My Life – Bill Clinton

First of all, seriously?  “My Life”?  Nobody at Knopf or Clinton’s cabal could think of anything more allusive or intriguing than “My Life”?

I just finished Clinton’s monumental (in size, at least) autobiography of 950 pages.  Here are some takeaways.

The writing is serviceable but not remarkable.  Too much of it consists of long sequences of events, meetings, trips, and milestones, with occasional interludes of analysis, self-congratulation, and admiration for people who admired him.  It reflects the source material: 8 years of detailed notes, chronological order, some reflection and insights gained in retrospect.  Too much, at times, like a list.  I never stopped to think, oh, that’s a great sentence or paragraph, from a literary point of view.

Clinton left three years of budget surpluses.  Yes, it’s true.  He is the only president since Jimmy Carter to even come close to balancing the budget (though in his last year, Carter did leave a $60 billion shortfall).  The Republicans under George W. Bush immediately pissed it away with tax cuts without cutting any popular programs.  You can’t convince me that this is not an intentional strategy: whine and holler about deficits, but be sure to leave them for your Democratic successor so you can run on the issue again.   (You can count on the voters having a short memory.) (Obama reduced the deficit; Trump blew it up).  If congress had stuck to Clinton’s overall budget plan, the U.S. could have paid off it’s national debt in 10 years.  If there was an ounce of sincerity in the claims the Republicans make about addressing the deficit, they had a glorious opportunity to demonstrate it.  They did not.

Clinton accomplished a lot.  He appointed competent people.  He crafted useful, productive legislation on everything from education to the environment.  He tried to improve the lives of average Americans, mostly successfully.   He left an unemployment rate of about 4% and very a very healthy GDP.

Al Gore may have been the most competent vice-president since Lyndon Johnson.  And yes, he really did play a significant role in the creation of the internet (as a Congressman).

Presidents have to attend an incredible number of ceremonial events, dinners, parades, parties, and so on.  It strikes me as kind of idiotic, actually.  They should just elect a Presidential-Shaman to do all that kind of shit and let the real President do his work in peace.  This kind of profile attracts a certain type: men who love jetting all around the world and visiting exotic and beautiful locations, surrounded by Secret Service agents and staff, staying in lavish hotels or palaces–  all while claiming to be working on American foreign policy.  Sometimes they are.  Sometimes they are just thrilled to chat with the Queen or receive an exclusive personal tour of a museum or castle.  In Clinton’s case, Hillary and Chelsea got to share in the largesse.  How nice that the president can privilege his own family at taxpayer expense.

Did I even mention the obscenity of having a military band play fucking “Hail to the Chief” every time you enter a room?  Seriously?  What kind of monumental moron thought this was useful or appropriate or even not absurd in any way?  It is literally cartoonish.

In one of the most embarrassing passages, Clinton heralds Yeltsin’s successor in Russia, a tight-lipped reserved former KGB agent named Vladimir Putin, as a very promising world leader.  He also visits Hafez Al-Assad, dictator of Syria,  who massacred 30,000 civilians in the town of Hama, and reports how delightful he was.  Seriously, Bill?

Benjamin Netanyahu was at work sabotaging peace deals with the Palestinians long before Trump came along, though Clinton was pretty clue-less about it.  All those “surprising” developments that prevented Netanyahu from implementing his side of the agreements?  Just coincidences, according to Clinton.  Bad luck!  Darn it!  And Bibi seemed so excited about finally signing a peace deal and getting that two-state solution everyone knew was the only pathway to peace!

Kenneth Starr remains one of the most repulsive human beings to ever investigate anything– second, perhaps, to Senator Joseph McCarthy.  And let’s not confine the stink to Whitewater and Monica Lewinsky:  Starr defended Jeffrey Epstein against the first set of charges in 2007 and helped negotiate the sweetheart deal that allowed Epstein to walk.  He defended Trump at his impeachment hearings, directly contradicting most of what he said during Clinton’s impeachment hearings.  We don’t know what exactly he did at Baylor in regard to a pair of students charged with sexual assault, but he was fired for it.

Janet Reno was an extremely regrettable choice as Attorney-General though Clinton doesn’t want to admit it.  And it wasn’t just Waco.

As everyone knows, Arafat had the deal the Palestinians wanted in Clinton’s last year in office.  Israel had made very significant concessions under Ehud Barack– probably costing him re-election– including a Palestinian State but Arafat seemed terrified of having to actually govern, rather than just lead an eternal insurrection.  Or, he may have been losing it: Clinton thought his faculties had “declined” by that point.  (Has anyone considered whether Trump might resemble Arafat in that respect: a preference for nurturing grievances against a viable opposition over actually governing.)

Al Gore would have won Florida (actually, he probably did win Florida), and the presidency, if Ralph Nader hadn’t run for President as an independent in 2000.  I think Al Gore would have been an excellent president– a Bill Clinton without the scandals (like Barack Obama).  He was forward-looking, smart, accomplished, and competent.  If he had won, there probably would not have been a war in Iraq.  9/11 would probably have still happened  though given that there were warnings and given Gore’s cautious nature, it might not.  The U.S. budget would have continued on it’s path to eliminating the debt.  But the 2008 financial meltdown would still have happened: Gore was an enthusiastic supporter of Clinton’s deregulation of the financial industry.

Which leads me to Ms. Brooksley Born.  Clinton does not mention the name “Brooksley Born” anywhere in this voluminous biography.   You should watch this documentary to see why.  For a summary of what happened, check this.  This one item is the most disgraceful lie (by omission) in the book, one that Clinton probably knew he could get away with: do you know who Brooksley Born is?

Clinton (and Gore) decided, on the advice of people like Robert Rubin, Henry Paulson, Larry Summers, and Alan Greenspan, that deregulating the financial markets would lead to wonderful magical entities like Enron that would make countless Americans rich.  They either knew or should have known that the essential nature of these financial instruments is that they allow ruthless money-mangers to make fortunes by deceiving investors into putting their money into accounts that provide no real economic value to the economy but from which they can skim off millions of dollars in management fees.  They exist to facilitate the extraction of wealth from gullible investors.

They surely knew it would at least make thousands of money-managers rich in the filthiest way you can imagine.  Brooksley Born, who was head of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, thought these instruments of bundled risk created the conditions under which major bank defaults and massive fund collapses could occur and she opposed them.  Clinton fired her. 

Instead of the fantasized wealth, deregulation led directly to the bubble burst in the late 1990’s and the massive financial meltdown of 2008 and the collapse of Bear Stearns and the Lehman Brothers banks.   It is striking that Clinton admits to the Lewinsky affair, and alludes to other “indiscretions”, but not to the worst decision of his administration with the most catastrophic consequences.  “Brooksley Born” is not in the index of “My Life”.  Clinton refuses to name the most prescient financial advisor in his administration.  It seems he can’t bear to take responsibility for this one.  While American’s were insanely obsessed with the sex scandals, the far more consequential real scandal slipped right under their noses.

Clinton was very enthusiastic about free trade, a position that seems quaint today.  I’m not saying he was wrong.  I think he was probably right.  Trump has succeeded in convincing a lot of people that going back to the same policies that caused the Great Depression is a great idea.

Clinton thought bringing China into the World Trade Organization was the only way to keep them from following the path that would lead to war in the future, by keeping them engaged with trading partners in the developed world, and encouraging them to gradually become more democratic.  He had no concern about their lower production costs undermining American industrial capacity.  He doesn’t discuss the impact they could have by holding massive reserves of American currency.   He doesn’t discuss the idea of holding China to conditions: advances in human rights, unions, democracy, before they can expand their trade within the WTO.

But then, he doesn’t mention the fact that robotics cost America far more industrial jobs than off-shoring ever would.

The jury is still out on that one.  It may well be that, in the long term, integrating China into the global economic system was a stroke of genius.  It may well turn out to be a gigantic mistake.  Cuba today remains a thorn in the side of America largely because, right after Castro’s revolution, the U.S. tried to bully it into compliance with it’s hegemonic interests rather than engaging with them constructively.  Castro turned to Moscow because America turned away from Havana.

 

 

 

 

 

 

The Coming McCarthyism

The proposed legislation would remove the presumption of relevance from that showing and require also, before the information is examined, proof of how it relates to an investigation – which is to say, information may be sought only to confirm facts already known, not to investigate and determine what the facts are. The same illogical requirement would be imposed regarding phone records, even though one cannot know how numbers dialed to or from a telephone relate to an investigation until one knows what those numbers are and to whom they belong.

… from an OpEd piece in the Washington Post, by Michael Hayden, former CIA director, and Michael Mukasey, chief civil rights abuser under Bush.

If you care about civil liberties and democracy, you should read this quote carefully. Mukasey and Hayden are actually, literally, complaining that Homeland Security would actually lose the right to investigate any citizen they feel like investigating even if there is no evidence at all– nothing– that the individual has committed any crime. It’s another sorry chapter in the Republican “why should we have to wait until after someone has committed a crime before we can lock them up” theory of jurisprudence.

Part of the ongoing Republican strategy of demanding the preposterous and settling for the ridiculous.

How to Attend to an Emergency, Mr. President

In the tenth episode of Season 1, “In Excelsis Deo”, of West Wing, President Bartlet is entertaining a group of school children in the White House at a Christmas Celebration when urgent news arrives concerning the health of a gay youth who had been beaten nearly to death (obviously based on the Matthew Shepherd murder).

An aide approaches Bartlet as he is speaking to the children and whispers in his ear. Bartlet, cool as could be, tells the children that one of the parts of his job is to attend to emergencies from time to time. He leaves them for a moment and goes off with the aide who fills him in. He makes a few comments and then returns to the children.

This episode was filmed in 1999, two years before 9/11.

I have heard people defend President Bush’s performance on 9/11 by saying it was quite reasonable for him to continue sitting there, looking painfully at a loss, for seven minutes after an aide had informed him about the planes crashing into the World Trade Center. It’s odd that Aaron Sorkin, merely creating a fictional situation for his tv series, thought the President would do what Bartlet did, so smoothly and confidently, in that episode. At the time I saw it, of course, I barely noticed it. It was only after viewing Season 1 again, years later, that I was struck by the uncanny resemblance of the fictional scene to what happened in real two years later, and the contrast between what Aaron Sorkin thought the President would do and what Bush actually did. I believe that had Bartlet been a conservative Republican, Sorkin would have had him do the same thing: it’s so simple, so logical, so becoming of the President of the United States.

Just noted.

Bullies

There is a grave flaw in the conservatives’ argument that the government should stay out of our lives as much as possible. Or maybe it isn’t a flaw. Maybe it is the real essence of conservatism.

If our world is a school yard, big corporations and the rich are like the bullies. Conservatives want the government to stay out of it: the bullies knock you down, kick you, and take your lunch money. They abuse the girls, toss their garbage wherever they like, and when the ice cream man arrives, they take all the ice cream, drive off the ice cream man, and then resell it to the rest of the kids at twice the price. Oh wait– the school yard does have an army. It’s role is to go to other school yards and bully those kids and take their lunch money. They bring it back and have a parade commemorating their success, and then keep it all for themselves. Every day, they remind you that the bullies in the other school yards are all plotting to steal your lunch money, or worse. They make up songs praising themselves and force everyone to sing them.

If George Bush runs this school yard, then the bullies take your credit cards and run up a huge bill buying weapons with which to go invade other school yards. They buy these weapons from themselves and make huge profits. Most of the weapons cost a lot but they don’t work properly and eventually get tossed. Then they hold solemn parades on the basketball court. “If only,” they tell us, “the other bullies would stop trying to take our lunch money, we could have peace!”

In Glenn Beck’s and Sarah Palin’s ideal world, that’s the way it should be. If you’re not big enough or tough enough to stand up to the bullies, too bad for you.

They look solemnly at the faces in the school yard: you don’t want the government telling you what to do, do you?

Mr. Yoo Justifies His Unwarranted Intrusion

“The law has recognized that force (including deadly force) may be legitimately used in self-defense,” Mr. Yoo and Mr. Delahunty wrote to Mr. Gonzales. Therefore any objections based on the Fourth Amendment’s ban on unreasonable searches are swept away, they said, since any possible privacy offense resulting from such a search is a lesser matter than any injury from deadly force. NY Times, March 3, 2009.

Mr. Yoo and Mr. Delahunty were Bush Administration officials who believed they could justify unconstitutional and illegal actions because someone might die. This rationale would come as a huge surprise to Thomas Jefferson and Benjamin Franklin. How could they not have foreseen that lives would be endangered if the police were not allowed to enter your house and search it at will?

It’s just one final piece– the release of memos detailing how the Bush Administration, in hysterics after 9/11, contemplated a police state.

Don’t ever again ever believe a “Conservative” when he tells you he loves freedom and democracy and especially if he claims he loves the constitution.

And if he claims to be a Christian and he loves George W. Bush because he stood for Christian values then, lest you believe that Christians do not believe in freedom, let me tell you these people are not Christians.

They have all either spoken out clearly in condemnation of these memos, or they are all cold-blooded, contemptible liars.

Pardon Me

I thought for sure that George Bush would issue a large number of pardons during his last few days in office, eight years after Republicans expressed dire outrage at Bill Clinton’s last minute pardons. He did not. I’m guessing he thought it would look hypocritical. He deserves credit for that, if not for much else.

Apparently, VP Cheney lobbied long and hard for a pardon for “Scooter” Libby, reflecting the more traditional Republican approach to justice: severe punishment for the poor and minorities for even minor crimes, and bottomless generosity and grace towards our friends.

Libby was convicted of perjury by a trial jury and the fact that he was buddies with the VP should not have played any role at all in the consideration of a pardon– and the fact that Bush resisted it is a little amazing, but was clearly the right decision. Libby likely lied to cover up the role played by Cheney and Rove in the outing of Valerie Plume. To pardon him would be a clever way for any president to lie at will, induce lower-ranking aides and officials to take the blame, and then issue pardons to them. Bush was right in every respect to withhold the pardon.

All Libby had to do to avoid any punishment at all was reveal who lied and who leaked. The Bush Administration tried to discredit political opponents who knew the truth about the doctored intelligence on Iraq. The tragedy is that Cheney and Rove both walked away.

I believe that George W. Bush, contemplating the legacy, the disasters of Iraq and Afghanistan that Cheney had pushed him into, left office in a rueful state.  He stood up to someone who had pushed him into bad decisions as his last act as President.  That was almost honorable.

Surge and Purge

Contrary to general belief–can I shock you?–the “surge” is not a “success”.

It has achieved the political goal of short-term reductions in the numbers of casualties. It hasn’t moved us one iota closer to a stable Iraq.

The supposedly left-wing media swallowed this one hook, line, and sinker. What has happened, in a nutshell, is this: local U.S. commanders have negotiated a sort of power-sharing arrangement with some of the powerful Sunni militias who were leading the attacks against troops and civilians in Baghdad. In exchange for local control, road blocks, and, apparently, considerable cash– and continued possession of their weapons and territories–, they have implemented a truce. One of the reasons President Maliki would like to see U.S. troops leave is so he can go into these enclaves and rout his political opponents for good so he can consolidate real power in his Shiite government. He doesn’t have real power over these militias. Does anyone other a few diligent journalists know about this in America?

Some of the Sunni groups were fighting both Al Qaeda and the Americans. Some analysts believe they have negotiated a temporary truce of convenience in order to focus on their Iraqi opponents. The idea that this is a step towards a stable, pluralistic democracy is rather naive. It looks more like Lebanon or Egypt or Syria.

The idea that the U.S. is fighting for democracy and freedom, and for a free pluralistic society in Iraq that will resemble…. well…. who? Nobody. Because such a state cannot exist in a nation in which the majority of citizens believe that Allah should govern and infidels should be killed. The only way such a state can evolve into a progressive, liberal western-style democracy, is through progressive secularization. We need to give them high-definition TV’s and Walmarts. We need to convince them that American Idol is satisfying entertainment, and that Paris Hilton really is important, and that Cadillac’s really do cause women to have orgasms. We need to convince them that you can feel quite spiritual by being anti-abortion and opposed to sex education and homosexuals without having to sacrifice the even the smallest material comfort.


Call me crazy but I stand by something I said years ago:  Iran will be the first true Islamic democracy in the Middle East.

I found this after I had written this rant.  It’s a rarity– a media outlet that questions the claims McCain and Bush are making about the success of the surge.  Here’s another.

Bush Pardons

You undoubtedly remember vividly the apoplectic outrage of conservative commentators when Bill Clinton issued his list of pardons just before leaving office. That outrage, of course, is reserved only for occasions on which the Democrats appear to be doing what the Republicans think the Democrats would do if they had the ethics of Republicans.

I might be wrong, but I believe we are about to see George Bush make Bill Clinton look like a piker when it comes to pardons. I’ll even stick my neck out and predict it: George Bush is going to have to issue a large number of pardons… for people who will not admit to having committed any crimes.

The problem is this: Barack Obama wins the election. Do you think Obama will interpret the constitution to mean that the President of the United States can make torture legal by commanding his minions to torture?

Maybe he will. Or maybe he will feel the same way that most civilized western leaders have felt for 100 years: that the use of torture is repugnant to the fundamental principles of human rights. Okay. So what do all the torturers in the CIA do? Quietly quit their jobs and move to Switzerland or Argentina? Apologize? I’m really, very, very sorry that I tortured you– I had thought it was legal. And resort to the standard “I was only following orders” defense?

I suspect that an understanding might be reached, that would see the federal government under the new administration not ask any embarrassing questions, provided that the violations of fundamental human rights comes to a quick stop. But what if any of the victims are put on trial? What if their lawyers challenge the validity of evidence obtained against their clients because it was adduced under torture? Sticky wicket, isn’t it? What if they call in the FBI witnesses who objected to what they termed “rough treatment” of suspects by their colleagues in the CIA and Defense Department?

Bush is going to have perform that goofy voodoo thing wherein you forgive people for crimes you claim they haven’t committed. He tried to do a similar thing by getting Congress to grant immunity to corporations that he swears were merely obeying the law when they allowed the government to spy on individuals in the U.S. without warrants. If they were obeying the law, why do they need immunity? This kind of hypocritical bullshit should not be allowed to pass: why will anyone need a pardon if, as Bush says, everything they did was legal?

Congress should make a simple demand– it should insist that no one can be pardoned unless they have committed a crime. So Mr. Bush may only pardon torturers if they admit they illegally tortured people. And then we may turn to the President and impeach him in the hour before he leaves office.

By golly– George Bush really does understand the constitution. He just willingly shits on it.


Update

2011-03 I was wrong. George Bush — much to Cheney’s displeasure, apparently– refused to pardon anybody, not even Scooter Libby.

Yes, I do think more highly of him than I did before. Barack Obama, on the other hand, basically continued the same policies. So, yes, I think much less of him for that. By continuing the policies, of course, he erased the possibility of charging members of the Bush Administration with violating the rights of prisoners at Guantanamo Bay and elsewhere. That’s exactly what Bush needed and wanted and I do wonder just how overt this kind of understanding between one President and another is.

Don’t forget Karl! There are strong grounds for suspicion that Karl Rove orchestrated the malicious and false prosecution of Alabama Democratic Governor Don Siegelman. A Republican lawyer has sworn, under oath, that she was told that Rove directed the United States attorney for Montgomery to undertake proceedings against Siegelman though there was no real evidence of any crime.  For a political operative to instigate such an investigation is a felony.

Congress has subpoenaed Rove but he refuses to testify. How on earth can he get away with that? The Attorney General is ultimately responsible for enforcing the law. George Bush appoints the Attorney General. There you go.

We need to start a campaign now to head off the inevitable. The campaign should focus on the demand that no pardons should be issued by President Bush for anyone who has not publicly admitted that they have committed the crimes for which they are being pardoned. (It’s probably too much to ask that they actually be charged with those crimes and put on trial.) It’s simple: no confession, no pardon. So all those intelligence agents who tortured and generals who lied and secretaries of state who lied and phone companies who allowed the government to eavesdrop on conversations without a warrant and so on and so on should have to line up on television and takes turns telling us exactly what they did that requires a pardon. It would be the ultimate reality show, and it would be GREAT for the country. These are the sonsofbitches who have been running your country for the past eight years. What do you think?

But I was only following orders!

Right. America supported the findings of the Nuremburg judges that the “following orders” defense does not exculpate actions that a reasonable person would perceive to be illegal and abhorrent. So Nazi soldiers that participated in atrocities, unless they had good grounds to fear for their lives, were not excused from their sins. The same standard was applied to the William Calley case.

Unfortunately, I’m not sure a judge in the U.S. in today’s political climate would agree with me that anyone participating in the use of torture has no excuse. America is moving backwards, towards barbarism. The idea that torture is “abhorrent” prevails in civilized countries. What is a civilized country?


 

The Disneyland George W. Bush

Let us all take a moment and celebrate the achievements of George Bush, now that the full moon wanes on his administration and the pardons are readied to be delivered. When George Bush came into office, America was troubled with a vast budget surplus, peace and stability, cheap oil prices, a decreasing crime rate, low unemployment, a functional but deficient social security system, modest but effective environmental regulations, and a split Supreme Court.

After George improved the education system so that America is now– what is it? 21st in the world? And then solved the social security crisis by doing nothing, he eased everyone’s health care concerns by providing elderly Americans with a confusing and expensive drug plan. He open the nation’s forests and wildlife preserves to oil drilling and forestry where-ever he could, and made it easier for America’s manufacturers to sell defective products without consequence, which didn’t stop them from shipping most of those jobs to China. Did I mention the trade deficit?

Or the unimaginable increase in military spending which has succeeded in creating millions of new enemies in Pakistan and Egypt and Saudi Arabia? He did nothing for peace in Palestine but that’s a lost cause anyway. He corrected the crazy perception that most independent scientists believe that humans are causing global warming by arranging an overwhelming number of oil industry employees to say they’re not.

He appointed partisan political hacks to the Justice Department to correct fears most Americans have that the justice system is above partisan politics.

He managed the mortgage crisis so effortlessly that naive observers are still convinced he did nothing. He managed health care so effectively using competition to drive down costs so precipitously that most Americans now claim they don’t need health insurance.

The inevitable George Bush presidential library should have one volume in it, with the title, written in crayon. “How I helped a small number of wealthy Americans become even more wealthy.”


Added December 2008:  How much was Bill Clinton paid? He and Hillary have together collected over $109 million in the eight years since leaving office.  “Pretty good wages, for one little kiss….”

Americans, this is how your government works.


Paying Off George Bush

[2022-05-12: I am leaving this in because I was wrong, and I admit it, and you should know it.  George W. Bush has had a generally honorable post-presidency life, painting, and giving anodyne speeches here and there, and showing up for appropriate ceremonial events.  Of course, the election of Trump, which gave us one of SNL’s better jokes in recent years: the Will Ferrell as Bush going “how do you like me now” has transformed everyone’s appreciation what we now see as a fundamental decency in George W. Bush utterly lacking in the current Republican Party.  It should also be acknowledged that the Clintons were far more avaricious in cashing in the post-presidency boom in speeches and fund-raising events.]

You will not have seen the likes of this before– when George Bush leaves office, he will embark on the greatest orgy of corporate pay offs in the history of Capitalism.

George’s corporate Svengali’s can’t pay him now, of course. That would be unseemly. And illegal, of course. But they are waiting in the wings flush with gratitude for the President who delivered more to them they could even have imagined in their wildest dreams. He gave them tax breaks, deregulation, corporate-friendly judicial appointments. He gave them Alito and Roberts and the ironically titled “Clear Skies” act. He gave them oil and ethanol and mythologized global warming. He gave his friendly military contractors billions and billions of dollars in fat government contracts with embarrassingly little oversight. He gave them everything they asked for.

And now, the reward.

The reward will look like partnerships and speaking engagements for unprecedented amounts of cash– he won’t even really have to move his lips– just show up and smile and cavort. The reward will look like Board appointments and investment opportunities and parties and jets and jewels and medals and awards and statues and presidential libraries in the name of the president who never reads or learns or studies or thinks.

Perhaps Laura, a former librarian, might find something to do at his.

There will be highways and airports and bridges named for the man without the slightest interest in building anything that would benefit anyone except his corporate cronies.

 

A “Finding” Does not Make it Legal

You might think that torture is actually presently legal in the U.S., given all the efforts by Bush and his Attorney Generals to make it so. And maybe you just don’t care that it is– or you approve– because you are a God-fearing patriotic American and you don’t take bullshit from foreigners– whatever— I don’t care. Jesus loves you, whatever, because you approve of the use of torture, and you really can’t remember or think of or imagine any reason why that would make you less of a human being than, say, believing in witchcraft or astrology. Whatever.

Back to my point: I don’t believe torture is, technically, “legal”. It is, in fact, quite illegal, no matter what Bush says it is. Then why hasn’t anybody been arrested? Who would arrest who? Because Bush is in command of the only apparatus that can enforce the law: the Attorney General’s Office and the FBI (which is accountable to it) and he has ordered it not to.

[added October 22, 2008: if a New York City cop on the beat, for example, stumbled into a group of men treating an individual the way they are, in fact, treating the detainees in Guantanamo, he would surely make an arrest and lay charges.  Nobody would or could excuse the crime with a “finding”.]

If Bush or his Attorney-General issues a “finding” that torture is legal (he calls it “enhanced interrogation techniques” but no court is so stupid as to not see through that), and thereby instructs federal officials to abide by that “finding”, he hasn’t really changed any aspect of the law. What would it take to activate the apparatus on behalf of the courts? Well, how about a new executive who believes in the constitution?

Take for example any prisoner being held currently in Guantanamo, who had previously been tortured, either through rendition, or by CIA officers at locations outside of the U.S. Bush has succeeded in blocking this individuals access to any court with the power to respond to his circumstances with directives that will actually be obeyed by Federal agencies. At the moment, Bush simply ignores any legal motions he doesn’t like and then obfuscates.

Now suppose a new Chief Executive– a new President– instructs the new Attorney General (John Edwards?) to investigate whether anybody involved in the handling of prisoners by American forces or intelligence agencies or proxies has broken the law, or violated the rights of these prisoners.

I think about this a lot. I can imagine that nothing will happen, if the new President turns out to be gutless and decides that he can live with simply stopping any more torture from happening. That’s hard to imagine, however, because the lawyers for all of the prisoners being held by agents of the U.S. Federal Government will be clamoring for due process and habeas corpus and dozens of other constitutional rights we all used to think Americans treasured dearly. And I can’t see this new President doing what Bush did, which is, instructing his staff to find ways around the courts, so we can suppress the rights of these individuals.  [Update: that is, in fact, exactly what Obama did.]

So imagine instead that President Obama (or Clinton) allows the attorney general to investigate and he finds out that there has been some torture going on… and he decides that his interpretation of the constitution is that torture is never allowed.

Just imagine.

[2011-03: of course, it didn’t happen. Odd, but not really surprising now that I think about it. Would a politician who was seriously intent on enforcing the law survive the primary process in the U.S.? I doubt it. ]