Identity Theft

Some notes on property rights and identity, from an article in the New York Times, March 28, 2011

Ownership of a person’s identity after death is regulated by the states. Each one does it differently. In New York all such rights expire upon death. So, because Marilyn Monroe was legally a resident of New York State when she died, any one can use her likeness or identity for any purpose.

You can’t use Einstein’s likeness or identity without permission, and without paying a fee.

There is no legal mechanism by which a person who disdained endorsements in his or her own life can prevent others from selling their name or image after death. Too bad Chaplin, Hendrix, Einstein. If Einstein had expressly declared in his will that he didn’t want his face and name to be used to hock automobiles– too bad. It’s like the courts would have nullified his wish.

Guess what– the right of publicity is taxable. So the heirs of a famous person’s property may have to sell those rights simply to pay the taxes on the value of those rights. That seems very wrong. The law essentially seems to require that a person’s good name and image be despoiled.

In fact, that seems repellent. Are the courts actually insisting the government has the right demand the commercial exploitation of deceased celebrities, because, that, in fact appears to be the case. (Unless the tax only kicks in if the property is sold. That actually makes more sense. The Times article was not clear on the point.)

Did you know that it is accepted tenet of will law that a person cannot demand the destruction of property or assets in his or her will?

Well, he or she can “demand it”, but courts will generally rule against it.

 

127 Hours

Based on Aron Ralston’s book “Between a Rock and Hard Place”. Leaving aside the point that someone who did something unimaginably stupid (tracking off into the back-country without telling anyone where he was going) now commands $30K + to give inspirational speeches, this is a very compelling true story about how Ralston was trapped in a narrow crevice with a large chock-stone rock pinning his hand against the side, for 5 days. He had no cell phone or personal locator, only a small amount of water, and a dull knife. He had not, as I pointed out, told anybody where he was going. [Note Ralston’s not the only failure to cash in on his own stupidity. Click on the line to read about the commander of the Greeneville, who crashed into and sank a Japanese fishing vessel while essentially taking guests on a joy ride.]

As the world knows, Ralston eventually had to cut off his own arm to escape, and was rescued a few hours later by some Dutch hikers. Not much actually happens in the film, other than the obvious, but Boyle imbues the story with stylish flourishes, exploring Aron’s memories and feelings as his predicament becomes progressively grim. It’s well-filmed, at the exact location it happened.

I guess I missed the part where this is an “uplifting” paean to the human spirit– he made a stupid mistake and, like any sentient being, wanted very, very badly to survive, and that’s what the movie shows us. How you morph this into the theme of a speech so that everyone rises and applauds at the end is a mystery to me. We’re supposed to learn that we want to live. We’re supposed to be incredibly pleased that he did something so stupid he had to pay for it with part of his arm. So when you are out there thinking that you just want to die, think of Aron Ralston, and be inspired by his example: you want to live.

For my money, “Into the Wild”, about a not dissimilar situation, has far greater insight into the issues involved, distilled, at one moment, (in the film) into the sadness of Hal Holbrook’s face as he realizes that Chris McCandless is about to do something precisely that stupid. If you missed it– a far, far better film than “127 Hours”– “Into the Wild” is about a young man named Chris McCandless who was a bit of an adventurer (like Ralston) and a non-conformist (he gave away his college money to travel, penniless, around the country, hitch-hiking and camping out), who makes the reckless decision to try to survive on his own in the wilds of Alaska, hunting and fishing, and living off the land. The older adults around him can’t really try to stop him, but they know just how crazy and foolish he is, and they still like him, and try to discourage him.

The difference is that “Into the Wild” offers some thoughts about the idea of just running off like that, taking large risks, without the slightest thought for the loved ones you are possibly leaving behind. “Into the Wild” raises the suggestion that there is something self-centered and willfully naïve about that attitude. We still admire McCandless, and the adults he met on the road certainly found him likable– but that was precisely why his fate was so poignant. It wasn’t necessary. What was the upside to the risk?


In short: if you saw and admired “127 Hours”, please, please get yourself a copy of “Into the Wild” (2007), and think a lot about the differences.  “Into the Wild” shows you what happened– like “127 Hours”– but it has a lot more wisdom to offer.

“127 Hours”, like “Slumdog Millionaire”, is a film that tries to give you the feeling that you’ve been through a bracing, intense, authentic experience, without having to actually have the authentic experience.

Which is not to say that watching an enlightening film enlightens anybody:  really awful discussion IMDB.

Why is there no name for this syndrome of young men who admire the courage, the grace, the beauty of self-immolation?  But we know about them.  That’s where we get our killers from, whenever we need an army.


FYI the scene with the two girls at the idyllic pool in the cavern… yes, pure Hollywood. Didn’t happen. But you probably didn’t need to be told that, right?

In a film that is otherwise quite respectful of reality, I guess the producers couldn’t resist. I’m not sure I blame them entirely.

They also couldn’t resist going a little over the top at the end… you’re desperate, damnit! You’ve been trapped for five days! You think of your dear mother! So you push yourself on and on but your body gives out and you collapse! You’re delirious. Look delirious. More delirious!…

Or the audience won’t get it.

Sophie’s Choice

“Almost no one knows — including Sophie and Stingo — that Nathan is schizophrenic.” From the Wikipedia entry on “Sophie’s Choice”.

The question is, if no one knows that Nathan is a schizophrenic, how does anyone know he is a schizophrenic?

First, I do want to make it clear that I think “Sophie’s Choice” is a fine book by a fine author. But I find this little episode silly. We’re supposed to give knowing nods to each other, aren’t we? Ahhhh! He’s a schizophrenic! No wonder. We were fooled because he was self-medicating.

In fact, Nathan has just been labeled. Nobody has to prove that he is anything now: he has a label. That is sufficient. A label is what you use when you can’t be troubled to find any specific facts or evidence for your belief. [In an unusually contrived episode of West Wing, that could only have been written by a writer with an unnatural dependence on his therapist, “Noel”, Josh Lyman is similarly glibly labeled as “PTSD”.]

So how would you know if it’s true– if you were a character in this fiction. How would you know if Nathan is a schizophrenic? Author William Styron needs the label for dramatic tension so he glosses over the question.

Is there some tattoo somewhere on his body that tells the discerning acquaintance: schizophrenic? No– some person with a degree on his wall, who may be a genius or an idiot– we’ll never know, for both of them have an equal chance of getting the degree (the Nazi party was full of degrees)– this person, by virtue of society’s capitulation to the pseudo-sciences, has decreed: Nathan is a schizophrenic.

You can lock him up now. Anything he says in his own defense is to be regarded as further proof of his insanity. The more justly he becomes angry at your attempts to pigeon-hole him, the crazier he is. But no one may question the sanity of the man with the diploma on his wall. He has science on his side. He had the audacity to give the first label, thereby shifting the burden of proof on the labeled. Nathan is deprived of the presumption of sanity.

If only it was science, or something, anything more credible. In my view, most of what passes for “psychology” is a religion in drag; it’s a religion that tries to hide it’s assumptions behind a veil of mangled statistics and manipulative language that always manages to give a plausible answer to the wrong question.

There is no greater arrogance in the entire world than to sit in judgment of another person’s sanity. Anyone who would do this should get his head examined.

And if only Nathan had had the foresight to get his diploma first– he, also, was a genius– he could have decreed his brother as delusional instead of the other way around. Just imagine the scene in which the brother informs Stingo that Nathan is insane. Imagine, if you will, that Stingo has been told in advance by Nathan that the brother is delusional: the scene would work perfectly, and the brother would come off as no less creepy, least of all for inviting a perfect stranger to secretly report to him on the private activities of his brother.

So the lesson is this: be the first to get your diploma, so that you can deem all those who offend your prurient sense of good order and propriety insane.

The power of labels. Stingo is too naive to actually question whether a label means anything. He assumes that psychiatrists have some magical powers that allow them to reduce the sum of a person’s behaviors to a syndrome which, like all good labels– including the star of David– shall subsequently determine the context in which all other behaviors are regarded. Nathan’s rage at an unjust world– a world with lynch mobs, or HUAC, or the inquisition, or Salem’s magistrates, or a KGB — around every corner– is the result, say the doctors, of his schizophrenia.

Or maybe it’s the only sane reaction to a world gone mad. To a world that shows no signs of learning from it’s mistakes. From a world that still embraces the passions of the mob.

[Upon re-reading this, it has occurred to me that someone might say, well, would you rather Nathan be allowed to do whatever he wants, including harm himself or others? That’s always the rejoinder, isn’t it? If you dare to challenge social orthodoxy, then you’re responsible for bad things that happen, even though these people never take responsibility for the failures of their own ministrations. So, just to clarify for the easily confused: no, I’m not advocating that people do nothing. I’m just saying that we often use labels to avoid grappling with complexity, and, in many cases, to justify drastic actions that end up doing more harm than good.]

Kitty Cat: Tolstoy’s “Anna Karenin”

“The Shcherbatskys consult doctors over Kitty’s health which has been failing since she realizes that Vronsky did not love her and that he did not intend to propose marriage to her, and that she refused and hurt Levin, whom she cares for, in vain. A specialist doctor advises that Kitty should go abroad to a health spa to recover. ” From the Wikipedia synopsis of “Anna Karenin” by Leo Tolstoy.

“Anna Karenin” is allegedly the greatest novel of all time. Well, on some lists. “The Brother’s Karamazov” is often at the top of the list, and so is “Ulysses” by Joyce, and Flaubert’s “Madame Bovary”, and “In Search of Lost Time” by Proust.

So Kitty needs to go to a spa to recover. That, in essence, is the problem I have with Anna Karenin. The whole book is about extremely privileged people committing stupid acts and then having nervous breakdowns and scooting themselves off to a spa or an estate somewhere to “recover” from their awful, horrible, traumatic experiences. It’s sounds like a Russian “Gone With the Wind”. We all want to be rich and privileged just so we can have such beautiful crises.

In the film “The Last Station”, Sophia, Tolstoy’s wife, is informed that Tolstoy has run away from home. Yes, he did, at 80, fed up with his wife’s nagging him about giving her the copyrights to his books. There are a lot of terrible flaws to this scene that are emblematic of the entire film.

Firstly, Sophia immediately becomes hysterical and tries to throw herself into the pond. But you thought, he just left on a train, right? And she’s been married to him for 30 years, right? It’s simply hard to believe in that reaction. Dramatically, that moment cries out for a few moments of “what do you mean he left on a train? Where to? Why didn’t he tell me?” You would expect some annoyance on her part, rather than this immediate, overwhelming despair.

She really does throw herself into the pond and sort of drowns. It’s a silly scene. It’s not like she picked some lonely time and place where no one was likely to rescue her. Her family and friends haul her out and turn her on her side, but she hasn’t swallowed any water and doesn’t vomit, and then, later, she reacts comically when she is told that Tolstoy was merely concerned about her. You do wish that someone would grab her and shout, “don’t be pathetic!” Send her to a spa.


I started reading Tolstoy again because of a reference by Philip Yancey, and because of the recent movie “The Last Station”, which, by the way, is as melodramatic and overwrought as “Anna Karenin”.


“Vronsky, embarrassed by Karenin’s magnanimity, attempts suicide by shooting himself. He fails in his attempt but wounds himself badly.” Wikipedia Synopsis.

Is this tragic or comic? When I first read this novel back in the 1970’s, I thought it was gloriously, beautifully, astonishingly tragic.

Now, I find it a bit ridiculous.

My personal list of the best novels ever written?

1. Crime and Punishment (Fyodor Dostoevsky)

2. Brothers Karamazov (Fyodor Dostoevsky)

3. Beautiful Losers (Leonard Cohen)

4. The Stranger (Albert Camus)

5. The Pearl (John Steinbeck)

6. The Castle (Franz Kafka)

7. Animal Farm (George Orwell)

8. Huckleberry Finn (Mark Twain)

9. Slaughterhouse Five (Kurt Vonnegut Jr.)

10. Anna Karenin (Leo Tolstoy)

But don’t put too much weight on my list: literature is not American Idol. There is no point to this competition, except perhaps to draw peoples’ attention to great books.

“Wolf Hall” by Hilary Mantel is also a great book. So is “Life of Pi”.

More uptodate:  Jonathan Franzen’s “The Corrections” and David Foster Wallace “Infinite Jest” and “Brief Interviews with Hideous Men”.

To Kill a Stereotype

Ebert’s Review of “To Kill a Mockingbird“.

I usually find Roger Ebert overly generous in his appraisals of new films, so I have to tip my hat to him for his brave review of “To Kill a Mockingbird”– he gives it a very modest (for him) 2.5 stars out of 4.0, after noting that it is rated as the 29th greatest film of all time by the users of the IMBD.

I’ve always liked the film, but I’ve always been conscious of the fact that I liked the film more than I admired it. I totally respected the liberal sentiment behind it. I just didn’t respect the contrived plot developments, the squeamishly overwrought emotions (of the scenes with Boo Radley at the end, for example), or the generally weak performance of Mary Badham as “Scout”.

Aside from being way too old for the part (a problem with the book is that her perceptions and actions seem beyond her age as given) her big scenes look as if they were hacked together from short snippets of adequacy, rather than from a single decent shot. This is especially evident in the scene with Walter and the molasses. But she is affected and deliberate in all of her scenes. I’ve always suspected that she did great at the auditions but once filming started– too late to try someone else–didn’t live up to expectations. I cannot believe that a director was happy with her performance.

You really can’t blame TKAMB for the “white savior” syndrome: it practically invented it. But you can blame the weak characterizations of the black characters, especially Calpurnia, on the source material and the movie.

2019-03-15

Incidentally– here’s a piece of heresy for you: “To Kill a Mockingbird” really is kind of a mediocre book, and Harper Lee never wrote another novel in her life (I don’t count the sequel as a genuine second book) because she didn’t have it in her. She knew that if she did sit down and write a completely new book that her inadequacies as a writer would be laid naked. So she never did.

This is complex because I do like the book. It is indeed likeable, and the era, and the setting are intriguing. But it’s actually quite contrived and psychologically trivial. There’s no depth to most of the major characters.


Similar contemporary film: “Blind Side”.

Hollywood does scads of deplorable remakes of films that were perfectly fine the first time out (“The Taking of Pelham 1-2-3” being the latest travesty). Why not wise up– “To Kill a Mockingbird” is a film that should be remade.

Firstly, the contrived plot twists should be improved upon– can’t there be a better way for the kids to realize that Boo Radley is a human being than to have him save their lives?– and, secondly, the tone could be changed so that, as Ebert observes, the blacks in the film don’t serve as props for the virtue of Atticus Finch. (Calpurnia could be shown to have an actual personality and life, for example.)

I didn’t know this– Jimmy Stewart apparently turned down the role because he thought the story was “too liberal”. How about that.

What is the least respected profession in the United States? Right. And who is the most admired fictional character? That’s right– Atticus Finch, a lawyer.


Best things about the film? Gregory Peck’s Hollywoodized dream dad. Scouts funky haircut. Elmer Bernstein’s exquisite theme. The lovely opening credits, with the cigar box full of collected items that breathe nostalgia. A skinny misfit named “Dill” standing in for the real Truman Capote.

Worst, most unconvincing moment in the film? Scout cozily sitting on the porch swing snuggling up to the Boogey Man himself, Boo Radley (Robert Duvall, in his debut), shortly after he saved her life from the evil Mr. Euell.

This scene reeks of the adult picturing it as it ought to have been. But Scout does not behave like a child who probably would not even have fully comprehended what happened, even with Atticus’ explanations, and certainly would not have warmed up to a creepy adult male neighbor that quickly, no matter how marvelous, as an adult, we think he really is.

In the remake, have Boo disappear as quickly as he appeared. Leave us with Scout’s face, wondering.

 

The Third Man: How do you know a thing like that Afterwards?

It’s 1948. Postwar Vienna is suffering shortages of everything, including medicine. It is administered by a cooperative security force comprised of British, French, American, and Russian soldiers. In a unique arrangement, a representative of each country takes part in each routine patrol, even if they can’t speak each others’ language.

The city is in ruins. The people, demoralized, desperate.

Holly Martins is an American writer of pulp westerns. He gets a message from an old school chum, Harry Lime, to come visit him in Vienna. Sounds like an adventure– old times! But he arrives just ten minutes after Lime’s body has been carted away to be buried, after a car accident. Instead of a happy reunion, he attends a somber funeral, along with a very small number of Lime’s friends. And a young woman, Anna, who walks away quickly when the service is over.

Martins is clearly already infatuated with her and later catches up with her at the theatre where she performs in sad, dispirited, period comedies. Perhaps the most depressing moment of the film– the actresses, in sumptuous costumes, smiling and cavorting on stage, in some pathetic effort to recapture something magical from a hopelessly distant past– and the audience half-heartedly laughing.

After the play, she offers him a cup of tea, but it is clear that she is in no mood for sentimental reminiscences.

MARTINS
You were in love with him, weren’t you?
ANNA
I don’t know. How can you know a
thing like that afterwards? I don’t
know anything any more.

Well, damn right it’s written by Graham Greene. Martin’s line is freighted with a misguided nostalgia for Lime (we come to understand, even if Martins doesn’t, that Lime used him) and Anna’s line is freighted with bitter disillusionment.

Holly is one of the earliest incarnations of George W. Bush, blundering into complex situations which he can’t remotely understand but determined, nonetheless, to do something about them, and, in the process, causing mayhem and suffering to all those around him. He’s the ugly American, the bumbling fool who thinks his native wit will triumph over sophistication and cunning.

This is not a coincidence.  It is a known theme of Graham Greene’s: how the naïve but well-meaning Americans sew disaster around the world.

Anna wants nothing to do with him. She just wants time to go by. She’s filled with fatalism, resignation, and emotional fatigue.

You begin to understand how war saps away hope and passion. And you begin to understand the complex, disturbing attraction of Lime. And it is a wonderful tribute to Greene that he resists the temptation to imbue Anna with some kind of special nobility: it is clear she doesn’t care about the victims of Lime’s black market activities– she only wants him back. Because he was the only thing in her bleak life that made her laugh.

You don’t even get to anesthetize yourself with this illusory “true love”– she doesn’t know. She doesn’t know how you would even know something like that “afterwards”

[spoiler] Then there is the astonishing last scene. The camera stands distant, at the end of a long laneway leading away from the cemetery. Martins, the fool, prevails upon Major Calloway to let him off. Calloway, reluctantly, stops the jeep and lets him out. He stands there waiting for Anna to catch up to him. The camera watches impassively as Anna slowly approaches Martins… then walks right past him as if he doesn’t even exist.

Martins doesn’t move.

We fully understand that he is being forced into a tremendously painful realization, and all he can do is stand there and watch her walk away.


Graham Greene, who was no stranger to Hollywood movies, thought the original ending of “The Third Man” was too bleak for most audiences and wanted to change it….

Well, no– it wasn’t the “original” ending: [spoiler] in the novella he wrote as a first draft, he actually had Anna walk off, after Lime’s funeral, with Martins. [end of spoiler] It was director Carol Reed and–shockingly– the producer, David O. Selznick– yes, the American Hollywood producer– who insisted there should be no compromise, because it was “right”, artistically, because it was inevitable, because the romantic ending would have been completely contrary to the spirit of the story.

It is very hard to imagine otherwise. It was an uncharacteristically cheesy idea of Greene’s, and a brilliant realization by Reed and Selznick. And I am convinced it is one of the main reasons “The Third Man” is regarded so highly more than fifty years after it was made. The romantic ending might have provided a moment of transient gratification– but it would have trivialized the rest of the film.

Considering all the indignities Hollywood has rendered upon good stories over the years, that is amazing.


I can’t stand it when a movie like “The Reader” comes along acting as if it was something like “The Third Man”. Watch the two one after the other: what’s different? The world. But mainly the writing. The difference is that there is not a single moment in “The Reader” that is even a shadow of the “how do you know a thing like that afterwards” or the cuckoo clock, or “Victims? Don’t be melodramatic. ”

If someone were to do a remake of “The Third Man”– a terrible idea, of course– you could do worse than…

Holly Martins: Steve Carell
Harry Lime: Phillip Seymour Hoffman — without a doubt.
Anna: Taryn Manning, or maybe Amy Adams, if she ever decides to take on a challenging role, instead of those lightweight confections she’s been indulging in lately.

Or how about Kelly MacDonald? I don’t know. Yes– absolutely Kelly MacDonald, with Franke Potente as a close second.

Leadership Training

Bill’s 21 Irrefutable Rules about Leadership Trainers:

Nobody who is really busy doing real productive work has time to indulge in this kind of narcissism that they call “leadership training”.

Amazingly, the rules of leadership invariably serve the interests of the people who make the rules, and the people who sell leadership training.

Almost all people famous for leadership training never led a single real organization in their lives. All of them lead organizations dedicated to making them rich by selling “leadership” training.

If you really believe you need leadership training, you can’t be helped by leadership training.

You send your staff to take leadership training because you know that none of them will ever hold any authority over you.

There is not a single thing you would learn at a leadership training seminar that would have prevented you from investing in credit default swaps.

If you are selling leadership training to an audience of people who will never be effective leaders because they believe you can improve their leadership skills, you probably know exactly what you are doing– especially when you offer them more of your tapes, books, and CD’s. And they all automatically buy them.

Leadership training is easy because no one can ever really disprove any of the bland observations you make. For that same reason, leadership training is worthless because no one can ever prove it works.

I hear you: you are a weak leader who now believes he is a strong leader because he watched 9 hours of leadership training videos. No, you are not. You are a weak leader who will need to hire a consultant the minute you are confronted with a real problem because you still are not a real leader.

What is leadership? Sounds noble, doesn’t it? What if they called the workshop: “how to boss people around”? Not quite as glamorous, right? But at one level, leadership is all about bossing people around and the trouble with this world is too many people who love to boss people around think they are leaders.

 

Shacked: “Sin is it’s Own Punishment”; So is “The Shack”

[If you really enjoyed “The Shack” you may want to skip this.]

I don’t believe that any of the millions of readers of “The Shack” ever really believed that God, if he appeared to them in the flesh, would take on the appearance of a mighty old man with a beard and thunderbolts and a stern visage. But they believe that’s what other Christians think, and what non-Christians think they think, and therein is the essential appeal of the book: this is so wise! God is an obese, middle-aged, singing and chortling black woman baking in the kitchen, just loving you to death, and smiling indulgently at all those misperceptions you can then pretend to be enlightened of.

“Mack” even claims to be surprised that Jesus isn’t handsome, or Caucasian. He’s “surprised” that God doesn’t enjoy punishing bad people and casting them into a pit of fire. The fact that not a single one of those misperceptions is really upsetting to a conventional, conformist view of Christianity is beside the point. It just feels wise. It feels deep. They remind you of those tedious youth ministers some churches hire specifically to minister to young people, who wear jeans and listen to DC Talk to show that they’re hip, and admit that they sometimes feel tempted to, gosh, darn it, curse right out loud. These revelations will not, as the cover claims, “astonish” you. If you like the book, they will simply confirm what you already believe, and make you feel smarter about it. The same way Morgan Freeman makes you feel like you’re not a racist.

Making God a middle-aged black woman is actually as predictable as the old man with the beard and the staff.  What would have been fresh is making God a door-to-door salesman, or a Puerto Rican bathroom attendant, or Jerry Falwell.

“The Shack” is fiction, in more ways than one. Mackenzie Phillips’ youngest daughter, Missy, is abducted and murdered while “Mack” is in the water rescuing his son from an overturned canoe. The police, who behave like New Age saints in this story (always tenderly sensitive to Mack’s feelings), can’t find Missy, but they do find a small wooden shack with her dress and blood on the floor. Later, a bitter Mack receives a note from God to come to the shack. Is it a hoax? Or will his experiences there “change his life forever”?

Yes, that does sound a bit cheesy. It is a necessary convention that Mack is reluctant to go to the shack. It is also necessary, for the conceit of this book, that Mac was not just sitting on a dock fishing, or checking out girls at the beach, or washing dishes when Missy is abducted. Or that the police never seem to hold any suspicions at all about Mack, even when he knows something that only the murderer would know. Unless you believe in miracles. Do all cops believe in miracles?

There is an explanation (but it’s a spoiler) about why the three beings sound so much like youth pastors– and it is an artistic weakness of the book that all three sound alike– but it doesn’t explain or illuminate why Mack would ever be surprised at the revelations. I mean, it would have been fun if he had found a clever way to allude to some aspect of his own personality but… well, that’s asking a lot.

I am reminded, whenever Young tries to describe a scene of overwhelming magnificence, of Mark Twain’s observation that most people would describe heaven as consisting largely of the same activities that bore them to tears in real life: singing and harp playing and floating around in gossamer chaste ecstasy. When Young describes a host of children, and Mack’s father, emanating light and song and colour– it sounds a lot to me like that kind of weird picture of the afterlife.

There’s nothing particularly awful about Young’s book. There’s just nothing particularly amazing about it either. Why is this so popular?

I’m not sure that a real victim of violent crime would find “The Shack” all that comforting. Or enlightening.


This is to music what “The Shack” is to film:
An alternative example of theological inspiration.


My comments on another contrived excursion into “authentic” faith: Donald Miller’s “Blue Like Jazz”.

My apologies for my views on “The Shack”. This is an incredibly popular book and people I love and respect do like it and claim that it has healing properties. I still like and respect those people but I also believe “The Shack” is really not as great as they think it is.

I would feel poorly served if I read a favorable review about some book or record or film and then found out the reviewer was kind to it because people he knew liked it.

The heart of this book is a relatively mundane writer speaking for God, trying to teach the reader theology by expressing it–stiffly– as dialogue between “Mack” and the Trinity, represented as a three persons living together in a shack.

That’s all. Since a real human can’t really even begin to explain, adequately, a real God, it all sounds more like a youth pastor to me than real characters. I’m not saying it couldn’t be done– a far more talented writer could do something with the idea, but that would require more poetry than William P. Young is capable of. A lot of it sounds like the villain carefully explaining all his nefarious plots to the hero who is tied to a chair and about to escape. After the explanation, of course.

I also find it really amusing that some conservative commentators, including Chuck Colson, don’t like “The Shack” and accuse the author of heresy. Wow. You would think there was something genuinely provocative in this book. Well, maybe there is. Young seems to take a fairly liberal approach to the idea of Hell, but then, so does Hollywood. He also suggests that all people, of all religions, are children of God– though it’s not very clear what the implications of that thought are, to him.

“The Shack” is essentially an attempt to explain the existence of evil in a world created and ruled by God. Is God just? It’s an old problem and I’m not particularly impressed by Young’s crack at it.

In a nutshell: “The consequences of selfishness are part of the processes that bring us to the end of our delusions, and helps us find you (God). Is that why you don’t stop every evil?” God replies, “All evil flows from independence and independence is your choice.”

No, it’s not. Either we’re independent or we aren’t. If we are independent, it’s because God planned the world that way. We didn’t choose to sign on to this arrangement. And we didn’t willingly bargain the sufferings of children for independence (see below).

And of course, if we are independent, God cannot be omnipotent.  If he is omnipotent, he can stop the Nazis, the Stalins, the bombs, the land-minds, and James Dobson.   If he can than he must, or God cannot be good.  [It would take a book to elaborate why exactly.]

There’s just not much of anything in Young’s rather lengthy and dry explanations. In fact, the more “God” goes on about how wonderful the entire scheme is, even if a few children have to suffer and die, the more unconvincing he is. And this makes it doubly insufferable when Mack professes such astonishment at the “wisdom” he puts into God’s mouth. He sounds like a bad TV ad: and you mean I get all this for only $19.95— why that sounds too good to be true. “It does– but wait– there’s more…”

From the time I was in high school, I have heard this argument and I’ve never accepted it.

Dostoevsky’s twist on the idea was this: what if I refuse the bargain? What if I say, you can keep your “independence” or freedom. I refuse any deal that assumes, as a precondition, the suffering of innocent children. I refuse my ticket. God’s reply, in “The Grand Inquisitor” is that Jesus, because he was innocent, had a right to accept the bargain.

The flaw in Dostoevsky’s argument is that this does’t change the objection:  it doesn’t matter if Jesus accepts the bargain: Jesus is not me.  I still do not.

February 12, 2009

A lot of “The Shack” consists of a very orthodox Christian theology rendered in insipid dialogue, with the distressing frequency of self-satisfied chuckles or laughter from the three persons representing God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit. What is the purpose of “Jesus chuckled in the dark. ‘Since I am human, we have much in common…’ ” Does theology presented with chuckling seem more folksy and down-to-earth, and not at all some pie-in-sky abstraction?

Good and evil? Simple. Humans should never rely on their own judgment– God is truth. Why didn’t I think of that? Maybe because the real problem is that humans tend to spend a lot of time and energy telling us that they know what God thinks and it happens to coincide with their own personal beliefs. The real problem which “The Shack” neatly sidesteps, is how do you know what the will of God really is? Isn’t there always some interpretation going on? How do you know it’s even God’s voice you hear when you claim He is telling you, clearly, to do this or that?

Is it supposed to be delightful to think that God might want to lie on a dock at night and look at his own stars? It would have been more amusing if he would have a special fondness for “Grey’s Anatomy” or “Friends”, or fresh cut fries. I checked to see if Young’s God is a vegetarian. Don’t know.

We do know, thanks to Young, that God likes Bruce Cockburn’s “Lord of the Starfields”. Well, that beats “Just as I Am”, I guess.

Alternatives: without question, the most accomplished version of this approach to theodicy is “The Grand Inquisitor” from “The Brothers Karamazov by Fydor Dostoevsky. If you have never read the whole book, you should– it’s one of the two or three greatest novels ever written.

 

 

[If you really enjoyed “The Shack” you may want to skip this.]

I don’t believe that any of the millions of readers of “The Shack” ever really believed that God, if he appeared to them in the flesh, would take on the appearance of a mighty old man with a beard and thunderbolts and a stern visage. But they believe that’s what other Christians think, and what non-Christians think they think, and therein is the essential appeal of the book: this is so wise! God is an obese, middle-aged, singing and chortling black woman baking in the kitchen, just loving you to death, and smiling indulgently at all those misperceptions you can then pretend to be enlightened of. “Mack” even claims to be surprised that Jesus isn’t handsome, or Caucasian. He’s “surprised” that God doesn’t enjoy punishing bad people and casting them into a pit of fire. The fact that not a single one of those misperceptions is really upsetting to a conventional, conformist view of Christianity is beside the point. It just feels wise. It feels deep. They remind you of those tedious youth ministers some churches hire specifically to minister to young people, who wear jeans and listen to DC Talk to show that they’re hip, and admit that they sometimes feel tempted to, gosh, darn it, curse right out loud. These revelations will not, as the cover claims, “astonish” you. If you like the book, they will simply confirm what you already believe, and make you feel smarter about it. The same way Morgan Freeman makes you feel like you’re not a racist.

“The Shack” is fiction, in more ways than one. Mackenzie Phillips’ youngest daughter, Missy, is abducted and murdered while “Mack” is in the water rescuing his son from an overturned canoe. The police, who behave like New Age saints in this story (always tenderly sensitive to Mack’s feelings), can’t find Missy, but they do find a small wooden shack with her dress and blood on the floor. Later, a bitter Mack receives a note from God to come to the shack. Is it a hoax? Or will his experiences there “change his life forever”?

Yes, that does sound a bit cheesy. It is a necessary convention that Mack is reluctant to go to the shack. It is also necessary, for the conceit of this book, that Mac was not just sitting on a dock fishing, or checking out girls at the beach, or washing dishes when Missy is abducted. Or that the police never seem to hold any suspicions at all about Mack, even when he knows something that only the murderer would know. Unless you believe in miracles. Do all cops believe in miracles?

There is an explanation (but it’s a spoiler) about why the three beings sound so much like youth pastors– and it is an artistic weakness of the book that all three sound alike– but it doesn’t explain or illuminate why Mack would ever be surprised at the revelations. I mean, it would have been fun if he had found a clever way to allude to some aspect of his own personality but… well, that’s asking a lot.

I am reminded, whenever Young tries to describe a scene of overwhelming magnificence, of Mark Twain’s observation that most people would describe heaven as consisting largely of the same activities that bore them to tears in real life: singing and harp playing and floating around in gossamer chaste ecstasy. When Young describes a host of children, and Mack’s father, emanating light and song and colour– it sounds a lot to me like that kind of weird picture of the afterlife.

There’s nothing particularly awful about Young’s book. There’s just nothing particularly amazing about it either. Why is this so popular?

I’m not sure that a real victim of violent crime would find “The Shack” all that comforting. Or enlightening.

Here’s an alternative example of theological inspiration.

 

All Contents Copyright © Bill Van Dyk
2009 All Rights Reserved

Information Highway Robbery

Apparently there a lot of orphaned books out there. These poor little documents have no mothers or fathers or other living relatives. They reside in research facilities and libraries. But fear not little books– Google wants you.

Google has cut a deal with an association of publishers and an association of authors: we will take all those books. Thanks. Goodbye.

Google wants to scan in all these books. I don’t think they plan to sell access to them directly– they will profit by having you end up at their websites whenever you do an online search for any text in any of these books.

This is not all bad. In fact, this could be wonderfully useful. What has some people upset is that Google, in order to protect their investment, is demanding exclusive rights to this material. And they must have paid some money to the people in charge at the publishers and authors associations– people in charge– for these rights. Will any individual publishers and authors ever benefit? Almost certainly not as much as the people who negotiated the deal will benefit. This is the same principle behind the government giving away oil and gas and water: we citizens get nothing. They get lavish campaign contributions and parties.

Google would probably argue that if they don’t get exclusive rights, it won’t be in their interests to scan all these books in, so they won’t do it, and nobody else will either.

You also have to understand that this agreement is not the same as legislation. Google has simply paid off the only groups likely to be able to muster a legal battle against them. If you were to start scanning in all these books yourself and then offer them online on your own web page, Google would likely resort to the standard corporate practice of threatening you with their lawyers with no intention of ever actually allowing the case to go to court.

The article in the New York Times.

Need some therapy? Apparently those librarians do. They are angry about this deal. They think it stinks. And they are “mad”, “angry”, “upset”.

A good therapist could provide an effective solution to this problem: they just need to get some therapy. They aren’t “angry”– they have “anger issues” that need to be addressed.

Open Source Books

I do not know what to do with my books. I don’t even know how many I have. Probably over a thousand. They sit on their prefab bookshelves, two layers deep, along my basement wall. They look fine. They testify to my learning and erudition. They show that I am not one of the thoughtless mob who spend hours and hours watching television.

Books have become very, very expensive. I know of a student at the University of Waterloo who recently spent over $900 for her course books. Is there some kind of scam going on with the universities and book publishers? Students are always told they need the latest, newest, revised edition. No effort is made to make new editions compatible with old editions, by retaining a consistent paging sequence, or by publishing addendums, or online updates.

How on earth can a laptop computer cost less than your course books? The computer requires thousands of manufactured parts from all over the globe, carefully assembled and tested, and shipped thousands of miles. Yet you can buy a new laptop for $500 or $600 nowadays. You can buy a lawnmower for $240. You can’t buy five books for less than that?

I think we need a movement. We need a group of intellectual hackers to devise an alternative to the established publishers, to write new text books and publish them on electronic readers like the Kindle. We need students to organize themselves and demand that professors adopt these new electronic books for their courses.

Their objection, of course, will be that they only want this particular book, a printed, published one, for the course. Only this book will do. Just as, in the computer world, first it was “only IBM will do” and then “only Microsoft will do”. Finally today, more and more users, including governments and corporations have discovered Linux.

What would happen if Universities supported this movement and began to require that all books be supplied in digital format and that they cost less than $20 each? Well, what would happen if they told the publishers they were no longer going to buy their inefficient, over-priced, tree-slaying compendiums? The publishers would have no choice. First, they would claim that they would be driven out of business. Then some smaller, more nimble publishers would start filling the gap. Then the big companies would buy them out and double their prices.

If there are enough hackers out there to support Linux– very efficiently, I might add– then there must be enough intellectuals, scientists, and others who would support a new “open source” text book system. In fact, isn’t Wikipedia a demonstration of this exact idea?


The Amazon electronic book reader.

It connects to Amazon through a wireless network– that is not compatible with European standards. Has the publishing industry learned anything from the music industry? Indeed they have: they appear to be just as stupid. A monthly subscription to the New York Times on Kindle– which is free, online– is $13.99. All right, so you buy a Kindle, and you decide to read five or six online news magazines or news papers, a few books, a few reference works… how long before you arrive at over $100.00 a month? And you are paying this for a technology that eliminates the publisher’s need to actually print something, on paper, and transport it to your eager little hands.

Add that to your cable bill, your phone bill, your cell bill, your iTunes bill, your movie rentals, and your CD collection… I think they’ve lost their minds. Why not do what Google, and most online newspapers have learned to do? Discretely sell some advertising in a non-intrusive way and hope to earn back the revenue through volume of hits?


[2009-11]

Apparently the State of California is now trying to do just what I describe here: it is creating digital versions of text books for high school and making them available online for free.  Story here.

[2010-08-01 ]

I just read that there is a website devoted to this cause.


“The drive-through, which accounts for 60 percent of the chain’s business in the United States, was reconfigured to become more efficient….” The New York Times in an article on the resurgence of the McDonald’s Restaurant chain, January 11, 2009.