Disney and Hefner

As T-Bone Burnett observed, in the song “Hefner and Disney”, Disney and Hugh Hefner actually have a lot in common. Both are selling air-brushed facsimiles of something desirable but not real, catering to our shallowest desires for easily digestible, consumable tripe. They are both purveyors of smut in their own realms.

The Facebook Stream of Sewage II

According to AI, Yes, “Facebook’s algorithm is explicitly designed to show you content it predicts you will find interesting, relevant, and engaging, based on your past behavior.”

If that’s true, it is a colossal– even perverse– failure. I’ve learned to never respond to any of the voluminous provocative posts (mostly from thinly disguised carbon industry flacks, anti-trans evangelicals, pipeline and Danielle Smith partisans, and Beach Boy fans) and keep telling Facebook to never show any posts from those sources again. It has no effect. The same type of posts keep reappearing under different names. They almost never refer to any kind of publicly accountable institution or journal or scientific body.

Is Facebook being paid to push them into my news stream even when it’s algorithm should show that I detest them? It seems odd that such a large proportion of these items could be coming straight from Pete Hegseth’s Twitter feed or Stephen Miller’s cesspool of a brain.

It’s possible that their algorithm is incredibly bad at its job. On the other hand, Zuckerberg has been cozying up to these people. It’s possible Facebook is actively promoting their cause without telling anyone.

The Facebook Stream of Sewage I

Facebook is becoming a bottomless torrent of scurrilous innuendo, provocative click-bait distortions, cherry-picked data, and apocalyptic predictions of utter doom and disaster if this or that government policy isn’t changed immediately. All designed to enrage you and get you to click and comment and share. All sponsored by Facebook’s advertisers and enabled by government policy which has decided that internet platforms are not responsible for content.

No amount of “blocking” stops them– they reappear under different names, different fake foundations or “news” sites, or under the name of some deservedly obscure podcaster. They come from both sides of the aisle though, to be fair, a majority in my feed seem convinced that Satan has become prime-minster of Canada and that we will soon run out of solar power.

If you do a quick search on any of the stories, you will often find they are false or distorted. You can’t afford to assume any of them are reliable.

There is a reason why established media outlets, conservative or liberal, are more reliable sources of information. They have editors and fact-checkers. They are transparent. They have reputations. They respond to criticism. Now somebody will point out one story out of thousands that had a mistake in it and declare that you can’t trust the media. So you trust some Facebook or TikTok loudmouth you never heard of instead? I usually find that people who say “you can’t trust the media” actually mean “I only trust the media that confirms what I already believe”.

And there are some who would argue that there is a vast global conspiracy out there that controls all of the mainstream media outlets and prevents the truth from being heard. That would be an incredible achievement. I can’t help you.

The sources of this perspective never seem to have a long series of specific facts and research or vetted data to show it. Just “I heard…”.

For those of us who prefer to get the news from established, accountable, well-documented journalists, Facebook should offer an option to shutdown ALL of those feeds. They are awful and their effect on our politics and culture is vile. If I want to know about something, I know which sources are trustworthy, from a range of political perspectives, and can go there.

Ken Burns’ “The American Revolution”.

I just watched Ken Burns’ “The American Revolution”. Aside from the inflated sense of global importance to the “revolution” and self-monumentalism, it was pretty good. It acknowledged the problem of slavery and the indigenous peoples. But you wouldn’t know from Ken Burns that Canada, just a few miles to the north, developed its own responsible, accountable representative governmental institutions without all the violence and mayhem, and it eliminated slavery thirty years before the U.S. When I was in college in the 1970’s, an American professor and a Canadian professor used to debate if the “revolution” was really revolutionary or just a war of independence. The Canadian, of course, thought it was merely a war of independence. The colonial governments were already fairly representative– society did not radically change after the war (only white propertied men could vote) and real British policy was actually controlled by Parliament at the time.

Aside from that, most of the series documented the sequence of battles– a lot of which involved poorly planned supply lines and retreats– and the squabbles over states’ rights. Not very much on the historical or intellectual origins of “the rights of man” or the Constitution.  I think Burns’ wanted it that way: he is aware of his audience and he was aiming for the mainstream.  He was provocative enough to earn some credibility (particularly in regard to the treatment of indigenous peoples) but the series lacked perspective.  It pulled it’s punches.

The French Revolution was far more radical and historically important really– and was a genuine revolution that had a massive impact on French society, abolishing tithes, limiting the authority of the church, confiscating church lands, ending the feudal system. But it also taught us radicalism has a terrible price.