Rogers & Hart: Blue Moon

In an article in the New York Times, Jesse Green lauds the new biopic of Lorenz Hart (“Blue Moon”) for its relative honesty in dealing with Hart’s homosexuality and alcoholism.  In the process, he savagely ridiculed biopics from the 1940’s and 50’s that lionized these Broadway composers while completely ignoring the factors in their lives that made them who they were.

Some letter writers– more than a few– objected to the criticism of these early biopics, arguing, essentially, that the antiseptic, homogenized, white bread version of the lives of artists like Lorne Hart presented in these films was virtuous in some way, honorable.  Pleasing.  Kind of true.  

I never ceased to be amazed at just how willing most people are to embrace something they know to be a lie rather than admit to an unpleasant– to them– truth.

Truth does matter. Fantasy is these cases is not neutral. It’s a way of imposing an audience’s prejudices on the raw material of real life and manipulating events to gratify them. And if there is an audience for the kind of fantasies those early biopics provided, then, for heaven’s sake, write a story and make up the characters. What I object to is hanging a fantasy on a simulacrum of an artist’s real life as if “this really happened this way”. I want to know something like what really happened.

Springsteen: Deliver Me From Nowhere

I was very disappointed in the new Springsteen biopic, “Springsteen: Deliver me From Nowhere”.

It achieved one thing remarkable: it made Springsteen boring. And it took the unfortunate path of having secondary characters act as one-dimensional props for slavish admiration of the “tortured genius”. Did we all learn nothing from the wonderful Dylan biopics?

Artists seem to love the idea that they have suffered greatly for their art.  It creates the illusion of heft and substance where none might exist.  It is odd that Springsteen, with all of his songs about urban disillusionment, driving, roads, the streets, hot girls who let you unzip their jeans, and so on, should cave to the most familiar and tired tropes.  I don’t begrudge for one second Springsteen’s embrace of therapy for his depression: just the idea that this particular passage of his life is worthy of his first serious biopic, and that it should be rendered with such contrived self-regard (having secondary characters allude to your genius because if you did it yourself you would look conceited).

There is one particular sequence that I think is a “tell” of the director’s intent.  After Springsteen ghosted a girl he was seeing (and romancing),  (acknowledged as a fictional “composite” character by the film-makers) she confronts him with slyly flattering dialogue (let me ease your pain!) instead of really letting loose on the guy who just treated her like a jerk.  From her point of view, he used her and then dumped her.   Just because we might like Springsteen doesn’t really change the facts here. 

The director/writer seemed to have made no effort to give her personhood, an identity, a history, a face.  He used her.  And now his biopic uses her.  He ignored her repeated efforts to connect with him after the sex no longer interested  him.  Yes, he ghosted her.  But all she can talk about is how he must be suffering.

It’s appalling.  Even worse, it’s bad art.  It makes the film dull.

As for the singing, Cooper says this, about White doing Springsteen’s voice:

it wasn’t about mimicry or imitation; it was about finding the truth of who Bruce is

Seriously?  Listen to yourself!  The “truth of who Bruce is” is the kind soft, platitudinous Hollywood bullshit that sells movies, that film-makers hope to have audiences mumbling to themselves as they leave the theatre, that 50-year-old women say when they have finished their memoirs.  I just heard the truth of who Bruce is.  And what is that?  Well, that he hurts.  He’s very, very sad. And wrote some great songs on that album I never bought because it didn’t have any hits on it.  It’s Bruce!  Yeah!  Born in the USA!

“Springsteen: Deliver me From Nowhere” is so bad it has made me reassess my long admiration for him, and to wonder if this film will not do permanent damage to his reputation as an artist.  Something which, however, I admit did not start with this film.  When I first encountered Springsteen’s albums, “Born to Run” and “Darkness on the Edge of Town”, I was blown away by the sheer velocity and volume of his voice.  On songs like, “Backstreets”, Springsteen poured out his rage in song, at the wasteland of deindustrialized America, at his haunted father’s frustration, at the girl who dumped him.  It seemed, at the time, to be powerful in a way that Bob Dylan’s voice never was.

Springsteen’s voice on those albums is still impressive but not as convincing as it used to be and I have since come to have a greater appreciation of Dylan’s singing on his albums from the 60’s and early 70’s.  Yes, he is pretty wretched now (almost unbearable), but his vocals on “Like a Rolling Stone”, “Lay Lady Lay”, “The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll”, and so on and so on, is more than satisfactory.  He is subtle at times, nuanced, beautifully paced, evocative.

Sometimes Springsteen just shouts.

Dylan’s biopics (“A Complete Unknown”, “I’m not There”), in contrast to “Deliver Me From Nowhere”, did nothing but elevate his status.

Political Violence

The media often uses the phrase “political violence”. The phrase implies a purposeful objective to these acts that doesn’t exist, as if these attackers have a rational objective that would be realized if they succeed in carrying it out.


Random Last Ditch Late Night Comment:

Watched a bit of “Star Trek: Discovery”. Imagine the Enterprise staffed by an entire crew of tranquilized and high transgender Chuck Schumers. Everyone is so blissful you’d think it was an ad for eco-friendly cleaning solvents, in space.

The only Star Trek I really liked was the first year of the original series. They made a point using really good sci-fi writers, and, for all the mockery, Shatner was pretty good, Nimoy was even better, and the rest of the cast was always at least lively.

Film: “The Good One”

Sheila O’Malley at rogerebert.com gives “Good One” four our of four stars. That means she rates this bare-bones, muted film in the class of “The Godfather”, “12 Angry Men”, “Zone of Interest”, and so on.

I would call that movie critic malpractice. I give it 2 our of 4, and I think that’s generous.

Baseball Culture

I really dislike baseball “analysts” who say things like, “well, you gotta pitch Scherzer– you’re paying him big money and he’s famous” or “you don’t want to let Aaron Judge beat you– walk him every time” or “you can’t start a rookie in the playoffs” (even after the Yankees just did that– Schlittler– with outstanding results, and your best starting pitcher the last three weeks has been your rookie, Yesavage). No, no: let’s put the 40-year-old out there with his 5.19 ERA (9.00 since August 25); he won’t be nervous.

Might as well add: “and you better put Hoffman out there for the 9th inning if it’s close because he’s your closer and you’re not allowed to put someone else out there who might not walk the potential tying and winning runs before maybe getting an out or two”.

A lot of this coming from Joe Siddal. Good advice coming from someone who hit exactly one home run in his career with a batting average of .169. And who doesn’t have a clue as to who is really the deadliest hitter on the Yankees in the playoffs (it’s NOT Aaron Judge).

No doubt he also likes the sacrifice bunt, intentional walk, and stolen bases.


The Blue Jays of 2025 are inexplicable.  I admit that I fully expected them to finish fourth or fifth this year.  I thought George Springer was basically finished, and Guerrero over-rated and Bichette insincere.

I was right about Guerrero.  Yes, he hits for average with some power, but that’s not what he is being paid for.  Twenty-seven home-runs is a poor return on that big fat contract.  He also makes a lot of base-running errors (I’ll admit he has improved there, as well as his defense).  I am not a fan.

So why did the Blue finish with the best record in the American League?  Some commentators on ESPN are as mystified as I am.  The consensus seems to drifting towards the idea that they have depth, a good roster of exceptionally above average talents, some good pitching, and high contact hitting.  The hitting doesn’t always clear the fences but they get men on base and keep them moving.

How will they do against the Yankees in the ALCS?  I cannot predict.  I have seen them push the Yankees around earlier in the year, but the Jays struggled through September until finally rousing themselves for the last four games to stay tied with the Yankees (and earn a bye because they beat the Yankees 8-5 in the season series).