Conservatives Will Never Be Cool

I recently heard a right-wing influencer on a podcast chortle about how magnificent it was that now, on college campuses and high school cafeterias, it was now “cool” to be conservative.

Rule number 1: if you have to tell people you’re cool, you’re not cool.

That has always been true, going back to the 1950’s, when parvenus and pretenders would don a beret, tuck a Ginsberg under an arm, light up a smoke, and trek out to the local folk club for some rebel vibe.  The cool guys and chicks were the ones who left when you walked in.

Rule number 2: it is never cool to adhere to a culture of hate and grievance.  Especially when grievance is your defining characteristic and your grievance is that smart, educated, cool people have always looked down on you.

Rule number 3: Just how cool do you think, “and I’m proud to be an American/Where at least I know I’m free” is?  It is a monumentally stupid line (“at least” sounds like something a desperate eight-year-old says when realizes he can’t get his yoyo back from his big sister).

Adjunct to Rule Number 3:  Patriotism is never cool.  You are averring a blind obedience to a fake ideology and culture that is manipulating you for perverted ends (usually oil profits).  There is no good reason for patriotism, which essentially consists of bellowing platitudes and bragging that your country is better than everyone else’s.

Rule number 4:  there is a difference between parody and mockery.  Parody and satire are cool; mockery is banal, tiresome, but it does require a lower IQ threshold.  There will never be a conservative “Dr. Strangelove or how I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb”.  The closest thing to a really searing conservative satire might be some Monty Python skits (as in “Life of Brian” when a member of the Palestinian Liberation Front declares that he wants to be a woman) but it is the essence of cool to be able to self-parody and if you parody a cool self you’re still cool.  Conservatives are so bitterly immersed in grievance that they can’t bear self-parody.

Rule number 5: William F. Buckley Jr. was a fop.  He wasn’t always wrong– cool people can handle anomalies– but he was always a pretentious fop and a snob– exactly the kind of intellectual that right-wing influencers today would find so insufferable if he wasn’t the goddess of nice reactionaries.  Jordan Peterson is a milquetoast current incarnation of the posture.  Charlie Kirk was a wannabe imitation of Buckley who didn’t understand that you shouldn’t wear kilts if you’re going to walk on stilts.  Okay– you should actually know history and economics before you engage in trivial quibbles about the subject with credulous audiences.  He could argue anything– that is not a compliment.