The Politically Correct “Star Trek New Worlds”

For not the first time, the custodians of the Star Trek legacy have decided deflower Mr. Spock.

What, my friends, was unique and interesting about Mr. Spock in the original TV series?  It was that he was a rational person who believed in Reason and Science, in contrast to the humans around him who were still wildly swayed by their emotions (though one could argue that Kirk, in his best moments as captain, acted rationally).

Spock would sometimes inform the captain that the odds of succeeding in a particular course of action were miniscule– and then Kirk would take the gamble anyway.  This was TV land, so Kirk’s unlikely gambles always succeeded but, even as a  12-year-old watching “Star Trek” for the first time, I thought they should have showed us that Spock was usually right, and gambles against ridiculous odds were foolish.

We all want the virgin.  Yes, I am comparing the character of Spock to a virgin.  The creative teams that handled the Star Trek franchise realized they had a lovely virgin on their hands, a character who, through his dedication to Science and Reason, had won the admiration of an entire generation of sci-fi fans.  It is similar, to me, to the appeal of a young virgin in a whorehouse.  Who does the guest most want to deflower?  Not those tired old saggy whores, but the young beauty who has never been violated.   In the same way, for cheap dramatic effect, they wanted to twist Spock’s character and have him become emotional at a moment of peak tension.  You see?  Even Spock agrees with my cheap emotional insistence that the entire crew of the Enterprise be risked in order to save his buddy, Kirk, even though it is unreasonable to do so.

In a subsequent iteration (“Star Trek Into Darkness”, 2013), they even had the older Spock time-travel so he could advise the younger Spock to “go with your feelings”.  I cringed.

And now we have “Star Trek: Strange New Worlds” in which “the series takes the opportunity to explore Spock’s human emotions before he becomes more computer-like”.

Thank you.  You just destroyed the most interesting character in the entire series.

Again.

Not only that, but Spock gets a human girl-friend, Nurse Chapel, whom, we are given to understand, becomes one of “Spock’s great teachers about his humanness”.

I think I’m going to vomit.  Not only do they emasculate Spock’s rationality– they emasculate his gender.  And clearly, the purpose is to attack the alleged “toxic masculinity” of the original version.  Captain Pike, in this new version (set ten years before the original series), is “more thoughtful and empathetic” and likes to bake.  I’m not making this up.  The character of La’An Noonien-Singh, the “chief of security”, was, we are told, bullied as a child because of her ethnicity.

The courage of the original producers to include an Asian, a Russian, and a black woman among the command personnel has been replaced by gratuitous adherence to woke ideology.

And we get a prequel that is more socially “progressive” than the most socially progressive program on TV in the 1960’s except that in 2025 it’s not progressive at all: it is utterly conventional, by today’s standards.

I am a progressive.  But there are times when I get why so many right-wing podcasters attack the culture of political correctness.  Having a Mr. Spock who is masculine and rational is not a political endorsement of masculinity or rationality: it is recognition that such things exist, given the storyline about the planet Vulcan, and have existed, and will always exist (sometimes it feels like the stereotypical forms of masculinity are returning right now).

And I would join the argument that Mr. Spock’s rationalism is good, and more likely than Kirk’s hunches, to lead to victory or success.

It would have been far, far more interesting, to let Spock’s rationality play out because, as in real life today, the Rational and Coherent and Scientifically Defensible, is under attack by MAGA and the reams of people who really believe that American healthcare is superior to that in all the other nations, even if it is free for everyone, and that the recycling label on the bottom of your plastic jug means it will be recycled, and the evidence or climate change is the product of a hoax, and that nations should negotiate for the release of hostages.

It would be electrifying to see Spock inform his crew that negotiating for the release of a hostage would make the strategy successful for their adversaries and will only ensure that more hostages will be taken.  Or that promoting minorities by ethnicity rather than merit would diminish the effectiveness of the crew.  Or that a crew member shouldn’t be so thin-skinned about a harmless sexually suggestive joke.

The new series, “Strange New Worlds” appears to at least embrace more of a sense of humor than the dour “Next Generation” did.

My Previous Dissection of the Issue

Robert Munsch

Dementia Is Stealing the Imagination of Robert Munsch, Children’s Book Writer – The New York Times

From a New York Times article on Robert Munsch, a comment on other children’s books:

The results fill the shelves of children’s bookstores today: the joyless and relentlessly realistic books inspired by various pedagogical frameworks; the strained, platitudinous and inexpertly rhyming stories published by celebrities.

I agree with him. I find many children’s books are obsessively moralistic and pious.

And, on “Love You Forever”: “Some readers found the book too sentimental, almost drippy. Also creepy. Even Oedipal. ‘It is the most loved and the most hated book I’ve ever seen,’ one bookseller told The Times.”

I’m with the group that find it sentimental and “creepy”. Apparently, kids laugh at the story and moms cry. This dad cringes.

Your mileage may vary.

Surprised to read that Munsch had issues with depression and bipolar disorder and a drinking and drug problem way back when. And not so way back. Sadly, he is now suffering from dementia and other physical frailties. After watching one of his brothers die very slowly from Lou Gehrig’s disease he is considering MAID.

I’m not a fan of his writing (they remind me of badly improvised dialogue in some films) but I admire his attitude and his irreverence for traditional story-telling.

The article in the New York Times is quite moving. He lives in Guelph, Ontario, Canada.

The Karmic Cost of Freedom: Charlie Kirk

“I think it’s worth to have a cost of, unfortunately, some gun deaths every single year so that we can have the Second Amendment to protect our other God-given rights. This is a prudent deal. It is rational.”
-Charlie Kirk

(Think this is “fake news”?  Check it out.)

What else can you add to that?

Trump ridiculously wants to award the Presidential Medal of Freedom to Kirk posthumously, in spite of the fact that Kirk was nothing more than a partisan hack.  Partisan hacks should not win national awards.  Such awards should reflect bipartisan respect and admiration.  You don’t give the Medal of Freedom to Charlie Kirk, or James Carville, or Dick Morris, or Karl Rove, or all the other party hacks out there.

Well, we could all point out– as many have — that it is pretty rich for the man who pardoned the January 6 rioters to declare that political violence is never acceptable, and that it is the result of liberals and progressives being mean to conservatives.  The man who refers to his political enemies as “savages” and “vermin” and “communists” — and even “Fascists” (!!) suddenly has such delicate sensibilities.

There is hypocrisy and then there is raging hypocrisy.

Yes.  Unless it is against people I don’t like.

As for Kirk himself:

    • he believes the 1964 Civil Rights Act was a big mistake; in case you’ve forgotten, the Civil Rights Act finally guaranteed the rights of black people to vote at a time when many southern states effectively prevented them
    • he believes women should cheerfully submit to their husbands (it’s amazing how many women in his camp are out there trying to tell other women, and men, how to live their lives).
    • he is an election denier
    • he thought Martin Luther King Jr. was an awful person.
    • he believes the United States should — shades of “Handmaid’s Tale” — be governed by Christian principles, contrary to the constitution; more than that, he believes that education, government, and media should all be control by “the church” (which means, him and his coterie of white nationalists).
    • probably his most hypocritical position was his advocacy of “free speech” which he clearly meant only to apply to right wing speech.  He urged students to attack professors who disagreed with him and
    • he believed women who become pregnant as a result of rape must be compelled to carry the baby to term
    • he believed other cultures should be repressed in favor of “Americanism”.

In all the rather exuberant sanctification of Charlie Kirk, the Republicans, eager to blame all political violence on leftist extremists, seem to have completely forgot about Melissa and Mark Hortman (Melissa was a Democratic Speaker of the Minnesota State House of Representatives) were murdered by Vance Boelter, a right-wing extremist with passionate views on abortion and transgender rights.  They also forgot about the attempt to kidnap Gretchen Witmer, governor of Michigan, and the assault on Nancy Pelosi’s husband during an attempt to kidnap her.

And they seem oblivious of the fact that Kirk’s assassin appears to be from their own party.

The Chilling Death of the Constitution

PBS’s “Frontline” recently showed a powerful– and chilling– documentary on Trump vs. the Courts. The over-arching question was what happens if Trump finally decides to simply ignore a Supreme Court ruling? (It’s getting close.) The Court only has power through U. S. Marshals under control of Trump’s lapdog Attorney General.  And even then, it’s not a very compelling lever.  They are not going to arrest the President.
‘
A number of Republican Senators say they sincerely believe in the Constitution and separation of powers. But will they act if it means Trump, with his iron grip on the party, threatens to primary them?
Given their recent obsequiousness, I doubt it.
Do enough voters care? Doesn’t seem like it. The FBI just raided Trump critic John Bolton’s home and offices, a flatly transparent attempt to use the Justice Department to silence critics; yes, weaponization. John Yoo (who argued that torture was legal, for Bush) and others actually assert that the President can ignore the courts. Congress refuses to assert their own constitutional authority over agencies and budgets, and, of course, the Republicans will never vote to impeach.
John Roberts and the rest of Trump’s acolytes on the Supreme Court seem terrified that they will issue a ruling that Trump will ignore thereby eviscerating whatever illusions of power they still wield. So they carefully nitpick legal doctrine to find some way to justify finding in his favor.
Chilling, chilling, chilling.

At the Circus With Wim Wenders

“Shiny Happy People” (Documentary on Prime) is about people who see life in this world as an insignificant temporary smudge of reality in which we are tested for admission to the ecstatic after-life of angels and gossamer clouds of beauteous immortality. Obsessive about sexual purity and utterly blind to sins like vanity, materialism, selfishness, militarism, gun fetishes, and so on, many of the leaders of the movement inevitably succumb to sexual scandals and material corruption.

I think of Wim Wenders exquisite film “Wings of Desire” in which an angel, after watching humans live out their joys and sorrows and regrets and passions, longs to become mortal and live in the world, and have a smoke, and drink coffee, listen to music, and go to the circus, and feel desire for someone beautiful.

The Bear

The Guardian loves Season 4 of “The Bear”. “Where once The Bear made pulses pound, now it lets the happy tears flow; the second half of the season is like one long therapy session.” Yes it is. It’s like the whole show is seeing a bad therapist. It’s become like an old 70’s soap opera, with better music. Long dreary close-ups of characters having feelings and feelings about feelings and feelings about the other characters having feelings about feelings until most of the characters begin to sound alike.

Clearly, a lot of improvised dialogue. Not everyone should write dialogue.

Maybe not really “feelings” so much as over-flowing self-infatuation.

What’s left of plot and narrative makes little sense.

I don’t necessarily think it’s a mistake to make Sydney a young genius.  But I’m not convinced by Ayo Edebiri’s performance in the role.  She does nothing to convey the kind of personality you see in people who are extremely accomplished or intensely ambitious.  She is decidedly mundane in demeanor, prosaic, even dull.  Nobody thought to insert scenes in which she has a real rapport with the other staff, or pleasure in success, or a deep-seated commitment to her tasks.  She is predictable.

Fiscal Responsibility and Smoke and Mirrors

For decades now the Republicans have predicted imminent economic catastrophe because of large government deficits and then, once they are in office, they run up the deficit more than the Democrats did. This time they have made an astounding reach, adding more than $3 trillion (if the bill passes). They are borrowing $3 trillion++, financed by Treasury Bonds, to give Elon Musk, Peter Thiel, Mark Zuckerberg, and the rest of his fellow billionaires a massive tax break. How will they pay for those bonds? We know how they want to pay for it: by eviscerating Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security — the only places where that kind of money can be found. All these cuts to USAID and Voice of America are really pretty marginal but they make good Fox News clips.

They know those programs, Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security, are popular so they don’t dare cut them as much as they’d like.

It’s win-win for them: eventually the Democrats will return to office and try to save those programs by raising taxes to pay for them. Then the Republicans will once again wave their magic wands and pose as the fiscally responsible party and declare that deficits are ruinous.

They may have gone a bridge too far on this one. Campaigning on fiscal responsibility in the mid-terms has an appeal. The government may also have to increase interest rates on the bonds to get people to buy them which can have negative effects on the economy.

TACO Goes to Iran

I doubt that Trump is going to attack Iran.
1. He knows the history of U. S. failures in the region.
2. He wants to be known as a brilliant deal-maker rather than a war-monger.
3. He won’t want history to know him as Netanyahu’s poodle.
4. If Iran retaliates and attacks American bases, he will face enormous pressure from Congress to re-retaliate and escalate. The military and Lindsay Graham will assure him of quick and total victory– just like Iraq and Afghanistan and Viet Nam.

My guess is he will extract some kind of deal, even a bad one, with Iran. Israel will keep pressing but I think they know they’re losing Trump’s enthusiasm for their aggression and their lack of cooperation on getting a deal in Gaza.

5. TACO.

(Trump Always Chickens Out).

Just re-watching “The World at War”, the excellent documentary series on World War II. And noticing how often military strategists and political leaders were very wrong about the results of their tactics, the determination of their opponents, and the collateral damage.


2026-06-28

Well, obviously, he did launch the attack on Iran.  The initial reports indicate that it was somewhat successful.  Trump immediately announced that it was, in fact, gloriously successful, and no president ever, before, or since, has ever, ever, ever made as brilliant and courageous a decision as he did.

It remains to be seen.  And how smart, really, is Trump?  If he is as smart as he thinks he is he might approach Iran now with a deal that would lift many of the sanctions in return for Iran not reconstructing its bomb-making facilities.  If Iran takes it, he looks like a genius, regardless of outcome.  Trump does not care if Iran actually does proceed to secretly develop a nuclear bomb anyway– the only things that matter to Trump are things that glorify or enrich Trump.

Objectivity in the Age of Trump

ABC News fired correspondent Terry Moran after he made comments on social media about Trump and Stephen Miller being “world-class haters”. This apparently fell afoul of ABC’s claims of being “objective.”

I doubt that any rational, “objective” person would consider “world class hater” to be anything less than “objectively” accurate. When Trump and Miller refer to protesters or government officials or entertainers who disagree with him as “scum” or “losers” or other epithets, and threatens to arrest the governor of California and Bruce Springsteen, or expel millions of Palestinians from Gaza, and refers to political refugees as murderers and rapists, would even he deny that he is a world class hater?

It is not “objective” to pretend that this is an administration that behaves within what we expect in terms of decency, civility, and integrity.

That’s why I sometimes prefer to hear the news from John Oliver or John Stewart rather than Wolf Blitzer. He doesn’t have to pretend to be “objective”.

Freyed at the Edges

‘He maintains, adamantly and with expletives, that he wrote every sentence of “Next to Heaven.” “Not a word of the book was composed with A.I.,” he said. Anyone who says otherwise is lying, he told me.’

From Here.

Said the man famous for lying (James Frey, author of A Million Little Pieces, famously discredited by Smoking Gun and publicly shamed on Oprah).

And now making a name for himself by insisting that nobody cares about lies in memoirs anymore. Nobody cares about lying, period, anymore. He has a new book, a novel to sell, about people behaving badly. The public will eat it up.  If Trump needs a new press spokesman, here he is, ready to represent you to America, in perfect harmony with your character and taste.

Frey has a new novel out– of course.  And he’s sure to get a lavish hearing on the talk shows and podcasts.  When people complain about the media being full of bullshit, they are not entirely wrong: there is a body of media out there that is more than happy to oblige James Frey.  They will just as readily castigate him when the wheel turns, if that attracts eyeballs, and it will.

There’s a lot of people that may study this and decide, hey, maybe I could write a memoir after all.

I am very glad to say that on the question of James Frey,  I am not jumping onto a bandwagon.