Paul Kalanithi – When Breath Becomes Something

I recently read the memoir by the late Paul Kalanithi called “When Breath Becomes Air” (a title which, even after finishing the book, doesn’t resonate with me).

Paul Kalanithi was a brilliant neurosurgeon who died in March 2015 shortly after graduating from residency and having not quite finished his memoir.  People recommended the book to me, though, as is often the case, they mostly did not give me much of an idea of the taste or texture of it.

I read it.  It can be compelling, as most medical dramas are, when he tells us about several patients and their afflictions, and some peculiar cases, like one in which brain damage created a condition in which a patient could only express himself with numbers, and tried very hard to tell something important to Kalanithi but could only blurt our a seemingly random group of digits.  Yes, medical dramas are compelling, but they are also a dime a dozen– though Kalanithi is a very good writer.  He draws on literature and philosophy and that enriches his narrative to a point.

Kalanithi spends considerable portions of the book describing his search for meaning, in philosophy and literature and neuroscience.  This part sounds a bit schematic, even sophomoric at times.  I don’t sense a real struggle.  I sense someone rationally processing possible theoretical frameworks for understanding life, comparing a few possible options, and then settling for the rather orthodox view that someone must have created reality so there must be a god and if you don’t believe in god your life will be empty.  He doesn’t consider the possibility that the incredible richness of life, of history, of nature, of beauty, or art and music, can itself be profoundly meaningful.  He expects something transcendent– I think– because he’s already settled on god and god is transcendent and a belief that there is no god would be missing that transcendent part that is required.

I found the book more disturbing on another level.  While rhapsodizing about the wonderful benefits of good medical care he gives almost no consideration to the horrible state of the American health care system.  Why would he?  He has great insurance coverage and a prosperous family and he is offered the services of Emma,   “Emma not only was one of the best– a world-renowned oncologist who served as the lung cancer expert on one of the major national cancer advisory boards– but she was also known to be compassionate…”.

Well, how nice for you.  Wouldn’t we all want to have the services of a person like that if we had cancer?  Or to be able to consider flying to Houston or New York or some University somewhere to try to get better treatment than that available locally?

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *