Brett Kavanaugh

I hope the Democrats don’t make the mistake of trying to prove that Brett Kavanaugh should not be on the Supreme Court because he may have assaulted a young girl 35 years ago in a drunken stupor at a party somewhere when he was 17.

The problem with Kavanaugh is that the Republicans have openly and overtly announced that they are putting a party hack on the Supreme Court.

If you are young, you might be forgiven for not knowing that you are not supposed to do that.  You are supposed to at least pretend that your candidate is neither Republican or Democrat, left or right, Catholic or Atheist or Buddhist.  Your candidate will interpret the LAW as it is laid down in Constitution and it’s amendments.  Both sides used to agree on this.  That’s the why the threat of a filibuster would usually be enough to stop a nominee dead in his or her tracks.  They would still tend to promote candidates that were more congenial to their vision of justice, but they would at least pay lip service to the idea that there should be bipartisan support any candidate about to get a lifetime appointment to the highest court in the land.

In face, it would have been considered shameful if a candidate had been elected without at least some votes from the minority party.

It is remarkable that the Republicans, who would hate real “originalism” if it French-kissed them in the ass, have gotten away with repeatedly claiming that they alone among the political parties want a candidate who does not impose his own views upon government but only defends the intent of the original framers of the constitution– slave-owners and all.  So when the Supreme Court rules that black children have just as much right to an education as white children– where the hell does it say that in the Constitution?  No where.  All right– there was an amendment.   But the amendment doesn’t specify that schools must be equally funded for all races.  So the court–as implied by “originalists”–  is imposing its own views onto the constitution.   When the court rules that corporations are persons who have the right to free speech, along with those who don’t have millions to spend on lawyers and pr firms, well…. wait a minute.  No, that kind of interpretation we like.   When it rules that a corporation does not have to pay back the wages owed to a woman who was paid less than a man for the same work for 20 years, by golly, that’s jurisprudence!  Because nowhere in the constitution does it forbid paying women less than men.

How about this: in 1789, there was no law against abortion for at least the first 15 weeks.

There should be an outcry and Republicans should hold their heads in shame that not a single Democrat seems ready to vote for Mr. Kavanaugh.  They should withdraw the nomination and consult with Democrats to find a candidate at least a dozen or more of them could support.   So that the next time there is a 5-4 decision, at least some voters could feel that the court weighed all the facts, examined the law and the constitution, and came to a fair judgement based on principles of justice and fairness.  Not which party appointed them to the court.

Incidentally, I’m not sure, in the end, that the Democrats would suffer too badly if Kavanaugh is appointed and, even better, does overturn Roe v. Wade.  That would leave it to the states, again, to decide on a women’s right to choose, meaning that state elections will suddenly matter a whole lot more to both sides.  I would bet that a majority– perhaps a slim one– would leave it to a woman to decide what happens to her own body.

 

[whohit]Kavanaugh[/whohit]

The Settlements

Harvey Weinstein is a jerk.

As reported in the New York Times, he often invited women looking for work in the movie industry up to his “luxury suites” for a meeting and then would hit on them.  By most accounts, he didn’t exactly use force, but he clearly didn’t want to wait until a deep friendship had been established before asking for sexual favors.  Several women, including Sarah Polley, have reported that he attempted to initiate something with them and they refused and walked away.  When the other women complained and threatened to report him, he offered them money.  A lot of the women took the money, in exchange for which they signed non-disclosure agreements.

It is highly probable that some women acquiesced.   There might be some uncomfortable attempts to come to terms with the compromises made, which, in effect, enabled further abuse.   [See Salma Hayek]  It is probable that some of those women received choice roles in Miramax films.  This will be an uncomfortable issue in the future for some people, though, so far, nobody has named them.

In the article linked above, Bari Weiss thinks that Weinstein should release these women from the non-disclosure agreements they signed so they can speak out.    Nowhere does she suggest the obvious corollary: that they return the money.  That is a glaring omission and one I think she might regret eventually: to accept the money and then proceed to break the agreement would be repugnant, though in today’s culture it would probably be readily dispensed with by the media.  To accept the money in the first place, in exchange for not alerting other women to the possibility of harassment, was also, probably, repugnant.  Weiss wants to argue that the agreements were illegitimate in some way, and that the women are entitled, therefore, to break them.  But they took the money, and that cannot bed swept conveniently under the carpet.

In essence, they agreed not to blow Weinstein’s cover, and prevent him from exploiting other actresses, in exchange for a large sum of money.  Nobody wants to discuss that.

She also suggests that there is hypocrisy out there because Weinstein won’t receive the same treatment as Bill O’Reilly or Roger Ailes received from the liberal establishment, because Mr. Weinstein is a well-established liberal icon and fund-raiser.  [2018-09: obviously she was wrong about that.]

It’s always poor form to make assumptions like that.  You get to make your rhetorical flourish and feel all pious and righteous about it without having to actually wait and see if your accusations are true.

But the first issue is this bullshit idea that Roger Ailes and Bill O’Reilly suffered any real consequences at all for their behaviour towards women.  Like Harvey Weinstein, they paid off most of the women who made allegations against them.  And, as in the case of Harvey Weinstein, most of the women accepted the money and agreed not to warn other women about these gentlemen in exchange for cash.

We know all about the consequences suffered by Donald Trump after allegations of his harassment of women came forwards: nada.  Not a thing.  Not a blessed thing.

So perhaps Weiss is publishing in the wrong forum here: you need to get on Fox News and find out why so many women– especially, good Christian evangelicals– went ahead and voted for Trump anyway.

I might add that there is another difference: Ailes and O’Reilly are both stalwarts of the allegedly “family values” party, the Republicans, and have long been advocating for a return to “traditional values” in America, to abstinence instead of birth control, to “character” development instead of gratification, to valued institutions instead of self-fulfillment, and so on.  They proclaim their alliance with evangelical Christians who don’t seem to believe what they say about sexual morality, unless it concerns a Democrat like Bill Clinton.

It always was obvious that conservatives believe that everyone should live by those values, except themselves.

Which leads to this question: what of the women that accepted these payouts from The Weinstein Company rather than reporting the behavior?

Reporting to whom?

Take note of this, from NYTimes 2017-10-10, offered as an indictment:

Zelda Perkins

In 1998, Ms. Perkins, then a 25-year-old assistant in London,
confronted Mr. Weinstein over his alleged harassment and threatened
to go public or take legal action if it continued, according to former
colleagues. A lawyer for Mr. Weinstein was later dispatched to
negotiate a settlement with her.

Which she accepted.

Which, yes, makes her complicit.  And which has not adduced any critical comments whatsoever from Bari Weiss or Amy Schumer or any of the other women who are insisting that women don’t have to not be complicit to be innocent of this tacit arrangement.  It hasn’t even stopped them from calling Ms. Perkins “courageous” even though she accepted the pay-off.  The “courageous” thing to do would have been to say, “I will never accept money in order to hide your criminal behavior.  That would allow you to victimize others.  I’m calling the police”.

But isn’t Ms. Perkins in dangerous territory there?  We are told over and over again that the women should be believed and that men who try to discount their allegations by alleging that they are seeking a payout are wrong.  But if you accept the money, are you not validating the charge?  Are you not agreeing to deceive people in exchange for money?  You weren’t seeking money, but you took it anyway?

Weinstein’s behavior may have been ugly and offensive, but I doubt that it really crossed a line into criminality.   He was a hustler and a pig and disgusting.  Some of the women might be able to show that their careers didn’t advance after they refused him, but some women, like Gwyneth Paltrow,  can show that their careers advanced very quickly at Weinstein’s organization after the incident.

Without a doubt, a lot of established feminist opinion believes that Weinstein’s behavior was “criminal”.   I don’t.  I believe the women should have walked away or told him off and reported it to the media and to other employees and the board of the organization: not to the police.  Weinstein would easily have been deterred very quickly if thought that most women in the situation he placed them in would be likely to report his actions.

But at least some of the women accepted money instead in exchange for silence– or acquiesced to his wishes.  Or obtained good roles in films he controlled.

We now have the gruesome process– which we were spared in the cases of O’Reilly and Ailes– of Weinstein toadying to the cultural avatars and proclaiming how he will reform himself, get therapy (oh please!), and donate to good causes.  And various female politicians declaring that they will take the money he donated to their campaigns and forward it to charities instead of using it to get elected.

I don’t blame him entirely for the absurd “therapy” angle he’s putting out there: the absurdity comes from the social entities who really believe in that crap.  He’s just following the script and I’d almost admire him more if he would just say, “look, I’m a creep, but explain to me why they accepted the money and I’ll explain to you why I didn’t stop”.

[whohit]The NDAs[/whohit]

They Love Each Other So…

NYTimes has a wedding profile for a couple that consists of a transgender man with three children from previous marriages as a female and a transgender woman.  It’s a milestone for me– I’m sure it’s happened before, but that’s first official announcement of it I’ve seen.

This is what I would have played as they walked down the aisle:  Why not?

[whohit]They Love Each Other So[/whohit]

The Unwelcome Mat

What is an “unwelcome sexual advance”?  Under the Obama Administration, this thing, this “unwelcome sexual advance” was considered, by definition, harassment.   That is, it constitutes harassment plain and simple without any other aggravating factors.  Make an unwelcome “sexual advance” on someone and you are in trouble.  Big trouble.

Not clear?  Think of a “welcome” sexual advance.  What is it?  Is it when a woman or a man says, “please touch me or kiss me or oogle me”?  Did you ever do that?  Put it into words, or writing, in advance?  You are out on a date with someone and you say, “why don’t you give me a kiss?”  Or is it more likely that you will lean in and give him or her a kiss, without a formal announcement or invitation.

You will not know if it was welcome or not until it is too late.  If it is unwelcome, you have committed an unwelcome sexual advance.   You are guilty of harassment.

Everybody thinks they know what it means.  No, you don’t.  What is a sexual advance in the first place?  It is an action that is intended to evoke a response from the subject that might indicate receptivity to sexual activity with this person.  That’s what an “advance” is, of a sexual nature.  It is not the sex itself though it is “sexual”.  It is not intercourse.  It’s not nothing, sitting on your hands waiting to see if something happens.  It’s an “advance”– a tentative move forward to explore, test, provoke.

You won’t like an advance if you don’t like the person doing the advancing.  But that’s the point: if your advance meets resistance, you back off.  If you don’t back off– I agree with the mainstream here– you are committing an offence.

Nor is it usually a verbal question.  It’s a move, a hand on a knee, leaning in, touching, sitting on someone’s lap, even patting a bum (before you object, I can tell you it happened to me, and it was exactly what I thought it was).  It’s lots of things, most of which, if attributed to a politician, will elicit squeals of horror from the sanctimonious.  You monster!  You must be punished!  You must show me that you are totally contrite before you may be allowed to resume your career.

The Obama Administration played around with phrases: “unwelcome conduct of a sexual nature”.  Here’s some shocking news: “conduct of a sexual nature” does not just apply to “why don’t we go sit in the back seat for a while, honey”.  It applies to, “Tommy is such a brat, let’s chase him” and “why don’t you come join me on the couch” and “could you walk me home?” and “you are so mean to me” and “you want to hang out together” and I know how to improve my tips 30%: shorten my skit and undo the top button of my blouse.

I think the general public operates as if it believes that there is a very clear, thick demarcation between conduct of a sexual nature and conduct that is not of a sexual nature.  But, like, allegedly, gender identity, I believe it is more like a continuum, and that it can sometimes be very hard to draw that line, and I know that a lot of us are very hesitant to admit it when our own behavior does cross the line.  There is no way to determine, objectively, whether any of a myriad of teasing, provocative, funny actions is conduct “of a sexual nature”.  The phrase is absurd.  There is no clear, definitive line between many social behaviors and many sexual behaviors.

Flip it over for a minute: what is a “welcome” sexual advance?  If we claim that we know what an “unwelcome” sexual advance is, then we must know what a “welcome” sexual advance looks like.  More importantly, we better know what the difference is.  But how can we, until it’s too late?  We can’t.

How would you know it was welcomed if you hadn’t received a “sexual advance” to begin with, or in return?  Step closer to a person you like– what if he or she leans towards you?  Should I bring my lawyer along on this date?

[whohit]The Unwelcome Mat[/whohit]

The Great Mime Parade

I think what offends me the most about the whole process of nominating and confirming a new justice to the Supreme Court is the utter, contemptible phoniness of it all: Honestly, I have no opinion on abortion at all. None whatsoever. Never thought about it. Gosh, if a case ever comes to me if I’m on the Supreme Court, I will certainly think it over very carefully. Who knows what my opinion will be.

So Donald and Mitch and Paul and Vice-Wienie Pence and the entire evangelical community are all excited about you on the off chance you might vote against Roe v. Wade?

Why don’t the Republicans simply announce they are looking for a Supreme Court Justice who will restore the right of the state to control womens’ bodies?  Get it out there and get over with it.  Why on earth don’t they proclaim it, celebrate it, relish it?  They won, they have the votes, let’s do it!

Susan Collins met with Kavanaugh and came out of the meeting assuring her feminist supporters that Mr. Kavanaugh sees Roe v. Wade as “settled law”.  She needs this cover, because she is committed to a pro-choice position and it would be a betrayal of her constituency, in moderate Maine, to choose otherwise.  So she needs this cover story, that Kavanaugh has assured her that Roe v. Wade is “settled law”.  When he votes to overturn Roe v. Wade (probably incrementally), she needs to be able to say, “I never thought he would do that when I voted to confirm him”.

Does Susan Collins know this is a lie?  Is she lying?  Probably.  She puts on a good show, like John McCain, of being moderate and centrist, but almost invariably votes for the Republican platform.

They know why and you know why.  They could never win an election in most states on that platform.  They always have to be very vague about it even while their supporters openly celebrate the possibilities.  I figure they would lose about ten seats in the Senate if those Republican Senators campaigned on a the promise of ending abortion rights.

“Honest, I have no opinion on abortion. None whatsoever. Never even thought about it. What is ‘abortion’? Is it something bad?”

In his record, it is amazing how many different rationales Kavanaugh provides for invariably deciding in favor of stock holders, police, corporations, security agencies, negligent employers, ISPs, all the while insisting he has no political bias.  The constitution itself, you see, clearly says “the stockholders, owners, and oligarchs are always right”.

When the state tries to ensure that all citizens have the right and opportunity to vote in elections– that’s “over-reach”. Excessive. Intrusive! When it wants to see who you’ve been calling on your cellphone, by golly, the constitution itself says right there, “you have no privacy”.

[whohit]The Great Mime Parade[/whohit]

Hypocrisy 101

It was so predictable, so inevitable, so laughable, that you almost want to cry.  A woman in a position of authority is alleged to have sexually harassed a young man she had authority over.  And at least some feminists defend her by asking whether the male “victim” did enough to make it clear he did not welcome her advances.  Why didn’t he just say no?  Why didn’t he just leave?  Why did he wait so long to report it?  Was it really harassment, or was it mutual?  What was he wearing at the time?

He responded the way many victims have.  He didn’t say no.  He didn’t leave.  He didn’t fight her off.  He said he believes it would have harmed his career if he had rebuffed her.  He had no choice but to give in.

He felt she was in a position of power over him.  He felt that he couldn’t refuse her.  And now, years after the fact, he is suing.  As a result of the abuse, he was anxious, depressed, unable to focus on his work.

These are things that have a cash value.

Now we all admire his courage.

It’s all too much.

By the way, has the #metoo movement got a hold of Atticus Finch yet?  Here we have a rape victim, Mayella Ewell, who is re-victimized by the defense attorney who questions her own behavior and suggests she was asking for it.  It’s Victim-Blaming and Victim-Shaming galore.  And women never lie about such things, so Tom Robinson, truly, got what he deserved.  Shame on you, Atticus Finch!

 

[whohit]Hypocrisy 101[/whohit]

Ronan Farrow, Sit Down and Shutup

Well, now it’s CBS News and 60 Minutes.

At Last: Someone Takes a Closer Look at Ronan Farrow’s Journalistic Credibility

Stop everything you’re doing, all the research and investigation and interviews, travel, exploration, documentation and exposure– stop it all and resign and crawl into a hole, because Ronan Farrow has managed to find some former female employees and associates who didn’t like the way you hit on them.  No matter how long ago, or how disputed, or how misinterpreted or misjudged, or how marginal it is to whatever it is you do with your life, you must now resign, because the almighty, pitiless, puritanical Inquisitor Ronan Farrow, son of Frank or Woody– we don’t know– has deemed you to be shriek-worthy and foul and you must be replaced by some woman or transgender woman or man or gay man or gay woman or black transgender gay indigenous being, because he or she or it is really just as talented and hardworking as you, but you, oppressor, bully, monster!— kept him, her, or it from fulfilling the great destiny worthy of his, her, or it’s talents, by kissing without permission, by expressing your desire for him, her, or it, by leaning too close, by initiating sex with her, him, or it while he, her, or it was asleep.

By not asking politely, in writing, before hand, if you could say to them, “you are hot– I’d like to have sex with you.”

Let us gather a red cloak for Ronan Farrow and  begin the purge of our libraries and museums and art galleries,  and let us expunge all the works, the films, the books, the paintings, the sculptures, the music, the podcasts, the radio programs, by all the horrible men who made them, who created the models we use today, who inspired generations of other artists, who moved us, who wrought the world of culture– let us take all their works and burn them.  For it doesn’t matter and never mattered that you actually built or created or invented or led or organized or directed– it never mattered at all.  It doesn’t matter that you saw beauty or truth in a gesture, an expression, a conversation, a shape, a way of describing a scene.  None of your acts of compassion or generosity, or wit, or improvisation, or imagination can now be countenanced: you must be expelled from human society!

The only thing that mattered, ever, is that in one of the millions of small moments of your life, you offended one of God’s dainty little angels who, though gentle and delicate and innocent, and helpless, when roused, is mighty and bold and courageous and will now speak out and tell her story!  On Oprah, if possible, or Jerry Springer, if necessary!   Now that it is safe to do so.   That is enough.  It erases everything else you were or could be.  And it makes a monument of courage and genius of the accuser, who never had any such courage or genius when it was all that would have been required for her, to turn around and spit in your face and say “no” and leave.

Let’s replace them all with Ronan Farrow’s scribbles.  Or the films written and directed by Mia Farrow.  Or Illeana Douglas’s exposes.  Or Kirsten Gillibrand’s mountains of legislation.

[whohit]Ronan Farrow: Please Shutup[/whohit]

The Wolf Who Cried Boy

Here and Here

The key thing is this: if the journalists at the annual Correspondent’s Dinner had wanted informed editorial opinion, they would have chosen an informed editor to give it.  What they chose was a comedienne.

There is a big difference between journalism, editorial opinion, and comedy.  Trevor Noah– who is not that sparkling of a comedian– completely lost the distinction.  So did Michelle Wolf at the 2018 Correspondent’s Dinner.

Wolf is not a journalist.  She is not a graduate journalist: an editor.  She is not a qualified reporter.  She is a comedian.  And she is a trained kinesiologist.

But thanks to Jon Stewart, Trevor Noah, and Stephen Colbert, people are beginning to lose that distinction between an editorial opinion and comedy.  Trevor Noah has become horribly boring because he acts as if he is a journalist and offers unqualified editorial opinions all night.  It’s not funny, and it’s not informative, and it’s not even interesting.  Why does he do it?  When did he start thinking he was sort of like an editorial writer for a newspaper, instead of a comedian?

The same problem has happened to SNL’s “Weekend Update”.  There is no longer a parody of news casts.  It’s mainly a couple of blow-hards just mouthing off about Trump.  It’s not funny or interesting when they do that.  It can be funny when they actually parody the news, but when Michael Che reads a report of some comment or action by Trump and then more or less says, “what a moron”, it’s not funny.  It’s not witty.  It’s not even amusing.

I think I can safely assume that Wolf was chosen for her qualifications as a comedienne.  I’m not even sure if the people who appointed her get the difference: she mainly just got up there and called Donald Trump names.  That’s what Donald Trump does to other people and it’s not fun to watch.  It’s contemptible.

Undoubtedly, Michelle Wolf felt she had a right to express the following, but it’s pure editorial.

“You guys are obsessed with Trump,” she said, near the end of her routine. “Did you used to date him? Because you pretend like you hate him, but I think you love him. I think what no one in this room wants to admit is that Trump has helped all of you.

“He couldn’t sell steaks or vodka or water or college or ties or Eric, but he has helped you. He’s helped you sell your papers and your books and your TV. You helped create this monster, and now you’re profiting off of him.”

There is no joke, no wit, no cleverness to it at all.  This is the kind of commentary– when done right– that you would expect from a journalist with good first-hand knowledge of Washington politics and the White house.

But it’s just a comedienne who suddenly thinks she’s Martin Baron.

I will say this though– Stephen Colbert was right when he observed that the reporters complaining about Wolf’s speech sound like a man complaining that the valet just stole his car.  Think about it– it’s a great metaphor for what happened at the Correspondent’s Dinner, which, in all truthfulness, is a bizarre and unnecessary annual ritual anyway.

 

[whohit]The Wolf Who Cried Boy[/whohit]

Why Was This Allowed in Court?

In a description of the testimony of one of the witnesses against Bill Cosby in his second trial for sexual assault, we hear that one of the women remembered going to Cosby’s hotel suite for drinks and then waking up in her bed at home.  That’s what she remembered.

Later, after hearing about the other accusations against Cosby, she suddenly “remembered” that she must have been sexually assaulted during that blank period of time because, after all, that’s what Bill Cosby does.  Everybody knows it.  Case closed.

Soon, she found herself on that bastion of unimpeachable journalism, the Dr. Phil show, thrilling millions with her lurid tale.

I’m not going to act surprised that a court allowed this testimony– it is no secret that real courts are not like TV or movie courts.  They will often allow ridiculous evidence to be introduced, without effective challenge–  like fiber evidence and blood splatter evidence.  So a woman who admits that she has no memory of any such thing is allowed to assert that Bill Cosby sexually assaulted her.   And the purpose of this testimony– Cosby is not on trial for assaulting her– is to put the jury into the right mood for convicting him of assaulting Andrea Constand.

I will point out that “recovered memories”, which is what this is, have long been rather convincingly discredited, and that no burglar, for example, should ever be convicted even partly on the basis of a neighboring home owner telling the court that one day she came home and found that her house might have been broken into and things she did not remember owning might well have been stolen, and that a neighbor she had given a key to might be the culprit.

I hope an appeals court will think differently.  [2023-20-22: Yes, the appeals court did think differently and tossed out the conviction.]    I hope an appeals court throws the entire case out because it amounts to double jeopardy: Cosby reached a court supervised agreement with Andrea Constand in 2006 under which she was offered and accepted $3 million dollars to go away.  This was not an agreement between two individuals: it was supervised and administered by a court, which certified that both parties had agreed to this settlement and that that would be the end of the legal procedure against Cosby.  Cosby has, as you might expect, launched a civil action to recover the money.

There is a debate over whether Constand did violate the terms of the agreement.

I have no doubt that Bill Cosby was and is an asshole– I never liked him, not during his days as a stand-up comedian when he ducked the civil rights movement, and especially not as Cliff Huxtable, in a boring, sanitized, ridiculous sitcom– a black “Daddy Knows Best”.  He played a denatured caricature of himself so that white audiences could safely enjoy his shtick.

But that does not make all of his accusers angels, and doesn’t remove the slight taint of suspicion that many of these actresses and models went to his hotel room or apartment hoping he would do something for their careers.  He didn’t drag them there.  He didn’t even pay them to come there.  He just invited them and offered to help them with their careers.  And these women accepted.

You might believe that they had no idea what a man might be up to when he invites a woman to his apartment or hotel suite, alone, or when he offers her drinks, or Quaaludes or benadryl, or massages their hair.   No idea at all.

And in the current political climate, none of them will ever have to truthfully answer the question of just what they expected to happen there.

[whohit]Why Was This Allowed in Court[/whohit]

The Subtle Aesthetic of Soap Opera

This Piece by Lili Loofbourow

If you cannot appreciate the most complex, richest, best writing or film-making or art or music in the room because you just aren’t smart enough to get it, you will be completely baffled as to why the stuff you do get is not regarded with the same esteem.

Ms. Loofbourow believes that female writers and film-makers are just as good if not better than male writers and film-makers, but do not get the respect they deserve.  Let’s be clear– she is making a judgement based on her own personal knowledge, that female writers she knows of are just as good as male writers she knows of.

And we all devalue women’s writing due to the fact that “we” devalue the art works that women value more highly, because they are valued more highly by women.  I’m confused too.  Here’s a quote:

Study after study has shown that, no matter how loudly we complain that reality TV is heavily scripted, or that an image is the product of makeup, lighting, and Photoshop, we’re totally unable to disregard the evidence of our own eyes.

And that “evidence of our own eyes” is that this stuff is brilliant.

Who the hell is “we”?  In the most outrageously narcissistic comment in the piece, Ms. Loofbourow declares that she– and she alone, because all of the rest of us have deficient appreciation– knows what we are all thinking.  She can’t “disregard the evidence” of her own eyes and so she must insist that no one else can either.

She cites Mark Twain’s inadequate appreciation for Jane Austen as if, again, she really believes that Jane Austen–a fine writer who nevertheless remains one of the founders of soap opera, with it’s obsessive concern with how men unjustly under-appreciate the wonders of women–is on par with Tolstoy or Dostoevsky or even Dickens.   She is not.  She is a fine novelist in her genre who inspired an endless parade of mediocre writers– but her novels are still about the emotional lives of women who are consumed with their relationships with men and with each other and don’t have any real importance in the world of politics or science or the arts apart from their emotional lives.

Besides, it wasn’t Jane Austen’s fault that she wasn’t involved in research on gravity or negotiating treaties, or commanding armies.  What else could she write about?

This is really a giant, hoary screed at men: how dare you not think that I am as smart or smarter than you.  And rather than show us, she tells us and expects us to take her word for it.

Apparently, men like me are too stupid to realize that the narcissistic Lena Dunham character in “Tiny Furniture” is supposed to be unattractive.  I don’t believe it.  There is a difference between acknowledging the reality that cannot be denied and deliberately creating an unattractive character in order to say something important about unattractiveness.  Aura is Lena Dunham, her mother is her mother, her sister is her sister, the apartment is the apartment.

Is Maude Lewis supposed to be unattractive in “Maudie”?  Or is she just Maude Lewis, described to us by the film-makers using all of the information available to them?

Amy Schumer’s most distinctive passion is her instance that, no matter what men think, she really is very sexually attractive.  She doesn’t care what you think.  You think what she tells you to think.

Dunham is too honest to fall for that shtick.

Sometimes we just get pure blather:

Thanks to shows like Fleabag, Enlightened, Insecure, The Good Wife, Awkward Black Girl, The Book Group, Scandal, One Mississippi, The Maria Bamford Show, The Comeback, Top of the Lake, Orphan Black, Orange is the New Black, Getting On, Happy Valley, and Doll and Em, we’re finally getting some nourishing fiction that welcomes female protagonists with wrinkles and corrugated narratives that don’t easily convert to motivational posters. Most of these narratives destabilize the implied male position behind the camera and queer its conventions in sometimes transformative ways.

“Destabilize the implied male position behind the camera and queer its conventions in sometimes transformative ways”?  I defy you to defend that line.

She even believes that because three colleagues of an award-winning professor missed a clumsy joke — which, in her mind, was somehow transmuted into a brilliant piece of performance art–  that they therefore must also have completely ignored her speech, sitting there for an hour, apparently, not listening to the speaker in front of them, and had discounted her work as a teacher because they misread her lousy joke as nervousness.  This is idiotic.

In a desperate attempt to empower herself, she presents a self-condescending comment by a 19th century memoirist as an incredibly hilarious satirical jibe at Mark Twain, again, even though, it is clearly intended to disarm critics by proclaiming the modest ambition of the writer, while subtly claiming that women’s thoughts might actually have some value.

Elizabeth Gilbert, she alleges, was considered a serious writer when she wrote about men, and trivial when she wrote “Eat, Pray, Love”.  The latter truly was a mediocre book, but whoever thought she was ever a great writer must belong to the mythical “we” of this piece who only exist as the imagined monument to Lili Loufbourow’s ego.

The further you move away from white masculinity, the more points of view you have to juggle.

Well, let’s keep it simple for a minute Ms. Loufbourow: how the hell do you know what white masculinity sees?   How do you know that those who are not white males have a deeper, more embracing perspective?   Show us even one clue that you have one clue what white men see when they look at women’s writing.

I don’t regard Alice Munro as a one of the greatest writers in the English language today– or Salmon Rushdie– because she is a woman, or because he is a man.  They are both simply brilliant writers, and if you don’t know what makes them brilliant that is a limit on your perspective, not theirs.

 

[whohit]The Subtle Aesthetic of Soap Opera[/whohit]