The Illusion on the Hill

Ross Douthat of the New York Times, the resident reactionary on this liberal paper, enjoys nothing so much as erecting straw men and then knocking them down.

In this column, he tries to argue that America was essentially a Christian nation before the 1960’s, and then those evil hippies, liberals, environmentalists, feminists, and civil rights leaders came along and ruined everything.  He takes up the idea that America could return to it’s biblical roots, or not, but obviously should.

The fundamental lie in his argument is something that has become rapturously evident only since Donald Trump began his run for the presidency: America was never really a “Christian nation”.  It proclaimed itself to be it, adopted the symbols and emblems, sang their hymns, and never really believed in any of it.  What does America’s so-called religious right really believe?  My tribe against your tribe.  My grievance against your competence.  Tradition and ignorance against innovation and science.  Women as handmaids.  White male privilege.

Douthat wants you to believe that from the time of the War of Independence (it wasn’t really a “revolution”), America has modeled itself on principles derived from the Bible and the ministry of Jesus Christ.  Well, in a way– the bible does not really tell us that there is anything wrong with slavery.  In fact, it urges slaves to be “good” slaves.  Pick that cotton with enthusiasm!  Nurse that baby!  Make that bed!  Take a few lashes occasionally if necessary.  And the bible doesn’t envision women working 9:00 to 5:00 office jobs, or becoming astronauts.  Or, for that matter, getting paid to do anything.

If a person in the U.S. is anti-abortion, he or she is also almost certainly believes this:

    • climate change is a myth
    • guns are good and keep honest citizens safe from crime
    • homosexuality is unnatural and sinful
    • unions are bad
    • expensive government programs that benefit the poor are a waste of money and encourage indolence and irresponsibility
    • systematic racism is not a problem in America
    • socialized health care is a pernicious, evil idea that will inevitably lead to communism
    • capital punishment is appropriate and good for serious crimes
    • there are only two genders and ever will be

Why?  If there are sound reasons for being opposed to abortion (at any stage of pregnancy, they will insist), why do so-called “pro-life” voters almost invariably hold most of the other  values as well?  The only explanation is that they are not really “pro-life” at all: they are tribalists and anything that promotes their tribal interest is good and anything that promotes someone else’s tribal interest is bad.  Their moral judgements are determined by their loyalty to their tribe, not to their bible or Reason or evidence or science.  If their tribe believes we need a new ballroom or reflecting pool or deportations, then they will try to argue that they agree because they have thought carefully about it and came to the conclusion that these beliefs are valid and justifiable and supported by evidence.

But if that was true, they would be a substantial variety in the views they hold on those issues.  It is inconceivable that large numbers of people would all hold the same view on so many issues if they approached those issues with genuine principles, or if they had the integrity to admit it when evidence shows they are wrong.

They don’t.  They are loyal to their tribe.

Now the first thing one might say in defense of these conservatives is that liberals do it too.  Firstly, that is partly true.  Secondly, two wrongs don’t make a right.  But I think a far larger number of liberals hold diverse views on these various issues than conservatives do.   Bill Clinton famously embraced capital punishment and proclaimed the end of the welfare state.  (And he balanced the budget.)  Obama deported more people than Trump (check it out: it’s true).  Biden was pathetically servile towards Israel.  Kamala Harris was tough on crime in her role as Attorney-General of California.  Bernie Sanders is opposed to most gun regulation.

 

The Traditional

My response to this column in the NY Times by Ross Douthat.

 

“a mechanism to constrain sexual misbehavior that’s more effective than the traditional emphasis on monogamy and chastity.” I like how you sneaked in there the phrase “the traditional”, as if this was some kind of monumental edifice of unquestioned provenance. As if it was not a social mechanism for the control of women’s bodies by patriarchal “authority”. A social mechanism inevitably dispensed with for themselves by privileged men in power. Whether you personally or not love Donald Trump, your side owns him and you could not invent a more ragingly hypocritical avatar of “traditional” values.

Pope Francis’ Deficiencies

Ross Douthat writes as if there is a real core Catholic faith that is being smothered by Francis’ liberal leanings. But after decades of evangelicals proclaiming themselves to be the party of spirituality and faith and integrity and humility and all the other values derived from the example of Christ and then stampeding into the arms of the most repugnant narcissist to ever run for office, one might be forgiven for regarding Douthat’s tears about the state of the Catholic church as disingenuous as best. Thanks to this embrace of Trump, and the sexual abuse scandals, and the residential school scandals, and the Magdalene laundries scandals, and so on and so on, it is very, very hard to regard any religion as anything more than a charade, a club, an exclusive confederation of self-righteous hypocrites. I gaze at these pious individuals in wonder and ask myself, what do you really believe? Anything, other than gaining advantage for the members of your club? Francis should declare that the era of Big Church is over and leave every locality to indulge in their own preferred hypocrisies.

Oh My God! We’re Getting More Anxious

Ross Douthat of the New York Times— the token conservative commentator on the opinion page– accepts the results of a study by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention that show that teenagers today– especially–omygawd! girls– are more anxious, more depressed, and more unhappy than ever before.

By “social liberalism” I don’t mean the progressivism that took off in the Trump era — antiracism and diversity-equity-inclusion and #MeToo. I mean the more individualistic liberalism that emerged in the 1960s and experienced a second takeoff across the first decade of the 2000s. Its defining features were rapid secularization (the decline of Christian identification accelerated from the 1990s onward) and increasing social and sexual permissiveness — extending beyond support for same-sex marriage to beliefs about premarital sex, divorce, out-of-wedlock childbearing, marijuana use and more.

And it’s all because of the liberals!  Douthat doesn’t think gun violence should depress anyone, or the cut-throat competitive nature of the U.S. economy, or the fear of being bankrupted by medical expenses, or the fact that a sexual predator and psychopath was elected president in 2016.  Oh no.  It’s the widespread availability of sex, gay or hetero, as a woman or a man or neither, and, of course, drug use.  Have we heard this before?

I have two points.  First of all, we hear about these studies all the time– and I mean ALL the time.  Sociologists and social scientists just love asking teenagers if they are happy.  Now, imagine for a moment you are a teenager.  And life is not great, but it’s not all bad either.  You’re kind of getting through it.  You have some hopes and dreams and know you might have to work hard to achieve them.  You have friends.  Then someone comes along and asks you if you are happy or depressed or anxious.  They ask you again an hour later.  They ask you again the next day, and the next, and the next.  You read articles in the New York Times or see pieces on CNN that tell you that a big problem today is that teenagers are not very happy.  You start to wonder.  Maybe I am unhappy.  Maybe I’m depressed.

I don’t deny that it might be true.  What I question is the assumption that these numbers represent a net change from previous eras, like the 1940’s, the 1950’s, and 1960’s.   How would we know?  It’s a great question to thoughtfully ask yourself: how would we know?

Nobody studied issues like this in the same comprehensive, systematic way in the 1950’s as we do now.  We didn’t have the internet, obviously, or social media, and even television and radio was completely different than they are today.  We didn’t have as many books or magazines or records or films.  We didn’t have as many family photographs or recordings, let alone video.  We had numerous wars around the world, and the U.S. itself was embroiled in Korea, and about to get embroiled in Viet Nam.

We had a lot of obvious racism, whites only schools, whites only restaurants and drinking fountains.  We had a lot of drunk driving and date-rape, both of which now are severely punished, but were not back then.  In fact, the consensus on rape seemed to be to not report it at all.  We had a lot of teen pregnancy, “shotgun” weddings, and groping and petting.  We had a society that blindly worshipped the military and the police.  (It is no coincidence that Douthat, a conservative, would harken back to an era of such “stellar” values even if he doesn’t make explicit those particular values).

I suspect that a big part of our perception of the 1950’s has been shaped by unrealistic media portrayals, most emblematically, in “Happy Days” and the movie “American Graffiti”.   Have a look at “The Last Picture Show”, “Diner”, “Rebel Without a Cause”, or “Badlands” for a corrective.

Secondly, Douthat clearly implies that enthusiastic membership in a church is a viable corrective.  If only we had a study that showed that teenagers who are active members of churches are happier, less depressed and less anxious,  and happier, than those who are not.   We have no such study.

What studies we do have that compare church-going folk with non-church-going folk seems to show that we are all largely the same, holy or profane, saved or damned.  We all indulge in porn.  We all cheat and lie.  (But only one side votes for Trump and loves guns and only one side believes you may have been born to the wrong gender and the world is warming.)

Even for Douthat, this column is unusually contrived in his desperation to find some way to blame liberals and progressives for the sad state of America.   Like all conservatives, he knows that his side, the side of regressive, low tax, deregulated economies, benefits by promoting a sense that we are on the brink of catastrophe.  Nothing new.  We’ve been on this brink according to the Douthats of the world since Elvis first gyrated his hips.