You Will Be Found … and nauseated

This is a video promoting the Broadway show “Dear Evan Hansen”.  If you thought it was a video of cult members singing a hymn to their incredible founder, you would be wrong.  It is an absolutely horrible video; the entire thing is dubbed from a studio recording and lip-synced with the wandering camera —  blissful triumphant faces insisting that all is well and wonderful and sweet.

“Dear Evan Hansen” looks like a good play.  I bought tickets for my wife and I: we’re going.  But these ads bug me because they indulge in a peculiar form of fraud.  Most of the time, these videos are blatant dubs: pleasing videos of singers and musicians obviously lip-syncing to studio recordings of the music.  But these ads purport to show the performers actually recording the audio.  They are not: they are posing, hamming it up for the camera, creating contrived shots intended to make it look like they are really feeling the drama of the song.

This is from a “serious” musical?  Everyone is smiling as if they just overdosed on Prozac.

We have reached a new low.  For years, I have been suggesting that a good music video would be a simple recording of the artists in the studio actually performing the song instead of the usual ridiculous lip-sync.  Well, someone thought that was a cool idea, and now we have videos of the artist supposedly  in the studio and being all dramatic and earnest in expression– but instead of hearing the actual recording of that performance,  we hear a highly edited and homogenized different studio recording.  The mic is a prop.  They couldn’t bear to show the real recording sessions because then they wouldn’t be able to get all cutesy with the wandering camera, the faces, the cutaways, and so on.  They would have microphones blocking a view of the mouth.  They would have artists concentrating on their technique instead of their facial expressions.

The facial expressions here are intended to show and audience what it thinks serious musicians who are feeling the drama would look like.  Watch a real musician perform: they look nothing like this.

This is a stunning new low in pop music.  It is beyond fake.

I am perplexed by what I hear and see about “Dear Evan Hansen”, including this line:  “Once you’re outside of the theatre, the entire story feels ickier and creepier than it ever did from the plush seats of the Royal Alex” from the favorable Toronto Star review of the Toronto Production.

I listened to some samples of it on Youtube: it sounds like superior factory pop.  Well, at least it’s not rap or hip hop.

From the New York Times:  “Rarely – scratch that — never have I heard so many stifled sobs and sniffles in the theater.”  Are we reviewing theatre or a therapy session here?  They continue:  “The musical is ideal for families looking for something yeastier and more complex than the usual sugary diversions.”  And yet that sample video above is pure meringue.

Here’s another video:  utter dreck.   Once again, we are supposed to think we are seeing the actual artist’s performance, but it clearly is not the actual performance.  It is a bunch of actors hamming it up in the studio.  Nobody looks like they are actually concentrating on holding pitch or tempo or rhythm: they are all posing for the camera.

I understand the market for this.  There are a lot people who want to believe that the french fries they are consuming are actually green beans or spinach.  They want to believe the art they enjoy is actually substantive and original and authentic.  That’s what the videos are supposed to look like.

Finally, the promotional materials for this production emphasize the phrase (and the song) “You will be Found”.  It doesn’t sound like the play is really in tune with this sentiment, which might be a good thing: “You Will Be Found” sounds like a desperate attempt to be inspirational and anesthetizing.  It sounds like something Oprah would promote.

Why Spielberg’s Cheap Emotion

Steven Spielberg has confessed that if he had a chance to make this movie today, Roy would never have abandoned his family to go to outer space. Source: “Spielberg on Spielberg”, 2007, TCM.

Probably the cheapest, most predictable effect in movies today is the family reunion.  Whatever the adventure, where-ever the journey, whenever the time, ending the film with a family reunion gets the tears flowing and a sense of smug satisfaction all around.  You don’t need to think of a story or dialogue or a shot.  Just have the family reunite.  Done.  The “family” can even be a loosely knit group of friends, or workplace colleagues.

And one of Spielberg’s least uninteresting characters, ever, is Roy from “Close Encounters of the Third Kind”.  At the end of the movie [spoiler alert!] Roy decides to go into the spaceship and travel to some distant planet and have a lot of very, very interesting adventures.  The only problem is– and it’s not really a problem– Roy is married and has a family.   Richard Dreyfuss played Roy and did his best to suck all the life out of the character and I think he generally succeeded.  The drama here is just how intensely Roy wanted to restart his life.  That’s interesting.  But it’s not homogenized or generic or white bread enough for Spielberg.

So if Spielberg were making the movie today, he would resume his unending quest to remove all interesting characteristics from all his major characters and make sure there is a family reunion at the end or lots and lots and lots of weeping so that just in case his story or the filming or the acting didn’t move you– god knows, the horrible music by John Williams won’t–  you will be clobbered with this exhibitionistic display to tell you how to feel.

 

Bill’s Oscar Rules

Sometimes movie reviewers reach for the heights: “But even without knowledge of the artist’s life, the photos step beyond neo-kitsch into a realm where child-like transference merges with a dramatic grandeur to create both a feeling of vintage Hollywood artifice and authentic pathos.”

Whoosh! Thank you Village Voice!  From a review of the documentary “Marwencol”, the film that inspired the new Steve Carrell movie “Marwen”. It’s about a man who suffered a severe beating which caused permanent brain damage. He retreats into a marvelous world of G.I. Joe and Barbie dolls, that act as a kind of therapy for him. Hope the Carrell treatment is as good as the documentary.

And remember the well-known rules for Oscars:

  1. accents  preferably Polish
  2. Nazis and victims of Nazis
  3. a disability
  4. a white person enduring terrible obstacles in defiance of racist authority

Other Oscar rules–

  • the Scorcese rule: you made a brilliant masterpiece we overlooked at the time so we now give you an Oscar for a later mediocre film to make up for our previous misjudgment
  • The DiCaprio rule: You are trying so hard and it’s so obvious and we’re sick of it all so here, take your damn Oscar
  • the Spielberg rule: you got famous making shallow, popular films and now you did a holocaust film to show you are really capable of being serious so we must give you the Oscar
  • And the Amy Adams-Scarlett Johanson-Jennifer Lawrence rule: you gave a brilliant performance in your first film so we knew you were very good but we had to wait for you to be in a big-budget, heavily promoted, commercial Hollywood film before we could give you the Oscar for a far less interesting performance.

The films were “Junebug”, “Ghost World”, and “Winter’s Bone”.  Check them out.

Freddie Mercury

Freddie Mercury was a very talented singer and performer.  He is ranked 18th on Rolling Stone’s roster of great rock singers.

Seriously: 18th.  Behind Bob Dylan.  Behind John Lennon.  Robert Plant?

(Ahead of Van Morrison???  Way ahead of Art Garfunkel and Tom Waits???  It’s a strange list.  I love Bob Dylan, but number 7 on this list?  And if Dylan is 7th, why is Bono 32nd and  Neil Young 37th?  What really is the criteria here?   It appears to be a mix-up and random blend of “greatest vocalist” and “greatest artist”.  Is Mick Jagger really a better singer than Janis Joplin or Nina Simone?)

All right– he did have a good voice.

A research team undertook a study in 2016 to understand the appeal behind Mercury’s voice.[39] Led by Professor Christian Herbst, the team identified his notably faster vibrato and use of subharmonics as unique characteristics of Mercury’s voice, particularly in comparison to opera singers, and confirmed a vocal range from F#2 to G5 (just over 3 octaves) but were unable to confirm claims of a 4-octave range.  (Wikipedia)

So it must be conceded that technically he had a terrific voice, a terrific instrument at his command.  What did he do with it?

So, quick, name one of his songs that really mattered.

Me neither.

Let’s be clear here: people who regard Queen as a great band will cite “We Are the Champions” as one of the greatest rock recordings of all time.  If you are in that camp, I am talking a foreign language to you.  How can “Bohemian Rhapsody” not be one of the great songs of all time?  It’s epic.  No, it’s not even a great song.  It’s not even in the same league as “Anchorage” by Michelle Shocked, or “Homeward Bound” or “The Boxer” or “Like a Rolling Stone” or “Tangled up in Blue” or “Thunder Road”.

Gosh, Elizabeth Taylor and Liza Minnelli both attended his 20th April 1992 tribute concert.  Both of them!

What he did do was kill several people by refusing to accept the diagnoses of AIDS, and refusing to disclose to his numerous sexual partners that he probably had it.

When asked whether he altered his behavior, Freddie responds, “Darling, fuck it, I’m doing everything with everybody.”  Poz

He also refused to “come out”.  Not that anyone has a duty of any sort to “come out”, but it would have been honorable for him to do it at the time of the AIDS epidemic, to do what he could to increase public awareness of the issue and help those lobbying for more funding for research and treatment.  Unfortunately, he appears to have been more concerned about selling records and tv appearances and not offending his family than about the lives of other gay men.

Was that his worst sin?  Or was inflicting “we will, we will, rock you” upon millions of sports fans even worse.  Or “we are the champions”.  Or– please– “Another One Bites the Dust”.  And another one.  And another one.  And another one.  Seriously, folks, it’s a insecticide commercial gone bad.  Really bad.

Or, worst of all, “Bohemian Rhapsody”, an absolute marvel of inane kitch which they never could perform live, because that would have really required musical gifts beyond Freddie Mercury’s grasp (they cheated with tapes of the choral and other parts).   I mean, obviously it could have been performed live, but it would have required a choir and more musicians and– here is the crucial part– that would have diluted the attention paid to Freddie.

NME rightly called it “a masterful, if ludicrous, six-minute suite of operatic cock-rock about a lad who’s killed someone, sold his soul to Beelzebub and wants to know if Scaramouche can do the Fandango”.  Well, I’m not sure about “masterful”.  It was really produced by a bunch of engineers in a studio.  It’s not hard, apparently, to convince people that there is something brilliant about that but surely a lot of those people were disappointed when they saw Queen live and they couldn’t do their most famous opera.

You Don’t Have to Put out the Red Light

No matter how desperately you try to imbue the form with substance and meaning and importance, a musical is still just a musical: a ridiculously implausible, trivial, trite, and boring art form.

So with all the raves “Hamilton” received, I think I kind of thought Lin Manuel Miranda was different.  That, like the creators of “Cabaret”, he had found a way to integrate the form into a serious drama with real art to it.  Sadly, I now know that Miranda’s models, his ideals, include “The Little Mermaid”, and “Chicago” and “Moulin Rouge” and “The Bandwagon” and– god help us– Jim Henson’s “Labyrinth”, which I believe is one of the worst movies ever made.  Let me emphasize: it is extremely difficult to reconcile the acclaim given to “Hamilton” with it’s creator’s fondness for one of the worst fantasies, with the worst script, and the most inept direction, ever perpetrated on the screen.

I grew up ridiculing musicals, for obvious reasons: people sing to each other, accompanied by invisible orchestras and choirs, in the middle of what otherwise appears to be a realistic drama.  (The “Wizard of Oz” is different: it is a fantasy set in a fantasy world– it makes “sense” to establish ridiculousness as part of the fantasy landscape.)  But there is more to it than that: most musicals had plot lines that made situation comedies like “My Mother the Car” seem plausible and richly developed.  It seemed to me that the art form itself, the musical, was hospitable to the most heavy-handed, clumsy, contrived expression imaginable.

Just to confirm my views, both “Mary Poppins” and “West Side Story” dubbed the voices of the stars.  I mean, all musicals are dubbed anyway (the songs are recorded in the studio and then lip-synched in front of the cameras).  What kind of artist would use the body of one actress and the voice of another?  The same kind of artistic imagination that would use a drum machine (and today, believe me, they do and they are).

I do not anticipate great things from Miranda.  I think his current projects reveal that “Hamilton” was a bit of a fluke.

 

Decidedly Blue

A few years ago, I saw a movie called “Blue is the Warmest Color” about a lesbian relationship between a younger and (relatively) older woman, which disintegrated as the younger woman decided she was not sure of her sexuality.

It was a beautiful, incandescent film, full of startling sequences of physical intimacy.  It was a landmark.  It attracted favorable critical appreciation, and made it’s two stars famous.

And now we have this.

Why now?  Why not the minute you experienced this harassment?  Why didn’t you leave the set and go to the police?  Why did you wait until the film was released, until it was acclaimed?

And why is the author, Julie Maroh, more concerned about getting recognition for her source material than she is about making her own film, if she really believes she could make a better one?

The Wives

There is a movie coming out soon called “The Wife”.  From the early reviews and synopsis it sounds like this: a great American writer wins the Nobel Prize for literature.  We are assumed to believe that because he is a great writer he must also be a great husband and father, even though nobody I know of, who has any awareness of the biography of any well-known person, would ever assume this.   But, shockingly, we find out that he has been mean and unfaithful, while his loyal and selfless wife has sacrificed her own stellar career to serve as his constant help-meet, washing his clothes, making his meals, cleaning his house, and raising the son who now resents his successful father.  So we are to hate him and admire the plucky woman for, apparently, in the end, finally–finally!– summoning the amazing courage to stand up to him.

We are supposed to be shocked, as I said, that a brilliant writer might be a lousy husband.  We are supposed to find irrelevant any aspects of the wife’s character that might diminish the horror we are to feel.  But then, they don’t tell that story.  In the story I expect, she is faultless.  She’s not manipulative or needy or nagging or petty or vindictive.  She didn’t push him into marriage.  She didn’t spend his money as if she had earned it.   She is just perfect.  It wouldn’t shock me– this is Hollywood– that we find out that she actually wrote all his books.  [I just checked a review: I think I’m correct.  That’s too bad: it would probably have been a more interesting movie if he had been terrified of her, that she would reveal the secret, and she used this dynamic to toy with him.]

And it is incredible how someone in a relationship with such a perfect being could fail to treat her like a goddess.

[When the movie arrives, I’ll see it, and correct my impression if necessary.]

Added January 19, 2019: I have seen the movie now: I was correct.  Pretty well, exactly correct.  Though I think the film-makers thought her nagging of Joe was adorable in some way.  What it reveals is that this story, written by a woman, is really judging Joe as a husband who didn’t appreciate everything his wife did for him.  The fact that she supposedly wrote most of his work– the most preposterous and unbelievable aspect of the story– is incidental to the real point:  he wasn’t nice enough to her.   Or to his son– in the movie, Joe is a prick for not being more supportive.  In real life, of course, we all are especially appreciative of those privileged people who get published because they were related to someone with strings to pull, like Joe Castleman.  (Look at Ingmar Bergman’s daughter, Linn Ullmann, who was extremely wary of attracting readers who were more interested in her famous parents than in her writing.)  The fact that David, the son, doesn’t seem to realize what position he has put his father in — how dare you not recognize my talent!– tells you just how mediocre the thinking behind this film is.

From the start, Joan seems paralyzed by the realization that she has wasted her life devoting herself to a man incapable of even the most momentary act of selflessness.  [Slant]

WTF?  Wait a minute– you are trying to suggest that she is actually an incredibly worthy person because she actually wrote the award-winning books so her husband could take all the honors.  Then you suggest that what really matters is that he wasn’t grateful! 

So Joan is “selfless”?  But if she was– think about this– if she really was selfless, she wouldn’t care.  That is what selflessness is.  But she is in fact very selfish because she expects a considerable amount of gratitude and respect in exchange for the waste of her life.  Her “love” is more like overflowing self-infatuation.  Her view of justice is that now that I’ve done all these things for you, you owe me.

Is the remarkable thing here that a person can be an asshole?  Or that a person can devote her life to serving an asshole and not realize it until she is old?  I’m not sure, in the end, that there is anything to admire about this woman.  Seriously?  You didn’t leave?  Are you an idiot?  Are we now supposed to be moved by your predicament?

It also appears “The Wife” will suggest that the wife would not have received recognition if she had struck out on her own, as a woman, right at the start.  Because the establishment is dominated by men.  But that only matters if she didn’t really care about literature— if it was the recognition that mattered, and the material success.   That men think she is just as good as they are.   Even though she didn’t take any of the steps necessary to become a successful novelist.

Besides, this will be shocking news to Doris Lessing, Shirley Jackson, Patricia Highsmith, Flannery O’Conner, Francoise Sagan, Agatha Christie, Sylvia Plath and others.

Because she’s entitled.

Isn’t that exactly the difference between great artists and mediocre ones?

You think you’re so smart, you men.

It would be a far, far more interesting movie if she didn’t care about the fucking Nobel prize or any other prize: if what she really cared about was writing something beautiful and true, for the satisfaction of those who didn’t care about awards or celebrities or what fucking outfit she was wearing, or if Oprah will have her on, or if men still find her sexually attractive at 50,  but only about the really beautiful and original and profound and true.

Like Doris Lessing.  Or Muriel Spark.  Or Alice Munro.

And I would wager that, in this movie, her outfits are to die for.  Because, she really only cares about real literature.  [They were.  At least, if you care about the fashion.]

It will be irresistible to the Oprah crowd.  Oprah, who wouldn’t make Jonathan Franzen’s novel a book of the month unless he agreed to appear on her show and, frankly, grovel.  He rejected it at first but (after his publishers begged him) finally took the bait and his novel flourished.  I’ll bet, in his own mind, he still can’t wash away the stink.  That, my friends, is a story for a movie.  For a potentially great movie.  For a movie that Hollywood will never make.

Here’s the thing, feminists: if Oprah Winfrey had had a single ounce of real integrity, she would have made Franzen’s book her selection and would have praised him for his refusal to kowtow to narcissistic tv hostesses who wanted to use him to enhance their own prestige.  Well, she wouldn’t have had to go that far to show any class.  It would have been enough to say, “I don’t care if he won’t come on my show: it’s a great book and I want to talk about it and urge all my viewers to read it.”

And is this dynamic supposed to be representative of which spouse takes advantage of which spouses’ abilities?  See Hillary Clinton below.  See Melinda Gates.  See Greta Gerwig.  See Soulpepper.

That’s mainstream Hollywood.  For the adult version of this story– I mean “adult” in the sense that it presents a mature intellectual context– see “Wild Strawberries” by Ingmar Bergman, one of my favorite films of all time.  Or try his “Autumn Sonata” if you want the more likely story.   Or “Scenes From a Marriage” if you can handle complexity.  Or Asghar Farhadi’s  brilliant “A Separation“.  Or even Robert Redford’s “Ordinary People“.  But then, those are not feminist fairy tales.

This in an era where women have accused numerous brilliant men of being monsters because, even though they created great art or produced important products or were very funny, they were not nice to them.  Because even though they took the money, they still feel aggrieved and wronged.   You took the money.  Bill Cosby (whose work I generally can’t stand anyway), Harvey Weinstein, Woody Allen, Al Franken, Jeff Fager, Leslie Moonves, Louis C.K., Albert Schultz.

Steve Jobs is accused of being a lousy dad by his daughter, Lisa Brennan-Jobs.  He was a lousy dad.  He was not nearly the brilliant innovator his acolytes claim, either, but he did something important and significant.  And the role of his daughter’s book is to excoriate him because he was not nice to her.   She is asking you to buy and read her book because you will want to know that he was not nice to her.    Because we all needed to know this, just in case we assumed that because he ran Apple he was also a great husband and father.  Because he didn’t make her a princess.  Because maybe you don’t think she is important enough to merit your attention (whereas, he is).  He didn’t give her his Porsche, even after she asked for it.  He didn’t love her unconditionally.  [Lisa’s book deserves a much more extensive discussion: it’s complex and alternately self-serving and expressive.]  He merely acquired the fame that allows his daughter to write a book and go on the talk shows and talk about me, me, me, and me.

And how mean it was of him to not give her a Porsche.

Therefore, he is not worthy of respect or admiration or awards?  We are supposed to be shocked that a man admired for one thing should not be admired for something else?

Apparently, Brennan-Jobs was concerned that people would believe she was writing a book just to cash in on her relationship with her famous dad.  She should be concerned about that.  It sounds to me like nobody would buy a book by Lisa Brennan-Jobs if the book was not about her father.  That’s not to say she can’t write.  That’s not to say she didn’t have editorial help from the kind of editor you get if your book is assured of big sales and high profile.  And you will be invited onto Oprah, or Ellen, or whoever that audience worships today.

Here’s the problem I have with this.  The implication of #metoo is that the work done by these artists and geniuses is now worthless because they were not nice to their accusers.  The implication is that the sources of these allegations are convinced that we are all under the illusion that because a man is famous for his films or paintings or music or jokes we all assume he was a fine person as well.  We don’t.  We never did.  It was never the point.

So we should fire these men, boycott their films, rescind their honorary titles, retract their Oscars and Grammys and Nobels, and so on?  We should all hate them and declare that we are no longer moved by their art, or amused by their jokes?

While some of the most famous musicians of all time may be our favorite idols, it can be easy to forget that they’re not as great as we build them up to be. Yes, they may make amazing music, but that doesn’t necessarily make them a good person.  From Here

What?!  It is “easy to forget” that they might be assholes?  We’re supposed to be shocked to find out that even artist might be jerks?

You people think this guy is great? Well, he was very mean to me, so that proves he is not great.  And he wanted to have sex with me– he saw me as an object, so he is now subhuman and I get to decide when he has paid enough for his monstrous sins.

Dylan Farrow displays conspicuous anger directed towards people who continue to regard Woody Allen as a great director.  What about me?  He treated me badly, so he’s not so great.  Why do you keep saying “Manhattan” was a great film?

Because “Manhattan” was wildly greater than anything you will ever do in your entire life.  Especially if your claim to fame is that you were a victim.

And Greta Gerwig, who was delighted to star in a Woody Allen film when it helped her career, now says she would never do it again.  Really?  I don’t believe her.  (There are women who now insist that Gerwig’s “Lady Bird” is as good as a Woody Allen film– no, better.  It’s not true, not even close.   “Lady Bird” will be completely forgotten in a year; “Manhattan”, “Crimes and Misdemeanors”, “Annie Hall”, “Hannah and Her Sisters” will endure.)

It’s an odd equation.  I can’t find a good analogy for it.  Is “Manhattan” now a bad film?  Should we remove all the Picasso’s from our art galleries?  Should we stop watching the only serious prime-time news program on the big three networks, “60 Minutes”?

Is the equation this: your novels, your movies, your music doesn’t matter, because you were mean to me.

It is the argument of a narcissist.

I don’t mean to use the word “mean” in a demeaning way.  That is, in a way that minimizes the seriousness of the offenses.  In some cases, like Woody Allen, I don’t believe the allegations at all.  In other cases, like Weinstein, I believe he was exactly the kind of creepy, awful person it is claimed.  So does that mean “Thin Blue Line”, “Sex, Lies, and Videotape” (the most aptly named of Weinstein’s films), “Tie Me Up, Tie Me Down”, The Cook, the Thief, His Wife & Her Lover”, “The English Patient”, “Pulp Fiction”, “Clerks”, “Shakespeare in Love”, “Good Will Hunting”, and so on… are now crummy films?

The people accusing Albert Schultz of improprieties did not go out and found their own theatrical group, find donors and raise money, build a theatre, develop training programs, select plays, develop talent, arrange a New York tour, and win awards for their productions.  No, they deposed him and then took over Soulpepper, which is entirely the result of Albert Schultz’ visionary work.  Does nobody at least find this distasteful?  Are those women now parading around going, “look at this great theatre company we made!  You’re welcome!”

The people who took over “Q” on CBC are benefiting, to an overwhelming degree, from the pioneering work performed by– like him or not– (I always found him a contemptible sycophant) Jian Ghomeshi.  If the CBC had meant to be honorable, they should have cancelled the program, and taken the hit in ratings.  Instead, they are cashing in on the format and style and memes that Ghomeshi brought to the program while pissing all over his reputation.

And I find the name “The Bill and Melinda Gates” foundation a bit cheesy.  Bill Gates– whom I regard as an asshole for what he did to computing-– built a gigantic software company that dominates the entire world of computing.  Melinda Gates married a man who built the company that dominates the entire world of computing.  So their accomplishments merit equal recognition in the name of the foundation?  Without a doubt, Melinda Gates will share innumerable awards for handing out her husband’s money.  And she shares equal billing on the foundation even though her contribution to the funding that gives it all of its cache is exactly zilch.

(Bill Gates is a unique case: he is widely and mistakenly admired for his personal character and for his material success.  His charitable work is admirable, but I refuse to let him off the hook for the damage he did to the progress of computers for at least ten years.  I believe he did for software what Harvey Weinstein is alleged to have done for actresses).

Fortunately, Bill Gates reserved his predatory behavior for other software companies, like Word Perfect and Novell and Lotus and Geoworks and Vermeer Technologies, and not women.  So this is not about #metoo.  Well, it is.  It’s about women asserting that there is something about themselves that is just as valuable and just as admirable as the accomplishments of the men they were attached to.  But there is a similar equation going on here: why should the wife share the recognition?  Why should Bill Gates get all the love when I’m his wife.  I’m just as good.  I’m just as important.  The foundation should have my name on it.  Because I help run it.  With Bill’s money.

For the same reason, I annoyed some of my female friends by complaining about the fact that the wife of a former President was running for president.  I found it bizarre.  Is the U.S. like those tin pot dictatorships in the 60’s and 70’s in Latin America?  This is Eva Peron territory.   This is Isabel Peron territory.  This is Imelda Marcos territory.   This is Rosario Murillo territory.  This is Mary Bono territory.

Why on earth, in a nation of 350 million people, could the Democratic Party have found no one to nominate for president except for Bill Clinton’s wife?  It’s absurd.  It was Bill who ran for governor, and then president, and won, and served for 8 years.  So Hillary stepped up and said, well, I’m his wife.   I should be Senator from New York.  And then, I should be Secretary of State.  And then, I should be president.  I am entitled to be president.  And several of my acquaintances really insisted that, remarkably, the most qualified person to be president of the United States was the wife of the former President of the United States.

She came along and jumped to the front of the parade, because that’s where her husband, who started in the back and actually worked his way to the front, was now marching.  And then she brought along Kirsten Gillibrand, mentored her, supported her move into politics, came out with Bill to support her candidacy to the House of Representatives, pulled strings to get her appointed to  her vacant Senate seat, raised money for her, only to have Gillibrand turn around and smear Bill Clinton during the #metoo campaign.  Once again, a woman riding on a man’s coattails (Bill Clinton->Hillary->Kirsten) acts as if her position was entirely or even mostly the result of her own hard work and determination.  Bill Clinton stood in my way.

Now, somebody is going to claim that Bill Clinton would never have got as far as he did without Hillary.  Bullshit.  Hillary was smart, well-educated, and would have been an exceptional lawyer.  She was also interchangeable with any number of smart, educated, talented women.  On her own, she did nothing particularly unique, other than bungling the Clinton health-care initiative.  Bill Clinton was not interchangeable; Hillary Clinton was.

I think sooner or later a balancing will occur and people will recognize that just because a famous man was an asshole– and many of them were– doesn’t mean that his accomplishments were not remarkable.

And we know that no biographical movie or book is going to give you the chapter showing these women suggesting, politely, discretely, ever so seductively, and persistently, to their husbands, that they be given prestigious positions in their company, foundation, or party, ahead of all the other employees, campaign workers, artists, and political staff who worked their entire lives to get to that position.  They won’t mind: I’m your wife.

No more than the latest “Star is Born” is going to show you Ally begging Jackson Maine to give her a slot on stage.  No, no, no– the convention that is required here is that she is begged to perform because the star is indisposed or no one else can do it, and besides, the backup band just adores you– they know you are really fantastic, and the audience– they didn’t need to be told by the director to give you a standing ovation– they just felt it!

No, because it would be a dead giveaway to the audience if you were to ask for it.  It must be deserved, not weaseled for.

Or Consider

Vanity and Barbara Walters

What’s Wrong with Windows?

How Microsoft Killed Geoworks

 

[whohit]The Wives[/whohit]

The Settlements

Harvey Weinstein is a jerk.

As reported in the New York Times, he often invited women looking for work in the movie industry up to his “luxury suites” for a meeting and then would hit on them.  By most accounts, he didn’t exactly use force, but he clearly didn’t want to wait until a deep friendship had been established before asking for sexual favors.  Several women, including Sarah Polley, have reported that he attempted to initiate something with them and they refused and walked away.  When the other women complained and threatened to report him, he offered them money.  A lot of the women took the money, in exchange for which they signed non-disclosure agreements.

It is highly probable that some women acquiesced.   There might be some uncomfortable attempts to come to terms with the compromises made, which, in effect, enabled further abuse.   [See Salma Hayek]  It is probable that some of those women received choice roles in Miramax films.  This will be an uncomfortable issue in the future for some people, though, so far, nobody has named them.

In the article linked above, Bari Weiss thinks that Weinstein should release these women from the non-disclosure agreements they signed so they can speak out.    Nowhere does she suggest the obvious corollary: that they return the money.  That is a glaring omission and one I think she might regret eventually: to accept the money and then proceed to break the agreement would be repugnant, though in today’s culture it would probably be readily dispensed with by the media.  To accept the money in the first place, in exchange for not alerting other women to the possibility of harassment, was also, probably, repugnant.  Weiss wants to argue that the agreements were illegitimate in some way, and that the women are entitled, therefore, to break them.  But they took the money, and that cannot bed swept conveniently under the carpet.

In essence, they agreed not to blow Weinstein’s cover, and prevent him from exploiting other actresses, in exchange for a large sum of money.  Nobody wants to discuss that.

She also suggests that there is hypocrisy out there because Weinstein won’t receive the same treatment as Bill O’Reilly or Roger Ailes received from the liberal establishment, because Mr. Weinstein is a well-established liberal icon and fund-raiser.  [2018-09: obviously she was wrong about that.]

It’s always poor form to make assumptions like that.  You get to make your rhetorical flourish and feel all pious and righteous about it without having to actually wait and see if your accusations are true.

But the first issue is this bullshit idea that Roger Ailes and Bill O’Reilly suffered any real consequences at all for their behaviour towards women.  Like Harvey Weinstein, they paid off most of the women who made allegations against them.  And, as in the case of Harvey Weinstein, most of the women accepted the money and agreed not to warn other women about these gentlemen in exchange for cash.

We know all about the consequences suffered by Donald Trump after allegations of his harassment of women came forwards: nada.  Not a thing.  Not a blessed thing.

So perhaps Weiss is publishing in the wrong forum here: you need to get on Fox News and find out why so many women– especially, good Christian evangelicals– went ahead and voted for Trump anyway.

I might add that there is another difference: Ailes and O’Reilly are both stalwarts of the allegedly “family values” party, the Republicans, and have long been advocating for a return to “traditional values” in America, to abstinence instead of birth control, to “character” development instead of gratification, to valued institutions instead of self-fulfillment, and so on.  They proclaim their alliance with evangelical Christians who don’t seem to believe what they say about sexual morality, unless it concerns a Democrat like Bill Clinton.

It always was obvious that conservatives believe that everyone should live by those values, except themselves.

Which leads to this question: what of the women that accepted these payouts from The Weinstein Company rather than reporting the behavior?

Reporting to whom?

Take note of this, from NYTimes 2017-10-10, offered as an indictment:

Zelda Perkins

In 1998, Ms. Perkins, then a 25-year-old assistant in London,
confronted Mr. Weinstein over his alleged harassment and threatened
to go public or take legal action if it continued, according to former
colleagues. A lawyer for Mr. Weinstein was later dispatched to
negotiate a settlement with her.

Which she accepted.

Which, yes, makes her complicit.  And which has not adduced any critical comments whatsoever from Bari Weiss or Amy Schumer or any of the other women who are insisting that women don’t have to not be complicit to be innocent of this tacit arrangement.  It hasn’t even stopped them from calling Ms. Perkins “courageous” even though she accepted the pay-off.  The “courageous” thing to do would have been to say, “I will never accept money in order to hide your criminal behavior.  That would allow you to victimize others.  I’m calling the police”.

But isn’t Ms. Perkins in dangerous territory there?  We are told over and over again that the women should be believed and that men who try to discount their allegations by alleging that they are seeking a payout are wrong.  But if you accept the money, are you not validating the charge?  Are you not agreeing to deceive people in exchange for money?  You weren’t seeking money, but you took it anyway?

Weinstein’s behavior may have been ugly and offensive, but I doubt that it really crossed a line into criminality.   He was a hustler and a pig and disgusting.  Some of the women might be able to show that their careers didn’t advance after they refused him, but some women, like Gwyneth Paltrow,  can show that their careers advanced very quickly at Weinstein’s organization after the incident.

Without a doubt, a lot of established feminist opinion believes that Weinstein’s behavior was “criminal”.   I don’t.  I believe the women should have walked away or told him off and reported it to the media and to other employees and the board of the organization: not to the police.  Weinstein would easily have been deterred very quickly if thought that most women in the situation he placed them in would be likely to report his actions.

But at least some of the women accepted money instead in exchange for silence– or acquiesced to his wishes.  Or obtained good roles in films he controlled.

We now have the gruesome process– which we were spared in the cases of O’Reilly and Ailes– of Weinstein toadying to the cultural avatars and proclaiming how he will reform himself, get therapy (oh please!), and donate to good causes.  And various female politicians declaring that they will take the money he donated to their campaigns and forward it to charities instead of using it to get elected.

I don’t blame him entirely for the absurd “therapy” angle he’s putting out there: the absurdity comes from the social entities who really believe in that crap.  He’s just following the script and I’d almost admire him more if he would just say, “look, I’m a creep, but explain to me why they accepted the money and I’ll explain to you why I didn’t stop”.

[whohit]The NDAs[/whohit]

The Scream

“The Work” is a searing documentary about a program at Folsom Prison to get men imprisoned for violent crimes to face their deepest anxieties and grievances about their past, their absent fathers, brothers who betrayed them, and so on, in a kind of large psycho-therapy session moderated by social workers and joined by volunteers from the community, and largely led by the inmates themselves.

Filmed in 2009 but not released until 2017. Frighteningly raw at times– and not to everyone’s taste. You can see some of the volunteers hang back, then get drawn into the confessional style confrontations.  Violent fathers.  Absent fathers.  Abusive fathers.  Fathers who expected too much or too little.

Then one of the volunteers reluctantly recounts how his father was disappointed in him for fetching the wrong tool several times, and then sent him into the house. This is transformed by some of the inmates into some kind of traumatic thing that contaminated the volunteer’s relationship with his father, though it seems more likely it was and remained trivial. No, no, you’re concealing a deeper wound.  It must come out.  It was a strange sequence.

Other sequences are more intense, in which a person howls and thrashes his outrage while embraced tightly by the other men. One volunteer, Brian, says something condescending that really aggravates an inmate.  He seems to actually believe he should be automatically respected by these men because he is smart and wise and together.  They hate him.  Later, he calls a native inmate, Dark Cloud, “gentle”, which he misinterprets as an insult.  Dark Cloud lunges at him, prevented by the other inmates.  Just how suitable was Brian for the experience?  Didn’t they screen?

At times, searingly compelling. It is claimed that none of 40 men who went through the program returned to prison. I remain skeptical. I see some of this kind of programming as similar to faith healing and charismatic church services, speaking in tongues, and so on. It’s all very dramatic and full of lingo, but is there any real evidence that, 1) all of the experiences related by the participants are real or true, and, 2) that any of it is really therapeutic, at least, in the way the conveners think it is.

It is not difficult to imagine that the love and acceptance these men express towards each other doesn’t make them less dangerous to anyone outside of their artificially created circle of trust. Implicit in all of this is the suggestion that these men committed crimes primarily as a consequence of a deprived or abused childhood. If you are in this circle, you seem obligated to come up with something and to cry and to thrash and scream, and it would not be hard to imagine a deprived participant making something up, or exaggerating, in order to fit in.

I’m not sure it doesn’t work.  Maybe, for it’s own reasons, it does.

When the volunteer relates about his dad’s frustration with his inability to find the right tool, he also adds that he feels guilt over bringing this relatively trivial issue up among men who have experienced genuine trauma, but the men will have none of it.  They like him.  They urge him on to confront his trauma-inducing father, to weep and thrash, and break through, and confront him (one of the inmates role-plays for him).   It’s a moment in the film that is nearly comical and made me think of a potential SNL skit, which some might think disrespectful.

Yes, it is.  But let’s be clear: in my mind, it doesn’t diminish the real emotions felt by the inmates, or their expressions of rage.

 

[whohit]The Scream[/whohit]

Ronan Farrow, Sit Down and Shutup

Well, now it’s CBS News and 60 Minutes.

At Last: Someone Takes a Closer Look at Ronan Farrow’s Journalistic Credibility

Stop everything you’re doing, all the research and investigation and interviews, travel, exploration, documentation and exposure– stop it all and resign and crawl into a hole, because Ronan Farrow has managed to find some former female employees and associates who didn’t like the way you hit on them.  No matter how long ago, or how disputed, or how misinterpreted or misjudged, or how marginal it is to whatever it is you do with your life, you must now resign, because the almighty, pitiless, puritanical Inquisitor Ronan Farrow, son of Frank or Woody– we don’t know– has deemed you to be shriek-worthy and foul and you must be replaced by some woman or transgender woman or man or gay man or gay woman or black transgender gay indigenous being, because he or she or it is really just as talented and hardworking as you, but you, oppressor, bully, monster!— kept him, her, or it from fulfilling the great destiny worthy of his, her, or it’s talents, by kissing without permission, by expressing your desire for him, her, or it, by leaning too close, by initiating sex with her, him, or it while he, her, or it was asleep.

By not asking politely, in writing, before hand, if you could say to them, “you are hot– I’d like to have sex with you.”

Let us gather a red cloak for Ronan Farrow and  begin the purge of our libraries and museums and art galleries,  and let us expunge all the works, the films, the books, the paintings, the sculptures, the music, the podcasts, the radio programs, by all the horrible men who made them, who created the models we use today, who inspired generations of other artists, who moved us, who wrought the world of culture– let us take all their works and burn them.  For it doesn’t matter and never mattered that you actually built or created or invented or led or organized or directed– it never mattered at all.  It doesn’t matter that you saw beauty or truth in a gesture, an expression, a conversation, a shape, a way of describing a scene.  None of your acts of compassion or generosity, or wit, or improvisation, or imagination can now be countenanced: you must be expelled from human society!

The only thing that mattered, ever, is that in one of the millions of small moments of your life, you offended one of God’s dainty little angels who, though gentle and delicate and innocent, and helpless, when roused, is mighty and bold and courageous and will now speak out and tell her story!  On Oprah, if possible, or Jerry Springer, if necessary!   Now that it is safe to do so.   That is enough.  It erases everything else you were or could be.  And it makes a monument of courage and genius of the accuser, who never had any such courage or genius when it was all that would have been required for her, to turn around and spit in your face and say “no” and leave.

Let’s replace them all with Ronan Farrow’s scribbles.  Or the films written and directed by Mia Farrow.  Or Illeana Douglas’s exposes.  Or Kirsten Gillibrand’s mountains of legislation.

[whohit]Ronan Farrow: Please Shutup[/whohit]