Big Pink

The crucial difference between Bob Dylan and artists like him and Elvis Presley and Michael Jackson and Brian Wilson and artists like them can be distilled to a simple set of transactions that took place in 1967.

Bob Dylan had been riding high on the celebrity charts, some top ten singles, a massively successful set of albums, critical acclaim.  Like Elvis, to some extent, though he was a completely different kind of artist.  The point is, he had money.  Lots of money.  And he had the status.

When Elvis and Michael Jackson arrived at this point they built themselves massive ugly tasteless mansions, surrounded themselves with parasites and plastic men, and spent enormous personal capital on sustaining their celebrity status and wealth.

Well, so did Bob, a little later.  But I am interested in this brief transition about 1968-69.  There is a record.  Dylan was very ambivalent about the devotion of his fans.  This is an artist who understood that “don’t follow leaders/Watch the parking meters” was more than a quip.  Like Kurt Cobain, much later, he knew the dark side of celebrity worship and was repelled by it.

What did Dylan do?  He moved to Woodstock, New York, and started regularly dropping by to join The Band in their home, the Big Pink, and write songs and  jam with them in the basement.  You can see this building on Youtube.  It’s is a very pedestrian-looking house in a remote area in the woods.  There is not even a paved road leading to it (I’ve driven the dirt trail that takes you there).  The house is rather ugly, to be truthful, and the basement in which they jammed is remarkably plain.  Bare rafters.  Cinder block walls.  A carpet they put down to absorb sound.

While Elvis and Michael Jackson surrounded themselves with sycophants and status symbols (cars, limos, body guards, expensive toys, private jets, and so on), and Brian Wilson played in his sandbox and got therapy, Dylan spent hours and hours and hours in this house writing and testing new songs  that evoked Americana in it’s most vital and authentic forms.  He treated The Band as colleagues and absorbed their idiosyncratic musical tastes.

He also bought a mansion nearby on 175 acres in the woods, for seclusion.  Later, he acquired other properties in Malibu, New York, Minnesota, and Scotland.

For a time, he lived like folk and interacted in a healthy way with a group of talented musicians who shared his love of Americana and roots music.  Obviously, something about the prosaic surroundings and the real people (most of The Band were Canadian folks) appealed to him,  Surely it kept him grounded and honest and humble (when playing with The Band, he was often  one of many voices within the ensemble: not the “star”, the only one in the spotlight.

The Rolling Thunder Revue was another attempt to stay connected and authentic.

It’s a real dilemma for genuine artists who really can’t just walk down a city street without being immediately recognized and probably mobbed.  People, in general, are awful.  John Lennon saw the same problem and made an effort to stay connected.  It cost him his life.

A lot of literary writers choose to live in quiet little farm houses in rural areas in New England and are able to shop and pick up their mail in small local villages without a problem.  But they are not pop stars on the scale of Dylan or Lennon.

Lately Dylan seems to be on an endless tour.  At 85 years old.

 

Fat is Thin, White is Black, Music is Noise, Art is Shit

There inevitably comes a point at which some clever writer or critic seeking prominence will proclaim that contrary to established opinion, this shitty artist or musician is actually great and should be adored but only us truly sophisticated or pure thinks can appreciate the utter brilliance of the man or woman or fish.

And it’s usually bullshit.

Justin Bieber really is a genius.   Michael Jackson actually matters.  Look at how many records Paul McCartney has sold.  Frank Sinatra — the phrasing, the world-weariness!  Leonardo DiCaprio’s desperate commitment to his roles!

We’re all supposed to go, oh yes, I’m cool, I can see how the contempt for that artist is just snobbery.  Andy Kim really does belong in the Canadian song-writers Hall of Fame for “Sugar Sugar”, along with Leonard Cohen and Neil Young.   That guest on CBC’s “Q” that Tom Powers is desperately sucking up to (“Is it possible that you are so great that it actually works against you?” and “when did you first realize that you were a genius?”).