Paul Kalanithi – When Breath Becomes Something

I recently read the memoir by the late Paul Kalanithi called “When Breath Becomes Air” (a title which, even after finishing the book, doesn’t resonate with me).

Paul Kalanithi was a brilliant neurosurgeon who died in March 2015 shortly after graduating from residency and having not quite finished his memoir.  People recommended the book to me, though, as is often the case, they mostly did not give me much of an idea of the taste or texture of it.

I read it.  It can be compelling, as most medical dramas are, when he tells us about several patients and their afflictions, and some peculiar cases, like one in which brain damage created a condition in which a patient could only express himself with numbers, and tried very hard to tell something important to Kalanithi but could only blurt our a seemingly random group of digits.  Yes, medical dramas are compelling, but they are also a dime a dozen– though Kalanithi is a very good writer.  He draws on literature and philosophy and that enriches his narrative to a point.

Kalanithi spends considerable portions of the book describing his search for meaning, in philosophy and literature and neuroscience.  This part sounds a bit schematic, even sophomoric at times.  I don’t sense a real struggle.  I sense someone rationally processing possible theoretical frameworks for understanding life, comparing a few possible options, and then settling for the rather orthodox view that someone must have created reality so there must be a god and if you don’t believe in god your life will be empty.  He doesn’t consider the possibility that the incredible richness of life, of history, of nature, of beauty, or art and music, can itself be profoundly meaningful.  He expects something transcendent– I think– because he’s already settled on god and god is transcendent and a belief that there is no god would be missing that transcendent part that is required.

I found the book more disturbing on another level.  While rhapsodizing about the wonderful benefits of good medical care he gives almost no consideration to the horrible state of the American health care system.  Why would he?  He has great insurance coverage and a prosperous family and he is offered the services of Emma,   “Emma not only was one of the best– a world-renowned oncologist who served as the lung cancer expert on one of the major national cancer advisory boards– but she was also known to be compassionate…”.

Well, how nice for you.  Wouldn’t we all want to have the services of a person like that if we had cancer?  Or to be able to consider flying to Houston or New York or some University somewhere to try to get better treatment than that available locally?

 

The Sad Way of All Medical Dramas: The Pitt (Season 2) Descends into Soap

The surest sign that a medical drama has descended into the depths of  television vulgarity is when one of the patients is a relative or close friend of one of the doctors.  Mel King’s sister is admitted.  Why the hell do we suddenly have patients with close relationships with the doctors? Then another: an old friend of Robanovitch’s.  Then another.   It is a tip-off that more obscenity is to come.

The inevitable second bad sign: characters start treating other characters like family.   Robinavitch is planning a sabbatical on a motorcycle and nurses and doctors nag him about safety in a way that feels like a projection of the perceived audience’s feelings about Robinavitch.  Not the audience I like– but the mass audience out there now dropping in to see “The Pitt” because of all the acclaim.  Other characters are beginning to offer advice and uncomfortably intimate expressions of concern for each other.  The proverbial “television family”.  We project our feelings of warmth and trust upon these avatars of our own narcissism.

And the third, most fatal sign: the doctors start treating each other.

“The Pitt” started out well.  Very well.   It was the averred intent of the program to focus on the action in the ER of a major hospital, and season one did so, and it was scintillating.  Fresh.  Shocking at times.  Frank.  We all know where medical drama’s usually go: to dreck and soap but  “The Pitt” was going to be different.  It was going to be rich with texture and depth and insight.  It actually asserted that it was NOT going go the way of “ER” and “St. Elsewhere” (which also started out well), or “Grey’s Anatomy” or– horrors!– “House” (probably the drama of this bunch with the highest ratio of narcissistic piety).

Season 2 started out okay– more shocking scenes and some texture and depth.  Until.  Until we realized– about episode 11– that Noah Wyle (a producer) was mugging for an Emmy.  Until we started getting long heart-to-heart conversations between the regulars while patients are shown waiting for one of the damn doctors to actually come and treat them.  Until we are treated to mawkish displays of characters “caring too much”, getting all self-righteous and pious about defending “my nurses”, or standing up to ICE, or planning to deprive an elderly couple of their independence after a very brief interaction with them about a minor injury: oh how smug and insular that little episode was!

A patient attacks a nurse and Charge Nurse Dana Evans, armed, apparently, with some kind of powerful sedative, Versed, (which she just happened to have in her pocket), jumps him and knocks him out, and everybody is just kind of isn’t that adorable that she is so protective of her charges even after we find out that the patient was on a bad drug trip.  The repellent aspect of this sequence is the way the show manipulates the viewer into seeing Evans as a hero by having the patient later curse and swear at the doctors.  It’s a cheap trick.  It would have been far more interesting if he had been shown to be somewhat appalled at himself and perhaps remorseful at learning he would be charged.  But the then the audience wouldn’t have been able to congratulate themselves for siding with the virtuous Evans, whom we are given to understand is “feisty” and smart– and, of course “cares too much”–  which is a way of allowing a character to behave in ways that we would otherwise would find annoying or offensive or illegal.

Incidentally, have you ever been in an Emergency Room at a major hospital?  How often would you hear doctors or nurses saying “fuck this” or “fuck that”?  And why do almost all the characters do it when, in real life, a good portion of any group do not?  It makes all the characters begin to sound alike, dulling the interesting diversity in this group in the first season.

The real reason they do it?  Actors love it: it’s a badge of “authenticity” and grit.  Actors rarely offer to be the character that provides realistic balance to the array of personalities in the story.

And the problem with introducing more and more patients who are directly related to the doctors?  We see Duke, a dear, witty, bearded friend of Robinavitch come in for a sore throat.  I was puzzled as to why he was admitted.  With a sore throat?  But he languishes in a room for a long, long, long time while Robinavitch carries on various conversations and drops in on other patients and lectures this resident or that and kvetches over paperwork.  One wonders why the hell he doesn’t go take care of his patient. Someone wants us to believe that none of the other doctors  in the ER can handle the various issues that arise.  Seriously?  Our world is on the brink of disaster, if this is true.  It’s not.

We wonder why Robinavitch, who had been shown to be a patient, caring Chief Attending Physician in Season 1, is suddenly short-tempered, intolerant, and  irrational.  And then we realize where we are heading:  to the most predictable  marshland of TV Drama cliche:  Robinavitch is going to get some therapy to deal with his trauma goblins.  He’s not a prick!  Oh, no: he’s got trauma!  He’s going to cry and break down!  He will seek therapy because even an amazing charge physician like Robinavitch is not qualified to deal with his “issues” all by himself.   He needs a credentialed therapist!  He will find healing and love. And I will mentally puke with disgust and curse the TV gods for taking another promising drama and turning it into wretched dreck.  And curse the vanity of actors/producers who shamelessly promote themselves by providing  the story with exhibitionist scenes of wildly extravagant emotional breakdowns at the expense of dramatic integrity.

In another episode, or the same one, a different hospital that was hacked pays the ransom to get back on line.  That’s realistic but it would have been nice to have an acknowledgment of the problem: paying off ransomware hackers encourages more ransomware.  The script should have acknowledged that issue.

In the new world of the second season of “The Pitt”, we enter the realm of affirmations and therapy and the fantasy of nurses and doctors who always find time to have emotional conversations in the middle of an ER we have been led to believe is frenetic with urgent medical emergencies. Unfortunately, S02E14 descends even further, with the preposterous sequence in which Dr.  Langdon redeems himself in Robinavitch’s eyes by performing a near miraculous procedure, a “closed reduction of facet joint” on a traffic accident victim.  Seriously?  And we’re not back in the worst traditions of the medical drama?  (We are).

And Robinavitch will not be the only doctor to take the path of TV therapy (in which the only cure for emotional distress is to uncover the “trauma” that caused it — because it is always caused by trauma, and not by deficiencies or weakness of character):  Dr. Al-Hashimi must reveal to Robinavitch– whom she has known for exactly one day– her own past trauma (involving an ailment) which, again, is offered as an excuse for emotional distress, lavished on the viewer while patients continue to mob the ER. What a pity.  Robinavitch has become a bore.

This episode, written by Noah Wyle himself, appears to credit the claims of some critics that Wyle is pandering for an Emmy.  Now it’s all about him and how he just cares so damn much that can’t bear to even leave on his sabbatical because– we are given to believe– nobody else can run the ER like him.  This is obviously bullshit.  If it were true, the ER could never survive since he can’t possibly be there all the time, and there is nothing remarkable about the day being dramatized that would not be remarkable about any day in the ER. We are further encouraged to believe that Wyle is heroic and beloved for his dedication when any self-respecting physician would actually likely get royally pissed off at him interceding in every case like an overbearing nanny.  “I only do it because I want the best.”

Even worse, we have a doctor who has been on his feet racing around for 15 hours straight: in TV land, everything goes right and he saves lives.  In real life, you make mistakes when you are exhausted and can’t resist taking a shortcut here or there and someone in some lawsuit is going to point out that it is a fucking bad idea to work 15 hours straight. The dynamic of other physicians expressing concern about his health makes me cringe.  He is their boss and the creative team behind these episodes seem clueless about the psychological dynamics of boss-staff relations.  When they question his well-being, they are questioning his competence.  People in the position of Robinavitch would take umbrage in real life.

I am reminded of the decline in “West Wing” when suddenly Leo was hectoring President Bartlett about his behavior and policies.  It was stupid.  No President would put up with it for a second.

What would have improved these episodes immeasurably would have been a creditable character ridiculing Robinavitch and pointing out how his obsessive enmeshment with all of the decisions being made is not the product of virtuous professionalism but of narcissism.

Episode 15: well, there it is.  It’s now the Noah Wyle show.  Pity the rest of the cast who now get the delicious opportunity to deliver five or six lines in a one hour program, because all the rest of the screen time is now occupied by Robinavitch’s kvetching about maybe not wanting to come back after his sabbatical.  Then it really takes the plunge: he hints about considering suicide.

Because, well, he just cares too damn much!

It’s preposterous.  “The Pitt” hasn’t laid the groundwork for that kind of epochal development.  They want Robinavitch to be a saint who insists on interceding with every other ER physician’s process and can’t leave even when he’s exhausted and doesn’t think anyone can match his level of genius and leadership, and then they suddenly want him to be broken and considering suicide?  It’s a gratuitous and banal twist in his character and almost certainly the product of the actor Wyle having control over the script and direction.

The scene of the day-staff on the roof watching fireworks while “America the Beautiful” plays was gauche; just restrained enough to avoid being called “gauche” but not elegant enough to not be gauche.

If this is where “The Pitt” is headed, I will not be back, 

Death by Discretion

I read an account of a bear attack a while ago that I found somewhat a disturbing.  A young woman camping in a wilderness area of a park in Colorado had been pulled out of her sleeping bag in the middle of the night by a large grizzly and dragged away screaming while a friend of hers nearby, who was also attacked, fled for help.

Help was found and a group of people set out to find the girl, if they could, and scare away the bear, if they could.  The bear did wander off leaving the badly injured girl lying on the ground.  The bear had ripped all of her clothing off and inflicted several life-threatening wounds.

I read the accounts given by some of the rescuers and could not find any reference to any attempt to stop the bleeding, staunch the wounds, apply a tourniquet, or any other first aid.  When recounting the story later, what they all agreed on was that someone  immediately covered her up with a coat.  Others returned to a nearby lodge to find equipment with which to carry her up to the lodge.  After considerable time, she was brought to the lodge and a doctor there treated her wounds but it was too late and she died.

It appeared to me that the rescuers were more concerned with the propriety of looking at a young woman’s naked body than they were with saving her life.  Nobody involved describes even examining her carefully to determine where the wounds were, let alone attempting to stop the bleeding.  It is by no means certain but it seems possible that her life could have been saved if someone had made a serious attempt to staunch the most critical wounds.

It is quite possible that she would have died anyway.

It shouldn’t surprise anyone.  Here’s an account of a man in Japan who admirably attempted to save the life of a woman by applying a defibrillator (an AED or Automated External Defibrillator) only to be labelled a pervert by a bystander.   Now, I personally have wondered for years about how an AED is used– does the skin have to be bare?  A surprising number of people don’t know.  According to the information I found, it must be applied to bare skin, on the chest.

So if, I came across a woman suffering from a serious heart ailment and attempted to apply an AED, would someone watching would be outraged and demand that we all let her die rather than see her naked breasts?

I learned that the AED kit comes with a scissors, and yes, you absolutely should remove any clothing over the chest area, especially the bra (which may have an underwire in it).  

And good luck with that.  I know exactly what you will encounter.  You will encounter some asshole who thinks he’s a god-almighty guardian of public safety and good order and he will forcefully demand that you wait for a nice respectable ambulance to come along and handle the emergency.

I am quite confident that people have died because of people’s delicate sense of decency and that you will never hear about it.


 

The $1,200 Hockey Stick

“Total bill: $42,156.50, covering emergency surgery, scans, laboratory testing, and three hours in a recovery room. His insurer has said it will pay him about $8,184 (7,260.40 in Swiss francs), which is double the procedure’s price in Switzerland. This left him to cover the remaining roughly $34,000.” NPR

Presidential Candidate Tim Scott says America has the greatest healthcare system in the world. Yet this same procedure would cost about 1/7th the price in Switzerland, which is not exactly a backwater. Wait– no, it’s 1/10th (the insurance company voluntarily paid double). This is Switzerland- not Thailand or the Philippines (not that there’s anything deficient about health care in those countries).

If you took anything produced in some other country and gave an American company 10 times what it cost in that country and said see if you can produce one that’s better, well, heck, yeah, I think they probably could. They could certainly equal it. So if an American company could produce, say, a hockey stick for $1,200, I guess they could say it was the greatest hockey stick in the world and they might be right. If you want hockey sticks to cost $1,200.

Does that make the American company “the greatest”? I would argue that if it cost that much to make a hockey stick when everyone else knows how to make one for 1/10 the cost, they might be the worst.

And I’ll bet those sticks would break just as quickly as the $120 Canadian sticks. In terms of health care results, that is demonstrably true (life expectancy in the U.S. is lower than most other developed countries, including Canada).

The most depressing part of the story is the long list of itemized charges on this guy’s bill. It’s like this giant mechanical octopus with 100 arms wrapping itself around you and sucking as much blood out of you as it can. You’ll live, but those suction cup marks will be around for a long time.

Vampires of the Health Care System

The New York Times reports on a woman named Kim Little who had a tiny thread-like spot on her cheek and asked her doctor to check it out. The doctor thought it was harmless but an assistant at her dermatologist’s office thought it might be cancerous. She had a biopsy done: it was indeed cancerous, but it was the kind of cancer that is easily, routinely treated, with complete success. Except that she fell into the hands of the AMERICAN MEDICAL SYSTEM, which seizes those with insurance or money or assets with powerful stainless-steel talons and bleeds them drier than Dick Cheney’s heart.

She went in for treatment. The spot was removed! Success! Except that it wasn’t. All that was required was the removal of the spot and a few stitches. Local anesthesia. And then her grandmother could have stitched her up. Ms. Little told her doctor that she was not concerned about a scar. Tough luck. The doctor who removed the spot refused to do the stitches and sent her over to a specialist in a different building in the same complex. The specialist ordered nurses to prepare the patient to be bled dry: she was undressed and put in a bed and given an IV bag, which undoubtedly cost $600 or so. An anesthesiologist put her under, for $1,000. The plastic surgeon robbed her of $14,000 but left a scar anyway. The hospital fanged her for $8,774.

Now, a vet could very well have performed the entire procedure almost as well– if not better– for a hundred bucks or so. Wait a minute– that’s silly. Really, it should have cost about $50, given the effort and skill required. All right– $75. We’re talking about two or three stitches here on a patient who made it clear she was not concerned about a possible scar.

You’re thinking: you would trust a vet with cancer? On a human being?

I’m thinking: you would trust the three or more medical personnel who charged her thousands of dollars for a medically simple procedure that should not have required more than ten minutes to perform?

Yes, I would trust the vet. Maybe not with liver cancer, or a brain tumor, but with this spot? Yes, I would. Just as I would trust the cancer drugs that cost about 1% of the cost to humans when used on an animal. Same drug.

But dogs don’t carry health insurance.  Maybe that is why treating a dog’s illness is so much more economical than treating a human’s illness.  (On the other hand, the vets seem to be catching on.)

It is interesting that a perfectly competent individual with appropriate training and equipment could easily have performed this procedure just as well as the doctor did. It is in the nature of the American health care system, however, that nobody is going to start a business that performs this service cheaper than hospitals. Nobody is going to be allowed to train in the specific skills needed without also having to be sucked into an entire program of training which has the desired collateral result: complete absorption into this profit-generating system. Even a nurse or doctor who trained in the existing system could never get away with opening a practice that advertises low, low prices.

Why not? What would happen? He or she would not have any customers. The customers come from Health Care Plans, Groups, Employers, Government. They start out with connections to labs and clinics, all of whom refer to each other, and none of whom will refer a patient to a cheap, alternative clinic, if there were any. Ms. Little was undoubtedly presented with numerous forms which entrust the key monetary aspects of her treatment to a blind and unfeeling bureaucracy which then proceeds to bleed her dry and expunge any trace of real accountability from the system.

If she sued, or refused to pay, the system would turn her over to a collection agency, which is empowered by legislation to annihilate her credit rating, her assets, and, ultimately, her freedom.

Addendum

How is this story different from a story about a man who takes a gun and walks into a corner store and demands money?  You’re the clerk.  You are being robbed.

The difference is that if you didn’t have any money to give the robber, he can’t turn you over to a collection agency to get it.

The difference is that institutional medicine in the United States has developed very sophisticated and culturally rich methods of kicking you in the teeth with documents and forms instead of a gun or a crowbar. The attitude is exactly the same. The greed is the same. The ruthlessness is the same.

Well– wait a minute. I don’t think it is. I think a robber with a gun might actually care if you die during the robbery because he would receive a stiffer sentence if caught.

The doctor and the hospital do not care. They will get paid regardless.

Repealing Obamacare

It may not matter much in a real election with real people who watch reality TV, believe they are getting a good deal with the Super Jumbo Sized Soft Drink, and hope to win the lottery some day, but the question in mind, for the coming Congressional elections in the fall, is this: which parts of Obamacare are you going to repeal?

I don’t know how most Republican candidates will answer that. They won’t want to. They will not want to go on the record declaring that they will take away insurance for the 5 or 10 million people who now have it who did not have it before. They certainly will try to make it sound like they have a better alternative but even Fox News might occasionally ask a question: what? The answer will be magical thinking: we will find imaginary efficiencies that will produce imaginary care and provide imaginary cost savings for an imaginary future. But, hey, have you seen my new, larger flag lapel pin?

As polls have shown, if you ask the average American if he likes Obamacare, only about 45% say yes. But if you ask them if people should be dropped from their insurance coverage because they develop a serious, expensive illness, or should be denied coverage because they had an illness previously, or if children should be dropped from their parents’ insurance while they are in college or university, a large majority say no. Can the Democrats run on that paradox? If I were a campaign advisor, I’d suggest they start early and hammer their Republican opponents with that question: which provisions of Obamacare will you repeal?

 

A Parable of How America got Obamacare

You want to go on a trip. You think Hawaii would be great. It’s beautiful and sunny and warm. Lots of people go there.

Your wife says no, no, no, it’s too expensive, and you’ll never get a hotel room. You say, I need a vacation. She says, you do not. Vacations are stupid.

Finally she says, okay, you need a vacation? Let’s go to Alaska. I really want to go to Alaska. I LOVE Alaska.

You book your trip to Alaska, really glad that she finally agreed.  You really didn’t want to go to Alaska, but you compromised, like a good husband.  You put up the money, which is non-refundable, and anticipate your trip.

Then she leaves you.

You go to Alaska by yourself. You think, so what if that b—- left me! I’m gonna have a good time.

Your ship gets locked into the ice and starts to sink. You tell the Captain, are you kidding me?!

He says, what kind of idiot would book a trip to Alaska anyway?

And that is how America got Obamacare.

An Epidemic of Diagnoses

You have to distinguish between an epidemic of diagnoses and an epidemic of allergies. Dr. Nicholas Christakis

A recent story out of Sacramento describes the tragedy of the death of Natalie Giorgi, a 13-year-old girl who was allergic to peanuts and inadvertently swallowed a bite of a Rice Krispies square that had “peanut products” in it. Her parents had two EPI-Pens, used them both, then used a third from the camp where their daughter had been staying. Natalie’s father, a physician, couldn’t save her, and neither could the EMS team that arrived by helicopter.

Now the Giorgi’s have gone public because they want to convince a skeptical public that food allergies are real and pose a real threat to public health and safety. They believe most people aren’t already hysterical enough about food allergies. We need to ramp it up.

Now, I don’t know where the Giorgis stand on gun control, or drunk driving, or lightening, but, if we, as a society, were to respond intelligently to genuine threats to health and safety, we might be better off channeling our energies into more productive causes.

Even worse, the remedies proposed most often– declaring schools “peanut free”, for example– may actually be having the opposite effect. In Israel, where peanuts are a popular snack, the rate of peanut allergies among children is about 0.17%. In Britain, where peanuts are less popular, the allergy rate is 2%.

About 150 people die every year in the U.S. due to an allergic reaction. About half are due to peanuts. That’s slightly more than the number of people who die from lightening strikes.

Be it noted: there is a lot of misplaced faith placed in Epi-Pens.

The Disappointment of Free Enterprise Healthcare

What an unfortunate result! The Americans, alone in the Western World, decided to boldly embrace an alternative model of health care: free enterprise. There is no government plan, and very little government regulation. In theory, we were told, this would reduce the costs of health care because competition among doctors and hospitals would drive costs down.

It has had the opposite effect. The U.S. has the most expensive health care system in the Western World, and the worst results.

I am genuinely disappointed.  Look at the computer industry, and related technologies:  the bang for your buck has grown astronomically since the first PCs entered the market in 1981.  Today, you get fabulous technology, lavish memory, incredible capabilities, for a fraction of the cost.

Medical care, on the other hand, is absolutely through the roof.

It is also, to be fair, more effective– look at cancer deaths.

Doctors and hospitals, of course, don’t compete.  Just imagine if you had to take your broken computer somewhere and nobody would tell you what it was going to cost to repair, and may not even tell you what repairs are going to be done.  You will get a bill for $40,000.

No Historians

There are seven members of the conservative bloc on the board, but they are often joined by one of the other three Republicans on crucial votes. There were no historians, sociologists or economists consulted at the meetings, though some members of the conservative bloc held themselves out as experts on certain topics.

NY Times, March 12, 2010.

This is the Texas Board of Education making decisions about text books for millions of students. This is an important decision: these men are entrusted with a serious responsibility. What should our children study in school? How will their perspectives on life be shaped for years to come? How should their education as citizens be guided?

Well, whatever we do, let’s not get an expert on any of the subject areas were are establishing guidelines for. Heavens no.

I wonder if any citizens of Texas realize how close they have come to the 18th century? The only things missing are signs and wonders. Then I wonder if any of them care about how the state is perceived by outsiders. Well, we know the true believers in this movement certainly don’t care. The question is, does Mr. & Mrs. Mainstream care, as they travel through Europe, and identify themselves, and watch people nod and go, “Oh, you’re from there.” Tell me, have you seen any flying saucers lately? Mr. And Mrs. Mainstream reply, “no. Have you tried to open a business lately. Notice how many restrictions there are? How many permits you need? How long it takes to get approvals from the various bureaucracies?”

And the European says, “and how’s your health care?”