Cool Hand Luke as the Evil Twin of Shawshank Redemption

I hope some lovers of “Shawshank” will take the time some day to watch “Cool Hand Luke”. To me, “Luke” is everything “Shawshank” thinks it is but is not. “Luke” explores the function of hero worship in a society of losers and miscreants, how they make him a sacrificial substitute for their own fears and inadequacies, and how, when he forces them to face the reality of their own weaknesses, they must destroy him. And then, once he is safely expelled, they re-imagine him as the avatar of their own fantasies of power and defiance. It is a fascinating film, and a comment on the type of heroism expressed in “Shawshank”. I call “Luke” the “evil” twin of “Shawshank”, in the sense that it incisively undermines the fundamental myth of the latter, the same way “The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie”, in my opinion, destroys the mythic con of “Dead Poets Society” by showing you the real implications of a charismatic teacher who develops a cadre of followers among his students.

The story:  It is 1948.  Luke (Lucas) Jackson is introduced to us as a miscreant, a rebellious young man who takes a pipe cutter to the parking meters in a small town somewhere and is arrested and sentenced to a work prison.  He is tested by the other inmates, particularly Dragline, to see how tough he is.   When he refuses to knuckle under to the established hierarchy in prison, he arouses the dislike of Dragline, the reigning tough.  But when he proves to be very, very defiant, even challenging Dragline to a boxing match (which he loses, very badly)  the other prisoners begin to admire him.  When he bets that he can eat 50 hard-boiled eggs, and wins,  he becomes a hero and even Dragline acknowledges his preeminence.  At a card game, he successfully bluffs a very weak hand and earns the nickname, “Cool Hand” Luke.

He persuades the other prisoners to put maximum effort into a road-building task.  To their own surprise, they finish the job early and get a break from the guards.

When he is denied a temporary release to see his mother before she dies, he bides his time and then escapes, and the admiration of the other prisoners knows no bounds.  Dragline, in particular, idolizes him and never tires of recounting his exploits which grow bigger and bigger with each telling.

“What we have here, is failure to communicate”.  It’s a wonderful scene: the prison warden, having attended a seminar somewhere, seems genuinely, twistedly well-meaning: if you would just obey and respect us, your life would be miserable, yes, but we wouldn’t have to beat you.  They beat him relentlessly sure that they will break him.  And they do.  He becomes so docile and respectful that they make him a “trustee”, and the other prisoners begin to hold him in contempt.  As they relax the strictures around him, Luke breaks free one more time.  Dragline, seizing the opportunity, and intoxicated with Luke’s audaciousness, joins him, only to realize, shortly afterwards, that with only two years left on his sentence, it was stupid decision.

Spoiler alert: the police do catch up with Luke, thanks to a betrayal but the Judas of this film, Dragline.  It is clear that this time the warden does not intend to take him alive.  Dragline does survive, however, to regale his fellow prisoners with his selective rendering of Luke’s defiance and courage.

The summary you will find on the IMDB then ends with “Luke managed to unmask the injustice and hypocrisy of the system in which he was confined… in the final analysis, he could not be broken by the system”.

Did this person really watch the film?  Did he get it?  It is a very common misapprehension of “Cool Hand Luke”.  Most people seem to come away with the idea that Luke was heroic for standing up to brutal, ignorant authority.  I don’t think the movie is really about that.  It is really about how  the role of myth in our culture, how our “heroes” become substitutes for own responsibility for our own freedom and dignity.  Dragline and the other prisoners have surrendered their individuality and self-respect in exchange for a slightly less toxic life in the prison camp.  They have given up something of enormous importance in exchange for a trinket.

You Can Have it Back

The U.S. is now negotiating with the Taliban to return the nation to some kind of hybrid administration that gives a significant amount of power to our former arch-foes.  The current government of Afghanistan is not invited to these talks.  Can there be a more anxious government in the world right now than the government of Afghanistan?

In other words, after almost 20 years of war and the loss of thousands of lives, we are going to restore things to exactly the way they were when we started.

The U.S. has lost this war.  It will never publicly admit it, but it has lost the war in Afghanistan and it is finally going to leave, but not before adding insult to injury.  The Taliban has no interest in a pluralistic, representative government.  They have no interest in the rights of girls and women to an education or any other choice.   Once the U.S. is gone, they will extract revenge on all who opposed them, including the thousands of Afghani volunteers who joined the police forces– at great risk– for $300 U.S. a month.  They will almost certainly drive out their coalition partners and establish a repressive Islamic regime, like the one they had before the U.S. invaded, and after they drove out the Soviets.

Will anybody responsible for this disaster ever be held to account?  The George W. Bush Presidential Library still stands.  Dick Cheney’s daughter sits in Congress.  Rumsveld?  Wolfowitz?  Richard Perle?  Probably serving on boards of large corporations for hugh sums of money?

The dead?  They remain dead and buried and mourned by their families and loved ones who think Colin Kaepernick should just go and piss off.  We are patriotic.  We invite you to use us.  We invite you to offer our bodies as a sacrifice to your political career.  They will name a freeway after you.  They will bury our fathers, brothers, sons, daughters, wives, and sisters under the freeway.

 

 

So Then You Shoot…

In his decision, Judge Norman determined that the officer “cannot be expected to coolly engage in a protracted analysis of all the information known to him in a rapidly changing circumstance, putting the officer in the position of having to make an immediate choice.”  NY Times

This is the fascinating rationale– part of it– offered by Mickey J. Norman of Baltimore County Circuit Court– to justify rescinding a $38 million award to the family of Korryn Gaines who, while being served with a summons for a traffic offense, and in the company of her 5-year-old son, was shot to death by Officer Royce Ruby (who has since been promoted).

This is about the source of the judge’s rationale: a Supreme Court judgement.  And here again we have an interesting interpretation of facts and law which clearly implies that the police have the right to shoot any person who approaches them, period.  Think about it.  That is all the woman did.  She didn’t have a gun or a weapon of any sort.  She called the police asking for help.  She went to meet the police she called.  They shot her dead.  The courts say– with impunity.  The article notes that many police forces now actually train their officers to act with impunity– in essence.  The law will be interpreted to mean that anybody approaching any officer at any time under any circumstance can be shot because you can’t expect the officer to exercise any kind of judgement in a situation that could be interpreted to consist of a “rapidly changing circumstance”.  The woman approached the car.  She got closer.  That was a “rapidly changing circumstance”.

It is curious that the court did not do any math.  How many times a day does an officer face a “rapidly changing circumstances”?  How many every week, month, year?  The court says you could shoot anyone in range at any of those times, with impunity.  What if the court had said, as they should have, you may never shoot unless you are reasonably certain that a real imminent threat to life and limb exists?  If you are uncertain, you don’t shoot.  That simple.  If you don’t like that rule, don’t apply to be a police officer.

The court imposes no obligation upon a police officer to exercise good judgment.  It is enough that the circumstances changed–  “rapidly” — in the estimation of the police officer who was so weak and frightened and incompetent that his only choice was to draw a revolver and shoot.  Frank Hamer would be proud.

I suspect that the judge had decided to rescind the award before he even heard any details about the case.  I suspect that, because, when you read the rationale, above, you realize that you could invent such a rationale to justify a police officer entering your home without a warrant and shooting you to death in your bed.  Because you might have a handgun under your pillow and an officer “cannot be expected to coolly engage in a protracted analysis of all the information known to him in a rapidly changing circumstance”.

Amazingly, the judge did not conclude that the police should avoid “rapidly changing circumstances” or withdraw from them, to prevent a potentially fatal conflict.  No, if a police officer encounters a “rapidly changing circumstance” he can go ahead and shoot somebody and then count on judges like Mickey J. Norman to exempt them from any responsibility.

Remember that Ms. Gaines lost her life over a traffic ticket.  Without the overdue traffic fines, there would have been no police invasion, and no shooting.  No “rapidly changing circumstances”.

There is a certain constituency out there who will argue that if she would have just obeyed the police, she would be alive today.   It was her own fault.  This argument assumes that our freedoms do not belong to us, but are granted only at the discretion of the police and the authorities.   That is the definition of a police state, of a dictatorship.   Furthermore, it assumes that no matter how trivial the offense for which the police are attempting to apprehend someone, the police in that situation are justified in using lethal force.

If I had been the judge in that case, for that reason alone– the relatively trivial nature of the offense– I would have wanted to make a very clear statement to the public and the police that the justice system will not tolerate rogue police officers killing people over traffic tickets.

The defense argues that it was not the traffic ticket.  It was the fact that she resisted arrest.  And I would say that it is a monstrous exchange here.  If our society had to make a choice between collecting overdue traffic fines and the life of a young mother, rationality would prevail and we would find some other more proportionate way to encourage people to obey the rules of the road.

Progress

Devolution

Ralph Northam

When the Ralph Northam “scandal” broke, I had several discussions with acquaintances and friends who were all convinced he should resign.  I didn’t agree.  I felt that anybody can do something stupid when they are young and it shouldn’t be held against you thirty-five years later.  In that time period, Mr. Northam left college, got a job, became a doctor, married, had children, went into politics, and eventually rose to the office of governor of Virginia.  But he did a stupid thing in university.  To demand his resignation is disproportionate to both the scale of the incident and the amount of time that has passed.

There is also something I don’t like about the self-righteous outrage expressed by many– but not all– on the subject.  Especially when some of that outrage comes from people with skeletons in their own closets.

I won my argument– a rare thing, you know– with one person.  I browsed through my collection of photos from college.  There, in 1975, Halloween, was a picture of a good friend of ours in blackface, posing as a slave, accompanied by a black girl in whiteface, posing as a southern belle.  I showed it to her.

Nobody then or now could seriously have regarded this man as a racist.  In fact, he was consistently liberal and progressive and got along well with the blacks on campus (which is more than you could say from a lot of the other white students there).  In fact, the black girl who played the southern belle worked with him in the cafeteria.  They got along so well they pulled this stunt together.

I wanted to post the picture on Facebook to show my friends that it is quite possible for a decent, progressive human being to make a mistake.  I am not even sure it was a mistake: there was nothing in his performance that was meant to mock blacks or slavery.  It made light of it to some extent but only a ridiculous person would have believed that this gentleman actually thought slavery was no big deal.  As I said, he was one of the most consistently progressive minds on campus.  Yet there he is, in blackface.  It was Halloween.  Have you ever used the costume of a horrible person at a Halloween party?  Jack the Ripper, maybe?  Cleopatra?  Gypsy Rose Lee?

One of the people who disagreed with me about Northam was convinced.  And very alarmed that I might post the picture: he could get fired from his current very responsible position if they found out about the photo.  I was convinced, not because the picture was really damaging, but because ignorant people might really demand that he resign his job.

 


To those who say they are able to “forgive” him, but he should still resign…

Whatever it is you think you are offering Ralph Northam, it is not really “forgiveness”. Call it something else. According to the bible, if someone stole your coat and you caught him and sent him to prison for it, and then announced that you forgave him– he is released. Because to “forgive” means to absolve of any obligation incurred as a result of a transgression. I like that meaning. I think we could use more of it. And I strongly believe that if you forgive Mr. Northam, then you are done with the issue and we move on.

If you want him to resign, you have not forgiven him.  You are vindictive.  You want to make him suffer more consequences.

You want to punish him.

You want him to pay.

Own it.

So Kamala Harris apologizes for her history as a nasty prosecutor.  Well, Democrats– be consistent!  You MUST resign your seat.  You really seem to be very sorry for it.  Your apology seems insincere and contrived, calculated to save your position, not to express real remorse.

Your apology counts for nothing.

It is not accepted.  It’s not enough.  You must pay and pay and pay for your offense, until the mob of  little purity fairies surrounded by microphones had decided they have had enough.  Never!  Quit the race!  Leave!  You are finished!  You are despicable!  Anybody could have known it was wrong and you didn’t!

Inception

[Someone got there first— I fully agree with this guy except for his reference to Leonardo DiCaprio as an “actor”.]

If your mind was blown by the movie “Inception” you may not want to keep reading.  But I beg you to look up a movie called “Wings of Desire” and watch it carefully and then ask yourself if “Inception” ever was anything but a sequence of suggestive disconnected strings of shit.

Dominic Cobb is allegedly a brilliant man, but, played by Leonardo DiCaprio, the suspense about that is over in a flash: he is actually an utterly self-absorbed nimrod, a dink, a twerp, a pretentious little wienie.  But the film thinks you believe he is profound, so let’s proceed.  Nimrod Cobb is allegedly the greatest dream hacker in the world.  He is able to insert himself into someone’s dream.   In order to convince you that Cobb is actually a deeply sensitive, intelligent, thoughtful man, we learn that there is a MYSTERIOUS reason why he no longer does the dream extraction himself, which makes it inevitable, in this lame plot, that he will.  A Japanese man named Saito hires Cobb to penetrate his own dream, in order to test his ability.  What he really wants him to do is penetrate the head of Robert Fischer, son of the owner of a company Saito wants to see broken up.

So Cobb assembles his dreamy team of people we are supposed to believe are amazing, because we are told they are, through casting and lighting and camera angle and music.  They are Eames, a conman and identity forger; Yusuf, a chemist who concocts a powerful sedative, an achievement so startling it’s hard to credit it in this movie; and Ariadne, an architecture student who is so brilliant, well… well, she just is, damn it: and she is played with pouty discipline by Ellen Page, one of the least likable actresses in the movies.   When she is recruited, she doesn’t even know that hijacking someone’s dream is possible, but somehow she acquires the ability to construct architectural landscapes within the dream.  The connection between technique and theory here is so absurd I wonder how any audience could have sustained the suspension of disbelief required to enjoy it.

Ariadne indulges in some “dream-sharing” with Domie.  She founds out he’s really very, very deep because he has a very dark, very mysterious, deep, dark, dark, mysterious secret, involving DEATH.  There.  Are you fucking intrigued?  This is going to be very deep.

Is the idea that Dom wants to go home sensible?  Home is where?  I’m going to reread the plot summary to see if I figure out what the movie thinks I want to think about Dominic’s home.  My theory is that it’s just a generic touchstone to evoke cookie-cutter emotional links to something like real feelings.

Anyway, the older Fischer dies and Robert flies to Los Angeles with the body, so the team, including Saito– seriously, the buyer wants to participate?–  fuck this — sedate Fischer and “take” him into a dream, which has various levels, apparently.  Why?  Because you can do more special effects and chase scenes, which adds time to the thin plot, as far as I know.  At each level, one member of the team hangs around to make sure the other members, who are “deeper” into other dream levels, can get back.  Again, isn’t that wonderful metaphor for something?  No, it isn’t.

So they break into Fischer’s head but they are attacked, because if the concept of the film isn’t stupid enough for you, Fischer has actually prepared for this invasion by implanting body guards in his own dreams.  Like you do when planning your summer vacation.

Saito comes with them.  Yes, I’m not kidding.  And he is “wounded” in the dream, which means he might not wake up.  “Of course,” you think.  “The powerful sedatives needed to stabilize the multi-level dream will instead send a dying dreamer into ‘limbo’, a world of infinite subconscious”.  Come on, people, you can be serious with this shit, can you?  This is your favorite movie?

You know what– I’m not even going to bother.  “Inception” is so infantile, obvious, and shallow that it does not deserve another word.

 

 

Self-Approval Ratings

One of the most perplexing polls in the currently political climate is the one showing that only about 20% of Americans approve of the job Congress is doing.  About 80% disapprove.

How can that be?  Did we not just have an election?  Did you not vote?  How on earth did the wrong candidate manage to usurp your candidate’s seat?

Oh.  Nobody usurped anything here.  The guy you voted for won.  Now you tell me he makes you vomit.  He is a failure.  You hate him.  You hate him even more than the president.

But this is not possible.  You have a democracy.  The majority wins.  You chose this Congress.  You’re obviously a masochist.

 

The Meaning of Facts

In his highly entertaining book, The Seven Types of Atheism, released in October in the U.S., philosopher John Gray puts it this way: “Religion is an attempt to find meaning in events, not a theory that tries to explain the universe.” It exists because we humans are the only species, so far as we can know, who have evolved to know explicitly that, one day in the future, we will die. And this existential fact requires some way of reconciling us to it while we are alive.   Andrew Sullivan in The Intelligencer.

The obvious question is, how can an event be meaningful if you don’t believe there is any meaning to all events– to the random conglomeration of events and things and ideas make up the universe?  If you can’t explain the universe, what meaning could an individual event have?  Other than, as some agnostics would have it, part of a life that is no less wonderful and amazing because it is limited to our lived experiences?

If you see an ant crawling along a box car, you could say that it is trying to get to a certain location.  Does that matter if the boxcar is going somewhere else?  Is the ant’s purposeful journey meaningful, if he can never possibly get back to his nest, or the food he is looking for?

Conversely, if an event is meaningful because it is part of a narrative of your relationship with an almighty creator, then how can you not draw conclusions about the nature of the universe from the meaning that you give your life?

 

Note to Andrew Sullivan

Something in Churchill resisted. There’s a factually ridiculous but dramatically powerful scene when Winston jumps out of his official car and into the tube, where the passengers greet him first with British politeness (no mass selfies back then), and then begin a conversation.  Andrew Sullivan.

Are you kidding me?  Even Andrew Sullivan is on-board for that ridiculous scene, and outright fabrication, designed to appeal to soft heads and mushy hearts?  Oh, the people support me, even if the elites have doubts!  Because the people are right!

Those same people, those salts of the earth, embraced Mr. Hitler too.  Sullivan admits that he got emotional and tearful as he watched the scene.  Seriously?  I knew immediately that it was staged precisely because it played so well into the cliche about a celebrated leader being closer to the pulse of the average guy than to the “elites”.  And these average guys were portrayed as unpretentious, hard-working, in possession of hearty souls.

And you got all tearful about it?

 

 

Bill’s Oscar Rules

Sometimes movie reviewers reach for the heights: “But even without knowledge of the artist’s life, the photos step beyond neo-kitsch into a realm where child-like transference merges with a dramatic grandeur to create both a feeling of vintage Hollywood artifice and authentic pathos.”

Whoosh! Thank you Village Voice!  From a review of the documentary “Marwencol”, the film that inspired the new Steve Carrell movie “Marwen”. It’s about a man who suffered a severe beating which caused permanent brain damage. He retreats into a marvelous world of G.I. Joe and Barbie dolls, that act as a kind of therapy for him. Hope the Carrell treatment is as good as the documentary.

And remember the well-known rules for Oscars:

  1. accents  preferably Polish
  2. Nazis and victims of Nazis
  3. a disability
  4. a white person enduring terrible obstacles in defiance of racist authority

Other Oscar rules–

  • the Scorcese rule: you made a brilliant masterpiece we overlooked at the time so we now give you an Oscar for a later mediocre film to make up for our previous misjudgment
  • The DiCaprio rule: You are trying so hard and it’s so obvious and we’re sick of it all so here, take your damn Oscar
  • the Spielberg rule: you got famous making shallow, popular films and now you did a holocaust film to show you are really capable of being serious so we must give you the Oscar
  • And the Amy Adams-Scarlett Johanson-Jennifer Lawrence rule: you gave a brilliant performance in your first film so we knew you were very good but we had to wait for you to be in a big-budget, heavily promoted, commercial Hollywood film before we could give you the Oscar for a far less interesting performance.

The films were “Junebug”, “Ghost World”, and “Winter’s Bone”.  Check them out.

Biological Annihilation

This sneaky little article in the New York Times seem to come out of nowhere– as the authors observed.  No one’s paying attention.  We better start.

It begins with observable detail.  If you are old enough, you will remember the annoying task of cleaning bugs off the windshield of your car after a drive in the country.  I remember it.  I remember how hard it was to get those messy little splatters off the glass, even if you used Windex or windshield washer.  You’d always had to take a second run at it to get the most persistent little blotches.

If you rode motorcycles, like I did for a time, you knew the experience of getting bugs into your eyes and mouth while racing along in the countryside.  Constantly.  There was no escape.

It turns out that we might be headed for a big, big problem.  Where are the bugs?

I look forward to the pesticide industry– which is surely studing the brilliant success of the oil (carbon) industry in sewing doubt about climate change — starting a campaign to try to convince people that 1) there are really more bugs than ever before,  2) pesticides do not harm bugs (except when they do, as advertised, and 3) suburban home-owners use more pesticides than farmers.  After a few years, and after these theories have been debunked, the arguments will become:  1) yes, there are fewer bugs, but the bats are to blame and 2) what’s the problem?  Do you like bugs?  3) pesticides actually eliminate predators of bugs.

A few years later and the strategy becomes, 1) all right, so we are causing the bugs to die, but you can’t sacrifice good farm jobs just to save a mosquito or two.   2)  it’s too late to do anything anyway.  3) don’t worry– by the time we die because the food chain is disrupted by the annihilation of insects, we’ll already have been killed by global warming.

At not point will anyone in the pesticide or farming industries admit that they were wrong.

 

 

 

 

Re. Noah’s Ark:

There 400,000 species of beetles
12,000 types of ants
20,000 of bees