Crucible 2023

In an article in an issue of the New York Review of Books, 2023-11-02,  Stacy Schiff lambastes “The Crucible”, apparently because instead of giving John Proctor his comeuppance for cheating on his wife (which she connects to Arthur Miller cheating on his wife, Mary, with Marilyn Monroe), the play gives it’s comeuppance to a society in which hysteria drives well-meaning people to charge innocent people with ridiculously preposterous crimes (of witchcraft) and then hangs them.  Revisionism gone berserk.

Schiff knows something about Salem.  She is the author of “The Witches: Salem, 1692”.  How did she do?

The Guardian liked her work:

These are upsetting tales and Schiff writes movingly as well as wittily; this is a work of riveting storytelling as well as an authoritative history.

Wikipedia tells us:

Writing in the New York Times Book Review, Jane Kamensky said the book was “curiously flat” and provided a “tenuous grip on the period,” concluding: “For all her talents in sketching the who, what, where and when of the Salem trials, [the] vexed question of why is one that Schiff simply cannot manage.”[13] Writing in The Wall Street Journal, Felipe Fernández-Armesto found that Schiff offered “a trial narrative unsurpassed for detail and impressive for her mastery of the fragmentary and frustrating sources,” but said that she “uncovers no new clues to understanding” how the sides in the trials aligned.

What a shame.   The two takes on her book are not incompatible.  Sounds like an exciting read but, perhaps, lacking in depth.

But, considering her skewering of Arthur Miller (she makes numerous allusions to his vanity), it is not surprising that she “uncovers no new clues to understanding”.  She has reduced Miller’s masterpiece to just another episode of male privilege, toxic patriarchy, and petty grievance.  She relishes details of Miller’s affair with Marilyn Monroe and breakdown of his marriage at the time he was writing “The Crucible”.  And here is John Proctor, having cheated on his wife, made the hero.  (The parallels break down quickly: Abigail Williams, with whom Proctor had his affair, doesn’t suggest Marilyn Monroe on any level.)

Miller was also angry at his friend, director Elia Kazan, for folding to the House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC).  Miller, unlike Kazan, steadfastly refused to name names.  He was indicted for Contempt of Congress and sentenced to a fine and prison time but won on appeal in 1958.

For feminists, there is a problem at the core of “The Crucible”, so it’s no wonder Schiff wants to take it on.  The problem is that the “afflicted girls” whose hysterics devolved into rabid accusations of numerous innocent adults  of practicing witchcraft, in the town of Salem, we are told, should not be believed.  Doctrinaire feminists, of course, insist that when women (or girls) make accusations, they should always be believed.  Especially when Abigail Williams, the lead accuser, charged John Proctor with having used her sexually, which he confessed was true.

“To Kill a Mockingbird”, which so far has escaped Schiff’s scrutiny, has the same problem:  we root for the hero, Atticus, who questions and discredits a woman’s account of being raped.

The girls are intoxicated with their newly discovered power, to wreck havoc upon the men in authority (and women), to control discourse, to compel society to bow to them in subservience to whatever whims their intoxicated rage produces.  They have no compunction about it even when it leads to hangings and abuse and torture.  But Schiff is not interested in whether any of them were ever sorry about that: she is only interested in whether Proctor, an otherwise decent man, was sorry enough about his infidelity.   So in her mind (and the mind of several feminist writers she cites), the play needs to be rewritten to highlight the predicament of the young girls.   Which is?  Well, that intoxicating fever didn’t last.  Massachusetts eventually recanted– the biggest surprise in history– and decided that the witch hunt was a witch hunt and paid some compensation to surviving victims.

Nobody who made the false accusations was ever punished.

Schiff points out that Miller didn’t stick to the historical record.  Neither did Peter Schaffer in his play “Amadeus” but neither “Amadeus” or the “The Crucible” is historic reenactment.  That has always seemed obvious to me, if not the general public.  Both, however, use real history as the springboard to their greater purpose: the mystery of talent bestowed upon an unworthy vessel, and the horror of a society swept into hysterical delusion and driven to commit horrifying acts against the innocent on its behalf.

Incidentally, Elia Kazan’s wife, Molly, pointed out to Miller that “there really are communists”.  Oh, well, that justifies it then!  A lot of MAGA people would agree.  So let’s put up that monument to Joseph McCarthy.

Yes, I’m being sarcastic.  But an incredible number of conservatives out there, most pungently Anne Coulter, believe that the red-baiting, lying, thuggish, ignoramus– Joseph McCarthy– was right.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *