Ross Douthat of the New York Times, the resident reactionary on this liberal paper, enjoys nothing so much as erecting straw men and then knocking them down.
In this column, he tries to argue that America was essentially a Christian nation before the 1960’s, and then those evil hippies, liberals, environmentalists, feminists, and civil rights leaders came along and ruined everything. He takes up the idea that America could return to it’s biblical roots, or not, but obviously should.
The fundamental lie in his argument is something that has become rapturously evident only since Donald Trump began his run for the presidency: America was never really a “Christian nation”. It proclaimed itself to be it, adopted the symbols and emblems, sang their hymns, and never really believed in any of it. What does America’s so-called religious right really believe? My tribe against your tribe. My grievance against your competence. Tradition and ignorance against innovation and science. Women as handmaids. White male privilege.
Douthat wants you to believe that from the time of the War of Independence (it wasn’t really a “revolution”), America has modeled itself on principles derived from the Bible and the ministry of Jesus Christ. Well, in a way– the bible does not really tell us that there is anything wrong with slavery. In fact, it urges slaves to be “good” slaves. Pick that cotton with enthusiasm! Nurse that baby! Make that bed! Take a few lashes occasionally if necessary. And the bible doesn’t envision women working 9:00 to 5:00 office jobs, or becoming astronauts. Or, for that matter, getting paid to do anything.
If a person in the U.S. is anti-abortion, he or she is also almost certainly believes this:
-
- climate change is a myth
- guns are good and keep honest citizens safe from crime
- homosexuality is unnatural and sinful
- unions are bad
- expensive government programs that benefit the poor are a waste of money and encourage indolence and irresponsibility
- systematic racism is not a problem in America
- socialized health care is a pernicious, evil idea that will inevitably lead to communism
- capital punishment is appropriate and good for serious crimes
- there are only two genders and ever will be
Why? If there are sound reasons for being opposed to abortion (at any stage of pregnancy, they will insist), why do so-called “pro-life” voters almost invariably hold most of the other values as well? The only explanation is that they are not really “pro-life” at all: they are tribalists and anything that promotes their tribal interest is good and anything that promotes someone else’s tribal interest is bad. Their moral judgements are determined by their loyalty to their tribe, not to their bible or Reason or evidence or science. If their tribe believes we need a new ballroom or reflecting pool or deportations, then they will try to argue that they agree because they have thought carefully about it and came to the conclusion that these beliefs are valid and justifiable and supported by evidence.
But if that was true, they would be a substantial variety in the views they hold on those issues. It is inconceivable that large numbers of people would all hold the same view on so many issues if they approached those issues with genuine principles, or if they had the integrity to admit it when evidence shows they are wrong.
They don’t. They are loyal to their tribe.
Now the first thing one might say in defense of these conservatives is that liberals do it too. Firstly, that is partly true. Secondly, two wrongs don’t make a right. But I think a far larger number of liberals hold diverse views on these various issues than conservatives do. Bill Clinton famously embraced capital punishment and proclaimed the end of the welfare state. (And he balanced the budget.) Obama deported more people than Trump (check it out: it’s true). Biden was pathetically servile towards Israel. Kamala Harris was tough on crime in her role as Attorney-General of California. Bernie Sanders is opposed to most gun regulation.
