Hollywood’s Gay Lovers

Most laughable headline of the day:  “Andrew Garfield Comes out as Gay”.  Ha ha.  There never was anything to come out of.  And even more laughable: “40 Celebrities You Didn’t Know where LGBT”.  Seriously?  We didn’t know?

There has always been a multitude of gay actors in Hollywood, gay directors, gay casting directors, and gay audiences.   Until relatively recently, Hollywood did it’s best to conceal the sexual orientation of its biggest stars, primarily for two reasons.  1.  homosexuality was considered deviant.  2.  audiences craved at the least the allusion that male romantic leads were genuinely sexually attracted to the female romantic leads.  Rock Hudson, Tab Hunter, Montgomery Clift, Laurence Olivier, John Gielgud.  Okay– nobody cared if John Gielgud was attracted to the actresses.

And let me amend that, with a nod to Mitch Hedberg: Hollywood used to try to conceal the sexual orientation of its gay actors.  It still does try to conceal the sexual orientation of its gay actors, but it used to too.

The key to the success of men like Rock Hudson was that he was handsome and charming without being the least bit dangerous.  By “dangerous”, I mean conveying an authentic interest in having sex with the female protagonist.  You just can’t picture Rock Hudson actually groping Doris Day.  You can’t picture Doris Day being genuinely worried about finding herself alone in a bedroom with Mr. Hudson.

You can’t picture Doris Day being groped either, but it is imaginable.

For women in the audience, this is not a problem.  A lot of women would be quite happy living with a gay man anyway, so having one up there on the screen buying flowers and opening the door for lovely actresses with substantial breasts and living in a tidy apartment and being well-groomed is an embraceable fantasy.

I cannot watch Andrew Garfield or Leonardo Di Caprio or Timothy Chalamet or Jim Parsons or Neil Patrick Harris, or Zachary Quinto or Tom Cruise or the hosts of others romancing those beautiful actresses without finding those scenes patently ridiculous.  Channing Tatum?  Come on!  Matthew Rhys?  They are absurd.  There is no desire in this transition, no lust in the characters eyes, no urge to grope or caress or squeeze: just that congenial tidy mop of amusing chatter.

In 2024’s “We Live in Time”, Garfield is supposed to fall deeply in love with Florence Pugh and if you don’t believe in it you are not going to feel the weight of this great tragic story involving (oh no!) a terminal illness (“Love Story” anyone?).  But that doesn’t matter to the audience.  As a gay man, Garfield has mastered the nuance of being servile and domesticated and solicitous and that is what some women seem to want in their Hollywood heroes.

I am more than pleased to say that I haven’t seen “We Live in Time”– I don’t think I could stomach it, and I certainly don’t want to waste the time.

Films with a convincing masculine lead:

Train Dreams

Who’s not gay?

Stanley Tucci

Prince

Charlie Chaplin

 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *