60 Minutes Flubs a Story

I am a fan of CBS’s “60 Minutes”, an enduring, credible, rational, program of pretty good journalism.  Most of the time.  CBS, like the New York Times, can occasionally fear for the establishment and slant stories just slightly to favor what they think is the “responsible” angle.  They also tend to salivate over celebrities and athletes in an unseemly manner, but, heck, who doesn’t nowadays?  Will they ever do a story on Autotune?  I doubt it; most of the artists they admire use it on all their recordings.  They will definitely do a flattering profile of Taylor Swift who fits beautifully into their enlightened mildly progressive politics, but they will be discernibly frightened of Zohran Mamdani.

They embody the Woody Allen joke (in “Bananas”): “it’s okay to be different; but not too different”.

They recently provided a story about “Havana Syndrome”, the mysterious anomalous series of illness and disabilities experienced first by embassy staff in Havana, Cuba, and then by people all around the world.  Headaches,  balance problems, dizziness, insomnia, and so on.  The diplomats and staff experiencing these issues sometimes associated them with an odd environmental sounds which some began to suspect were being deliberately made by the Cubans or Russians.

A number of very credible organizations have investigated and none were able to establish a cause, and many came to the conclusion that the symptoms were the result of pre-existing conditions, other environmental factors, or– dare we say it (because the official bodies won’t use the word):  hypochondria.

How about “mass psychogenic illness”.  How about “moral panic”.

“60 Minutes”, to my surprise, found “some evidence” of some kind of sonic weapon that might exist.  It was hard to figure out what evidence “60 Minutes” actually had because they repeated “three anonymous sources”, as if three of nothing makes three.  No one really critical to this story is on the record.  Normally, I think that means you don’t have a story, but I think Scott Pelle was moved by sympathy for some of the “victims” of Havana Syndrome and I think he wanted to believe in it.

I am surprised he omitted any reference to the fact that the U.S. is also researching building sonic ultra-wave weapons.  That is confirmable.

If you want to believe in Havana Syndrome, read this (Wikipedia) or this (NIH).

Here We Go Again

After the disasters in Iraq and Afghanistan, the political class swore that they would never again enter an armed conflict without knowing, in advance, what the off-ramp would be; how they would exit gracefully. Now Rubio and other Republican leaders are openly saying “never mind that– we’ll figure it out when we come to it”.

Unbelievable.

Though it was mildly amusing to see Republican leaders stumble over explaining how the GREAT INCREDIBLE SUCCESS of bombing Iran’s nuclear facilities didn’t actually accomplish what they said it did so they had to do it over again.

They also said (after the scandal of not finding WMD’s in Iraq) that they would ensure that the justification for the war (in this case, allegedly, long range missiles that could hit the continental U. S.) had been properly vetted. Yeah, complete blank on that. Trump’s own intelligence agencies say there is no evidence that Iran is even close to building missiles like that.

As for regime change, I cannot imagine that anyone seriously thinks the IRG is just going to put down their guns and disappear, especially when a successor regime might actually try some of them for mass murder. Trump, who has no real or imagined authority to do it, promised them immunity. Was he going to put them on trial, and then give them a pass or pardon? Without boots on the ground?

Does FIFA have a war prize they can give him now that Trump is bored with the peace thing.

Ecstatic!

From Here.

Just read this!  It is astonishing.

Oprah Winfrey, Reese Witherspoon and Jenna Bush Hager looked ecstatic as they stood onstage at the Ford Foundation in Manhattan earlier this year, posing with a new book. The crowd was so large it required an overflow room.

The book is a memoir, “The Tell” by Amy Griffith.  “One of the wealthiest women in the country”.

In the memoir, Ms. Griffin, 49, writes that she engaged in illegal psychedelic-drug therapy. While under the influence of MDMA, the active chemical in Ecstasy and Molly, she said she recovered memories of being raped on many occasions by a middle-school teacher in Amarillo, Texas, starting when she was 12.

How can anyone dare to continue to pose the question– so purely rhetorical it stinks– of why someone would tell the story of sexual abuse if it wasn’t true?  Well, isn’t it obvious?  Oprah, Reese, and Bush are all ecstatic– ecstatic– to present a book about the terrible, awful, horrible experience of sexual abuse.  Of a woman, Amy Griffith, who was raped when she was 12.   They are, I repeat, ecstatic.

Yes, of course they are not ecstatic about the abuse.  They are ecstatic about the privilege of presenting the information about it to the entire world– they are ecstatic about so many people hearing about it, buying the book (because they want to read about it), watching and relishing the endless talk-show regurgitations, the tears, the virtue signaling, the triumphalism.  And Griffin is ecstatic that she now has an excuse for why she felt so lousy about herself for so long even though she had everything anyone could ever want in life.  She is ecstatic to declare that she is a victim.

The unspeakable facet of victimhood that no one wants to talk about?  Privilege.  Usually, to excuse drug addiction, depression, professional failure.  I was good but then someone made me bad.

All of which, in this case, appears to be based on a fraud.

A former classmate of Ms. Griffin has told the same story– even about some of the actual specifics of Ms. Griffin’s telling– except that it involved a different teacher.  Did Ms. Griffin– who couldn’t remember the abuse without the assistance of a therapist and hallucinogens– lift the story from her classmate, while changing the identity of the alleged abuser?  This is pertinent: some people have decoded Ms. Griffin’s story and identified the teacher who committed the alleged abuse.  But it is not the same teacher identified by the former classmate.  And no other former students of the teacher identified from Griffin’s book have ever come forward with allegations about him.

An “expert” on MDMA says “the reliability of memories retrieved with MDMA… are often symbolic”.   He adds that even if the memories are not true, people can “develop stories that help them make sense of their life”.  Well, that’s a generous spin on confabulation.

I don’t think you could be more damning about it.  It’s okay to lie if it makes you feel better about yourself, even if you make very serious allegations about an innocent person, a teacher, whose reputation has been severely damaged.

Ms. Griffin’s “defamation lawyer” says this:  “the mere sending of this document [a letter from the Times asking for clarification] has caused additional trauma and extreme physical and emotional harm to a survivor of sexual assault, which is inexcusable.”  This from the lawyer of a woman doing everything she can to let the entire world know about her “abuse”.  This, from the lawyer of a woman who is “ecstatic” to appear on Oprah and talk about it with other celebrities.

How dare you challenge the honesty of a self-described victim of abuse?

The Times also asked the publisher if they had fact-checked the story.  The publisher responded to the Times by saying that Dial Press is a publisher, not an investigator.

With all the publicity, a family support organization in Amarillo, where Ms. Griffin is from, provided facilities for any individual to come forward to get help if they had been sexually abused.  After six months, not a single taker.

The danger in all this is that once again the idea of “recovered memories” is put into the mainstream and is sure to inspire others to recover memories of abuse and come forward and make allegations.  We’ve been through this cycle before I thought we had mostly come to our senses: recovered memories are not reliable and should never be the basis of public allegations.   The issue has been studied, researched, and tested, and it failed decisively.

More on Recovered Memories

At Home in Hibbing

The hazards of living up to your own myth: Bob Dylan has a new book. A reviewer in NYRB:

At times ‘The Philosophy of Modern Song’ feels like a sci-fi project set in a parallel universe where Bob Dylan stayed home in Hibbing and inherited his father’s electrical supply store.

Sometimes a well-known writer or artist begins to realize it is safer to be obscure and allusive than to try to produce something as dazzling and brilliant and disputable as your reputation betakes. From the reviews, it sounds like he’s just putting out a long list of songs that struck him as interesting in some way and then making random allusions to random things that came into his mind as he listened to them. I’m not saying it wouldn’t be an interesting read, but it sounds like it might be less interesting than a Jesse Welles concert, which was engaged, challenging, and fresh.

To The Posters of Family Faith and Farm Videos

There are some lovely videos of farmers out there farming with their children with texts declaring their good values and principles and faith.  I responded to one of them like this:

I love your values. Respect, integrity, support for “the underdog”. But I wonder what you think about people who claim to share your values but, in their personal lives and policies, show a lack of integrity, poor character, meanness of spirit, preferential treatment of the rich, and divisive political rhetoric? I see people who claim the support of evangelical Christians who don’t seem to reflect the values expressed by Jesus Christ, who pursue riches relentlessly, sew hatred of minorities, and shamelessly lie. Yet an overwhelming majority of Christians seem to adore them. I’m perplexed. I wonder if you really believe what you say you believe.