Ken Burns’ “The American Revolution”.

I just watched Ken Burns’ “The American Revolution”. Aside from the inflated sense of global importance to the “revolution” and self-monumentalism, it was pretty good. It acknowledged the problem of slavery and the indigenous peoples. But you wouldn’t know from Ken Burns that Canada, just a few miles to the north, developed its own responsible, accountable representative governmental institutions without all the violence and mayhem, and it eliminated slavery thirty years before the U.S. When I was in college in the 1970’s, an American professor and a Canadian professor used to debate if the “revolution” was really revolutionary or just a war of independence. The Canadian, of course, thought it was merely a war of independence. The colonial governments were already fairly representative– society did not radically change after the war (only white propertied men could vote) and real British policy was actually controlled by Parliament at the time.

Aside from that, most of the series documented the sequence of battles– a lot of which involved poorly planned supply lines and retreats– and the squabbles over states’ rights. Not very much on the historical or intellectual origins of “the rights of man” or the Constitution.  I think Burns’ wanted it that way: he is aware of his audience and he was aiming for the mainstream.  He was provocative enough to earn some credibility (particularly in regard to the treatment of indigenous peoples) but the series lacked perspective.  It pulled it’s punches.

The French Revolution was far more radical and historically important really– and was a genuine revolution that had a massive impact on French society, abolishing tithes, limiting the authority of the church, confiscating church lands, ending the feudal system. But it also taught us radicalism has a terrible price.