Bill Maher Gives his Incredibly Deep Well-Grounded Profound Take on the History of Palestine in a lecture directed to Chappell Roan. I don’t know who Chappell Roan is but I suspect that Maher is picking on an easy target here, as he often does.
This is a dumbed down, abbreviated version of the history of Palestine. And it’s mostly wrong. But Maher doesn’t let his prejudice inhibit his arrogance: he mocks anyone who dares to believe what is obvious: Israel’s actions in Gaza are criminal.
It’s a shame Maher wastes his talents on this dreck, with tedious laugh breaks from the audience and guests. Why does he do that? It makes me cringe. It appears to be conducted. His guests for that program are compelled to sit there and smile awkwardly at each round. If I were one of them, I would leave. You want to conduct a sequence of punchlines with coordinated audience applause? Go for it but I have a bus to catch. I am not a prop for the alleged audacity of your smug put-downs of woke excess.
That is the difference between Bill Maher and John Oliver, by the way. Maher is smug and cynical and pious about his own rectitude. Oliver is not. Oliver regularly, and brilliantly, embraces some seemingly idiotic project as a gesture of humility and insatiable curiosity. These gestures keep him from the kind of contemptuous arrogance that subverts Maher’s claimed insouciance.
He’s not wrong on most of the facts– except by omission– but would rather score a quick vulgar putdown than make a coherent point. And his criticism of the excesses of woke Democrats is not off target, but he seems cumulatively selective and one-sided. Would Bob Jones University ever invite a liberal speaker? No they would not. They wouldn’t even countenance the presence of John McCain– not conservative enough.
He also likes to have conservatives (like Mike Pence) on his show to hi-light and grant appreciative luster for the 10% of things they did right, while mocking and ridiculing people get 90% of what they do right.
This particular episode, defending Matt Damon from accusations of homophobia because he admitted that in his youth he sometimes called gay men “fags”, is absolutely right.
But.
His comments on the October 7, 2023 attack by Hamas that killed over 1200 people are certainly not really “politically incorrect”: he has a raft of conservative and MAGA people on his side on this issue. Yet he adopts this tone of sarcasm as if he is the adult in the room who knows about this history and he must indulgently learn those liberal critics of Israel’s genocidal attack in retaliation on Gaza about the true facts. There is nothing wrong with having a well-founded strong opinion about Gaza and Israel but his tone implies that other points of view that can be well-founded and intellectually credible are ridiculous compared to his own enlightened take on the subject. They are not.
It is very possible to be appalled and horrified by both the Hamas attacks on Israel, and by Israel’s utterly brutal revenge destruction of almost the entirety of Gaza and their attacks on south Lebanon. It is possible to find both Hamas and Netanyahu monstrous. Most of the people I know who have thought about the issue feel that way. Maher doesn’t seem to think it is a credible point of view. If you condemn Netanyahu, he thinks he can tag you as pro-Hamas.
Maher adopts the dubious rationale of Palestine being the historic homeland of the Jews– he even cites the bible– so, after an absence of 2000 years, they are entitled to re-occupy it, and he suggests that it was not occupied by anyone else at the time. I didn’t hear the word Nahkba once in his diatribe.
There is no moral law that rationalizes possession of a specific land according to who occupied it at any previous point in time. The world is full of places where peoples were driven out or annihilated or migrated. The idea of restoring everyone to their original native land is a recipe for chaos and does not serve any higher moral purpose. Does he have the same perspective on the Sioux or other indigenous tribes? On the Irish? Brazil?
Maher believes that Israel’s actions in Gaza are above reproach, justified by Hamas’ attack of October 7th, and Hamas’ avowed mission of destroying Israel. He’s not wrong about Hamas, but I do not believe that Israel’s response is proportionate or responsible. Where is the end of this progression? The two-state solution is almost dead, but the endless cycle of attack and revenge is not much of an alternative. Does Maher have any problem with the long-term status of Palestinians living in the region? Will they become second class citizens of an apartheid Israel?
Maher’s recent work belongs on Fox; not HBO. The net result of his rants is to convince people that because both sides of the American divide can be ridiculed, they are both essentially the same. His point is not moral truth. His point is that he is smarter than the people he ridicules by cherry-picking their public statements because he make witty vulgarities out of what seems obvious. Or he has a guest like John Fetterman and suddenly he’s a docile, congenial host, conspicuously ignoring questions about Fetterman’s health and fitness.
And yet, in a bizarre and incomprehensible attempt to buff his bipartisan credentials, he actually had the idiot harpy Anne Coulter on. Have a conservative on your show? By all means. But Anne Coulter is a phony, sponsored conservative apparatchik who doesn’t deserve the exposure, and Maher is an idiot for putting her on his show. Jordan Peterson? The man whose whole shtick is making idiot right-wingers feel smart.
The effect of his bipartisan ridicule is this: Donald Trump is the same as Kamala Harris. Pete Hegseth is the same as Lloyd Austin. Robert Kennedy Jr. is the same as Anthony Fauci. Andrew Miller is the same as Jake Sullivan.
This is a mistake John Oliver does not make. Maher is too narcissistic to bother with concrete solutions; Oliver almost never loses his rational perspective. He always offers a possible remedy for the toxic behaviors he describes. Oliver believes that taking potshots at everything from a safe virtual tower of pious cynicism is a lousy way to do commentary and leads to quietism and indifference.
Would Maher ever run for political office? And then have to be accountable for the actual implementation of his views? What, I would be very interested know, does he think politicians should do? Raise the minimum wage? Increase tariffs? Tax the rich?
He knows that there is another Bill Maher out there in wait who will shred his performance the way he shreds others.
Maher has a degree from Cornell University in English literature and history. You wouldn’t know it.
He’s not all bad. He’s right, here, mostly, about political aides, but, again, note how he implies that the Democrats and Republicans are equally absurd. They are not. There will always be a few on the fringe in either party who are idiots, but the Republicans have made idiocy their uniform identity with Donald Trump.
I suspect Maher is simply trying to please the lowest common denominator.
There is a resonant fable we can attach to Maher, though. In 2002, while hosting “Politically Incorrect”, Maher agreed with a guest that, whatever else you call them, the 9/11 hijackers were not cowards, while people firing cruise missiles from 2,000 miles away were cowardly. It tells you everything you need to know about American culture, and perhaps culture in general, that “Politically Incorrect” was then cancelled for being politically incorrect. The lesson is that everyone wants everyone else to think they are open-minded and intellectually courageous but the minute a genuinely courageous opinion generates a backlash, everyone ducks under the covers and shits themselves.
“No one is ever smarter from going on Bill Maher,” Ms. Pollitt said in an interview on Thursday.
One final observation: Bill Maher did a piece I generally liked on cancel culture. Unfortunately, he missed the forest. All the examples he gives are from “woke” crowds and institutions and universities objecting to certain controversial jokes without making a single reference to conservatives who are actually so much more regressive on the issue that you almost forget about them. Come on Maher: you’ve got to be kidding me. The party that will excommunicate anyone who doesn’t salute the flag (and display a lapel pin), praise Jesus, bow before the military, and praise America as the greatest, bestest, most wonderfullest nation in the history of the universe— you give them a pass? That’s not political correctness? Nobody is more politically correct than a conservative. You just don’t notice it as much because, unlike liberals, they don’t even simulate broad-mindedness and tolerance.
Okay. In fairness, here’s a recent attempt to take on the hypocrisies of Republicans. And here he is giving it to extremists and their enablers on both sides.
And here’s another good response to Maher’s arguments about Israel.