Free Enterprise is For Suckers

I guess I need some basic economic lessons again. Not sure I understand “free enterprise”. When a single mother with five children gets a small amount of money from the government, it’s a handout and builds an unhealthy dependency. When a extremely profitable multi-billion dollar corporation gets $1.2 billion in government handouts, it’s an “investment”.  Bombardier and Chrysler accepted billions in government “investment”, money that went to wealthy shareholders and top executives.  Most, if not all, of that money will never be repaid.  In fact, Bombardier just completely torpedoed the one semi-legitimate argument for that investment by laying off 5,000 workers.

Amazon and Foxconn have received even more lavish deals from the U.S. government, as does every major sports franchise in America.   As does every major defense contractor– these are for-profit companies, you know– not state-owned enterprises.   They don’t just sell their weapons to the United States.

So that single mom should just incorporate herself and ask for an “investment”.  She just needs better pr. She should maybe hold a competition among cities: who wants to get my “headquarters”.

As Charlie Chaplin said in “Monsieur Verdoux”– truly one of the most non-conformist films ever made– , about serial killers vs. generals: “numbers sanctify”.

Why we go on Failing

This Sad Story

Prostitution is illegal.  It is a sex act between two consenting adults for which one of them is paid a sum of money by the other.

Why is it illegal?  Because our society decided long ago that there was a moral– and physical– harm caused by the activity.  As opposed to, say, polluting drinking water, spewing carbon emissions into the air, or being Mitch McConnell.

The truth is, there was never a great reason to make prostitution illegal, at least, not insofar as it is an act between two consenting adults in which money changes hands.  Who is unwillingly harmed?  If you argue that society is, that it is debased by the existence of this transaction, that families are undermined and morality declines, you are making a religious argument.  It shouldn’t stand up in court.  We know that.  Yet almost no politician in North America has the guts to say the obvious:  prostitution will always be with us and we should legalize it and develop the infrastructure needed to keep sex-workers safe from violence and abuse and exploitation, and their customers safe from disease.

There has been progress.  We seem to be leaning more towards treating the prostitutes as social cases rather than criminals, but we still arrest them, like Sisi, and haul them off into court and force them into the dark shadows of dangerous streets and alley-ways, and tiny apartments that charge excessive rents managed by people with no legal or discernible relationship to the real owners.

We took two steps forward with the more recent tendency to not publicly identify johns so we could enjoy destroying their family lives and careers.  But the feminist and #metoo movements are threatening to go backwards on this issue and some police forces make noises about going after the customers rather than the girls.  But then they go after the girls anyway.

In the meantime, young women like Sisi are abused and ruthlessly exploited at least partly because they forced to keep their positions secret from the very people who could protect them.

[whohit]Why we go on Failing[/whohit]

Khe Sanh

The battle of Khe Sanh is memorialized generously by U.S. military fanboys as an example of courage, determination, military acuity, and patriotism.  These were marines!  These were real men!  They were heroes!

In it’s simplest form, a large group of American boys equipped with every piece of deadly military hardware available at the time flew over to a foreign country half-way around the world, landed in the jungle in the middle of nowhere, set up a base, and then courageously stopped the people who lived there from driving them out.  They fought on behalf of a corrupt, intolerant, dictatorial South Vietnamese government that was unwilling and unable to fight for themselves.

Let us salute the flag and sing the national anthem in respect of the wonders of foreign policy and the wit and wisdom of President Lyndon Johnson!

These were draftees, by the way, not volunteers.  They had no choice.  At the age of 18, these young men became eligible for the draft.  If drafted, they had to go or they would be sent to prison.  They were trained and then flown over to this undeveloped nation half-way around the world and told to fight off the young men who lived there.  Kill them.  Bomb them.  Blow up and burn their villages if necessary.  When you come back, we’ll hold a parade in honor of what you did (it turned out, there were no parades as American journalists didn’t understand the necessity of this war either and told the people).

This video talks about payback for the casualties inflicted on the marines by the Viet Cong and the NVA.  Payback!  As if the NVA had invaded Iowa.  As if the battle of Khe Sanh had had an actual strategic value in the war against communist tyranny.

It ends with some of the marines who fought there revisiting the scene in 2000.

There is a bit of a tone of “fuck the politicians” who sent us, but let’s have great reverence for the soldiers who fought there.  I always feel ambivalent about that.   Yes, they had no choice, really, but without willing combatants and parents and veterans who keep talking about the glories of military service, none of these stupid wars could happen.  They urge us to be proud of our fighting men but it is that pride that lines them up to be slaughtered as a result of idiotic and corrupt politics.

And how brave are you, really, when you are dropped into the circumstances these men were dropped into?  They were fighting to protect their friends and themselves from those unreasonable people who didn’t want them there.

President Lyndon Johnson admitted that he knew the war was lost but couldn’t pull out because the Republicans would have called him yellow.  That’s why your son, your brother, your husband, your father died at Khe Sanh.

 

[whohit]Khe Sanh[/whohit]

 

Kavanaugh’s Witchcraft

One of the more obscure rulings made by Judge Kavanaugh earlier in his career is that the Department of Defense should be allowed to keep secret it’s own studies on the efficacy of lie detector tests.  Kavanaugh ruled that because keeping this information secret could be useful to prosecutors, it should be kept secret.

Presumably, if prosecutors could convince a suspect that the ghost of the alleged victim had fingered him, Kavanaugh is on-board with keeping the fact that ghosts don’t exist a secret from the suspect.

More reasonably, if the prosecutor in a case asserted that fibres found on the body of the victim matched fibres found in the suspect’s closet, the defense should not have the right to ask the prosecutor how they know that the fibres don’t match fibres from anyone else’s closet.   It is possible that you could find those same fibres anywhere you cared to look– there is no science behind it.  Kavanaugh is on-board with keeping this a secret because it would help the prosecutors to keep it a secret.

We know what the secret is: lie detector tests are unreliable.  In short, they lie.  And we know how the police and prosecutors use them.  They have, in the past, and probably still today, lie to suspects about the results of their lie-detector tests.  You lied.  We know it.  You might as well confess.  This, it supposed, will be shattering to the self-confidence of hardened criminals.  The trouble is, it really will be shattering to the self-confidence of innocent but gullible suspects.

It also helps when they ask a suspect to take a lie detector test and the suspect, wisely, refuses.   Why?  What are you hiding?  No innocent man would refuse.

Yes he would, if he was smart.  Because if he passes the test it will not alter the beliefs of the police or the prosecutor, but if he fails the test they will flog him with the results until he confesses.  They will threaten to charge him with the most serious crimes that could be linked in any way to the actual crime, unless he agrees to plead guilty to a lessor offense, providing the police and prosecutors with their scalp.  How many court cases are actually settled outside of the courtroom, with plea-deals like that?  Over 90%.

I was surprised– well, not totally– when Kavanaugh’s accuser, Christine Blasey-Ford, announced that she had taken a lie-detector test on the subject of her attempted rape when she was 15 and Kavanaugh was 17, and passed.  Kavanaugh himself should salute her: smart girl.  There are a lot of suckers out there who will believe that this fact is determinant.  I don’t.

It’s an interesting ruling that indicates just how far Mr. Kavanaugh is willing to go to protect the power and privileges of the nation’s police.  That’s the real reason he should not be confirmed.

 

[whohit]Kavanaugh’s Witchcraft[/whohit]

Kavanaugh

I have an odd feeling on this day, Sunday, September 23, 9:40 p.m., that Brett Kavanaugh may well withdraw from the nomination by the end of this week.

It’s a hunch, yes.  I’m guessing that there must be other allegations out there, someone else with collaborative knowledge, perhaps an acquaintance or friend is just about fed up with the self-righteous bluster.  I’m guess that is true because I’m guessing that Kavanaugh is a liar, particularly after his comment that he did not attend the party that Christine Blasey Ford did not identify.

The correct answer, Mr. Kavanaugh, was “I did attend parties around that time but I never did what Ms. Blasey says I did” or “I never attended any parties that time in my life” or “I don’t remember ever meeting Ms. Blasey Ford at any party I attended”.  The first seems plausible, the second ridiculous, and third makes the most sense, if the accusations are false.

But he said, “I didn’t attend that party”.  It’s not a slam dunk, but it’s damaging, to me.  It’s like a burglar responding to an accusation that he is a burglar saying, “I did not break into that house on Maple Street on Friday.”    Nobody said Maple Street.  Nobody said Friday.

So I suspect the allegation is true, and if it is, I suspect there will be some form of collaboration.  And if there is, there will be a lot of cold political calculations going on in Mitch McConnell’s office.  Do they really want to go into the November elections with this dragging behind them?  Just how pissed off will educated white women be at the Republicans desperate attempts to whitewash the issue?  When McConnell says Kavanaugh will be confirmed (to a gathering of evangelical leaders), he has basically said that Ms. Blasey Ford is a liar.  All while vowing to investigate the charges fully.

And if no collaboration shows up, I’ll concede that Ms. Blasey-Ford’s allegations may well be false.  Nobody who remembers them both being at the same party.  Nobody who remembers similar behavior by Kavanaugh at other parties.  Nobody how heard about the incident at the time.  It may be a false memory, or a blended memory, or a recovered memory– who knows– but false.


I just read this:

After six days of carefully assessing her memories and consulting with her attorney, Ramirez said that she felt confident enough of her recollections to say that she remembers Kavanaugh had exposed himself at a drunken dormitory party, thrust his penis in her face, and caused her to touch it without her consent as she pushed him away.  New Yorker

Well, that’s sort of what I imagined but it sounds a lot like Ms. Ramirez is “recovering” memories, which I think are worthless.  And it comes from an article by Ronan Farrow who is not a reliable source for this kind of story.

 

[whohit]Will Kavanaugh Withdraw?[/whohit]

Brett Kavanaugh

I hope the Democrats don’t make the mistake of trying to prove that Brett Kavanaugh should not be on the Supreme Court because he may have assaulted a young girl 35 years ago in a drunken stupor at a party somewhere when he was 17.

The problem with Kavanaugh is that the Republicans have openly and overtly announced that they are putting a party hack on the Supreme Court.

If you are young, you might be forgiven for not knowing that you are not supposed to do that.  You are supposed to at least pretend that your candidate is neither Republican or Democrat, left or right, Catholic or Atheist or Buddhist.  Your candidate will interpret the LAW as it is laid down in Constitution and it’s amendments.  Both sides used to agree on this.  That’s the why the threat of a filibuster would usually be enough to stop a nominee dead in his or her tracks.  They would still tend to promote candidates that were more congenial to their vision of justice, but they would at least pay lip service to the idea that there should be bipartisan support any candidate about to get a lifetime appointment to the highest court in the land.

In face, it would have been considered shameful if a candidate had been elected without at least some votes from the minority party.

It is remarkable that the Republicans, who would hate real “originalism” if it French-kissed them in the ass, have gotten away with repeatedly claiming that they alone among the political parties want a candidate who does not impose his own views upon government but only defends the intent of the original framers of the constitution– slave-owners and all.  So when the Supreme Court rules that black children have just as much right to an education as white children– where the hell does it say that in the Constitution?  No where.  All right– there was an amendment.   But the amendment doesn’t specify that schools must be equally funded for all races.  So the court–as implied by “originalists”–  is imposing its own views onto the constitution.   When the court rules that corporations are persons who have the right to free speech, along with those who don’t have millions to spend on lawyers and pr firms, well…. wait a minute.  No, that kind of interpretation we like.   When it rules that a corporation does not have to pay back the wages owed to a woman who was paid less than a man for the same work for 20 years, by golly, that’s jurisprudence!  Because nowhere in the constitution does it forbid paying women less than men.

How about this: in 1789, there was no law against abortion for at least the first 15 weeks.

There should be an outcry and Republicans should hold their heads in shame that not a single Democrat seems ready to vote for Mr. Kavanaugh.  They should withdraw the nomination and consult with Democrats to find a candidate at least a dozen or more of them could support.   So that the next time there is a 5-4 decision, at least some voters could feel that the court weighed all the facts, examined the law and the constitution, and came to a fair judgement based on principles of justice and fairness.  Not which party appointed them to the court.

Incidentally, I’m not sure, in the end, that the Democrats would suffer too badly if Kavanaugh is appointed and, even better, does overturn Roe v. Wade.  That would leave it to the states, again, to decide on a women’s right to choose, meaning that state elections will suddenly matter a whole lot more to both sides.  I would bet that a majority– perhaps a slim one– would leave it to a woman to decide what happens to her own body.

 

[whohit]Kavanaugh[/whohit]

The Cowardly New World

China has embarked on an extraordinary program of continuous mass surveillance.

Yes, we are actually beginning to see the realization of George Orwell’s worst nightmare, not just in China, but everywhere.

Here it is.  No surprise, not anymore.  It is actually here.  It happened.  There is, probably, no going back, because, unfortunately, humans are really not very smart.  Would you rather have safety and security or privacy?   You can’t have both.  We believe them when they tell us that.  We invariably choose safety because when it comes right down to it we humans are very, very easily frightened.

Of course it’s a false choice.  We will not be safer if we give up our privacy and we will not not have privacy if we give up our safety.  The question is, how much do you want to give up?  And do you really, truly, seriously trust the government with the level of intrusive surveillance they are going to have?

China is moving faster than we are only because they have a dictatorial government that can do whatever it wants.  Ideologically, are they really all that different?  Their public reasons might sound different, but are they substantively different from “we must protect our citizens from terror” and “law-abiding citizens have nothing to fear”?

They even boast to their citizens that we can watch you all the time.  They scan faces in crowds at train stations and public squares looking for “criminals”, which often means people who dissent.

When we all read “1984” years ago most of us probably thought it would never happen here. Because we all read the book and we were all outraged and we all knew why it would be so bad.  Surely no democratic government would dare impose any practices that evoke visions of “Big Brother”.  But, especially since 9/11, they have gone right ahead and done it.  The U.S. government gave itself the right to examine all of your e-mails and all of your calling records essentially without warrant.  The Obama administration went right ahead and launched drone attacks on enemy targets without any real accountability.  And the hugely disappointing civil libertarian contingent in the U.S. has quietly rolled over in acquiescence.

So when western countries start following China’s lead and begin monitoring us in every public space with face recognition software to identify us and follow us and record our whereabouts at all times, I’m pretty sure the majority of brave, principled, patriotic citizens will cower in terror and comply fully with the new regime.  And we will have arrived at our nightmare.

[whohit]Cowardly New World[/whohit]

The Scream

“The Work” is a searing documentary about a program at Folsom Prison to get men imprisoned for violent crimes to face their deepest anxieties and grievances about their past, their absent fathers, brothers who betrayed them, and so on, in a kind of large psycho-therapy session moderated by social workers and joined by volunteers from the community, and largely led by the inmates themselves.

Filmed in 2009 but not released until 2017. Frighteningly raw at times– and not to everyone’s taste. You can see some of the volunteers hang back, then get drawn into the confessional style confrontations.  Violent fathers.  Absent fathers.  Abusive fathers.  Fathers who expected too much or too little.

Then one of the volunteers reluctantly recounts how his father was disappointed in him for fetching the wrong tool several times, and then sent him into the house. This is transformed by some of the inmates into some kind of traumatic thing that contaminated the volunteer’s relationship with his father, though it seems more likely it was and remained trivial. No, no, you’re concealing a deeper wound.  It must come out.  It was a strange sequence.

Other sequences are more intense, in which a person howls and thrashes his outrage while embraced tightly by the other men. One volunteer, Brian, says something condescending that really aggravates an inmate.  He seems to actually believe he should be automatically respected by these men because he is smart and wise and together.  They hate him.  Later, he calls a native inmate, Dark Cloud, “gentle”, which he misinterprets as an insult.  Dark Cloud lunges at him, prevented by the other inmates.  Just how suitable was Brian for the experience?  Didn’t they screen?

At times, searingly compelling. It is claimed that none of 40 men who went through the program returned to prison. I remain skeptical. I see some of this kind of programming as similar to faith healing and charismatic church services, speaking in tongues, and so on. It’s all very dramatic and full of lingo, but is there any real evidence that, 1) all of the experiences related by the participants are real or true, and, 2) that any of it is really therapeutic, at least, in the way the conveners think it is.

It is not difficult to imagine that the love and acceptance these men express towards each other doesn’t make them less dangerous to anyone outside of their artificially created circle of trust. Implicit in all of this is the suggestion that these men committed crimes primarily as a consequence of a deprived or abused childhood. If you are in this circle, you seem obligated to come up with something and to cry and to thrash and scream, and it would not be hard to imagine a deprived participant making something up, or exaggerating, in order to fit in.

I’m not sure it doesn’t work.  Maybe, for it’s own reasons, it does.

When the volunteer relates about his dad’s frustration with his inability to find the right tool, he also adds that he feels guilt over bringing this relatively trivial issue up among men who have experienced genuine trauma, but the men will have none of it.  They like him.  They urge him on to confront his trauma-inducing father, to weep and thrash, and break through, and confront him (one of the inmates role-plays for him).   It’s a moment in the film that is nearly comical and made me think of a potential SNL skit, which some might think disrespectful.

Yes, it is.  But let’s be clear: in my mind, it doesn’t diminish the real emotions felt by the inmates, or their expressions of rage.

 

[whohit]The Scream[/whohit]

What Did You Think You Were Getting

This article in NYTimes tells us that a number of gymnasts who worked out with coach and trainer Qi Han at Everest Gymnastics in North Carolina now allege that Mr. Han was abusive.

He absolutely was.  That’s how you do sports in the ultra-competitive U.S.A.  This is accepted as the way you drive young athletes to higher levels of performance.  Did you think your child’s coach was going to offer snacks as a reward?

I was on a collegiate hockey team in the Chicago area back in 1974.  We were coached by a Canadian history professor in a very relaxed, undisciplined manner.  It was decided– by somebody– that we would bring in a “real” coach for one practice, a Mr. Dave Vandenberg.  He immediately took to yelling and screaming abusively at us, trying to get us to play better.  I thought he was an idiot then, and I think so now.   I’m sure we would have played better had he hung around and coached us every day, but I just didn’t care that much.  Sports is trivial.  It is unimportant.  If you think it’s a way to bring glory to yourself, to make money, and become famous, then you get what you deserve.

Let’s make it clear.  Everest Gymnastics advertised itself to parents as an intensive training institution that could help young gymnasts improve their performances.  Do you know what kind of training we’re talking about, in ultra-competitive America?  Would it surprise you to find that coaches of any serious athletic discipline tend to be pricks?  That they shout at athletes and belittle them, and ridicule them, and mock them when they feel they are not making enough effort?

I have never been a fan of that school of thought that believes that there is something admirable in pushing athletes to perform better by screaming at them.  Why?  Why should I care if they perform better?  Is it worth it?  What’s the point?  To beat some other athletes whose coaches yell and scream at them?

You send your child to Everest Gymnastics just so he or she can have fun.  The children taking training from Qi Han are probably being pushed by their parents to achieve, achieve, achieve.  To be better than the competition.  This kind of coaching requires a lot of time and money.  Parents are up early, up late, driving here, driving there– if they have several children, they find themselves spending a lot of time and money trying to turn their children in to star athletes.  Medals.  Success. Maybe the Olympics.  Maybe the NFL.  Money and fame.

Are any of these parents under the delusion that these coaches are going to be nice to their children?  Sweet, and encouraging?

Are these coaching methods a secret?  The parents didn’t know what was going on?  Suddenly one day they went, “oh my god!  Coach Han is yelling at my daughter!”

[whohit]What Did You Think You Were Getting[/whohit]

Internal Contradictions

With the election of Donald Trump, all the rules about political success and failure seem to be out the window.  He should not have won the Republican primaries.  He should never have won the election.  He should not, right now, have 90% support among the Republican faithful.

Well, he didn’t actually win the election.  He won the Electoral College and he won it with margins in a handful of states that are not really very convincing.  His current approval ratings are not good.  And take a look at realclearpolitics polling on congressional races going into the 2018 mid-terms: they don’t look good for the Republicans.  In fact, they are stunningly, uniformly blue.  The Democrats should win back control of the House.  They might be able to take the Senate, but that appears unlikely.

Of course, polling showed that Clinton should have won the 2016 presidential election.  And she did: by 3 million votes.  But she lost the Electoral College.

Winning a significant majority of votes is not a trivial fact.  Most American citizens did not believe that Trump would make a good president.  In fact, given Clinton’s unpopularity, a very significant majority of Americans still preferred her.

My theory about politics– which is challenged, of course, by current events– is that a political establishment is in trouble when it’s avowed values and goals include contradictory elements that cannot co-exist sustain-ably.   That’s a mouthful but it comes down to this: much of what Trump stands for is at odds with majority American values.   And even what he says he stands for is at odds with a clear majority of American voters.

These contradictions can and often do coexist for a time– people have a monumental capacity to embrace hypocritical values (using a not-nice word for “incompatible”).  When these two sets do collide, usually as the result of a crisis,  one of them changes.  In the 1960’s, it was the draft and the war in Viet Nam in contradiction with the growing perception that the war could not be won.  It was also the ideals of equality and justice espoused by the Constitution in opposition to the treatment of black citizens.    In the 1980’s and 90’s, budget deficits in opposition to welfare policies, and increasing crime in opposition to criminal sentencing.  Under Obama, widespread social acceptance of homosexuality in opposition to the laws governing marriage.    Under Bush Jr., the threat of terrorism in opposition to privacy rights.

Trump’s avowed policies on the environment, trade, international relations, and civil rights are ridiculously at odds with mainstream American values– which have not gone away, by the way.   The Republicans have been revealed for what they always were: race-baiting elitist materialistic gun-mad turds.  Until now, they’ve managed to disguise their real attitudes behind “nice”, “decent” candidates like George Bush Jr. and Mitt Romney.  Trump has suddenly revealed the Republican Party for what it always really was.

You mean it’s actually okay to say that out loud?

I believe a solid majority of Americans are still solidly in favor of sound environmental policies, decent wages, Social Security and Medicare, civil rights, and immigration reform, including a path to citizenship.

So this contradiction should lead to a crisis which will force a resolution of some kind.  What will the crisis look like?  Massive budget deficits?  Lay-offs by companies affected by Trump’s anti-trade actions?  Polluted drinking water?  Dramatic increases in carbon emissions coinciding with flooding of coastal cities?  Violent demonstrations?  North Korea firing another test missile?  Putin invading Lithuania?

Maybe it will simpler than that.  I don’t believe Trump will be able to resist the temptation to enrich himself through his position.  I don’t think he understands why that’s illegal.  I don’t think he understands what will happen when it all comes out.

Who knows.

[whohit]Internal Contradictions[/whohit]