The Orwellian School

High schooler Blake Robbins filed an invasion of privacy lawsuit against his school, alleging that the Lower Merion School District had taken hundreds of secret photos of him over a two-week period. His family discovered this when a teacher accused Robbins of dealing drugs based on one of the photos.  Forbes (see link).

My first question is, does this school district teach George Orwell’s “1984”?  What do they teach about it?  What do they tell students about sick, totalitarian, repressive, intrusive, voyeuristic minds that have nothing but contempt for the privacy rights of any individual?

How the hell does this not result in criminal action?  Because the school district’s asserted intent was “good”?   How the hell does this not result in a police investigation in which it is determined which individual employee or group of employees at the school board decided to secretly spy on their own students, in their bedrooms, and retain the obtained images.  How the hell did these people not get arrested?

A student named Blake Robbins was photographed “dealing drugs”.  He says he was sharing candies, not pills, and the police never charged him, but Mr. Robbins wondered why the police ever thought he was dealing drugs.  Well, they had a photo, which the school district had given them, showing Mr. Robbins “dealing”.

The school denied any active spying, saying that security software activated for laptops suspected of being stolen kicked in automatically, and took photos every 15 minutes. That defense, while reasonable, was made shaky by the school’s possession of over 56,000 Webcam shots.   Forbes (see link below).

Forbes points out that the school district’s biggest mistake was not telling the students that the school district would be spying on them and taking photos of them in their bedrooms.    Forbes says, “if they had, they likely would not have gotten into so much legal trouble of the civil variety”, while pointing out, again, that there was no criminal charges filed.  The prosecutors “declined” to press charges.

You would think the school district had shot some people with a licensed gun: recklessly, with negligence, or in sheer stupidity– it doesn’t matter: they would be immune because Americans believe that of all the things in the world you could be liable for in terms of causing death, destruction, or mayhem, one of them is not ever going to be a gun.

Robbins successfully sued the school board.  He won $600,000.  Then his lawyer took $425,000 of that– the cost of seeing justice done.

How the hell, was this lawyer not also arrested?

The Forbes Article

The Discovery of Consciousness

Wow. Shocking. So this “talented” student has discovered consciousness. This is a “breakthrough”.

I assume these tests were normally conducted by employers to evaluate employees and judge how suitable they might be for senior level positions. Managers. Leaders. Supervisors.

What Carolyn Bate did was apply these tests to a number of students. First she measured their IQs. Then she had them answer a number of questions the answers to which will help assess whether the person is capable of empathy or other normal feelings of compassion or kindness. After collecting this information, Carolyn had the subjects go through a different test utilizing Galvanic Skin Response– a lie-detector, really– to measure responses to a series of pictures which are intended to evoke feelings of empathy and compassion.

Carolyn found that the GSR responses among her participants were much as she would have predicted – except for the fact that it was only those with lower levels of intelligence who displayed the expected levels of excitement.

In other words, smart people were able to fool the lie-detector. I mean, the Galvanic Skin Response machine. They were able to fake the right emotional responses.

Like Generals and politicians and hedge-fund managers and brokers and bankers and investors and General Motors executives and arms manufacturers and football players and so on and on and on.

This kind of muddies the issue. Do organizations use the Galvanic Skin Response machine to test their employees?

Can it be that most psychology students, until now, have assumed that people filling out their questionnaires simply responded to their queries with uninhibited instinctive honesty? Oh woeful day! Now they will have to go back over all of their studies and begin to account for the fact that people might have understood what those questions were about and how their responses might be interpreted and whether or not they like those interpretations and whether or not they really like the feeling of revealing their true thoughts to a stranger, even if it’s all supposed to be anonymous and private.

But Carolyn misses the biggest point of all: how many corporations would not, in fact, leap at the chance to hire a true psycho who was capable of concealing his complete lack of empathy for customers, investors, civilians, and reporters?

The Discovery of Consciousness

A BREAKTHROUGH by a talented University of Huddersfield student has shown for the first time that people with psychopathic tendencies who have high IQs can mask their symptoms by manipulating tests designed to reveal their personalities. It raises the possibility that large numbers of ruthless risk-takers are able to conceal their level of psychopathy as they rise to key managerial posts.   University of Huddersfield Academic Journal

Wow. Shocking. So this “talented” student has discovered consciousness. This is a “breakthrough”.

I assume these tests were normally conducted by employers to evaluate employees and judge how suitable they might be for senior level positions. Managers. Leaders. Supervisors.

What Carolyn Bate did was apply these tests to a number of students. First she measured their IQs. Then she had them answer a number of questions the answers to which will help assess whether the person is capable of empathy or other normal feelings of compassion or kindness. After collecting this information, Carolyn had the subjects go through a different test utilizing Galvanic Skin Response– a lie-detector, really– to measure responses to a series of pictures which are intended to evoke feelings of empathy and compassion.

Carolyn found that the GSR responses among her participants were much as she would have predicted – except for the fact that it was only those with lower levels of intelligence who displayed the expected levels of excitement.

In other words, smart people were able to fool the lie-detector. I mean, the Galvanic Skin Response machine. They were able to fake the right emotional responses.

Like Generals and politicians and hedge-fund managers and brokers and bankers and investors and General Motors executives and arms manufacturers and football players and so on and on and on.

This kind of muddies the issue. Do organizations use the Galvanic Skin Response machine to test their employees?

Can it be that most psychology students, until now, have assumed that people filling out their questionnaires simply responded to their queries with uninhibited instinctive honesty?

Oh woeful day! Now they will have to go back over all of their studies and begin to account for the fact that people might have understood what those questions were about and how their responses might be interpreted and whether or not they like those interpretations and whether or not they really like the feeling of revealing their true thoughts to a stranger, even if it’s all supposed to be anonymous and private.

But Carolyn misses the biggest point of all: how many corporations would not, in fact, leap at the chance to hire a true psycho who was capable of concealing his complete lack of empathy for customers, investors, civilians, and reporters?

Is “Huddersfield” a real name?

Falsifiable Theories of Depression

I offer a hypothetical.

Suppose that the best, most effective treatment for depression or emotional trauma was to suck it up and get on with your life?

Remember– this is a hypothesis. You don’t have to assume it’s true or that I am saying it’s true. You certainly don’t need to politicize it. I provide it in the spirit of Karl Popper’s idea — which I endorse– that it must be possible, theoretically, to prove any theory false, in order for it to be proven true. It must be falsifiable.

For example, if we assert that a certain bird eats worms, then we must be able to describe a method by which we could prove it false. Let’s say we are able to monitor the bird for every hour of every day for a week and to record with a camera everything that it eats. I think most of us would accept that if the bird never touched a single worm, the theory would be false. That seems silly on one level– don’t we only have to see the bird eat a worm to know that the theory is true? Yes. But that is because we can, theoretically, prove it if it didn’t. We think it’s a silly proof because it is so easy to do, but that’s why it works.

Here’s a more difficult one: preparing for war increases the possibility of war. In order to prove this hypothesis, we need to find an example of how it could be proven false. Let’s say, for example, that there was a country that never prepared for war. Like Costa Rica, which does not have an army. Costa Rica, sitting there in one of the most violent areas in the world, Central America, has never been invaded. Nobody is scared of Costa Rica. Nobody is worried that Costa Rica is going to invade their country and take their gold.

That’s only one example, so it’s not a very strong proof. We do have lots and lots of countries that do prepare for war and have prepared for war and got their wars. We don’t have so many countries who prepared for war and were thus able to avoid war. The big obvious one is the U.S., prepared– on a very large scale– for war with the Soviet Union, which, it would be argued, never happened because the U.S. was prepared. But our proxy nations like Guatemala, Iran, Chile, El Salvador, and so on, were not so fortunate.

Of course, the U.S. does go to war, often.  Point made.

Here’s another more anodyne example: pulling the goalie in the last few minutes of a hockey game does not improve the chances of victory.  Nobody dares to defy this piece of conventional wisdom.  Just imagine the crowd watching the home team trailing by one goal with one minute left and the face-off in the opponents end of the rink and the coach does not pull the goalie.  The crowd– and every sportswriter– would howl with derision.  But unless someone starts doing it regularly–not pulling the goalie– we’ll never know if it’s true or not.  (In fact, apparently in the KHL, Russia’s professional league, pulling the goalie is rare.)  My theory is that pulling the goalie doesn’t increase your chances of winning, but I’ll never be proven wrong, because nobody will test that hypothetical.

Anyway, suppose that you believe that the best way to deal with depression is to go see a therapist, get counseling, maybe some chemicals to adjust the serotonin levels in your brain (an idea which now seems to have been proven dubious). How would you know that was true? Well, you would have to be able to — theoretically– prove it was false.

Here’s the problem. If it is false, you would have a substantial number of people out there who were depressed but took the attitude that it was best to just suck it up and get on with your life…. and were less depressed because that’s what they did. In other words, just sucking it up and getting on with your life can be effective for some people who are depressed.

But here’s the catch: the clinicians and theoreticians and pharmaceutical companies who believe in therapies would say, those people are not really depressed.

Therefore, they are excluded from the sample that we analyze when discussing what works. In other words, the successes of the alternative approaches are simply excluded from the sample, so that only those who seek therapy and receive chemical treatments are in the pool of subjects.

That’s a self-fulfilling hypothesis.

Robin Williams

Robin Williams was a brilliant standup comedian, a master of improvisation, and an exceptional mimic. He became very famous for his brilliant improvisations– precisely the reason why it became impossible for him to make a truly great film. His talent was not the talent that is useful to a director or writer when creating a film. He made films because Hollywood makes films with celebrities, not actors.

As an actor, I always thought he was less than average, confusing restraint and modulation for character. Hollywood knew what to do with him– in the perverse way Hollywood deals with all original talents: take out all the guts, add some heart-warming dreck, and make the audience feel sophisticated. Make him a saintly, wise, lovable psychiatrist, only barely more believable than Liv Tyler in “Reign Over Me”, who devotes all of his waking hours to a single disturbed math whiz and provides miraculous cures that no one in the real world has ever experienced. Dress him as a woman and set his fake breasts on fire in the preposterous and schmaltzy “Mrs. Doubtfire”: a sure Hollywood winner because our hero is funny and wicked and naughty AND– he loves his family! This was a conceit so fantastical that it took hours and hours of the best make-up crew in Hollywood to make it even remotely not ridiculous. Set him up against cardboard cutout stereo-typed villains — in most of his films, but most egregiously in “Patch Adams”– so the audience feels wonderful about being on the side of people they can’t stand in real life. His roles were emasculated, neutered, homogenized, cleaned up and packaged for mass audiences.

But I would have liked to see him live as Estragon in “Waiting for Godot” (with Steve Martin as Vladimir). But even there, at least one reviewer was ambivalent about Williams’ “stage antics”. (Steve Martin, in the same production, was also dissed by the reviewer, for blending too far into the background, a phenomenon I have noted, in which great comic talents believe that by not being antic they are actually “acting” and creating a character.

Amid all the drivel that always rises to the top upon the death of a popular entertainer, the most ridiculous is that, besides being a great comic, he was also a great actor: he was not. I think people were so impressed by the contrast between his drawn-in, restrained, sedated performances an actor, especially in “One Hour Photo”, that they confused the absence of character expression with the presence of talent.

Williams’ talents were far more suited to secondary characters, dissolute friends, unfaithful husbands, writers and artists, drunks, and bums. So “The Fisher King” was an ideal platform for him– except, they couldn’t stand to have him play a real homeless psycho, so they eliminated all the real-life characteristics of homeless people– the things that make them a real problem to deal with– and sweetened him up and cleaned him up so he was adorable and safe, and thereby obviated the entire point of the movie. The only example of Hollywood doing this worse is “Reign Over Me”– which, it must be admitted, was way more repulsive.

Of all of them– and some were very, very awful– “The Dead Poets Society” pissed me off the most because it was a calculated pitch to audiences who think they have better taste than most people because they will go to a movie with the word “poet” in the title and features scattered readings of one or two lines from poets who are famous for being poets (but nobody too obscure, please, or my friends won’t be as impressed), but who could never actually stand listening to any poem more complex than a limerick.

“Dead Poets Society” was never really about poetry or life at all. It was about admiring yourself for seeing a movie in which a charismatic actor does everything except poetry. He has the pipe and the patches on the sweater and the high brow manners, but if “Dead Poets Society” showed you, for even an instant, the real stuff of poetry, mass audiences would be offended and frightened and would hurry back to their TV sets. The boys themselves don’t live poetry: they admire it like dilettantes, adopting the symbols and manners but none of the substance of a poetic conscious: they completely forget that great poetry is always about something and only the worst, dullest, least interesting poetry is about poetry.

The sad, sad truth is that Robin Williams did not factor in a single movie that mattered.

Robin Williams Least Worst Films (no, you haven’t seen them):

Have you seen “World’s Greatest Dad”?  Now go see “Dear Evan Hansen”.

Un huh.  Familiar, isn’t it?

Uninvited Unknowns

More than half of the female respondents said they weren’t taken seriously because of their gender, one in three had experienced delayed career advancement, and nearly half said they had not received credit for their ideas. Almost half said they had encountered flirtatious or sexual remarks, and one in five had experienced uninvited physical contact.

Here, at their most glib, the high priestesses of feminist grievance take their stand: “flirtations and sexual remarks” and “uninvited” physical contact.

How, I wonder, would you know if you were not being taken seriously because of your gender or because you are inane?

Assume nothing. In a scientific test of these theories you would need to establish some kind of baseline, a control, to measure “taken seriously” against. How do you know you are not just wrong and incoherent?  Or that you are talking about yourself instead of the subject of the conversation?

I certainly wonder how many uninvited physical contacts I would personally experience in an average day. I don’t mind the physical contacts, a woman patting my arm, a man offering a pat on the shoulders. Sometimes, it’s an expression of “way to go” or “careful, I’m crossing behind you”. They are always uninvited. I never invite anyone I work with to make physical contact. Nor do I ever mind if they do.

The Necessity of Secrets

To those who continue to insist that no law-abiding citizen has anything to fear from government surveillance or ubiquitous security cameras or cell phones that constantly report your location to your service provider: please go live in your own country with like-minded people and you can all watch each other all the time.

Better yet, someone needs to organize a group of volunteers to contact one of these congressmen or NSA administrators or FBI or CIA officials and ask for their address and their license number and make and model, and photos, and announce that this person is now going to be followed, 24/7, by these volunteer citizens, because this person doesn’t think the average American citizen has anything to fear from being spied on.

On-Line Learning

More Bill on Student Debt.

I have not yet seen a serious article or essay on the character, value, or deficiencies of “on line” education.

I am baffled by people who are convinced that you can replace classrooms filled with flesh-and-blood professors and students with a tv screen and a keyboard.

It is impossible to have a lively, dynamic, challenging, stimulating, discussion online. It’s just not possible. It’s crap. It’s turning education into television.
There is a caveat. In a lot of popular courses at a University or college it never was possible to have a lively interactive discussions because of large class sizes. But that only applies to the most mainstream courses. Surely, once you reach junior and senior level courses, classes would be much smaller and you could be engaged. The idea that you can replace this with an online course is insane.

And here’s the kicker. Do you imagine for even one second that you will see a drop in the costs of these course because they are now cheaper to present? Because one on-line professor can now present to 3,000 or 5,000 or 10,000 students at once?

Student Debt

In 1974 it cost me (a Canadian from Ontario) about $3,000 to go to a U.S. college for one year. That included tuition and room and board. I had a job cutting grass and plowing snow too, for spending money. So a poor boy like me could get a college degree and get a good job and do well.

I ended up with about $10,000 in student loans. A house, at that time, would have cost me about $80,000, in Chatham, Ontario.

Now of course there has been some inflation since 1974 and everything costs more and people earn more money, but the rate of increase in college tuition has been nothing short of astronomical. It is now, typically, $35-50,000 for a year in college. In the U.S., a graduating senior typically owes about $50,000.

What happened? Did it suddenly cost ten times as much to hire a professor? To build a lecture hall? That $80,000 house is now $175,000. Why is that $3000 education now ten times as much?

Part of the reason is that State governments cut back on the amount they contributed to the cost of higher education. In Washington State, for example, in 1991, the state’s contribution to the costs of colleges and university education was (inflation adjusted) $96 for each person in the state. Today it is $31. All while politicians of every stripe whine and kvetch about the low achievement of American students on international tests and their unpreparedness for work after they receive their diplomas!

The other reason college costs rose astronomically is quite simple: the money available to pay for it increased; the colleges knew how to get that money flowing by facilitating access to government-sponsored loan programs and young students with poor judgment about the relative advantages and disadvantages of massive debt signed up in droves believing that high-paying, secure jobs awaited them upon graduation.

There was, in short collusion. The government offered student loans thinking they would be applied to 1974 tuitions in a 1974 job market. College Presidents rewarded themselves for increasing student debt by paying themselves $500,000 a year or more, with lavish benefits. Athletic departments received more money for stadiums, dressing rooms, uniforms, and coaches. When tuitions skyrocketed and the job market tanked, you suddenly had a huge population of deeply indebted under-employed young people. It’s almost as if the fast food industry’s wettest and juiciest dream came true: a large population of macjob candidates, desperate for any kind of income.

I think what most people don’t get about the economics in the United States, and elsewhere, is that the system is largely controlled by the banks and large corporations and the purpose of the system to keep the vast majority of people in perpetual debt, continuously streaming vast sums of money into the coffers of the investor class. The government is utterly complicit with this process, allowing banks to offer money to people who clearly cannot afford to pay it back, at unconscionable interest rates which serve to trap them the way the giant insect alien in “Aliens” traps it’s victims, with gooey slabs of useless consumer goods and mortgages and degrees. Unable to move or free themselves or escape the massive interest payments.

And the emblematic moment of this relationship, in 2008, after the banks got too greedy– an almost incomprehensible development– more greedy than before?!– and the mortgage securities markets collapsed and the economy was threatened with disaster, the government bailed out the banks. The consumers were strung out to dry with continuing liabilities for houses that had lost half or more of their value or cars they could no longer drive or educations that no longer produced jobs.

There were no consequences to the investors or managers of these banks. In fact, most of them were lavishly rewarded for their greed, their ruthlessness, their incompetence, their monumental callousness towards the home-owners who held their mortgages, and their ability to bribe politicians effectively.

A few of them must have a sleepless moment or two imagining what it would be like to live in a world in which there are consequences for psychotic behavior on a grand scale– a moment or two. But such anxieties will vanish quickly when they meditate on the poetry, the operatic grandeur, the delightful, soaring arias of the capitalists, the Republicans singing in harmony praises every day to a system, they insist, that is going to benefit the average working guy as much or more than those who are already rich.

I found an article in Forbes online addressing the issue.  If this represents the caliber of debate, we are in big trouble.

A much better article on debt forgiveness.

It doesn’t: a much better, more informative article at the Seattle Times.

It’s Fun to Stay at the NCAA

It’s rather quaint the way university administrators and NCAA officials declare just how wonderful and pure is the devotion of their students to athletics. They play for the love of the sport; they aspire to greatness. They want to improve themselves. They want to be true to their school. They want to learn about leadership and team-building and self-sacrifice and self-denial and goal-setting and how to give everything you’ve got, for a higher purpose.

That kind of sentiment is for saps, of course, and the administrators and coaches and NCAA officials know it. If they claim otherwise, let’s make it simple for them.  Prove that you believe in the values you insist your students must believe in:  you now work for nothing. You are volunteers. You get no money, no limos, no first-class flights, no 4-star hotel suites, no dinners at the top restaurants. You too can express your purity and join in this ethereal expression of scholastic piety.

Don’t be too quick to dismiss the idea. I mean, it is not likely at all that it’s going to happen, but not because it makes sense to do it the way we do it now. It will not happen because of simple, unencumbered ruthless human greed. There is no body or institution or person who is in a position to prevent the NCAA from  perpetuating their positions of privilege indefinitely. There is a symbiotic relationship between college administrators, sponsors, coaches, and politicians, and they will all circle the wagons and roll out the big guns if anyone threatens the status quo.

The athletes, as you know, are pure and devoted and selfless. They play for nothing. In fact, if they do accept money or gifts, they can be fined and suspended and expelled. But their coaches are among the highest paid state employees in the nation. The head of the NCAA famously drives a Porsche and lives in luxury.

What’s my problem with NCAA sports in America? Nothing. Just drop the pretense and make it what it really is: a professional league. And pay your players and provide them with decent insurance and other benefits, and cut out all the bullshit. Strip all of the Universities and Colleges of all the professional sports– let them go back to amateur athletics organized purely, solely, and exclusively by and for amateurs.

And athletic scholarships should be terminated, period. The entire idea is stupid. What is an institution of higher learning doing paying for people to come play football or basketball or to swim for them? Who says they should? Who says it wouldn’t be a better world if Universities went back to the business of education?

Let’s get rid of the vampires and pimps. And let’s have a string of institutions that are actually dedicated to higher learning: to producing smart people of strong character. Let’s value them on the basis of how good they are at doing that. And let’s put cost controls on them so that the incredibly obscene rise in tuition costs (fueled by perverse application of federal student loan guarantees) stops.