The Preposterous “Reign Over Me”

There really is not a single honest moment in this movie, or a single emotion that isn’t the product of manipulation and contrivance..

Did anybody sitting in the theatre for the first five or ten minutes believe, even for a split second, that Alan Johnson (Don Cheadle) is going to cheat on his wife? There is no way it’s going to happen in this movie, because this movie is not about what a real person in Alan Johnson’s predicament would have done–it is about what the audience thinks it would have done if it had been Alan Johnson.

In the same way, Charlie Fineman (Adam Sandler) is not based on what a crazy man looks like or how he acts. It’s based on what the audience thinks Adam Sandler would act like if he was playing the role of a crazy man. We have Robin Williams syndrome (“The Fisher King”): make your disturbed characters lovably whacky so we can fool ourselves into thinking that we would be understanding and patient and kind if we knew someone like that. For God’s sake, open the door, it’s Adam Sandler– not some genuinely disturbed man who might actually do something disturbing!

Okay. So not everyone is annoyed with the idea that Alan Johnson hangs out with Charlie for hours and hours and, apparently, cannot imagine that it might be wise to phone his wife and let her know where he is. But then you couldn’t have the phony scene of the conflict with this wife.

Or that Dr. Oakhurst is an amazing psychiatrist who not only looks like a 19-year-old Playboy bunny, but must be the only psychiatrist in New York who doesn’t require patients to make an appointment, and who accepts referrals from dentists. Not only that, she is willing to drop everything on a moment’s notice so she can hang around with her patients during her off hours, and accompany them to court, but this remarkable PHD doesn’t seem capable of describing to a judge her qualifications.

Nor do I think the writers had the slightest clue about how the actual process of committing a patient to a psychiatric ward works.

The secondary characters in this movie are almost all mild stereo-types or one-dimensional cut-outs whose sole purpose is to validate your own saintly feelings about how understanding you are about Charlie’s mental illness. Alan Johnson’s wife– come on!– is the physically perfect wife of the actor, Will Smith: Jada Pinkett. Seriously. And Johnson’s crisis is that– get this– she doesn’t understand him. He feels constricted in his marriage. What’s so unbelievable about that?

Liv Tyler as a psychiatrist? This is one of the most astute casting choices since they made Meg Ryan a brain surgeon in “City of Angels”. You just look at Liv Tyler and think– yeah, she reminds me a lot of some psychiatrists I know.

Then you have the tiresome problem of creating dramatic tension by having Charlie resist being treated by the aforementioned saintly psychiatrist when, in real life, nobody seriously believes anyone could or should be treated if they don’t want to. In real life, Dr. Oakhurst says, ” You don’t want to talk to me? Fine. Good bye. Call me back when you do.” The movie makes a clumsy, awkward concession to reality by having Charlie say, “are we done yet” and Oakhurst replies, “if you want the session to be over, it is”, but after showing this three times, you realize that the movie is cheating. Either there is productive time in each session before Charlie wants to go, or the sessions are ridiculous. If there is productive time, then the dramatic tension is gone.

These scenes really consist of Charlie running away in the school yard yelling and giggling, “don’t chase me, don’t chase me”.  It is a lot of peoples’ dearest fantasy: to be able to behave like an asshole while beautiful people chase after us begging to let us be rude to them some more.

The only teasingly bright moment in the film is when Alan Johnson realizes that the reason Charlie likes hanging around with him is because he is the only one who doesn’t remind Charlie about his loss. Then Johnson immediately sets out to make Charlie acknowledge his loss, thus draining the potential for dramatic interest in that thread.

Bottom line: yes, this film is exploitive. By choosing to contrive a story rather than explore the reality of grief and loss, it attempts to cash in without paying it’s dues.


Sandler can act– check out “Punch Drunk Love”.  But not in “Reign Over Me” .

I’ve heard some people rave about Sandler’s acting in this film. With all due respect, I have no idea of what those people think good acting consists of. Sandler speaks louder and softer and louder again and softer again… and weeps. He doesn’t invent anything out of this character, doesn’t develop a rhythm or texture to him… every time he flew into a rage he conveyed, convincingly, what it would be like to see Adam Sandler imitate someone imitating a rage. There isn’t a moment in his performance that feels like it came from any particular insight into Charlie Fineman’s condition– it all feels external to me.

There are movies that do do a better job of dramatizing emotional disturbances than this one: “One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest”, for example. Mike Leigh’s “Naked”.

There are even more films that are equally bad or worse: “Prince of Tides”.

Films (good and bad) designed to make you feel good about your encounter with emotional (or mental) disturbance:

“What’s Eating Gilbert Grape”,
“I am Sam”,
“Beautiful Mind” (supposedly a true story: they left out all of the disagreeable characteristics of John Nash, including his first marriage, and his divorce).
“Prince of Tides”,
“The Departed” (the same bullshit trope about a psychiatrist begging the adorable patient to accept treatment while the patient resists).

 


Get off my case.

Some people seem upset when I point out to them that it is a kind of phoniness that Alan Johnson doesn’t cheat on his wife in this movie.  The fact that a lot of fans of the film resent my view on this tells me that I’m right.

Why, really, are they upset? Because they think I mean he should cheat on his wife in the movie.  No, I don’t care what he does in the movie as long as it’s believable.  As long as, given the reality constructed by the film, it is something that tells us something about the character in the film, not the audience.

Let me illustrate what I mean:  you could make a movie (like “Forrest Gump”) about a soldier who engages in numerous battles and sees numerous atrocities and rescues his friends and saves a baby from a wild dingo and never actually fires his weapon at anybody, to allow your audience the illusion that someone could serve “honorably” in Viet Nam by pretending that they didn’t go there to actually kill anybody, drop bombs, or even fire their weapons.  It caters to human vanity, to allow the viewer to enjoy two contradictory ideas simultaneously:  that serving in the military is  patriotic and honorable; that soldiers don’t kill anybody or blow anything up.

The film-makers want to titillate the viewer with the possibility that Johnson would cheat, while providing the cheap moral comfort of the idea that he didn’t, so you don’t have to feel bad about liking him.

The Alan Johnsons of real life, given the circumstances offered in the movie, do cheat. But we prefer our fairy tales. [added April 2008]

It should tell you a lot about this movie that Tom Cruise and Brad Pitt were both considered for the role of Charlie Fineman. Come on— do you really think anyone serious about dramatizing an emotional breakdown would consider Cruise or Pitt for the role?  Okay– maybe Pitt.

Nobody here is interested in someone who can really act or can be convincing as an emotionally disturbed man, like, say, Christian Bale or Heath Ledger. What the producers wanted is someone the audience would love, because otherwise they would understand immediately how preposterous the storyline is. If you are not rooting for Adam Sandler (or Pitt or Cruise) because he is a charismatic star, you would never believe the behaviour of the psychiatrist, or the judge, or the cops, or even Alan Johnson, or Johnson’s kids, or his wife. That’s because what you are really watching is a projection of your own self-image: you feel like you are a good person who feels compassion for disturbed individuals, because you feel affection for Sandler.

Although… maybe you don’t..

It also tells you something that the music that Charlie listens to obsessively is Bruce Springsteen, Jackson Browne, and The Who, rather than, say Tom Waits, or Dylan, or Leonard Cohen, or someone genuinely edgy. It tells you that someone is playing it safe– Springsteen, for example, is critically respectable, but not as original or interesting as Tom Waits. So the movie is not cheap, tacky Hollywood, but Binder doesn’t quite really want to do anything quite really daring.

One of Binder’s previous films, “The Upside of Anger”, featured an ending that was so ridiculously preposterous, it completely destroyed all of the dramatic tension built up by what was, until then, a fairly satisfactory narrative. Here, he doesn’t even get that far, the ending is almost equally preposterous and unsatisfying.

Spoiler: in “The Upside of Anger”, a woman’s husband disappears one day. She assumes he left her for his secretary and becomes bitter and disillusioned. She takes up a relationship with washed-up baseball star Kevin Costner; they have a crisis or two, save the family and…then they find her husband’s body in a pit behind the house. You realize that one day the man disappeared, and she never took the slightest steps to find out what happened to him. She just assumed he ran out on her. Without any possessions, of course. Without any evident planning or foresight. And she never called the police, and they never conducted even the most rudimentary investigation which would have revealed that his disappearance almost certainly was not planned or premeditated, and so on and so on…

And you are asked to believe that when he didn’t return to the house one day, it never occurred to his wife to take any action whatsoever to find out what happened to him. Binder didn’t think audiences would have too much trouble with this…

 

A Sweetheart Like You – Guy Davis Covers Dylan

If you have never heard Guy Davis’ version of Bob Dylan’s “Sweetheart Like You” you’re really missing something.

Unfortunately, I can’t make you sit down in a seedy bar with a glass of watery American beer and a plate of stale pretzels and a cloud of smoke and a worn-out sagging beauty eyeing you from the bar and the smell of urine and bacon drifting over the tables like yesterday’s politics so the song can start out at you just right, from the unbalanced jukebox in the corner, accordion and lead guitar poking through the din, and Guy Davis’ gravelly voice:

by the way, that’s a cute hat you’re wearin’
And that smile’s so hard to resist
What’s a sweetheart like you doing in dump like this?

All right– so that part is not so new. How about:

You know, I once knew a woman who looked like you,
She wanted a whole man, not just a half,
She used to call me sweet daddy when I was only a child,
You kind of remind me of her when you laugh.
In order to deal in this game, got to make the queen disappear,
It’s done with a flick of the wrist.
What’s a sweetheart like you doin’ in a dump like this?

That’s better. I like that line about “whole man”, not just “half”. What is the missing half? Sexuality? Manliness? Why is he “only a child”? Because he doesn’t understand that this woman, this “queen”, is ready to immolate herself for something that baffles even his royal Bobness, but which Guy Davis sounds like he understands better than anyone.

A “whole” man?  “I gave her my heart but she wanted my soul”.   (“Don’t Think Twice, It’s All Right”).

Bob being Bob then announces:

You know, a woman like you should be at home,
That’s where you belong…

It boggles the mine that the same expansive mind that wrote “Only a Pawn in the Game” and “Masters of War” and “Mr. Tambourine Man” and “Visions of Johanna” and “Tangled up in Blue” could drop a dud like this on the listener. A woman belongs at home with her husband!

Well, it’s not really a “dud”. It’s an alive line. It’s a dumb idea, but a live one. So it’s a bad line, but not a dud. It’s poetry.

But she is out to make the Queen disappear, which means, she wants to get rid of all the dignity and prestige and meaningfulness that comes with being “at home” with her husband (who is himself probably out sitting in a bar with an assassin on his lap– wondering why she’s not at home where she belongs) and to that end, she makes herself subject to a man’s trivial whim, the flick of a wrist. That’s all it takes to persuade this woman to immolate herself.

Regrettably, Dylan doesn’t see women as whole persons. They only exist in halves, and always half of whatever the man in the lyric is doing. In “Things Have Changed”, he isn’t even fully evil because, after all, she is sitting in his lap, drinking champagne, so she is merely an accessory to the narrator’s despair. Her only hope for salvation is to rush home, grow some flowers and do some sewing, and wait for her man to arrive for dinner to validate her existence.

That does not mean it’s a bad song. No, it doesn’t.

You know you can make a name for yourself,
You can hear them tires squeal,
You can be known as the most beautiful woman
Who ever crawled across cut glass to make a deal.

Wow. You really owe it to yourself to hear Guy Davis scrunch those lines into that lovely bridge, without missing a half-breath or letting the tension slack, so that the “cut glass” really is a shock and the “make a deal” is inevitable.

 


The liberated Bob Dylan:

Can you cook and sew, make flowers grow
Do you understand my pain?
Are you ready to risk it all,
Or is your love in vain?

“Is Your Love Is Vain”, from Street Legal.

Independent Women of Song: “Someday Soon” and “One of These Days”.

Surprise– to me. These songs were recorded only seven years apart and both are by strong, independent female artists, and both are unusually polished and crisp recordings with outstanding session musicians. They even have similar intros, one with steel guitar, one with electric. And they are both about women on the cusp of breaking out. But Judy Collins is waiting for her man to make her life happen; Emmy Lou Harris is about to make it happen for herself. Both feel constricted by their families, and can’t wait to leave and stretch out their minds, if not their bodies. First, from “One of These Days”.

I won’t have to chop no wood
I can be bad or I can be good
I can be any way that I feel
One of these days

And from “Someday Soon”.

My father says that he will leave me crying
But I would follow him right down
The toughest road I know
Someday soon, going with him, some day soon….

Judy Collins was a soulful interpreter of great songs by the outstanding singer- songwriters of the 60’s, Dylan, Cohen, Tom Rush, Ian Tyson. She was a romantic, and I personally found her a bit suffocating at times– too many whale songs and saturated memories of dreamy trips to Paris or smudgy interior emotional landscapes. Emmy Lou Harris leaned a bit to country and folk, and added some memorable background vocals to Gram Parsons, Neil Young, and Dylan. Her songs are always tasteful and restrained– she resisted the temptations that made very good singers like Dolly Parton and Loretta Lynn go very bad.

Might be a woman that’s dressed in black
Be a hobo by the railroad track
I’ll be gone like the wayward wind one of these days

Unlike Collins, the narrator of Harris’ “One of These Days” isn’t counting on being rescued by some man. She’s going to break out on her own, and be her own person. Collins’ narrator is waiting for her cowboy to come so she can follow him wherever he goes. Okay– the song was written by a man, Ian Tyson, after all, whose woman, Sylvia Fricker, eventually chose not to follow anymore. In fact, Sylvia Tyson basically decided she could be “any way that I feel” and went to work for the CBC in Toronto while Ian cooled his cowboy heels at his ranch in Alberta, writing soulful ballads about how wonderful it was to ride your horse, look at the mountains, and live alone.

So should I add Sylvia Fricker’s “River Road”, another fine song about escape, into the mix?

Here I go, once again
With my suitcase in my hand
And I’m running away down River Road…

Once again, like Harris, she isn’t waiting around for the cowboy.

There’s an odd verse in “River Road”:

Well I married a pretty good man
And he tries to understand
But he knows I’ve got leaving on my mind these days…

When I heard that line, I immediately thought, “the man is real”. She’s talking about someone real, whom she knows will hear the song– he’s “a pretty good man”, and she pulls her punches: she doesn’t want to hurt him too much. But she has leaving “on her mind” these days… This isn’t The Dixie Chicks’ “Earl” getting a vicarious thrill out of name-calling. This is a mature woman who is tired of having to account for where she is, what she’s doing, where’s she going, where is she going to be, what’s she going to do, when are you here, when are you coming, what’s for dinner:

When I get that urge to run
I’m just like a kid again
A 12-year-old jail-breaker running away…

And we can add one more: Lucinda Williams’ “Side of the Road”. The narrator tells her man to pull over, she needs to get out of the car and stand in the tall wet grass and be alone–.

I wanna know you’re there, but I wanna stand alone
If only for a minute or two
I wanna know what it feels like to be without you
I wanna know the touch of my own skin
Against the sun, against the wind…

Okay — two more: isn’t the marvelous “Anchorage” by Michelle Shocked really about the same thing, contrasting two women who made different choices? Her friend:

Hey, ‘Chell, I think I’m a housewife…

…New York City, imagine that!
What’s it like to be a skateboarding punk-rocker?

…Leroy says hello

Leroy says, send a picture…

[added 2009-12] And always, always, always, the Leroys of the world say “send a picture”. We want to see this; we want to see what it’s like to escape, because we don’t generally have the courage or determination to do it ourselves.

[added 2012-07] Oh, what the heck: let’s not leave out one of the best songs of independence: Joan Armatrading’s  “Me Myself I”:

I set here by myself
And you know I love it
I don’t need someone
To come pay a visit
I wanna be by myself
I came in this world alone
Me myself I.


Best Looking Earnest Female Folk Singer Primarily Known as an  Interpreter of Other People’s Great Songs:

1. Emmy Lou Harris
2. Sylvia Fricker/Tyson
3. Jennifer Warnes

Least Best Looking Folk Singer Song-writer:

Tracey Chapman

Sorry.  But it’s okay– she really wouldn’t care what a man might think of her looks anyway.

The Man’s Perspective:

Runaway, by Del Shannon.

If he doesn’t know why why why she left, he should listen carefully to the songs discussed here.

John McCain Takes a Leisurely Walk Through Peaceful Downtown Baghdad on a Bright Sunny Day in Iraq

According to the New York Times, John McCain and other members of a congressional delegation recently took a walk through a Baghdad Market, browsing, drinking tea, haggling with the merchants, and getting their shopping done. Afterwards, all smiles, they reported that great progress was being made in Iraq. It was now safe to shop.

Mike Pence, a Republican from that centre of cosmopolitan diversity, Indiana, reported that it was just like taking a walk through a market down home. Of course, in Republican America, eventually he will be right.

What they did not report to the media was that they were accompanied by 100 American soldiers in Humvees, sharpshooters, attack helicopters, and bullet-proof vests. They didn’t report that traffic had been diverted away from the area for their visit, and access to the delegation by Iraqi citizens restricted.

The merchants themselves, after hearing McCain’s comments, were incredulous. They thought he was out of his mind. They reported that they were being driven out of business by the failure of the Americans to provide security.

This is more than just an interesting anecdote. Bush accuses congress of sabotaging the Iraq project by linking funding to a time-line for American withdrawal. Congress says, we don’t see that there is any progress. Rather than stay for another five or ten years and another 3,000 American lives, let’s get out now.

McCain supports Bush on this issue. It is rather striking that, in his search for some symbolic act of confidence, to show that there is real progress in Iraq, the only thing he could hit upon was this– a exercise in fakery and deception. This is a supporter of the war, remember. He wants us to believe things are getting better– there is progress.


McCain has also announced that he will copy George Bush’s campaign fund-raising strategy of lavishing side-splittingly hilarious adolescent nicknames upon donors of especially large amounts of cash. They will be called-…. wait for it… the McCain 100’s or McCain 200’s.

Doesn’t quite have the pizzazz of “ranger” or “most honored and lavishly-sucked-up-to-crony now, does it?” No wonder he is beginning to trail… wait for it… Mitt Romney! Yes, the only Republican candidate who has never cheated on his wife! The Mormon! Could it be that the fundamentalist wing of the party, that cohort that still thinks, given enough time, Iraqi’s will be lining up for macjobs at local fast-food outlets, has finally spoken?

It is very, very sad to see a man like McCain, who once seemed like such a promising alternative to all of the sold-out, compromised politicians of both parties, go down in flames.

Like Colin Powell, he has learned that it almost impossible to be honorable and a Republican.

Sooner or later, you’re going to have to get down on your knees behind someone like Dick Cheney and in front of someone like Jerry Falwell or James Dobson– those apostles of intolerance.

Demythologizing the Myth-crackers

Demythologizing the demythologized.

Did they really?

The 300 Spartans were accompanied by some 5,000 other Greeks. An indeterminate, smaller number of these Greeks remained behind with the Spartans for a last stand after the Persians surrounded them.

Yes, judges in Medieval Europe, in many instances, believed witches would float, and that they copulated with the devil himself…

They didn’t burn witches in Salem– they hanged them.  In one instance, they “pressed” a witch: put a board on him and loaded it with rocks until he died (one “witch” was  man, Corey).

And after years of see-saw analysis, it looks like most researchers accept that a disproportionate number of rich people made it onto the Titanic’s lifeboats, which is what Walter Lord observed right at the start. They didn’t need to elbow people aside: the stewards simply made sure that the 3rd class passengers did not reach the boat deck until well after the first class had the opportunity to get into the boats.

Al Gore never claimed to have “invented” the internet– he claimed that he took the “initiative” in supporting it’s early development. Gore was in fact an early congressional supporter of the progenitor of the internet, Arpanet. For all practical purposes, that statement is substantially true, though his choice of phrasing was unfortunate.

On the other hand, the statement that he claimed to have invented the internet, while not accurate, does reflect something of the pomposity of the way Gore phrased his statement. It was clumsy. It should have been passed over quickly, but Republicans love to point out that their candidate is the stupid one who would never, in a million years, ever be mistaken for anyone who could have invented anything of any importance, whereas the Democrats nominated someone who arrogantly achieved things.

Marie Antoinette? The quote might well be apocryphal, but the perception that she was indifferent to the suffering of the poor, while leading a ridiculously extravagant lifestyle–even gambling and “playing” at being a milk-maid– is substantially true. I find it somewhat nauseating to now see websites aimed at high school students encouraging them to get to know this remarkable woman, with tie-ins to the movie. This is flat out ridiculous.

Yes, Joseph McCarthy persecuted innocent people.  He persecuted some guilty people too, but he persecuted many innocent people, destroyed their careers and livelihoods unjustly, and behaved like a bully and a pig.

Yes, Eva Duarte slept her way to the top.  Absolutely.  Please, please don’t accept Madonna’s spin on history.

And yes, 38 people were aware (to somewhat varying degree) of the murder of Kitty Genovese in Kew Gardens and did nothing.

The video of Arabs dancing in the street to celebrate 9/11 has long ago been debunked.  The video was of some other event.

How about “Does Donald Trump really have the world’s greatest memory?”  Judge for yourself.  By almost all accounts of individuals who worked with him, he never read any position papers or memorandums that were submitted to him, because he preferred articles with pictures and television.  [2022-05-08]

 

Kitty Genovese: The Immediate vs the Reimagined Truth — “Of course I heard the screams”.

It is somewhat inevitable that every genuinely sensational and shocking news story will eventually generate hype and exaggeration and distortion. We never seem satisfied with even the most surprising story. So humans rewrite and exaggerate and distort, and, after a time, it becomes difficult to know what really happened. Did 300 Spartans really hold off 5 million Persians all by themselves? Did judges in Medieval Europe really believe that witches float? Did they burn witches at the stake in Salem, Massachusetts in the 17th century? Did the rich really elbow their way into the lifeboats on the Titanic? Did Joseph McCarthy really accuse completely innocent people of being communists in the 1950’s? Did Marie Antoinette really suggest that starving peasants should eat cake?  Answers here.

Did Al Gore really claim to have invented the internet? Did some Arabs really dance in the streets to celebrate 9/11?

Did 38 people really stand by and do nothing while Kitty Genovese was murdered on the streets of New York in March, 1964?

Did Evita Peron “whore” her way to the pinnacle of power in Argentina?

The funny thing is, the core truth of many of these stories, if you can see beyond the ridiculous exaggerations imposed on them by later generations or Hollywood, is often quite remarkable. It is only in comparison to the hype that people sometimes think the gist of the story is not true. Often, that is a mistake. And then you will always find contrarians willing to throw the baby out with the bathwater, so to speak.

Public shorthand for shocking events does tend to simplify and distort and exaggerate. At the same time, there is undoubtedly a temptation for a journalist or historian to uncover the exact truth and shout, “eureka– the public has been deceived” when, in fact, the essential truth of the original story is still quite compelling. We know there will always be some exaggeration and distortion in the retelling of human events.  But immediate first-hand accounts are often quite accurate.  They are less likely to be edited in memory by the spin imposed on events by public hysteria.

We also know, for example, that some of the people Senator Joseph McCarthy persecuted really were or had been communists. Anne Coulter, who wrote a book on the subject, would have you believe that this a shocking revelation that changes the meaning of “McCarthyism” and proves that Joseph McCarthy was actually a hero.

But then, someone else will come along and go back to the original story and discover, all over again, that Senator Joseph McCarthy was a repulsive, vainglorious, vindictive alcoholic thug and bully, and that his tactics really did constitute “persecution” and that he really was engaged in a “witch hunt”, in which refusing to answer questions made you just as guilty as a confession, and, of course, that most of his victims were innocent.

And so someone named Joseph De May has made the shocking discovery that 38 people did not actually watch Kitty Genovese’s murder from beginning to end.

De May’s “discovery” is only shocking if you have ever actually believed that 38 people actually saw the killing, with their eyeballs, from beginning to end and clearly saw a knife and saw Kitty Genovese bleeding to death and did nothing. I’m sure some people remember the story that way. I wonder how many reasonable people do.

You first have to appreciate that De May believes that the word “witness” should only apply to people who saw an event, clearly, with their eyes. He believes that that is what everyone else thinks too, and he spends a lot of time trying very hard to prove that 38 people did not see the murder.

My memory of the event is that 38 people heard or saw something of the attack and that not one of them called the police or offered any assistance to the young girl. After all of De May’s convoluted explanations, that information remains essentially accurate.

I don’t remember anyone ever insisting that most or all of the 38 actually saw the attack clearly. I don’t know why that would make a big difference to Joseph De May who admits that at least 12 people saw some part of the attack and at least 20 other people heard part of the attack and knew something was going on on the street below their windows. The New York Times editor, Abe Rosenthal, who wrote a book on the subject, insists that no New York Times reporter ever stated that 38 people saw the attack. The article uses the term “witness” as I would: people who heard or saw.  People who were aware of the incident at the time it happened.

I don’t think it would even have occurred to me to think about whether all 38 people saw the entire attack from the beginning to the end. Why would that make any difference?

De May insists that there were two separate attacks, not three.. Again, I’m not sure why he thinks that makes a big difference. Are we supposed to go, “Oh, well then, I can understand why no one went down to assist the girl. They were waiting for a third attack…” Furthermore, his case on that point is not as air-tight as he seems to think it is. He finds very little evidence in the official court record, but there is some witness evidence that Moseley went away and then came back twice. It’s not clear– and it doesn’t really matter– if he counts that as two attacks or one.

The essential facts as reported in the initial New York Times article remain substantially correct. The one disputed fact that would matter is this: De May claims to know of someone who did phone the police after the first attack. His evidence for this is not very compelling. A former New York City cop claims to have known an unidentified “old-timer” who told him that he had worked at that precinct the night in question and had received the first call. This was reported to De May 30 or 40 years after the events. Remember — the New York Times article was written the same month as the attacks, before people had a chance to “interpret” their memories.

There is as much– no– less!– evidence for this blockbuster claim than there is for the assertion that there were three, not two separate attacks. It’s unaccountable hearsay by someone who would have an interest in proving that his family or friends were not indifferent to human suffering.

Talk about a scoop! And Mr. Michael Hoffman– the retired cop–decided, in the face of all the publicity about this case, to keep this information secret until just recently! That’s is truly astonishing. It is even more astonishing that Mr. De May was not embarrassed to put this into the public record without even being able to supply the name of the police officer who told someone who told someone.

Then he proceeds to report that Andree Picq also called. Why, there was a veritable torrent of phone calls. Except that Andree felt her throat constrict and didn’t actually say anything on the phone before hanging up. So how do we know she called? She says so. The police, who indisputably did respond when they received a real call later, have no record of her call.

De May quotes the Times article about a man who saw the second attack. He told the reporter that he didn’t call the police because he was tired. He went back to bed. De May stunningly excuses this man because the Times reporter did not provide details of what the man thought he saw– only of the fact that he went back to bed right after he claimed he saw it. The man, by the time he talked to the reporter, knew a murder had taken place. He knew that what he was claiming to have witnessed resulted in the death of a young neighbor, and he knew the reporter knew that. Yet he casually dismisses his responsibility with “I was tired”… and De May exonerates him.

The rest of De May’s article consists of a lot of quibbling. It was rather dark. It was cold. It was not unusual for boisterous people to make a lot of noise in the streets nearby. Genovese got up after the first attack and may not have staggered quite as dramatically as some people believe she did. She seemed to walk slowly.

But even De May does not deny that Kitty screamed, “Oh, my God, he stabbed me! Please help me! Please help me!” But he actually quibbles over whether Winston Moseley stabbed her before or after she screamed! If he stabbed her first, then the witnesses who came to their windows could not have actually seen a stabbing. So then… you can’t blame them for ignoring the cries of “he stabbed me! Help me! Help me!”?

De May tries to argue that many of the witnesses would likely have thought that the noise coming from the street was not unusual for a neighborhood with a bar on the corner. But he had already admitted that people came to their windows to try to see what was going on– he argues that they couldn’t see very much. Why would they bother going to the window at 3:00 in the morning if they thought the screaming was coming from just one of many inebriated couples having a quarrel?

De May seems to think that people generally believe that most of the witnesses told police that they didn’t call because they didn’t think it was any of their business. I don’t know why anyone would think everyone would say the same thing.

Rather astoundingly, De May, defending the indifferent bystanders, actually lists five instances of people who testified in court that they heard Kitty screaming but did nothing. He quotes a witness as stating that he heard Kitty say “help me, help me” as proof that he did not hear Kitty say “he stabbed me”, and therefore… therefore what? Therefore had no obligation as a human being to react? To help? To at least call the police? The question is not whether the witnesses had an accurate perception of what was happening. The question is whether what the majority of witnesses heard and saw should have compelled a responsible citizen to at least investigate further. Some witnesses opened their windows. How large of a step is it to the point at which you shout to Kitty Genovese, “Are you okay? Do you want me to call the police?”

De May admits that the reporter whose article he claims to debunk, Martin Gansberg, interviewed virtually all of the same witnesses the police interviewed, immediately after the event. The product of Gansberg’s intimate familiarity with the feelings and attitudes of these witnesses is the conclusion that most of these people did not care enough about what they heard to investigate further, to provide assistance, or even to phone the police. De May admits that at least a dozen people heard something at 3:00 a.m., got out of bed, went to the window, and then went back to bed, or just stayed at the window and watched. Why? Because, he says, they justifiably believed nothing important was happening. And none of them decided to investigate further, even though what they heard was compelling enough to get them out of bed?

We enter into the realm of ridiculousness when De May starts describing how complicated it was to call the police with a telephone in 1964– before 911. A reasonable person could be forgiven for believing that many New Yorkers might actually be familiar with the process, or might have the number near their phones.

Karl Ross, who did finally instigate a phone call to the police– by asking another neighbor to do it– told the police, “I didn’t want to get involved”. Another woman told the police that she told her husband not to get involved.

I can’t find any evidence in De May’s website to prove his rather astounding claim that some people did in fact call immediately after the first attack. He claims that the police might not have recorded such a call. But the police responded immediately to a specific call that was made too late. Why would anyone think they had ignored an earlier call, but not this one? They were at the scene in 3 minutes.

Given the publicity this case generated, if someone had called, why would they not have come forward? Why doesn’t De May identify the person? Such a person would have been received as a hero. But the police, who interviewed everyone who lived in the area, could not locate a single person who claimed to have called them earlier than the neighbor asked by Mr. Ross.

De May argues that some of the witnesses may have been reluctant to call the police because they feared retribution. Well, this has become pathetic. After trying very hard to convince us that the witnesses never saw anything anyway, De May now wants us to believe that these good citizens were simply wisely looking after themselves and that’s why they closed their windows and went back to bed. So now he concedes that a number of people, had they not feared retribution, could have been expected to call the police?

Here he has clearly entered advocacy mode. He is no longer really interested in clearing up some misconceptions about the attack: he wants to restore the reputations of the citizens of Kew Gardens. Amazingly, just before making this argument, he argues that Kew Gardens was so crime free, that most of the witnesses probably didn’t believe they were actually seeing a murder. Or was it that they were so used to drunks leaving a nearby bar that they didn’t see anything remarkable about a woman screaming at 3:00 a.m., though it was remarkable enough to draw them out of bed and to their window, and for some of them to open their windows and try to see what was happening?

As proof that the 38 witnesses were not indifferent, De May quotes this one:

Of course I heard the screams. But there was nothing I could do. I was afraid. My hands were trembling. I couldn’t have dialed for an operator if I’d tried. I never even thought of it. I was too afraid.

That sounds about right. I don’t know why De May thinks this would correct my impression of what happened that night. It is one of what I would expect to be many reasons given by the 38 as to why they chose not to do anything. The “of course I heard the screams” is a ringing indictment: obviously many of the witnesses heard the screams.

What we have is revisionism. Now that the notoriety of Kew Gardens has been established, the people involved have revised their memories.

None of the reasons each individual had for inaction are very good. Each individual excuses, while unfortunate, is not preposterous. But what was compelling about the story of the murder of Kitty Genovese and remains just as compelling today is that a large number of people had good reason to be concerned about what was happening in the street just below them and chose to do nothing.

Joseph De May Fixes History

De May’s “research” [the website is down] into the issue was neither scrupulous nor objective. One of many examples was his complete trust in single-sourced anecdotal evidence that there were earlier calls to the police. The original news story relied on interviews with dozens of residents of Genovese’s apartment building.

[The original website about Kew Gardens is no longer there.]

Update 2011-11: David Brooks in the New York Times casually referred to the “mostly apocryphal” Kitty Genovese case. What shocked me is that only one respondent called him out on it.

More Update: a new angle has emerged with the fact that Kitty Genovese was gay, and living in a relationship with another woman at the time of the murder. Was that a factor in the indifference of her neighbors to what was happening? I’m skeptical.

Wikipedia stumbles: I like Wikipedia and I think that it is generally an extremely reliable source of information. However, it’s entry on Kitty Genovese is a bit strange. On the contentious issue of whether anyone else called the police before Karl Ross, Wikipedia reports, without citation:

Records of the earliest calls to police are unclear and were certainly not given a high priority by the police. One witness said his father called police after the initial attack and reported that a woman was “beat up, but got up and was staggering around.”

There is no objective contemporaneous news source for this claim. It sounds a lot, to me, like someone is hoping to rewrite history.

Furthermore, Wikipedia states flatly:

Moseley also testified at his own trial where he further described the attack, leaving no question that he was the killer.

“No question”? Albert DeSalvo claimed to be the Boston Strangler and provided the police with details of the crime scenes that, supposedly, only the perpetrator could have known. If you read the book by Gerold Frank, you know how convincing this story was. How else could Albert DeSalvo had known, for example, about a notebook hidden under a bed, or what kind of scarf was used to strangle Joann Graff, and so on?

DNA evidence later proved that he was not the man who murdered and raped Mary Sullivan, who was widely regarded as the last victim of the Boston Strangler. For good reason, many now suspect he didn’t commit any of the murders.

Apparently, the police can sometimes carelessly let those details slip into the conversation while trying to build a convincing confession… or not so carelessly. Several persons involved with the investigation later ran for political office: there was enormous pressure to solve the case. According to the Crime Library, top investigator John Bottomly clearly fed DeSalvo information to make the confession look convincing.

These murders occurred in exactly the same time period as Kitty Genovese’s murder. I have never heard anyone question whether Moseley actually did it, but some of the parallels are interesting, including the lack of physical evidence linking him to the crime, the quick voluntary confession, and the lack of eyewitness corroboration.

Here’s the alarming bit: Moseley also confessed to at least one other crime for which he was never charged… because police firmly believed they already had the culprit in custody.  That flashes a big fat red light, considering what we now know about unethical police interrogation methods.

Has anyone ever taken up this case? I don’t believe Moseley himself claims innocence– but then again, what would be the point? I think Moseley probably did do it– I just don’t think anyone should be glib about it given the lack of physical evidence.

Making it More Illegal

I recently read about a murder and rape in Florida, of a young girl, which has led to demands for new laws. They want the new law to be named after the victim.

With all due the respect, this idea of creating new laws every time a sensational crime is committed, is a very bad way to make laws. It is a very, very bad way to make laws.

It was not legal to rape and murder children when the crime was committed, and there really is no way to make it even more illegal than it already was. The shameless politicians behind these laws evade this issue by adding meaningless technicalities. They make it a separate crime to murder someone while drinking a slushy or something. So suspects can be charged with murder and with committing murder while drinking a slushy, and then with willfully committing a murder while drinking a slushy on a Tuesday..

And the idea that sentences need to be tougher than they already are in the most barbaric nation in the industrialized world, is preposterous. Nothing is going to bring back the victim of a murder, and I don’t believe that it really is satisfying to anyone to see someone else suffer as a consequence of the suffering caused to you. It’s just surrendering to the most childish of natural impulses: to hit back.

Allan Bloom & Leo Strauss and Real Political Correctness

The 20th was a century unlike any other.

I am this moment interested in one particular difference– the democratization of knowledge– the massive influx of middle-class and poor students into post-secondary institutions of higher learning that occurred in the 1960’s, and our ever-so-sweet, controversial, apocalyptic moral decline. Here we are. We’ve declined. We have the morality of alley cats. How did we get here?

For all the white noise and rhetorical flashes over the issue, it’s really not all that complicated. Until the 20th century, only the children of very rich, very privileged people could receive a higher education. These were children of people who benefited from the status quo. They were the status quo, either the church or the aristocracy. And all intellectual conversation took place on their terms, in their language, in a manner congenial to their ultimate self-interests, especially when it concerned noblesse oblige.

And then suddenly you have democracy and a prosperous middle class and suddenly children of hard-working middle-class parents get to go to college, and buy records, and go to movies, and read books, and suddenly Leo Strauss and Allan Bloom are whining about the tragic loss of culture and learning when what they really mean is that their privileged little ivory towers no longer command the landscape, and those suckers, those helplessly inane but physically peerless farmer’s boys, were no longer mindlessly willing to go immolate themselves on spears and in trenches in order to preserve Allan Bloom’s right to buy $4,000 dinner jackets, smoke Cuban cigars, and troll the streets of Paris looking for rough trade.

The same elitist attitudes certainly exist today. There has been no decline. If anything, there is probably more elitist achievement and behavior today than there ever was before. But the elitists are outnumbered. And they hate it. They just can’t stand the fact that Bruce Springsteen sells more copies of his songs about seducing New Jersey girls named Sandy with tight unzipped jeans, than the Chicago symphony will ever sell of any work by Beethoven. More people have seen “Blade Runner” than will ever see “Hamlet”. Besides, I’m not all that sure that “Hamlet” really is more important, or more of an indication of sophisticated and developed taste than “Blade Runner” is.

The bottom line is never surprising. Neo-cons like Bloom and Strauss and their disciples (who don’t occupy quite as many positions within the Bush administration as they used to) want to build a world in which their social and political class get to dictate culture to the masses. For all their bitter complaining about the “nanny state”, they are far more authoritarian, and far more willing to over-rule popular taste.

They are and always have been the real advocates of “political correctness”: patriotism, chastity, prurience, and consumerism.

 

Throw Away the Key II

On the famously liberal TV network, CBS, there is a program called “48 Hours” which recently ran an episode on the efforts of two women to keep a murderer, Wesley Wayne Miller, in jail.

Wesley Miller was a football player. He looked like Tom Cruise. He was a star of the team– or is that just a cliché offered by “48 Hours” to hype the story?– and you know how America treats athletes. You can be a complete moron and a good athlete and everyone will love you. It’s hard to tell if Miller was a moron or not. He doesn’t get to express himself very much in this piece.

Wesley Wayne Miller was convicted of rape and murder and sentenced to 25 years in jail. I have no sympathy for Wesley Wayne Miller. He had a parole hearing after two years. That was probably due to some legal technicality and I doubt he had the slightest real chance of getting paroled– this is Texas– but it seemed disturbing.

I do have a lot of respect for the concept of “rule by law”. That means that a society agrees on a way to create and amend laws, creates and amends the laws, passes them, and then insists that they be applied equally and consistently to all citizens. The point of all this is that just because you like someone doesn’t mean you can give him a lighter sentence than someone else you don’t like. Personal bias should not be a factor. There should be clear and objective criteria. We don’t invite the family of the victim to determine what the punishment should be, for good reason: it would lead (as it has in the past) to blood feuds.

All of us, through our votes, determine what kind of justice system we have.

Well, now that I mention it– I don’t think that is true anymore. We do allow families of victims to give impact statements, though they still do not directly determine the sentence given.

The reporter of the piece, Susan Spenser professes astonishment at the “light” sentence Wesley Miller received. I was astonished that she considered the sentence light. That’s a pretty amazing judgment: 25 years locked up in a prison cell is a “light” sentence?  I suppose it is, compared to floggings or torture or slow strangulation.

The program proceeded to ascribe guilt for three or four other rapes to Wesley Wayne Miller, in spite of the fact that he was never charged or convicted of them. One victim now just “knows” it was him. He “probably” committed the others. Why bother with a trial? Who else could it have been?

And now that the viewers “know” (they do not “know” this)  that this man has committed all kinds of other crimes, over and on top of the one murder and rape, don’t you just share the absolute horror of the reporter at the idea that a man could serve his sentence and then be freed?

Miller applied for parole and was turned down several times. He was ordered to attend classes to remediate his sexual deviancy– is this some kind of joke? He refused. A psychologist regularly employed by the state certified that Wesley Miller had no redeeming characteristics whatsoever– a fascinating conclusion based on some kind of amazing insights that only a framed degree can give you.

Rona Stratton is the sister of Miller’s victim, Retha Stratton. She and her best friend, Lisa Gabbert, have made it their life’s mission to ensure that Miller pay forever for murdering Retha Stratton. They made sure that he never got parole by attending all of his hearings and organizing petitions.

They express deep pleasure– almost a sense of taunting– in watching Miller walk by during these hearings, knowing that they are partly responsible for keeping him in jail.

When he was finally released under Texas’ obligatory early release program (designed to reduce over-crowding in their despicably ill-managed prisons), they tried to get every community he could be assigned to to reject him. He ended up living in a county jail instead of a half-way house, where he was locked up for 23 hours a day. That kind of defeats the purpose of a transition home. Miller didn’t get any chance at all to adjust to life on the outside.

Now, I could see how the two women might take some grim satisfaction in seeing that Miller was not released early. But I was fascinated by the pleasure they took in it, their delight in hounding the guy. It’s almost impossible to feel sympathy for a former high school football jock, rapist and murderer, but you almost start to– he was told his sentence was for 25 years. They didn’t tell him that he would be fair game for family and friends of his victims to do whatever they could to increase his suffering as much as possible.

The two women succeeded in lobbying for a new law that created a special category of sexual offenders who could be controlled in various ways indefinitely by the state even after they had served their sentences. Is this constitutional?

More importantly: if a person is so psychotic that he deserves to be held indefinitely by the state, how can he be held to be criminally responsible for his crimes?

If Wesley Miller was criminally responsible, and not “psychotic”, then he would be sentenced to jail time. He wouldn’t get to go to a “cushy” psychiatric hospital, from which suspiciously intellectual and effeminate psychologists would be able to eventually release him as cured. No, no, no.

So he is a criminal. So he is criminally responsible. So, all right: he gets 25 years. I don’t think that’s a light sentence but some do. Well, tough. That’s the jury system. He was tried fair and square. If you don’t like the results, complain to the jury.

But don’t try this: change the laws afterwards so you can get back at him some other way. And that’s what they did. And now they are trying to get the law applied to Wesley Miller even though the law was enacted well after he had committed his crimes and been convicted and sentenced for them. Is that fair?  Is it constitutional?

It is absolutely not constitutional.

These two women are immune to any kind of backlash: they are family and friend of victims. How dare you think they might just might be vindictive or cruel, or that the sense of purpose they have found for their lives, inflicting suffering on another human being, is anything less than righteous, virtuous wrath?

That it might be misguided, narcissistic, and demeaning?

The sheer joy with which America punishes criminals with long, brutal sentences, makes you wonder if this will ever be a civilized society. It’s easy to be civilized if you think it means donating to charities and having award shows. It’s a lot harder if you think the heart of civility is the ability to see beyond personal payback.


2015-11-24 Update: And Just What is “civil commitment” anyway?

After serving his 25 years, and ending up in a county jail, authorities charged him with violations of the terms of his “civil commitment”. What did he do that was so awful? He received visits from his brother and his father. While incarcerated.

What did he receive for allowing his father and brother to visit him? (Presumably, it was his fault, even though you might think the prison authorities were partly responsible for letting them in when they presumably shouldn’t have.) Ten years, on each count.

But the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals– in a rare moment of sanity– overturned the sentences because, after all, he was incarcerated at the times of the visit, so the restriction, which applied to a person on parole, did not apply.

So what is “civil commitment”? It’s a way to get around the law to punish people we particularly don’t like. This statement from another report sums it up perfectly: “He was required to live at the jail after his release”. I’m sure Wesley Miller can’t afford the kind of constitutional lawyers who could tear this kind of law to shreds.

I remain baffled at the fact that some states have been allowed to use the results of lie detector tests to determine if a person remains in “civil commitment”. Lie Detectors do not work. Has no lawyer been able to challenge this rule yet?

Anne Coulter’s Outburst

Anne Coulter’s outburst about John Edwards, calling him a “faggot”, like some prissy little schoolyard brat, got more than a little undeserved media attention. And it’s true that it’s fun to watch. Like Borat, singing the national anthem at a Texas Rodeo.

If there is a difference, it might be that no liberal groups, that I know of, would seriously consider inviting Sacha Baron Cohen to give the keynote at a serious gathering on policy or governance. Anne Coulter would be invited, and she is invited. There are conservatives who actually like and respect her and think she is a kind of prophetic figure who, inevitably, will be persecuted for her faith.

Liberals probably shouldn’t take her seriously, but then again, I’m not sure liberals take the Christian Right seriously enough. If you’ve watched the documentary, “Jesus Camp”, you might be somewhat alarmed at the militant dogmatism of this segment of the political spectrum, the absolute conviction that God is telling them exactly what to do, and that anyone who disagrees or opposes them is Satan’s spawn. No, they’re not burning witches at the moment. Probably they won’t soon. But the U.S. is locking up people without trial, sending them off to be tortured overseas, and dismissing the need for evidence or testimony against terrorist suspects.

Anne Coulter, if you’ve forgotten, once urged the U.S. to invade and Christianize hostile Arab states.  The last person on the entire earth that I would believe exemplifies any value you could associate with Christ is Anne Coulter.

She is a pimple on the forehead of American conservatism– a big, ugly, festering red one that just won’t go away.