The Legalization Scam

An insightful blog post on Colorado’s legalization of marijuana– not enthusiastic about it, as you might think it would have been–  pointed out that the goal of the legislation was not to bring a absurdly criminalized activity into the open, but to commodify it for white people.

You see, most white people in Colorado, in recent years, did not go to jail for possession of marijuana.  Only blacks and indigenous people would actually be arrested and convicted if caught in possession of marijuana.

It’s as if the government made lipstick illegal, knowing full well that they would only ever check the purses of black women.

So when it was legalized, a clever but insidious little caveat was added to the law: no one with a previous conviction, a felony, for possession of marijuana would be allowed to become a dealer.

We’re so clever.

 

[whohit]Legalization Scam[/whohit]

Internal Contradictions

With the election of Donald Trump, all the rules about political success and failure seem to be out the window.  He should not have won the Republican primaries.  He should never have won the election.  He should not, right now, have 90% support among the Republican faithful.

Well, he didn’t actually win the election.  He won the Electoral College and he won it with margins in a handful of states that are not really very convincing.  His current approval ratings are not good.  And take a look at realclearpolitics polling on congressional races going into the 2018 mid-terms: they don’t look good for the Republicans.  In fact, they are stunningly, uniformly blue.  The Democrats should win back control of the House.  They might be able to take the Senate, but that appears unlikely.

Of course, polling showed that Clinton should have won the 2016 presidential election.  And she did: by 3 million votes.  But she lost the Electoral College.

Winning a significant majority of votes is not a trivial fact.  Most American citizens did not believe that Trump would make a good president.  In fact, given Clinton’s unpopularity, a very significant majority of Americans still preferred her.

My theory about politics– which is challenged, of course, by current events– is that a political establishment is in trouble when it’s avowed values and goals include contradictory elements that cannot co-exist sustain-ably.   That’s a mouthful but it comes down to this: much of what Trump stands for is at odds with majority American values.   And even what he says he stands for is at odds with a clear majority of American voters.

These contradictions can and often do coexist for a time– people have a monumental capacity to embrace hypocritical values (using a not-nice word for “incompatible”).  When these two sets do collide, usually as the result of a crisis,  one of them changes.  In the 1960’s, it was the draft and the war in Viet Nam in contradiction with the growing perception that the war could not be won.  It was also the ideals of equality and justice espoused by the Constitution in opposition to the treatment of black citizens.    In the 1980’s and 90’s, budget deficits in opposition to welfare policies, and increasing crime in opposition to criminal sentencing.  Under Obama, widespread social acceptance of homosexuality in opposition to the laws governing marriage.    Under Bush Jr., the threat of terrorism in opposition to privacy rights.

Trump’s avowed policies on the environment, trade, international relations, and civil rights are ridiculously at odds with mainstream American values– which have not gone away, by the way.   The Republicans have been revealed for what they always were: race-baiting elitist materialistic gun-mad turds.  Until now, they’ve managed to disguise their real attitudes behind “nice”, “decent” candidates like George Bush Jr. and Mitt Romney.  Trump has suddenly revealed the Republican Party for what it always really was.

You mean it’s actually okay to say that out loud?

I believe a solid majority of Americans are still solidly in favor of sound environmental policies, decent wages, Social Security and Medicare, civil rights, and immigration reform, including a path to citizenship.

So this contradiction should lead to a crisis which will force a resolution of some kind.  What will the crisis look like?  Massive budget deficits?  Lay-offs by companies affected by Trump’s anti-trade actions?  Polluted drinking water?  Dramatic increases in carbon emissions coinciding with flooding of coastal cities?  Violent demonstrations?  North Korea firing another test missile?  Putin invading Lithuania?

Maybe it will simpler than that.  I don’t believe Trump will be able to resist the temptation to enrich himself through his position.  I don’t think he understands why that’s illegal.  I don’t think he understands what will happen when it all comes out.

Who knows.

[whohit]Internal Contradictions[/whohit]

Was Teddy Even in the Car

This documentary from the BBC concludes with an astonishing theory about Chappaquiddick: Ted Kennedy was not in the car when it went off the bridge.

Sounds crazy at first, doesn’t it?   Sounds like a conspiracy theory even though it is not remotely like a conspiracy theory.  It’s a tragedy of chance, misjudgment, obsessive media fascination, and hubris.

The mystery of Chappaquiddick that has never been solved is a rational explanation of why Teddy– even assuming his self-interest– waited 9 hours to report the accident, and then  claimed to have been driving.  And then, why did he claim that he and Joe Gargan and Paul Markham returned to the site of the accident and tried, for 45 minutes, to rescue Mary Jo Kopechne from the car?  Why did nobody report this second attempt until more than a week after the incident?

Why is there a mystery?  Because one must assume that, had Kennedy been driving, (and again, assuming his self-interest), he could not have reasonably decided that pretending there had not been an accident and waiting until the next day to report it would have been smart.  Kennedy was no fool.  When a police officer approached his car in which he and Mary Jo were probably having a romantic moment or two he realized his political career was on the line and so he drove off.  Once he was away from the police officer, he would have to assume the officer would return to his car and follow him.  If we are to believe him, he then had a terrible accident in which he luckily escaped– something some experts believe to be unlikely– but was unable to rescue Miss Kopechne.

It is hard to believe that at that moment he would have seriously embarked on the course of action he claims to have taken, walking by occupied houses with the lights on, and the fire station, recruiting Markham and Gargan to go back to the car with him, not reporting the accident to anyone, and then going back to his hotel to sleep it off.  His claimed actions are implausible.  Possible, but implausible.

Most significantly, Kennedy, when asked to give the time of the second rescue attempts, said that he checked the clock in the car as they proceeded to the bridge.  There was no clock in the rental car they were driving.  He lied.  If he lied about the clock, clearly, his account of the second rescue attempt can’t be trusted.  He was clearly making it up.  Gargan and Markham, as good Kennedy loyalists, went along with this version.  And once it was out there, on the record, they were not likely to recant.

Add one more detail: the police officer who saw the Kennedy car parked on the side of the road, with two people in it, gave a very specific time for the sighting.  He had just left work, so his evidence is reasonably reliable.  And if it is reliable, there is no way that Kennedy had time to do all the things he said he did before returning to his hotel room by roughly 2:25 a.m. when he was seen by hotel staff complaining about the noise of nearby party.  It simply isn’t possible.

The BBC documentary advances this scenario: Kennedy, caught with his pants down, drove off and then stopped.  More than anything, at that moment, he did not want to be a married Senator caught drunk-driving in a car with an attractive young woman at a cottage retreat.  This was the 1960’s:  for a leading federal politician– party majority whip– his career would been in tatters.  So, what to do?  He couldn’t very well leave Mary Jo at the side of the road to walk back to the cottage alone, so he got out of the car and told Mary Jo to drive on alone and, if stopped, tell the policeman she was going to beach for a midnight swim.

It’s a bit of a strange explanation, but a lot less strange than the explanation Kennedy gave in his official statements.  And there are good reasons why it makes more sense in terms of Kennedy’s behaviour afterwards than his own explanation: he appeared to be calm, relaxed and composed the next morning according to witnesses, until the arrival of Gargan and Markham who, the BBC believes, first informed him that his car had been found in the water and Mary Jo was drowned.

Now, consider what is plausible here.  Either Kennedy admits that he drove off towards a secluded beach with a young single woman who had been drinking a lot and then left her to drive off in his car so they wouldn’t be caught together by a police officer, and the young woman crashed the car and drowned as a result, or….  How about fabricating a less awful story about trying to drive her home– that’s it!– and getting lost– yes! — and then this tragic accident– and his heroic attempts to rescue her.  That’s the ticket!  That won’t play too badly for too long.  Everyone will get over it and on to the presidency!

“Chappaquiddick” is a fine film, artistically.  But I don’t buy it’s version of events.  I find the BBC’s story more credible.  And I see the compelling irony of it all: had Kennedy not tried to fudge to the story in his favor, he might have become president after all.   Instead of a drunk driver callously leaving a young girl to drown in a car he had wrecked, he would have been a philandering charismatic Senator who was the last see Mary Jo Kopechne alive before she had a tragic accident and drowned.   The Senator is naughty but not preposterous.   Most importantly, if he had only known, he surely would have done something, because the Senator cares.

It’s not a favorable story, by any means, and it still might have ruined him, but in my opinion, it would have been far more survivable, politically, than the one he made up.

But let’s step back for one moment.  All of this assumes that Chappaquiddick is a gigantic story because it really is monumentally important and really affected so many people.  Let’s not minimize the tragic results for the Kopechne family, but, to keep it in perspective, it’s not nearly as monumental or important as everyone seems to think it is.  Is is dramatic, yes, and sensational, but it’s not really all that important.  Laura Bush was also involved in an accident that included a fatality: she never talked about it on the record with anyone.  It passed.  She moved on with her life.  Whatever happened in Chappaquiddick– please ignore the hysterical right-wingers here– was indisputably an accident that just happened to be linked to salacious insinuations about the party at the cottage.  Senator Kennedy, and those young women might very well have been there for the obvious reason that they enjoyed each others’ company, and the the company of the men they had worked closely with on the Robert Kennedy campaign.  They shared political ideals and were looking forward to Teddy’s presumptive run at the presidency in 1972.

It should never have been that big of a deal, and, in many ways, the infamous Reader’s Digest hatchet job on Teddy involved more evil intent than anyone at that party at Chappaquiddick ever had.

Here’s a digestible conjecture: would the U.S. have a national, single-payer health plan today if Chappaquiddick had not happened?  It is very, very possible, because the main reason it never passed during the Carter Administration was because of tension between Majority Leader Ted Kennedy and President Jimmy Carter over who was going to get credit for it.  (For the record, Kennedy claimed his alternative plan was better, but later seemed to acknowledge that any plan would have been a major success for the Democrats.)

 

[whohit]Was Teddy Even in the Car[/whohit]

Spontaneous Premeditation

‘Denial of parole requires premeditation. Despite the jury accepting the murder was a “spur-of-the-moment” crime, they also found it was premeditated. As one juror explained it, premeditated meant not only planning hours or days ahead, but could also mean planning in the seconds before committing a spur-of-the-moment crime.’

From a Wiki article about the Peterson Case, the subject of “The Staircase” on Netflix.

Juries can be stupid.

Okay, so once upon a time long ago, Congress passes a bunch of laws and creates the criminal code.  They choose to make a distinction between murders that are planned in advance– “pre-meditated”– and murders that occur in a violent outburst of rage.  They decide that punishment for a murder calculatedly planned in advance should be more severe because the perpetrator consciously intended to commit a foul crime and, given time and the opportunity to reconsider and amend his intentions, he, instead, follows through on his homicidal plan.  Whereas, a murder committed in the heat of the moment is something the perpetrator may instantly regret, and it is an urge that only came over him in that brief engagement with the victim.  He may repent of his action and perhaps he is redeemable.

This brilliant jury decided they would develop a new philosophy of criminal intent, and a new psychology of the criminal mind.  So “premeditated” now means that the culprit was conscious during the commission of the crime, and, in the instant before he swung the club or pulled the trigger or pushed someone onto the subway tracks– in that instant, he plotted.  He meditated before the act.  He pre-meditated.  So they apply the concept of pre-meditation to precisely the one thing that it was never intended not to apply to.

We do a similar thing with juveniles.  We thoughtfully, carefully, and wisely– as a society- with lots of deliberation-  decided that young folk beneath a certain age should not be charged for serious crimes as adults.  Because they are young. Because their brains are still developing.  Because as they mature, they may yet develop a consciousness of right and wrong that makes them an asset to society.   And we carefully chose the age of 18.   So we say that if someone is younger than 18, than they can’t be sentenced as severely as a man of 30 years old.

And then, the first thing we do, is we make an exception so that if we damn well feel like– if we’re really pissed at someone– we can try him as an adult after all.  Precisely the thing the law was intended to prevent.  Every time you hear of a serious crime committed by a juvenile we hear the same nonsense: let’s ignore the law and try him as an adult!  (Actually, the law, unfortunately, allows for that exception: if the law is wrong, change the damn law and stop making exceptions.)

I think this jury just wanted to really, really throw book at this repulsive person who was not them– not remotely like them– not at all like them.  They hated him– so sly, and clever, and literate, and with so many lawyers and paid experts and private investigators on his side!  It’s almost as if he was a minority.

I can’t wait until this jury– and I’ll bet this idea was mainly the product of one demented, clueless, amateur criminologist who just happened to find his moment in the jury room– publishes a book so we can also share the fruits of this profound insight.  There can never be another case of murder that is not premeditated in the form this jury has defined it as.

 

[whohit]Spontaneous Premeditation[/whohit]

Trey Gowdy Gets his Comeuppance

Trey Gowdy, one of the most conservative, devout, even fanatical Republicans in the House, has asserted that the FBI was perfectly correct to investigate Russian involvement with people associated with the Trump campaign.  A hostile foreign power was was messing with our election: you bet the FBI should investigate.  And since Trump staff have even admitted meeting with them, by golly, the FBI should inquire into it.  Sean Hannity and Fox News now insists that Gowdy is a part of the Clinton-Obama Deep State Conspiracy to foil Trump’s presidency and steal the election.

I’m curious. Hannity must be wondering, as I am, just how far he could go before a few of his devout followers start going, “what? Hey, wait a minute– Trey Gowdy?!” And will any of them begin to wonder what else might not pass the smell test. The answer, unfortunately, is that most of them won’t even bother to find out who Trey Gowdy is. And if they did, they would probably think, “wow– this is one heck of a conspiracy– even Trey Gowdy is involved! Who’d have thunk it?”

Or maybe this is one of those “at long last, Mr. Hannity, have you no shame? No shame at all?”

[whohit]Trey Gowdy[/whohit]

Big, Big Lies and Idiots

Make the lie big, keep it simple, keep saying it and eventually they will believe it.

A high school student chose this quote to go underneath his class picture in the Andover High School yearbook. It’s a quote from Joseph Goebbels. The student, CBS says, didn’t know it’s meaning.  He didn’t understand that the comment was associated with a psychotic individual who wanted to purge the world of Jews.

Massive outrage, anger, shock, horror, disgust, embarrassment, rage, and blah blah blah follows. The yearbook must be recalled! Stickers will be issued!

I’m not sure what is offensive about it the statement, and I certainly don’t see anything offensive with him posting it below his yearbook picture. 

I know what is offensive about big lies– we all know it so very well nowadays– but I don’t see why anyone should be outraged that this student cited this very timely quote. It’s something we should all be thinking about. I doubt he was advocating the policy– I think it’s quite likely he was being ironic. Even if he wasn’t being ironic, why does everyone have to get so hysterical about everything nowadays, falling over themselves to demonstrate just how unbelievably outraged they are?

Think.

What in heaven’s name is wrong with observing that our society will often believe something that is clearly untrue– that global warming is a myth, that immigrants take jobs, that trade is bad for American jobs, that Obama was born in Kenya, that North Korea wants to attack the U.S. or its allies, that there is a war with something called “terror”, that the Republicans care about deficits?  Those are all very, very big lies.  They have been repeated and repeated and repeated.  And a lot of idiots now believe they are true.

And some idiots believe that we should not be told that big lies, kept simple and repeated, are often believed.

[whohit]Big Big Lies and Idiots[/whohit]

North Korea

On the eve of Donald Trump’s acclaimed visit to Singapore to meet with Kim Jong-un, some clarity.  Are these my opinions?  Yes they are.  I state that to assure the reader that no one is impersonating me right now and writing opinions that are not mine.  They are mine.

  1. This is the most important thing to understand:  North Korea is a pipsqueak of a country with no serious possible intention of attacking the United States, ever.  It has 25 million people.   It’s entire GDP is about $12 billion (U.S.).  (South Korea’s is about $14 trillion).  It would be completely and totally crushed if it dared to attack the U.S. or it’s ally, South Korea or Japan.  Kim Jong-un is not insane.  It is not going to happen.  It was not about to happen.  Trump is trying to take credit for stopping something that was never going to start.
  2. In spite of the massive, relentless media coverage, during which North Korea is regularly characterized as the greatest threat to the United States in the world today, it’s not, and this story is not nearly as important a story as:  Yemen, Iraq, the Ukraine, Afghanistan, Putin, Italy, global warming, fracking, the death of the cod fishery, and Anthony Wiener’s laptop.
  3. North Korea has no intention of disarming.  I don’t know what they have planned for the summit but I am very sure that Kim Jong-un is not going to give up the only thing he has that prevents the United States from toppling his government: the threat of nuclear retaliation.  Well, it is possible, like Iceland winning the World Cup, or Congress enacting rational gun control or single-payer health care.  Just ridiculously unlikely.
  4. North Korea is a horrible, totalitarian state.  Kim Jong-un can only remain in power by exercising ruthless control over his population.  He purportedly has over 80,000 people in prison camps.    He has executed over 800 people he considered a threat to his regime.  The instant he begins to open up his society with any kind of tolerance of dissent, opposition, free speech, or even access to information, his government will face an imminent threat of rebellion.  He is not going to do it.  What exactly does he think the U.S. expects?  Does Trump expect to demand any kind of reform or accountability?  Seriously?  Is the U.S. simply going to ask for the nuclear missiles to be removed, and then allow Kim Jong-un to continue to rule North Korea with an iron fist?  Is he going to allow any kind of flow of information, persons, or goods to and from South Korea, as part of the “peace plan”?
  5. Lindsey Graham and John Bolton and others incessantly demand military action against North Korea, especially– but not exclusively– if they refuse to give up their nuclear weapons.  Exactly what scenario do they have in mind that does not involve either nuclear retaliation (it the North Korean missiles actually work, and can actually bring a nuclear war head back through the atmosphere without it disintegrating) or massive artillery attacks on South Korea resulting in the deaths of hundreds of thousands of people?
  6. Why would North Korea accept a deal that is, for all practical purposes, identical to the one made with Iran, which Trump has just torn up?  Why would North Korea believe that the U.S. would honor such an agreement?  Why would the U.S. offer a deal that is inherently absurd?  Well, we know why.
  7. At what point will Trump begin to realize that North Korea is not going to disarm?  What will Kim Jong-un offer to try to keep Trump engaged for as long as possible while he revels in the spotlight, going toe-to-toe, just you and me, the two leaders of the world’s nuclear powers?

Diplomacy here is the sacrifice bunt of international relations.  It is better than nothing– which is better than striking out– but all it does is move the runner to first base.  Then what?  I just don’t see the arc of this narrative landing anywhere sensible.  What I do believe will happen is this:

There will some kind of vague agreement for North Korea to disarm in the future.  Kim has to announce something that sounds believable and substantive, but no action will actually be taken. The U.S. will remove some sanctions and perhaps provide some economic aid, and perhaps remove some military assets from the South.  Trump will declare victory– peace in our time– complain bitterly that he didn’t get a Nobel Prize, and move on to the next target of his short attention span.  The talks will eventually break off and we will return to the same starting lines and the same basic circumstances that Bush Jr. and Obama confronted.  Someone in the Trump Administration will tell the military to prepare a military option and they will defer.  They will actually refuse to follow the orders.

Or…

Trump will realize quickly that he’s been had.  He will go home.  He will tweet insults about Kim Jong-un.  He’ll threaten military action.  The news media will move on to the next sexy story.  Trump will claim that even though he didn’t get the nukes removed, he taught North Korea a lesson they will never forget, and they will not dare attack the U.S., something they had absolutely no intention of doing anyway.  (Listen to how absurd that sounds: it is absurd.)

A day later: the incredible absurdity of it all is that Trump– and a good many other Republican’s — eviscerated the Iran nuclear deal because it didn’t contain enough safe-guards and didn’t guarantee that Iran might not eventually go back into production.  Now he brags about a deal with no safe-guards, no inspections, no conditions, and no time-table.  This is insane hypocritical.

[whohit]North Korea I[/whohit]

Facts and Information Are Biased

In a recent article in the Washington Post, a columnist asserted that mainstream media is not “consciously” biased but is biased in the same way that institutions and agencies can become biased, by unconsciously favoring one group or another because of an affinity for their values and objectives.  In a way, she is right: any institution or agency that prefers facts and information will have an affinity for people who respect knowledge.

There are people in this world who do not respect knowledge.  They don’t know that what they do not respect is “knowledge” or “truth” or “facts and information”.  They believe that what they think is all the wisdom there is to be had in the world, and the “cultural elites” are actually clueless.  They are convinced that most “knowledge” is a charade that privileged people are trying to pull over them.  They believe that their knowledge is just as complete and true as those peoples’ knowledge.

If you do extensive research on climate change and come to the conclusion that it is the result of human activity and that will have an enormous impact on the planet, are you “biased”?  And does that make someone who has never read anything on global warming but likes Doug Ford and Donald Trump “unbiased”?  Is your doctor “biased”?  Is your plumber?  Well, we know that all teachers are biased.  They have information.  They have knowledge.  That makes them unreliable and dangerous.

I believe this writer is falling prey to the mistake of false equivalency.  I believe that the more you discover about real facts and real information, the more likely you are to adopt positions that would traditionally be regarded as progressive and enlightened: in other words– “liberal”.

And yes, I’ll say it.  A lot of conservatives are willfully ignorant.  When Scott Pruitt decided to repeal the Obama standards for mileage for North American built cars, he relied on a 25-page document that was largely written for him by the auto-makers.  Obama created the regulations in response to a 1200-page document that was produced by scientists and engineers as well as qualified government staff and researched all angles of carbon pollution, global warming, the impact of the regulations of the car manufacturers, and so on.  They even consulted with the car-makers.

These are not two equivalent things here.

One of these things is not like the other.   You can argue that a persuasive case can be made for doing nothing about climate change– you’d be wrong, but you could argue it– , but you can’t argue that Pruitt has just as many facts and just as much information as Obama has about the issue.  He doesn’t care.  His objective is to enrich his patrons.  They will be able to afford to insulate themselves from the consequences of rolling back environmental regulations, whether it be contaminated drinking water, increased rates of asthma, or global warming.  He does not care.  He will never care.

And this pattern, of conservatives developing policy based on what their uninformed little minds feel is good for them and their friends, and liberals at least giving some respect to information and research, is consistent, from the Civil Rights era to Global Warming.  Not all liberals and not all conservatives, of course, but let’s not be fooled by false equivalencies: they are not the same.

Every action by Trump is really nothing more than this: “you think you’re so smart”.

[whohit]Facts and Information are Biased[/whohit]

Equilibrium

It is possible that what we are going through now, with the vicious polarization of politics all over the developed world, fake news, a plague of sexual harassment cases, and so on, is temporary.  Have you ever thought that?  Nobody ever does, about something happening at the moment.  If things look really bad, well, it’s the end of the world.

But I think we may be in a moment of transition, and the resurgence of far right and nationalist movements may be an aberration, a last gasp of a set of cultural values that has lost it’s place.  (That’s why it seems so vicious: the true believers are lashing out in frustration at a culture that seems to marginalize them.  It does marginalize them.)

They will prevail.

No they won’t.  They would prevail if the world is what they think it is and their solutions resolve many pressing issues, like unemployment, poverty, inequality, pollution, North Korea, Iran, global warming, school violence, low achievement scores, loneliness, and so on.  If the world is not what they think it is, their “solutions” will go haywire, and things will get worse, and the majority of us will gradually realize that there was a reason why we used to elect people who appear to be smart and competent.

Perhaps, we’ll even learn that progress is slow-moving and incremental, and almost never revolutionary and sudden.

It is possible that when things go wrong, people will say, well, it would have been even worse than that if we hadn’t elected a Trump, if we hadn’t reduced regulations, if we hadn’t burned more coal.  Unfortunately, that is entirely possible: never underestimate the power of denial among invested people.  They will then find a new Trump and give him a bigger majority in Congress, and we’ll be all in.

I think it is equally possible that Trump may vaccinate us against future Trumps, just as Hoover vaccinated America against Alf Landon and Wendell Willkie.

I have heard some reasonable people argue that while Trump may not end warfare as we know it, resolve the Palestinian issue in the Middle East, improve the world’s hygiene,  and win a Nobel Peace Prize, he may have a moderately successful presidency with good economic growth and low unemployment and might actually get re-elected in 2020.

But the people surrounding Trump are really not very smart.   He has gutted the foreign service, for example, refusing to learn from Clinton’s experience: he did the same thing and it resulted in the U.S. losing a great deal of influence on events in Africa and Asia, and Europe and Latin America, and was later reckoned as a big mistake.   The Chinese are very busy out there, making friends and influencing people, while America sits back with their hands in their pockets.   Scott Pruitt will be remembered, without a doubt, as the worst E.P.A. administrator in history, not just for his intent– which is to hand over every piece of wilderness in America to oil and coal companies– but because he doesn’t really know what he’s doing– he’s not even very effective at handing it over, and it is thought that most of his regulatory moves will eventually be overturned in court.  He is laying the groundwork for numerous legal challenges and has made his department a laughing stock.

As for foreign policy, there is nowhere to go.  If Trump breaks the Iran deal, Iran will proceed to develop nuclear weapons while the U.S. sits steaming in a pile of it’s own verbiage.  The U.S. is not going to invade Iran– nobody wants one more war (especially since we haven’t extracted ourselves from the last two or three).   We might see a few bombing runs, but that could lead to trouble: Iran is not impotent.

North Korea is not going to give up it’s missiles.  It will not happen.  The U.S. will be led on a magical mystery tour to nowhere.  When they finally realize they’ve been had, Trump will blame Obama.

Unemployment is down.  Thanks Obama.  The economy is moving along, but, so far, all of the benefits appear to be going to the rich, the share-holders and owners, not to the working classes with the McJobs, mortgages, and credit card bills– let alone their inadequate health care coverage.

How far will Trump go with his neanderthal trade policies?  Everything you buy today has a global connection, all of which provide efficiencies that have been forever lost to nationalist trade policies.  It may be ugly at times– consider child labour in Indonesia, India, and Bangladesh– but nations like South Korea, the Philippines, and India are beginning to prosper because of trade, and they will gradually humanize their labour policies as they become more affluent.

Ideas like the Universal Basic Income have already gained some traction.  There is more to come as we begin to cope with the possibility of robots doing more and more jobs, and with the realization that without a prosperous middle class, nobody is going to be selling anything.

 

[whohit]Equilibrium[/whohit]

 

 

 

North Korea’s Exquisite Dance of the Seven Veils

I would be as delighted as anyone to see North Korea dismantle all of it’s nuclear weapons, sign a peace treaty with South Korea, open it’s borders, and hold elections.  None of that is going to happen.

It’s April 30, 2018.  I am not alone: it took a few days for the intoxication to wear off but now numerous commentators are also very suspicious.  (Gwynne Dyer was one of the few to have never not been suspicious.)

The problem is this: Kim Jung An was, we have been told, mightily impressed– in a negative sense– by the brutal death of Moammar Khadafy, who was dragged out of a steel culvert and beaten to death by enraged citizens at the end of Libya’s recent civil war.  Khadafy also once had a nuclear bomb program but he was persuaded to give up this nukes and join the West in a battle against Islamic terrorism.  In the end, his own people turned against him and the Americans stepped in to assist the rebellion, and guarantee the collapse of Khadafy’s government.

The Americans could never have done that if Khadafy had had a nuclear bomb to threaten them with.

There are some possible explanations for what is happening right now with North Korea.

  1.  Kim Jung An has had a road to Damascus experience.  He wants to be a statesman and lead his nation to prosperity and international respect so that he can reign as the glorious leader of an enlightened, civilized, modern state.
  2. Kim Jung An believes that Trump might actually do it– he might actually launch a pre-emptive attack and try to take out North Korea’s nuclear weapons testing facilities and, if they can, the launch sites, and the artillery aimed at South Korea.  So, quavering in fear, he is prepared to surrender rather than face military annihilation.
  3. Kim Jung An is, like his father and grand-father, a canny genius who understands perfectly the dynamic character of Trump’s foreign policy– “dynamic” in the sense of ridiculously impulsive and short-sighted– and is playing Trump for a sucker, hoping to get some sanctions dropped and some economic benefits, in exchange for vague, indeterminate, and unverifiable “reductions” of his testing and development regime (but not of the existing missiles).

I think “3” is the most likely answer.  In fact, I think it is very, very likely that Kim is taking Trump and Pompeo and Bolton for a ride, no matter how much they all insist they cannot be fooled.  Kim Jung An is probably thrilled beyond imagination at the imminent summit: just the two of us– an unstable, impulsive, immature blow-hard and the leader of the most powerful nation on earth– on that day– Kim Jung An!

As of this day, Kim apparently has offered to allow international inspectors to witness the shutdown of his nuclear test facility– the one that recently collapsed and is no longer usable.  Then he offered to get rid of all his nukes if the U.S. promised not to attack North Korea.  The U.S. promise, of course, would be as worthless as Kim’s– especially under the Trump Administration which has shown the same deep, abiding, respect for international commitments and agreements as Trump has personally shown for wedding vows and sexual purity.  Item #1: the Iran Nuclear agreement, which the U.S. is poised to break?

Of course, it is possible that the U.S. will adopt a rational, defensible, strategically smart position that the nukes must be dismantled before there is even a moment given to negotiations on sanctions and economic agreements.  But then, the talks might have already been over and nothing will have changed.

The wildcard here– as should be obvious– is China.  Will China countenance any kind of reunification if it allows for an American military presence in South Korea?  I can’t imagine it.  Will the U.S. agree to remove all of their military assets from South Korea before North Korea dismantles their nukes?  Are they that stupid?

[whohit]North Korea’s Dance of the Seven Veils[/whohit]