be gauche.

If this is where “The Pitt” is headed, I will not be back, 

60 Minutes Flubs a Story

I am a fan of CBS’s “60 Minutes”, an enduring, credible, rational, program of pretty good journalism.  Most of the time.  CBS, like the New York Times, can occasionally fear for the establishment and slant stories just slightly to favor what they think is the “responsible” angle.  They also tend to salivate over celebrities and athletes in an unseemly manner, but, heck, who doesn’t nowadays?  Will they ever do a story on Autotune?  I doubt it; most of the artists they admire use it on all their recordings.  They will definitely do a flattering profile of Taylor Swift who fits beautifully into their enlightened mildly progressive politics, but they will be discernibly frightened of Zohran Mamdani.

They embody the Woody Allen joke (in “Bananas”): “it’s okay to be different; but not too different”.

They recently provided a story about “Havana Syndrome”, the mysterious anomalous series of illness and disabilities experienced first by embassy staff in Havana, Cuba, and then by people all around the world.  Headaches,  balance problems, dizziness, insomnia, and so on.  The diplomats and staff experiencing these issues sometimes associated them with an odd environmental sounds which some began to suspect were being deliberately made by the Cubans or Russians.

A number of very credible organizations have investigated and none were able to establish a cause, and many came to the conclusion that the symptoms were the result of pre-existing conditions, other environmental factors, or– dare we say it (because the official bodies won’t use the word):  hypochondria.

How about “mass psychogenic illness”.  How about “moral panic”.

“60 Minutes”, to my surprise, found “some evidence” of some kind of sonic weapon that might exist.  It was hard to figure out what evidence “60 Minutes” actually had because they repeated “three anonymous sources”, as if three of nothing makes three.  No one really critical to this story is on the record.  Normally, I think that means you don’t have a story, but I think Scott Pelle was moved by sympathy for some of the “victims” of Havana Syndrome and I think he wanted to believe in it.

I am surprised he omitted any reference to the fact that the U.S. is also researching building sonic ultra-wave weapons.  That is confirmable.

If you want to believe in Havana Syndrome, read this (Wikipedia) or this (NIH).

The Legendary Trump

Dear Donald,

Do you really want to go down in history as a great president? Your face on Mount Rushmore? A legend? A game-changer? Someone who made a lasting impact on almost every citizen?

You’ll never be remembered for stealing Greenland or bluffing Iran or enabling Putin and Netanyahu. Nobody will love your chaos in Democrat-led cities. Melania’s biopic will never win an Oscar. Your ugly gold-leaf decorations will be removed by the next administration before they even take office. History will record that inflation was already declining before you were inaugurated and hasn’t much declined since. Your crypto currency will collapse into Ponzi inertia.

Here it is: pass a national single-payer universal health care program. Cut out the insurance companies. Set standardized rates for procedures and hospital care. Tax the billionaires and the oil companies to help pay for it.

You are the only politician in America that can do it. The Democrats can’t possibly rally enough bipartisan support to even extend Obamacare. You can do it: rally the MAGAverse to your side, threaten the stubborn Senators and Representatives into compliance, primary the resisters, and give Schumer a hug. If the Supreme Court challenges you, threaten to expand it and stock it with compliant yes-men or Democrats like Elizabeth Warren.

The evangelicals will eventually support it because it is one of the best political expressions of “family values”, and, contrary to most conservative politics, actually does seem “Christian”.

There will be lots of opposition at first but you know how to bully them aside. In ten years, a large majority of people will wonder how they ever got by without it. How could we have been the only developed nation that didn’t have it for so long? Who was this genius who gave it to us? Yes, Donald J. Trump!

You’ll be remembered forever, like Franklin Roosevelt, like Eisenhower, like Lincoln.

You’re welcome.

Canadian vs U. S. Health Care

Someone, an American friend of a friend, commented on Facebook:

Some Americans think that the Canadian care is inferior. What I have heard is that there are longer waiting periods. Also, I have heard that Canadians come to the states for more timely service or even better service, i.e. our doctors are better. I don’t know if any of this is true, but one thing I know to be true: we have plenty medical bankruptcies, and you have none.

If the first part was true, generally, then U. S. life expectancy and infant mortality would be a lot better than it is. I am sure that any individual’s experience will vary– there are good and less than good doctors in both countries. There are definitely areas of the U.S. that have lost their hospitals and have challenges finding family medicine practitioners, as in Canada. Canadian hospitals and physicians are generally as competent as their U. S. counterparts. But the difference in the catastrophic impact on personal finance is absolutely astounding. Europeans and Canadians alike just find it shocking that America refuses to adopt universal health care because the advantages we see every day are so, so significant.

The U. S. pays twice as much for the same procedures as we do in Canada. The U. S. system by it’s own principles is supposed to result in more efficient, cost-effective care: it does the opposite. The administrative overhead is colossal, compared to Canada’s far more efficient system.

I have often considered that if the American system resulted in more competition, for price and quality, and resulted in lower costs and better care (for all– not just the rich), it worth considering seriously as an alternative. But in that respect, it has failed.

King’s Park Psychiatric Center

About this institution.

King’s Park Psychiatric Centre was a complex of dozens of buildings intended to house individuals with mental problems. It operated from 1885 to 1996.  At its peak, there were close to 10,000 patients.

The remains of the buildings are haunting.

The intent was good.  Of course.  The idea was to provide a healthy environment for these patients to live in, where they could work on farms and workshops and be fed and housed at state expense.

We are told that governments came to believe this was not a good way to deal with mental patients and the population of Kings Park was reduced through drug therapies, transfers to other institutions, and simple release.  I have read that many of these patients ended up homeless, but I don’t see any clear documentation about the disposition of the thousands of patients.  But they are all gone and the buildings have been abandoned for about 30 years.  Some of them were demolished. Some of them had asbestos in them complicating the idea of recycling the structures.  The remaining buildings are decaying.  There is a lot of graffiti.  People break into the buildings to take photos and videos.

There is something about the ruins that fascinates people.

Repealing Obamacare

It may not matter much in a real election with real people who watch reality TV, believe they are getting a good deal with the Super Jumbo Sized Soft Drink, and hope to win the lottery some day, but the question in mind, for the coming Congressional elections in the fall, is this: which parts of Obamacare are you going to repeal?

I don’t know how most Republican candidates will answer that. They won’t want to. They will not want to go on the record declaring that they will take away insurance for the 5 or 10 million people who now have it who did not have it before. They certainly will try to make it sound like they have a better alternative but even Fox News might occasionally ask a question: what? The answer will be magical thinking: we will find imaginary efficiencies that will produce imaginary care and provide imaginary cost savings for an imaginary future. But, hey, have you seen my new, larger flag lapel pin?

As polls have shown, if you ask the average American if he likes Obamacare, only about 45% say yes. But if you ask them if people should be dropped from their insurance coverage because they develop a serious, expensive illness, or should be denied coverage because they had an illness previously, or if children should be dropped from their parents’ insurance while they are in college or university, a large majority say no. Can the Democrats run on that paradox? If I were a campaign advisor, I’d suggest they start early and hammer their Republican opponents with that question: which provisions of Obamacare will you repeal?

 

An Epidemic of Diagnoses

You have to distinguish between an epidemic of diagnoses and an epidemic of allergies. Dr. Nicholas Christakis

A recent story out of Sacramento describes the tragedy of the death of Natalie Giorgi, a 13-year-old girl who was allergic to peanuts and inadvertently swallowed a bite of a Rice Krispies square that had “peanut products” in it. Her parents had two EPI-Pens, used them both, then used a third from the camp where their daughter had been staying. Natalie’s father, a physician, couldn’t save her, and neither could the EMS team that arrived by helicopter.

Now the Giorgi’s have gone public because they want to convince a skeptical public that food allergies are real and pose a real threat to public health and safety. They believe most people aren’t already hysterical enough about food allergies. We need to ramp it up.

Now, I don’t know where the Giorgis stand on gun control, or drunk driving, or lightening, but, if we, as a society, were to respond intelligently to genuine threats to health and safety, we might be better off channeling our energies into more productive causes.

Even worse, the remedies proposed most often– declaring schools “peanut free”, for example– may actually be having the opposite effect. In Israel, where peanuts are a popular snack, the rate of peanut allergies among children is about 0.17%. In Britain, where peanuts are less popular, the allergy rate is 2%.

About 150 people die every year in the U.S. due to an allergic reaction. About half are due to peanuts. That’s slightly more than the number of people who die from lightening strikes.

Be it noted: there is a lot of misplaced faith placed in Epi-Pens.

The Brutality of the American Health Care System

According to a New York Times article [2013-08-03], Michael Shopenn, a man living in Boulder, Colorado, needed a new hip and obtained a rock-bottom price of $13,000 through friends with connections in the industry. Then he tried to arrange the operation at a local hospital: they quoted him $65,000.

That is an unspeakable obscenity.

He chose, instead, to fly to Belgium and have it done in a private hospital there for $13,660. That price included the air fare, surgery, five days in a hospital bed, physical therapy, and the hip itself. The hip came from the same company that offered it to him for that rock bottom $13,000 in the U.S.

How is that possible? America is the greatest country in the universe. All Europeans are lazy, corrupt, and I forget the third one. The American health care system relies on good old capitalism and free market competition to drive prices down give Americans the cheapest health care in the world. The New York Times is lying.

What is the bigger obscenity? That large numbers of Americans continue to believe it, or that doctors and hospital administrators continue to believe that they are good, decent people, with ethics and morals and principles, who do their best to “help” people like Michael Shopenn. They are not like drug dealers, bank robbers, or, God help us, bankers. No, they work very, very hard and deserve to completely ruin your life. Shopenn’s example is a trifling one. I know of cancer patients who were charged $20,000 a day to stay in the hospital after breast surgery.

There is no country in the world where a health care system that charges these rates is sustainable. It is a system designed to deceive Americans into thinking that if they work hard, improve their skills, show up on time, and manage their money wisely, they will be able to retire when they get old.

No, you can’t. You will be robbed of every cent by hospitals and doctors who are unconstrained by morals or laws or regulations. They can charge whatever they want and they do.

The actual cost of manufacturing that hip: about $350. I’m not making this up. And Shopenn was quoted a bargain: many patients pay up to $50,000 or $60,000 for it. Why? Because every agency that handles or distributes or installs the artificial hip takes a huge cut, including the hospital.

There was a time when a man who charged you $13,000 for a device that cost $300 to make was committing “extortion”. I don’t believe for one second that it is not still extortion, and criminal.

But why the hell is the hospital marking up the cost? Why the hell is a hospital in the business of making a profit from a medical device?

Oh. This is America. Cue the anthem. Wave the flag. Get the marching band. Let’s remind the world that we are the greatest country in the universe and anyone who thinks otherwise should go live in North Korea!

It’s the American medical industry that behaves like North Korea. Hospitals are forced by secret agreements to not disclose the price they paid for devices like artificial hips because it would …. er… create competition among the manufacturers. And this is allowed in a Republic that claims to operate on the basic of market competition.

Michael Shopenn didn’t even have to go to India or Indonesia to save money on this operation. He only had to go to Belgium. But the interesting thing about this is that the skills required to safely perform this operation are not worth $65,000. They probably aren’t even worth $13,000. The skill set is not like oil or gold or an automatic transmission: it is something that can be taught to any reasonably intelligent, educated young person in most countries in the world.

Now you should not look at society through the lens of class warfare, but if you did, it would look very much like this: in order to get you to work, in order to make the rich rich, they have to offer you this charade of a “good living”, maybe even health insurance (more likely not), and let you invest in a house and in mutual funds so that when you get old you can retire on your savings. That’s the scam. Once you have actually reached that age, they will take all of the money back through medical costs. Breast cancer? Hip replacement? Heart surgery? It doesn’t matter– you will be charged an incredibly obscene amount of money so the rich can get back all of the money they paid you for your work. God forbid your children should inherit it!

What about insurance? Ah, but that is exactly what the Republicans are working on right now! They will tell you that America cannot afford health care, Medicare, Medicaid, or Social Security. You see, we desperately need that money….. to cut taxes for the rich. Oh– and to buy more F-35 fighters and nuclear submarines. And aircraft carriers, even if a drone from China or Russia or North Korea is going to be able to sink one in the next few years.

No, you couldn’t make that up. Nobody would believe it. But it’s right there in the Republican Party platform and re-election campaigns and policy conferences– that is what they intend to do.


The article about the hip replacement.

Hurray for Death Panels: I Mean it!

By the Republicans definition, any attempt to prevent people from choosing expensive but ineffective treatments, is a “death panel”.

It is a tribute to how badly outfoxed on public relations the Democrats have been: the public associates “Death Panels” not with congressmen determined to prevent them from accessing health insurance, at a sustainable cost, but with the Democrats who want to provide it. That is an amazing accomplishment.

As far as I can tell, the Republicans greatest concern about health care is the rising costs. It has been rising, rising, rising for fifty years under the Republican system: private insurance. Did I say the Republicans are concerned about these rising costs? Yes they are. They have a solution. Do nothing. As Ross Douthat in the New York Times admits, the conservative solution to the uncontrolled cost of health care is “modest reforms that would help the hardest-pressed among the uninsured”. Isn’t that inspiring? That covers a multitude of nothings.

As the health care industry expands to meet it’s central dynamic: we are a society that looks at itself in the mirror and says, “we believe life is more valuable than money”. Therefore, if someone’s life needs saving, we will spend as much as necessary to save it. The health care industry understands this. There is no reason why they should ever find cheaper, more efficient treatments: it is contrary to their fundamental interests.

It is not contrary to the real interests of the government and the people they represent to place some reasonable controls over how much should be spent on any particular disease or injury. But it’s something all the parties have to agree on or else one particularly stupid or ruthless party can exploit the fact that most people appear to refuse to believe what they see. An unfortunately large percentage of the population can be led to believe that one party can provide all the health care they want and need without bankrupting the country while cutting taxes.

So I’ll bet more than a few rational Republicans — if any are left– regret the choice of the word “death panels”. Because they have attached the phrase to the idea of limiting the relentless increase in health care costs. Because the potential cost of health care is infinite. The last twenty years of astonishing increases have proven it.

Come on, Democrats! Seize the term and turn it on the Republicans! They are the party that doesn’t want you to have affordable health insurance. They are the party of war, of unregulated industry, of tort reform: they are the Drop Dead Party.

The Republican approach will inevitably lead to a system where only the rich can afford proper treatment. By the Republicans definition, any attempt to prevent people from choosing expensive but ineffective treatments, is a “death panel”. Any attempt to limit treatments performed on people who are going to die soon anyway is a “death panel”.

Do you want to be the politician who tries to explain to the American people that too much health care is provided to people in the last few months of their lives, and that this is making the whole system unsustainable?

Here’s the naked truth: what the U.S., and most western countries need or already have, is something the Republicans have labeled as “death panels”.

As Douthat correctly noted, health care costs rise at astronomical rates. New treatments come on board constantly, new drugs, new techniques, and pharmaceuticals and doctors and hospitals charge enormous sums for these goods and services. Unfortunately, all this new technology has had the opposite effect that it had on computers: medical costs have risen steadily. Why? Really, in a nutshell, because people will pay anything to get better. Anything. Whatever it costs. People will sell everything they own to pay for it because nothing you own matters to you if you’re dead. And the medical industry knows it.

There really as an infinite amount of money we can spend on health care. Unconstrained, it will eventually consume most of the financial resources of the entire nation.

The health care industry also knows that people don’t go shopping around the cheapest cancer surgery, to see if they can get a discount. They don’t turn down an incredibly expensive operation just because they also have cancer and failed kidneys and diabetes and a heart condition, because they are 80 years old, or because they are Republican.

With this logic in place, there is no ceiling on medical expenditures, and eventually it will consume more and more and more of the economy, until it breaks. Or until Republicans, having created an unsustainable system, declare that no system is sustainable and announce their new policy for the uninsured: drop dead.

Most other developed countries simply negotiate what they will pay for particular treatments, which treatments will be available, and how much over-all spending will go into health care. What the Republicans call “death panels” are really nothing more than educated people trying to balance needs against resources, and so far it works pretty well in Europe, Australia, and Canada.

I have no problem accepting a system that declares that it will not spend an infinite amount of money on health care. I have no problem believing that we can still have a pretty good system that provides effective essential treatments for almost every illness. I accept that when I am 80 years old and suffering from all the ailments a typical 80 year old suffers from that I will not be a candidate for a kidney or heart transplant.

The only way to have a sustainable and effective health care system is with death panels.


The essence of the American debate was captured for once and always in this exchange:

Someone reportedly told Inglis, “Keep your government hands off my Medicare.”

“I had to politely explain that, ‘Actually, sir, your health care is being provided by the government,'” Inglis told the Post. “But he wasn’t having any of it.”  Huffington Post

Acronym Syndrome

A year or so ago, Stockwell Day (a Conservative cabinet minister, in case you’ve forgotten) was defending a number of initiatives by the Harper Government to “strengthen” the criminal justice system. By “strengthen”, he meant “make people suffer more”. When a reporter asked what the reason for this was, considering that the crime rate was actually in decline, Day famously replied that “unreported crime” was on the increase.

I think Day should have set up a website first. “UnreportedCrimes.ca”. Then people could report their unreported crimes and we would have a better idea of the scale of the problem. He should have invented an acronym for it — UCD for “Unreported Crimes Disorder”. He would have sounded more authoritative if he had said, “of course, UCD is way up over last year, and URPCA is also on the increase. (Under Reported Perception of Criminal Activity). He might have added that if a citizen sees any activity take place which is not clearly a known legal activity then it should be treated as an unreported crime. And reported.

The problem is, if he had done this tens years ago, the numbers would still have declined. Because, after all, the rate of crime really is down, if you look at actual facts, so the amount of reported unreported crimes would also likely have declined. Do you see the problem?

Similarly, or not, there is a website for “The Invisible Disabilities Association of Canada”. It’s about two particular “syndromes”– I don’t know what to call it exactly– myofascial and fibromyalgia. Your first clue: myofascial is not in the dictionary. That is because it is not a real word. It is a made-up word.  That means it was just discovered– or just invented.

Now before I go any further, I want to make it clear that I believe it is quite possible that some people in this world, particularly in the affluent developed countries, really do suffer from tiredness, sore muscles, aches, and pains. In fact, it is quite possible that all of us do, to some extent. In fact, it is quite possible that life, in general, sucks. I’m not being flippant– life generally sucks. You make the best of it if you can, but it sucks.

I don’t care about that. I do care about bad science and irrationality, because those things lead to trouble.

So when this website informs me that fibromyalgia is diagnosed when “other illnesses and conditions are ruled out”, I am astounded. Let’s say you meet a person. Are you French? No. Are you British? No. Then you must be Chinese.

Fibromyalgia, we are informed, affects either the upper half of the body, or the bottom half, and can affect the right side or the left side. I am not making this up– check out the website.  [The website is out of business.]

Fibromyalgia consists of general aches and pains and tiredness. That’s good– because if it only affected specific parts of the body in a specific way, you would know when you didn’t have it.

Now, I have no idea how you would know if your aches and pains and tiredness are a syndrome or if they are just aches and pains and tiredness, or if your life sucks and you hate making the effort and you just want to veg out on the couch and you don’t have the courage to get out there and engage the world…. I don’t know. Nobody will ever know.

According to the website:

Generally people with Fibromyalgia state that they hurt all over, especially in the parts that are used the most. Stiffness, especially on waking, sleep disorders, irritable bowel syndrome (see separate sheet), irritable bladder syndrome, premenstrual syndrome, restless leg syndrome, headaches (especially migraines and tension headaches) (see separate sheet), muscle spasms, cold intolerance, TMJ, cognitive difficulties, numbness and tingling in the extremities are some of the symptoms. Other common symptoms include a decreased sense of energy, disturbances of sleep, and varying degrees of anxiety and depression related to patients’ changed physical status.

“Irritable bladder syndrome”? “Numbness and tingling”? “Cold intolerance”?.

Think about how it sounds if you say “I am cold”. Now say, “I have cold intolerance”. Different effect, isn’t it? Now try: “I have cold intolerance syndrome”. I will rush out and get you a blanket.

All of it sounds like the normal wane and flow of everyday physical life. It gets cold, it gets hot. If you move, you use energy, and if you use energy you feel tired, and if you feel tired you want to sleep, and if you feel restless, you have “restless leg syndrome”.

Why? Because a label is a label. Why did you stop going to work? Why do you sit on a couch all day watching TV and eating potato chips? Why are you fat?

If you think you have fibromyalgia, I’m not saying your symptoms are not real. I’m saying that you don’t have something that is left over if nothing else can be diagnosed. I’m saying that you have no way of knowing how tough it is supposed to be to get up in the morning or to get out of the house and engage with the world. You say, I don’t know how real your symptoms are. You don’t know how real my symptoms are. Neither of us knows where the line is between attitude and illness, but I know that any illness that can affect the upper half of the body, or the lower half of the body, or the right side, or the left side, and fails to produce any empirical manifestations, hasn’t earned the right to an acronym.

Your last refuge: you don’t know what it’s like to not want to make the effort. And I admit that we have something pure there.


Of course there is an acronym. Developing an acronym for mythical conditions is essential to selling these conditions to the public. So fibromyalgia becomes “FMS”. I think it is believed that the general public will be more easily convinced of the reality of any condition if it has an acronym, especially if it has the word “disorder” in it.

PTSD. SARS. ADHT. TMJ. MPS.